Abstract. Doctoral attrition in the United States is high and persistent. In the most careful national study, only 57 percent of PhD entrants had finished within ten years. This paper asks who bears the cost when a doctoral student leaves without the degree. It combines doctrinal analysis of federal statutes, regulations and case law with published national data and the empirical literature on doctoral persistence. The paper finds that many causes of attrition, including absent or poor supervision, departmental culture, inadequate funding and conditions affecting mental health, lie substantially within institutional control. US law, however, rarely reaches them. Courts enforce only specific contractual promises and treat handbook language framed as aspiration as unenforceable. The educational malpractice doctrine and academic deference shield administrative as well as academic decisions. Federal misrepresentation rules govern what universities say rather than how they perform, and they are enforced by the Secretary of Education rather than by students. Title IX, Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act and the National Labor Relations Act offer partial protection, subject to high thresholds, institutional deference or unstable precedent, and no federal rule requires doctoral programs to disclose completion rates. Federal loan limits in force from July 2026 shift further financial risk onto students. The paper concludes that academic judgment should remain with academics, but that administrative commitments and information about outcomes should carry legal weight. It proposes enforceable supervision commitments, program-level completion disclosure, funding transparency, stronger leave and accommodation policies, and independent channels for raising concerns.
Abstract. Tanzanian succession law was built for paper. The Indian Succession Act 1865, as applied in Tanzania, requires a will to be signed by the testator and attested by two witnesses, and it assumes a physical document. The Electronic Transactions Act 2015 recognizes electronic records and signatures in general terms but is silent on wills. This leaves testators, advocates, probate officers and courts without clear guidance on whether a will made, signed, witnessed or stored electronically can be valid. This article uses a qualitative doctrinal and comparative method to examine the problem against the law of South Africa. South Africa expressly excludes wills from its electronic transactions statute, yet its courts have used the condonation power in section 2(3) of the Wills Act 7 of 1953 to accept electronic documents as wills where the deceased’s intention is proved. The article finds that Tanzanian law does not clearly regulate electronic wills and offers no mechanism for rescuing a genuine electronic will that fails the traditional formalities. It argues that the most transferable South African lesson is structural: a strict formal code can coexist with an evidence-based remedial discretion. It recommends legislative, institutional and professional reforms adapted to Tanzania’s own structures.
Abstract. This article critically examines the legal and institutional challenges affecting the enforcement of construction adjudication decisions in Tanzania, using the United Kingdom as a comparative reference. It focuses on the gap between the use of adjudication under construction contracts and institutional rules and the absence of a coherent statutory framework that expressly establishes the legal effect of decisions and a direct, expedited enforcement route. The article adopts doctrinal and comparative legal research methods, analysing relevant legislation, procedural rules, judicial decisions and legal literature in the two jurisdictions. The analysis identifies five interconnected issues: uncertainty over the status and binding effect of adjudication decisions; the lack of a dedicated enforcement procedure; the risk that enforcement proceedings may become a reconsideration of the underlying dispute; insufficiently defined institutional responsibilities and professional standards; and the need to coordinate adjudication with arbitration and litigation. The United Kingdom framework, particularly the Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act 1996, the Scheme for Construction Contracts and the courts’ enforcement approach, illustrates how statutory recognition and focused judicial supervision can preserve adjudication’s intended speed while retaining safeguards for jurisdictional and natural-justice defects. The article argues that Tanzania should adopt a context-sensitive statutory framework defining the scope of adjudication, the legal effect of decisions, enforcement procedure, limited grounds of challenge and the roles of relevant institutions. These reforms would improve legal certainty and the practical utility of adjudication in the construction industry.
Abstract. The Patents Act, 1970 grants the patentee the exclusive right to make use of an invention and also contains certain provisions to stop the right from being used for purposes beyond what patent law actually protects. This paper examines the practical application of sections 106 and 140. Section 106 provides relief to a person threatened with infringement proceedings without justification, through a declaration, an injunction and damages. Section 140 renders void certain restrictive conditions that a patentee may impose in contracts of sale, lease or licence. The study is based on doctrinal methodology, examining the statutory language, Indian case law on these provisions and legal commentaries. The analysis suggests that courts have not yet developed a settled interpretative test for either section, which leaves their scope and application uncertain. The Act does not say when a communication becomes a “threat” or when a threat becomes “groundless”, and the courts have so far answered those questions case by case. Section 140 has attracted even less judicial attention, so its categories, in particular the newer ones concerning grant-back, validity challenges and coercive package licensing, remain largely unexplained. The paper argues that this gap between legislative intent and judicial interpretation, and the lack of clarity in the legal words used, reduce the effectiveness of these provisions in regulating misuse of patent rights. It concludes that clearer judicial standards and more consistent application are necessary to ensure that patent rights are exercised within reasonable and legally defined limits.
Abstract. This article examines whether Indian family law should recognise prenuptial agreements. It analyses their legal status under the Indian Contract Act, 1872, relevant judicial decisions and matrimonial legislation, while considering the approaches adopted in the United States and England and Wales. In India, the enforceability of prenuptial agreements remains uncertain because there is no comprehensive statutory framework governing such agreements, and their validity may depend on contractual principles, applicable personal laws and public policy. Although prenuptial agreements can promote financial transparency, clarify the ownership of premarital assets and reduce uncertainty, unrestricted enforcement may expose a financially weaker spouse to coercion or injustice and may undermine statutory protections, including maintenance rights. The article argues that India should adopt a clear legislative framework that recognises fair and voluntarily executed prenuptial agreements, subject to safeguards such as full financial disclosure and judicial scrutiny. Such a framework should respect individual autonomy while preserving equality, fairness and the protective objectives of family law.
Abstract. This article examines the effectiveness of alternative dispute resolution (ADR) in resolving tax disputes in Tanzania, with comparative reference to Kenya. It argues that Tanzania’s tax laws recognize ADR but do not give it the procedural and institutional clarity that predictable, fair and enforceable outcomes require, and that Kenya’s experience shows how that gap may be narrowed. The article employs doctrinal and comparative approaches. It finds that Tanzania has a legal and institutional basis for ADR in tax disputes, but the framework remains fragmented and lacks a comprehensive tax-specific procedure. Key challenges include uncertainty concerning ADR and statutory objection and appeal timelines, inadequate safeguards for independence and confidentiality, uncertainty regarding the legal effect and enforcement of settlements, limited taxpayer awareness, unequal bargaining power and weak institutional coordination. Compared with Tanzania, Kenya has a more structured tax ADR framework supported by specific legislation and subsidiary regulations. The article concludes that ADR has significant potential to improve tax dispute resolution in Tanzania. It recommends the development of a coherent tax-specific ADR framework, clearer settlement procedures, stronger safeguards for neutrality and confidentiality, improved institutional coordination and greater awareness among taxpayers and relevant practitioners.
Abstract. The increasing reliance on digital technologies in the commission and investigation of crime has made digital evidence integral to contemporary criminal proceedings, while raising complex questions concerning its admissibility, reliability, and compatibility with fair-trial guarantees. This study examines the adequacy of the legal regulation of digital evidence in criminal proceedings and the extent to which it reconciles effective criminal investigation with the protection of fundamental rights. Employing descriptive-analytical, comparative, and inductive approaches, it analyses the legal nature of digital evidence, the procedures governing its collection, seizure, preservation, and examination, and the principles guiding its judicial assessment. The study considers selected Arab and international legal frameworks, with particular attention to the United Arab Emirates, and addresses the challenges of obtaining electronic data across national borders. The findings indicate that contemporary legal systems increasingly recognise digital evidence as a legitimate means of criminal proof. The principal challenge lies not in recognition alone, but in safeguarding the legality, integrity, and verifiability of such evidence throughout its lifecycle. A documented chain of custody and competent forensic examination are central to establishing reliability, while the ultimate assessment of probative value remains within the discretion of the criminal court. The study therefore recommends clearer procedural rules specifically tailored to digital evidence, standardised custody and preservation practices, professional standards for forensic expertise, and stronger mechanisms for international judicial cooperation. It concludes that an effective legal framework must integrate technical safeguards with procedural protections to strengthen criminal justice without undermining privacy, defence rights, or the fairness of proceedings.
Abstract. The paralysis of the World Trade Organization (WTO) Appellate Body since December 2019 represents one of the most significant challenges to the contemporary rules-based international trading system. Once regarded as the cornerstone of the WTO’s dispute settlement mechanism, the Appellate Body ensured consistency, predictability, and legal certainty in interpreting and enforcing multilateral trade rules. Its inability to function has generated a profound institutional and normative crisis, raising fundamental questions regarding the relationship between international law, state sovereignty, and power politics in global economic governance. This work critically examines the causes and consequences of the WTO Appellate Body crisis within the broader context of the changing international economic order. It argues that the institutional paralysis extends beyond a procedural dispute over judicial appointments and reflects deeper tensions concerning treaty interpretation, judicial legitimacy, geopolitical rivalry, and the evolving balance of power among major trading nations. Drawing on Realism, Liberal Institutionalism, Legal Positivism, and Third World Approaches to International Law (TWAIL), the paper shows how competing conceptions of law and power shape the functioning and legitimacy of international adjudicatory institutions. It further analyses the legal and institutional consequences of the crisis, including the erosion of legal certainty, the resurgence of unilateral trade measures, and the growing fragmentation of the multilateral dispute settlement framework. Particular attention is devoted to the implications for developing countries, with a special focus on India, whose economic interests depend significantly on an effective, impartial, and enforceable rules-based trading system. The present work also evaluates recent reform initiatives, including the Multi-Party Interim Appeal Arbitration Arrangement (MPIA), and proposes measures to restore the credibility, independence, and effectiveness of WTO dispute settlement. It concludes that the future of international economic law depends not merely on institutional restructuring but on renewed political commitment to multilateralism, respect for international legal obligations, and the preservation of a dispute settlement system capable of balancing state sovereignty with the rule of law in an increasingly multipolar world.
Abstract. The Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons (NPT) has played an important role in limiting the spread of nuclear weapons. However, its legal framework contains a significant imbalance. While the non-proliferation obligations of non-nuclear-weapon states are supported by an international safeguards system, the implementation of nuclear disarmament commitments remains difficult to assess. The continued modernisation of nuclear arsenals and the failure of the 2026 NPT Review Conference to adopt a consensus substantive outcome have brought renewed attention to this problem. This paper examines the difference between the legal obligations established under Articles II, III and VI of the NPT and the institutional arrangements available for reviewing their implementation. It introduces the concept of the “Nuclear Black Box” to describe the gap between the legal recognition of disarmament obligations and the ability of existing institutions to consistently assess their fulfilment. The paper argues that the Treaty’s central weakness lies in the limited continuity and accountability of its review process along with its unequal structure. This is based on the jurisprudence of the International Court of Justice, successive NPT Review Conferences, and recent proposals for greater transparency. It proposes an evidence-based implementation record that would utilise national reports, identify unresolved disagreements, and track commitments across review cycles, including the times when consensus cannot be reached. The paper concludes by emphasising that strengthening disarmament accountability within the existing treaty framework is essential to maintain the credibility of international nuclear non-proliferation.
Abstract. Public authorities in India are steadily handing eligibility screening, risk scoring and benefit allocation to software. This paper asks whether the code performing these functions can be treated as state action and, if so, how Articles 14 and 15 of the Constitution constrain it. It argues that the relevant act is not the programmer’s intention but the authority’s decision to adopt, configure and rely on a system, and that Article 12, read with the instrumentality and public-function tests, reaches that decision even where a private vendor builds the model. The paper then develops a theory of algorithmic arbitrariness. Drawing on E.P. Royappa, Maneka Gandhi and Shayara Bano, it contends that an automated determination which is unexplained, unvalidated or unreviewable offends Article 14 because it cannot be measured against any intelligible standard. Turning to discrimination, it shows how facially neutral models reproduce disadvantage through proxy variables and skewed training data, and it uses Lt. Col. Nitisha v. Union of India, India’s leading recognition of indirect discrimination, as the doctrinal bridge to effects-based review under Articles 14 and 15. Reading these authorities alongside Huq’s critique of intent-centred doctrine, the Micklitz volume and Sulmicelli’s safeguards architecture, the paper assesses NITI Aayog’s Responsible AI papers and the 2025 India AI Governance Guidelines and finds them principled but non-justiciable. It closes with four proposals: a presumption of arbitrariness where reasons and validation records are withheld, mandatory equality impact assessments, a right to human review, and aggregate remedies for systemic design defects.
Abstract. The emergence of cybercrime committed by autonomous artificial intelligence is no longer hypothetical. During cyber-range evaluations run by the UK AI Security Institute in July 2026, AI agents took nineteen unsanctioned actions on the live internet, seventeen by Anthropic’s Mythos 5 and two by OpenAI’s GPT-5.6 Sol, including an attempted supply-chain attack, social engineering and prompt injection. In the same summer, a swarm of OpenAI agents under evaluation breached Hugging Face’s production infrastructure, in what has been described as the first publicly documented fully autonomous AI cyberattack. No human directed either set of actions. This exposes a structural fracture in existing liability regimes. India’s Information Technology Act, 2000 and Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, the US Computer Fraud and Abuse Act of 1986 and the UK Computer Misuse Act 1990 all condition liability on mens rea, while the EU AI Act imposes procedural safety obligations but is silent on liability, a gap left open since the AI Liability Directive was withdrawn in 2025. The gap is widest where a developer has complied fully with its safety obligations, yet its system acts autonomously and unlawfully. Through a comparative doctrinal analysis tested in the light of the documented 2026 incidents, this paper examines who can be held liable and whether vicarious liability, strict liability and regulatory non-compliance models can be adapted to answer that question. Both civil and criminal law are considered in this regard, including in a few EU and Asian countries. It finds that criminal liability generally fails against a developer, that vicarious liability works only through statutory deeming, and that civil strict liability, especially India’s M.C. Mehta absolute liability rule and section 43 of the IT Act, offers solutions, though not complete ones. It recommends specific amendments to the IT Act and parallel reforms elsewhere.
Abstract. The proposal for simultaneous elections to the Lok Sabha and State Legislative Assemblies, popularly described as “One Nation, One Election” (ONOE), has moved from a recurring electoral reform debate to a concrete project of constitutional amendment. The Constitution (One Hundred and Twenty-Ninth Amendment) Bill, 2024 proposes the insertion of Article 82A and amendments to Articles 83, 172 and 327 in order to synchronise parliamentary and State electoral cycles. The proposal is defended on grounds of administrative efficiency, reduction of election expenditure, continuity in governance, minimisation of repeated application of the Model Code of Conduct and greater policy stability. Yet its constitutional significance extends far beyond election management. It raises foundational questions concerning federalism, representative democracy, parliamentary accountability, State autonomy, premature dissolution of legislatures, the power of the Election Commission of India, the constitutional position of the President, and the Basic Structure Doctrine. This paper examines the historical evolution of simultaneous elections, the recommendations of the High Level Committee chaired by former President Ram Nath Kovind, the architecture of the 129th Amendment Bill, and developments before the Joint Parliamentary Committee up to October 2026. It argues that synchronisation is not unconstitutional merely because elections are held together; India itself followed substantially simultaneous electoral cycles until 1967. The constitutional difficulty lies instead in the mechanisms necessary to preserve synchronisation once political events produce different legislative lifespans. Curtailing elected State Assemblies, limiting governments elected after premature dissolution to a “remainder term”, and permitting postponement of a State election on the recommendation of the Election Commission potentially alter the working relationship between democratic accountability and federal autonomy. Drawing upon Supreme Court jurisprudence on democracy, federalism, constitutional amendment and free and fair elections, the paper concludes that electoral efficiency cannot by itself justify constitutional centralisation. Any simultaneous election framework must preserve the independent democratic mandate of the States, maintain legislative accountability and incorporate stringent safeguards against arbitrary postponement or manipulation of electoral cycles.
Abstract. Maritime chokepoints stand in a paradoxical position in the international legal order. On one hand they constitute indispensable arteries of global trade, and on the other hand their security depends upon a fragmented arrangement of coastal sovereignty along with war-laden navigational freedoms, disconnected collective security mechanisms and patchy private commercial decisions. The United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) protects transit passage through the international straits. However, it does not guarantee the conditions required for uninterrupted commercial navigation. This paper examines the divergence between legal navigability and operational accessibility, using the Strait of Hormuz as its principal case study. It argues that conventional understandings of freedom of navigation do not address the economic consequences of armed conflict, non-state interference, maritime insurance restrictions, and anticipatory commercial withdrawal. The paper introduces the concept of the “Operational Passage Gap” to distinguish legal entitlement from effective access to international waterways. Additionally, it proposes a framework of cooperative navigational resilience rooted in the existing international maritime law. The framework underscores the importance of enhanced institutional coordination and transparent risk governance. The paper concludes by stating that the principal challenge is the inadequacy of legal and institutional arrangements for preserving the exercise of navigational rights during geopolitical instability.
Abstract. Human trafficking deprives people of their dignity, freedom and ability to make choices about their own lives. This goes far beyond a breach of law and order. The suffering often begins with false promises during recruitment and continues through coercion and exploitation. This may persist even after rescue when survivors face social stigma or inadequate support from institutions. This study examines trafficking through victimology and human-rights perspectives. It focusses on the relationship between structural vulnerability and organised exploitation. It examines human trafficking from different perspectives, beginning with its definition under international law and the factors that contribute to the crime. It discusses how victims are recruited and exploited, the protections available under the Indian Constitution and relevant legislation and the approach taken by the Supreme Court in selected cases. It also looks at the psychological and social difficulties survivors face, including the challenges of obtaining compensation and rebuilding their lives. The study adopts a doctrinal research methodology, examining statutory provisions, international instruments and selected judicial decisions. The paper argues that rescuing victims and prosecuting offenders alone cannot address the full impact of trafficking. Survivors also need protection from further harm, compensation, witness protection where necessary and continued support to rebuild their lives. The effectiveness of anti-trafficking measures must therefore be judged not only by the number of convictions but also by whether survivors are able to regain their independence, security and dignity.
Abstract. Cheque dishonour in Nepal has been governed by two overlapping statutes: the Negotiable Instruments Act, 2034 and the Banking Offence and Punishment Act, 2064. The Banking Offence and Punishment (Second Amendment) Act, 2082 did not introduce criminal liability for the first time, but it reorganised an existing dual regime. This article examines that transition through a doctrinal study of the relevant statutes, Supreme Court decisions and secondary materials. It focuses on the repeal of section 107A of the Negotiable Instruments Act, the replacement of former section 3(c) with section 3A, the forty five day notice and certification process, graded imprisonment, the five percent fine, limitation and compromise. The new framework gives the drawer an opportunity to make payment before formal certification and makes punishment more closely reflect the amount involved. At the same time, it continues to combine private recovery, banking regulation and criminal sanction. The article argues that the amendment has made the law more coherent and procedurally clearer, but important questions remain about holder entitlement, the role of earlier case law and the practical operation of certification and settlement.
Abstract. This paper examines the constitutional significance of the Preamble to the Constitution of India, exploring its historical origins, philosophical foundations, substantive ideals, and role in constitutional interpretation. It traces the Preamble to Jawaharlal Nehru's Objectives Resolution, adopted by the Constituent Assembly in 1947, and considers how the framers adapted constitutional ideas from other political and constitutional traditions to India's distinctive circumstances. The study analyses the expression "We, the People of India" as an affirmation of popular sovereignty and examines the character of India as a Sovereign, Socialist, Secular, Democratic Republic. The paper then evaluates the Preamble's principal commitments: justice, social, economic and political; liberty of thought, expression, belief, faith and worship; equality of status and opportunity; and fraternity, assuring individual dignity and national unity and integrity. It considers how these ideals are reflected in constitutional provisions concerning fundamental rights, directive principles, citizenship, affirmative action, political participation, religious freedom and the duties of citizens. Through an examination of relevant Supreme Court decisions, the study discusses the relationship between these constitutional promises and the development of substantive equality, social welfare, secularism and democratic participation. A further focus is the legal status of the Preamble. The paper considers the earlier judicial position in In re Berubari Union and the subsequent determination in Kesavananda Bharati v. State of Kerala that the Preamble forms part of the Constitution. It also examines the Forty-Second Amendment Act, 1976, which inserted the terms "Socialist," "Secular" and "Integrity," and the limits imposed by the basic structure doctrine on Parliament's amending power under Article 368. The study argues that, although the Preamble does not independently confer governmental powers or enforceable rights, it remains an integral constitutional component and an authoritative interpretative guide. It encapsulates India's constitutional identity and provides a framework for understanding the Constitution's enduring commitments and democratic aspirations.
Abstract. In the past decade, India’s drone policy has changed gear twice. The near-total prohibition of 2014 gave way to a policy of outright promotion in 2021, and the draft Civil Drone (Promotion and Regulation) Bill, 2025 now signals a move towards control and criminal punishment. This paper considers whether the Indian framework, as it stands and as proposed, withstands constitutional scrutiny and whether it has the capacity to address the security, technological and social issues raised by drones. It reads the Drone Rules, 2021 and the draft Bill against Articles 14, 19 and 21 of the Constitution, examines the gap between the civil aviation regime and counter-drone security, and evaluates programmes in agriculture, land records and health delivery. The comparative part focuses on the United States, the United Kingdom and the European Union. The paper argues that liberalisation and indigenisation have been a success for India, but that State surveillance, counter-drone authority and proportionate enforcement have received far too little attention. It proposes a risk-based classification in place of the present weight-based classification, an independent statutory code for State drone surveillance, and a recalibrated penalty system.
Abstract. This study examines the complex constitutional crisis resulting from the suspension of the Palestinian Legislative Council’s activities, which began in the summer of 2007 and culminated in the Constitutional Court’s 2018 ruling to dissolve it. It uses a descriptive, analytical, and comparative approach to analyze the causes of this structural paralysis and assess the constitutionality of the dissolution decision in light of the provisions of the Basic Law that protect the legislature. The study concluded that this suspension led to an encroachment of presidential power and the emergence of a dual legislative fragmentation between the West Bank and Gaza, thereby weakening democratic legitimacy. The study recommends that comprehensive general elections be held as soon as possible and that a legal committee be formed to unify the conflicting legal systems.
Abstract. Doping in sport is often discussed as a problem of prohibited drugs, positive tests, and sanctions. That framing is incomplete. Contemporary anti-doping governance also addresses prohibited methods and conduct that undermines testing and investigation, while effective prevention must account for health risks, athlete decision-making, team cultures, medical practice, and the commercial pressures surrounding sport. This narrative review synthesizes selected peer-reviewed literature and official anti-doping instruments to examine four connected questions: how doping is defined and regulated; what is known about health consequences; why athletes may consider prohibited performance enhancement; and how detection and prevention can be combined more effectively. The evidence indicates that health risks vary by substance, dose, duration, route, combinations, and the population studied, so findings from non-athlete users should not be generalized uncritically to elite athletes. Research on athlete attitudes identifies perceived performance benefits, social influence, recovery concerns, and financial or career pressures as relevant factors, although attitudes do not directly establish actual use. The World Anti-Doping Code and the annually updated Prohibited List provide a harmonized framework, but testing alone cannot address every source of risk. A more credible response combines risk-based testing and investigation with values-based education, competent medical advice, supplement-risk management, confidential reporting, and proportionate, procedurally fair results management. The review concludes with priorities for prevention and research, including better evaluation of education, improved evidence on long-term health outcomes in athletic populations, and clearer coordination between international standards and national implementation.
Abstract. Digital lending through mobile applications has become a major source of credit for individuals and small traders in Tanzania, but it has been accompanied by high and poorly disclosed costs, the harvesting of borrowers’ telephone data and abusive methods of debt collection. This article examines the legal framework that regulates digital lending by non-deposit-taking (Tier 2) microfinance service providers in Mainland Tanzania and asks whether that framework is applicable to the lenders it is meant to govern and capable of being enforced against them. Using doctrinal legal research supplemented by a limited comparison with Kenya, it analyses the Microfinance Act, the Microfinance (Non-Deposit Taking Microfinance Service Providers) Regulations, 2019, the Bank of Tanzania (Financial Consumer Protection) Regulations, 2019, the Guidelines on Fees and Charges, 2024, the Guidance Note on Digital Lenders, 2024, the Personal Data Protection Act, the Electronic Transactions Act and the National Payment Systems Act, and evaluates them against the public interest theory of regulation, the distinction between entity-based and activity-based regulation, and responsive regulation. The article finds that the rules specific to digital lending are contained in a guidance note rather than in regulations, although the Microfinance Act empowers the Bank of Tanzania to make regulations on digital microfinance business; that the price of credit is controlled by disclosure alone; that the binding rules on personal data and debt collection are general and fragmented, with inconsistent sanctions; and that the conduct rules bind only licensed providers, leaving unlicensed and foreign-hosted lenders largely outside the framework. The claim is one about statutory design, established by doctrinal analysis, and not about how the regulators perform in practice. The article recommends binding digital microfinance regulations under section 60(2)(q) of the Act, an activity-based regulatory perimeter, a defined standard of usurious lending, targeted amendment of the Personal Data Protection Act, a single code of collection practice, consistent sanctions and formal coordination between the regulators.
Abstract. Police officers exercise the most coercive powers of the state, and the legitimacy of those powers depends on how effectively their abuse is investigated, sanctioned and remedied. This article examines police impunity and compliance with human rights standards in Tanzania through a comparative doctrinal analysis with Kenya. Tanzania’s accountability architecture remains predominantly internal: disciplinary authority sits largely within the Police Force under the Inspector General, and the only external body with a mandate over police complaints, the Commission for Human Rights and Good Governance, can make only non-binding recommendations, enforceable only through court action. Kenya’s 2010 Constitution, by contrast, entrenches police professionalism, transparency and accountability and separates discipline from operational command through the National Police Service Commission, while Kenyan statute establishes the Independent Policing Oversight Authority (IPOA), which the High Court has held has exclusive jurisdiction over deaths and serious injuries caused by police action. Drawing on Principal-Agent Theory, Democratic Policing Theory and the Human Rights-Based Approach, supported by Institutional Theory, the article finds that the two states share the same binding obligations under the ICCPR and the African Charter but diverge sharply in domestic institutional design. Kenya produces verifiable, if still modest, outcomes in the form of published data and convictions of officers; comparable Tanzanian data is unavailable. Kenya’s own backlog, delay and continuing custodial deaths nevertheless show that institutional design alone cannot eliminate impunity. The article recommends constitutional entrenchment of police accountability standards, separation of disciplinary authority from operational command, an independent oversight authority with exclusive jurisdiction over serious misconduct, a statutory duty on the prosecuting authority to respond to oversight recommendations, publication of outcome data and protected resourcing, while cautioning against uncritical legal transplantation.
Abstract. Trademark law protects brand symbols, including words, logos and sounds, by conferring exclusive rights and preventing consumer confusion. It was built around physical goods, classified under systems such as the Nice Classification, and tied to geographic markets and channels of trade. The metaverse is a virtual space in which users interact by gaming, collaborating, shopping and exploring; they buy virtual products to adorn their avatars, many of them NFTs, unique digital creations, and spend real money, albeit in the form of digital currencies, to participate. For brand owners, protecting their brands in the metaverse will be critical and will require a legal strategy. This study asks whether the present trademark regime sufficiently safeguards brand owners and consumers, ensures freedom of expression and holds platforms accountable. It is based on a mixed methodology combining doctrinal and comparative approaches across India, the United States and the European Union. The doctrinal approach analyses the Indian Trade Marks Act, 1999 and significant case law, and the comparative approach examines Sections 32 and 43(a) of the US Lanham Act and the EU Trade Mark Directive. The paper also analyses Hermès v. Rothschild and Nike v. StockX as leading precedents. It finds that trademark law largely suffices for virtual goods except in six areas, that sui generis protection is unnecessary, and that targeted reforms can close the gaps: Registry guidance on classification, a use standard for virtual settings, a rebuttable similarity rule, a defined space for expression, function-based platform liability and international guidance on cross-border issues.
Abstract. The integration of Artificial Intelligence (AI) into corporate decision-making is transforming the traditional structure of corporate governance. From financial forecasting and risk assessment to recruitment, contractual evaluation, fraud detection and strategic planning, AI-driven systems increasingly influence decisions that were historically undertaken by directors and senior management. Although these technologies offer efficiency, predictive accuracy and cost advantages, their deployment raises fundamental questions concerning accountability, transparency, independent judgment and the fiduciary responsibilities of corporate directors. Traditional company law presupposes that directors exercise personal judgment, act in good faith and discharge their responsibilities with reasonable care, skill and diligence. However, algorithmic decision-making complicates this assumption because decisions may be generated through complex systems whose internal reasoning is difficult to interpret, whose training data may contain historical biases and whose outputs may change through continuous learning. The central question is whether directors can discharge their fiduciary obligations merely by relying on technologically sophisticated systems or whether such reliance creates a heightened responsibility to understand, supervise and monitor algorithmic processes. This paper critically examines the relationship between AI-driven corporate decision-making and directors’ fiduciary duties, particularly under Section 166 of the Companies Act, 2013. It analyses the emerging challenges of algorithmic opacity, automation bias, accountability gaps, data governance and the delegation of managerial judgment to technological systems. Through comparative examination of the United Kingdom, United States and European Union, the paper evaluates how existing corporate governance principles may be adapted to address AI-related risks. It argues that the adoption of AI does not dilute directors’ legal responsibilities; rather, it requires a more sophisticated interpretation of their duties of care, diligence, good faith and independent judgment. The paper proposes a risk-based framework of AI governance involving board-level oversight, human accountability, algorithmic audits, explainability, continuous monitoring and documented decision-making.
Abstract. Precedent sits at the heart of Indian adjudication, supplying the consistency, predictability and certainty that a justice system needs. Under Article 141 of the Constitution, whatever law the Supreme Court declares is binding upon every court in the country. Yet this binding force produces a lasting strain between continuity and reform. Uniform decision-making strengthens the rule of law, but rigid loyalty to past rulings can keep alive readings that no longer fit constitutional values, social conditions or later legislation. To manage that strain, the Supreme Court has relied on distinguishing, overruling, referral for reconsideration and purposive constitutional interpretation. This paper traces the constitutional basis and justification of precedent in India, examines the dangers of inflexibility, and assesses how the Court has weighed stare decisis against constitutional growth. Its argument is that precedent is neither untouchable nor disposable at the whim of changing judicial taste; departures should rest on principled criteria, constitutional values, institutional legitimacy and real shifts in law or society.
Abstract. Lok Adalats play a significant role in promoting access to justice in India by providing a speedy, cost-effective and accessible mechanism for amicable dispute resolution. They are particularly important for individuals who face financial, procedural and practical barriers in accessing conventional courts. This study examines the constitutional and statutory framework governing Lok Adalats, with particular reference to Article 39A of the Constitution of India and the Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987. It explores their concept, historical evolution, institutional framework and functioning within the Indian legal system. Adopting a doctrinal research methodology, the study draws upon statutory provisions, judicial decisions, books and scholarly literature. The study analyses the contribution of Lok Adalats in reducing litigation costs, expediting dispute resolution, simplifying procedures and alleviating the burden on conventional courts. Simultaneously, it critically examines challenges affecting their effectiveness, including inadequate infrastructure, limited public awareness, pressure to compromise, restricted adjudicatory powers and concerns regarding the protection of vulnerable parties. Particular attention is given to the finality of Lok Adalat awards, the significance of voluntary participation and informed consent, and the scope of judicial intervention in safeguarding procedural fairness. The study argues that the effectiveness of Lok Adalats must be assessed not merely through the number of disputes settled but also through the fairness and legitimacy of the settlement process. It proposes appropriate remedial measures to strengthen institutional accountability, protect the rights of disputing parties and ensure that the pursuit of speedy justice does not compromise substantive legal rights. Ultimately, it emphasises the need to reconcile accessible dispute resolution with procedural fairness to advance the constitutional vision of equal justice.
Abstract. India and China together feed nearly one third of the global population, and both nations have built that capacity on the back of agrarian reform programmes that could hardly be more different in philosophy. This paper undertakes a legal and historical study of agrarian reform in the two countries, tracing the evolution of land law from the colonial and red past through mid-century chaos to the present day. India’s experience is one of gradual, decentralised, rights-based reform conducted largely at the state level and anchored in constitutional guarantees of property and federalism. China’s experience is one of centralised, state-directed transformation, beginning with the forcible redistribution of landlord holdings, passing through collectivisation, and arriving eventually at a hybrid system of collective ownership coupled with individual use rights. The paper examines the constitutional and statutory architecture underlying each model, the market institutions that have grown up around them, the recurring legal and administrative failures each system has produced, and the reforms that scholars and policymakers have proposed to address them. It concludes that neither model offers a template that can simply be transplanted onto the other; each carries distinct trade-offs between efficiency, equity, and individual liberty, and each continues to evolve in response to pressures the original reformers did not fully anticipate.
Abstract. Direct Benefit Transfer (DBT) has become a major component of India’s social-welfare delivery architecture, seeking to move benefits and subsidies through bank accounts and to improve targeting, transparency and administrative efficiency. This paper critically examines the public-policy framework of DBT from a socio-legal perspective, focusing on rural women. It asks whether a technically direct payment necessarily produces meaningful access to welfare. The study adopts a primarily doctrinal and analytical methodology, supplemented by a review of official policy materials and existing scholarship. It examines constitutional principles concerning equality, dignity, livelihood and privacy, and considers judicial decisions including Olga Tellis v. Bombay Municipal Corporation and K.S. Puttaswamy v. Union of India. The analysis finds that DBT can reduce certain intermediary risks and strengthen traceability, but its effectiveness for rural women depends on conditions beyond the payment mechanism itself. Banking access, digital and financial literacy, accurate data, authentication safeguards, information and grievance redress materially affect whether a formal entitlement becomes an actually received and usable benefit. The paper argues that DBT should therefore be evaluated through a dual lens of administrative efficiency and substantive accessibility. A rights-sensitive model should combine reliable payment infrastructure with last-mile banking access, gender-sensitive monitoring, accessible grievance mechanisms and appropriate privacy safeguards.
Abstract. Shielding women and children from violence is one of the basic duties of a criminal justice system, and in India that duty is carried out through a layered set of constitutional, penal and protective laws. This article studies the framework set up by the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS), concentrating on dowry death under section 80 and on cruelty by a husband or his relatives under sections 85 and 86. It sets out the separate facts that the prosecution must prove for each offence, explains how the presumption in section 118 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 (BSA) operates, and asks how far Supreme Court rulings on the corresponding Indian Penal Code provisions still guide courts. The offences are then placed among related statutes: the Dowry Prohibition Act, 1961, the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005, and the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012. Following a doctrinal and analytical method, the article argues that real protection cannot be secured by heavy punishment alone. It also needs early intervention, careful investigation, proof directed at each accused individually, and dependable support for survivors. The article closes with proposals that aim to keep both the safety of survivors and the guarantee of a fair trial intact.
Abstract. Delivery partners in India ride to deadlines they do not set, on roads where two-wheeler riders form the largest group of fatalities and under contracts that call them independent partners. This paper examines when, and on what legal basis, platforms should answer for the road risks created by this arrangement. It examines the Motor Vehicles Act 1988 as amended in 2019, the Code on Social Security 2020 and its 2026 Rules, the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita 2023, and recent state gig-worker statutes. It contends that responsibility should depend upon who controls the conditions of risk, namely time, pay, allocation and deactivation, and not on the contract. It further considers how algorithmic management of allocation, incentives and deactivation affects rider safety, an area where Indian law remains largely silent. Current law protects delivery partners mainly through welfare schemes that are not yet operational, and it says little about unsafe system design. The paper proposes reforms that can largely be made through rules and targeted amendments.
Abstract. This article examines the relationship between the Uniform Civil Code (UCC), substantive gender equality and religious autonomy in India. It adopts a doctrinal legal method, analysing constitutional provisions, legislation, judicial decisions and selected comparative approaches. It distinguishes formal uniformity from equality in practice and considers family-law issues involving marriage, divorce, maintenance, inheritance and guardianship. The article examines the constitutional interaction of Articles 14, 15, 21, 25 and 44, together with the implications of state-level reform in Uttarakhand. It argues that common civil standards can advance legal certainty and individual rights, but their legitimacy depends on constitutional safeguards, meaningful consultation and protection against the dilution of existing rights. A phased, rights-based approach is proposed in place of an assumption that identical rules necessarily deliver justice.
Abstract. Street art and wall paintings have become a common form of artistic expression in public spaces. Many street artists create their work using a pseudonym or choose not to reveal their real identity. While copyright law provides protection to original artistic works, anonymity can create practical difficulties when an artist wants to protect or enforce their copyright. For example, if a mural is copied, used for commercial purposes, or shared online without permission, the artist may have to prove that they are the original creator while also trying to protect their identity. This paper examines whether the existing Indian copyright framework is sufficient to protect the rights of anonymous and pseudonymous street artists. It focuses on issues such as proving authorship, ownership of the artwork, registration of copyright, and access to legal remedies without unnecessarily revealing the artist’s identity. The paper also examines whether the existing provisions relating to anonymous and pseudonymous works are adequate for the special nature of street art. By identifying the gap between the legal recognition of copyright and the practical difficulties of enforcing it anonymously, the study aims to suggest possible legal and procedural measures that can protect both the artist’s copyright and their choice to remain anonymous.
Abstract. This article examines the effectiveness of disciplinary measures against arbitrators in Tanzania through doctrinal and comparative legal research. It analyses the constitutional principles governing fair hearing and administration of justice, the Arbitration Act Cap. 15 R.E. 2023, the Code of Conduct and Practice for Reconciliators, Negotiators, Mediators and Arbitrators Regulations, 2021, and the Reconciliation, Negotiation, Mediation and Arbitration (Practitioners’ Accreditation) Regulations, 2021. It also considers relevant international standards concerning arbitrator independence, impartiality, disclosure and professional conduct. The article identifies a distinction between the existence of disciplinary authority and the procedural capacity to exercise that authority consistently and fairly. Although the Tanzanian framework provides for complaints, disciplinary proceedings, sanctions and appeals, important matters remain insufficiently elaborated, particularly investigation powers, evidentiary standards, recusal, procedural timelines, publication of decisions, implementation of sanctions and the determination of appeals to the Minister. The article argues that disciplinary effectiveness should be assessed by reference to accessibility, procedural fairness, institutional independence, transparency and enforceability, rather than by the mere availability of sanctions. It recommends comprehensive procedural rules, clearer investigative and evidentiary standards, safeguards against conflicts of interest, reasoned publication of final decisions, effective sanction monitoring and a defined appellate procedure. The article concludes that targeted legal and institutional reform is necessary to strengthen professional accountability and public confidence in arbitration in Tanzania.
Abstract. Community mediation plays an important role in resolving rural land disputes by providing accessible, comparatively inexpensive, and locally appropriate processes for addressing disagreements over land boundaries, inheritance, land use, and competing customary claims. In Tanzania, the Village Land Act and the Land Disputes Courts Act establish a statutory basis for mediation through Village Land Councils and Ward Tribunals. Nevertheless, the existence of these institutions does not necessarily guarantee effective dispute resolution. Previous research has identified challenges involving institutional capacity, impartiality, legal awareness, boundary demarcation, and compliance with mediated outcomes. This article assesses the effectiveness of community mediation in resolving rural land disputes in Kishapu District Council, Shinyanga Region. The study employs a socio-legal approach combining doctrinal examination of the applicable legal framework with qualitative empirical evidence obtained from 40 respondents, comprising community members, Village Land Council members, Ward Tribunal members, Village Executive Officers, district land and legal officers, and legal practitioners. The findings indicate that community mediation is valued for its accessibility, affordability, and consideration of local circumstances. However, its effectiveness is constrained by inconsistent record-keeping practices, concerns about mediator impartiality, inadequate resources and training, delays in some proceedings, and difficulties securing compliance with settlements. The findings also indicate that customary practices may facilitate settlement while potentially reproducing inequalities where women’s and other vulnerable parties’ land rights are insufficiently protected. The article argues that improving community mediation requires strengthening institutional capacity, adopting minimum procedural standards, improving settlement documentation, and ensuring that customary practices remain consistent with statutory rights and principles of fairness.
Assistant Professor (Part-time) at University College of Law, Osmania University & Post Graduate College of Law, Osmania University, Hyderabad, Telangana, India
Abstract. One of India’s most well-thought-out and least enforced labour legislations was the Inter-State Migrant Workmen (Regulation of Employment and Conditions of Service) Act, 1979. The 1979 Act has been superseded by the Occupational Safety, Health and Working Conditions Code, 2020 and its content incorporated into a brief Part of the Code. The change is described by its supporters as modernisation: a broader definition which includes workers who migrate on their own, a moveable public distribution entitlement, a helpline and a national database. This article explores what remained and what has been lost. It claims that the Code has substituted a dense pyramid of recruitment-based regulations with a thinner structure of welfare and registration-based regulations. The displacement allowance, passbook, specific duties on accommodation and medical care, the low threshold of applicability and the role of the originating State have become either non-existent or reduced. The article argues that, taken together, from the Asiad case to the migrant labour suo motu proceedings of 2020 and 2021, the central issue with the old law was its inability to be enforced, and the task that the Code took up was to make it easier to let go of the obligation to enforce it. It ends with suggestions for State rules and future amendment.
Abstract. The swift expansion of the digital economy has confronted the standard approaches to CCI’s merger control framework, specifically those that are dependent on assets and turnover of an enterprise to decide its economic importance. Asset-light digital enterprises may hold considerable competitive value via user bases, data, intellectual property, algorithms, network effects and innovation potential in spite of having relatively low assets and turnover. This creates a regulatory problem where acquisitions of such asset-light digital enterprises may fall within the ambit of de minimis or small-target exemption and escape the standard merger inspection in spite of their potential importance for competition. This article analyses the functioning of the de minimis corporate target exemption under India’s merger-control framework and assesses its ramifications for acquisitions involving asset-light digital enterprises. This article further examines the relationship which exists between Section 5 of the Competition Act, 2002, the de minimis exemption and the new Deal Value Threshold introduced through the Competition (Amendment) Act, 2023. Specific attention is given to the requirement of substantial business operations in India and its pertinence to digital enterprises with substantial amounts of Indian users but comparatively limited domestic assets and turnover. This article further examines whether factors like transactional value, user presence, data, intellectual property and potential competition impart more meaningful indicators of competitive importance than traditional financial factors alone. Through a doctrinal as well as a comparative analysis, the article examines whether India’s merger control framework introduced after 2023 sufficiently deals with the possibility of competitively significant digital acquisitions getting away from the scrutiny while also maintaining regulatory and legal certainty. This article culminates by identifying the major challenges that persist in the application of merger-control thresholds to the rapidly evolving digital markets and suggests feasible approaches for strengthening India’s framework.
Abstract. Transport, food delivery, home services, logistics and other app-based services have transformed the way people work in India. Platform work is not just a flexible means of engagement in the labour market: it can also bring irregular income, ambiguous rating systems, unilateral termination of accounts and lower social security benefits, and so raises issues of dignity, equality, occupational safety and social protection. Through doctrinal and analytical methods, this paper explores the human rights position of gig and platform workers in light of international labour standards, the Code on Social Security, 2020 and the Constitution. The Code, which came into force on 21 November 2025, explicitly deals with gig workers, platform workers and aggregators: Section 113 provides for their registration, and Section 114 for schemes of life and disability cover, accident insurance, health and maternity benefits and old-age protection. Even with statutory recognition, registration, funding, portability and grievance redressal will remain important. The paper offers a rights-based solution which includes social security, clear algorithmic management, fair compensation, occupational security, no arbitrary disconnection, collective representation and accessible remedies, and proposes that innovation should never be secured by shifting economic and social risk from the innovator to the workers.
Abstract. Women engaged in urban food vending play an important role in supporting household incomes and providing affordable food to city residents. Despite their contribution, they may face several difficulties in carrying out their work, including uncertainty over vending locations, limited access to finance, inadequate public facilities, safety concerns and the burden of balancing paid work with domestic responsibilities. These challenges may become more difficult for women who also experience disadvantages relating to caste, income, migration status, disability or lack of access to local support networks. This paper examines the legal and institutional protection available to women food vendors under the Street Vendors (Protection of Livelihood and Regulation of Street Vending) Act, 2014. It analyzes the provisions of the Act relating to surveys, certificates of vending, vending zones, Town Vending Committees, relocation, eviction and grievance redressal, with specific reference to the requirement that one-third of the members representing street vendors in Town Vending Committees should be women. The study also takes into consideration constitutional guarantees of equality, non-discrimination, freedom of occupation and right to life and livelihood. The paper adopts a doctrinal and socio-legal approach and is based on statutory provisions, constitutional principles, judicial decisions and relevant scholarly and policy materials. It examines the availability of legal protection for women from different social and economic backgrounds using a feminist legal theory and intersectionality lens. The paper argues that while formal recognition under the Act is important, it is not enough by itself. Meaningful participation in decision making, clear administrative procedures, secure access to vending spaces and practical grievance mechanisms are needed to make livelihood protection effective. It concludes that a gender-responsive approach to street vending should balance the livelihood interests of women vendors with the legitimate regulation of public spaces and food safety requirements.
Abstract. Hannah Arendt described the condition of the stateless as the loss of a “right to have rights”; the right to belong to a community in which one’s actions and opinions count. This article turns that idea into a legal test and applies it to the Rohingya in Bangladesh. The test has three cumulative thresholds: recognition (being legible to the legal order as a person), standing (being able to bring a claim and have it heard) and agency (being able to act with legal effect). Each threshold is assessed at three levels: what the law says, whether a person can use it, and whether using it changes the outcome. Drawing on doctrinal and documentary analysis of the Constitution, statutes, case law and camp instruments, the article finds that the Rohingya are recognised but unheard. Registration makes them administratively legible but confers no civil legal personality; they appear before the legal system mainly as accused persons rather than as claimants; and their movement, work, association and expression are restricted by executive and camp-level measures. These failures flow not from any statute that denies their rights, but from sub-statutory instruments of doubtful legality under article 31 of the Constitution. The Constitution’s text grounds standing for “any person” in respect of core personal rights, but it cannot by itself restore agency, and standing on paper has not become standing in practice. The article offers a constitutional test of rightlessness that can be applied to stateless populations in other states outside the Refugee Convention.
Professor at Aligarh Muslim University, Aligarh, Uttar Pradesh, India
Md Asif Belal Ansari
Research Scholar at Aligarh Muslim University, Aligarh, Uttar Pradesh, India; Assistant Professor at Andaman Law College, Sri Vijaya Puram, Andaman and Nicobar Islands, India
Alqama
Assistant Professor at Andaman Law College, Sri Vijaya Puram, Andaman and Nicobar Islands, India; Research Scholar at Damodaram Sanjivayya National Law University, Visakhapatnam, Andhra Pradesh, India
Abstract. The Constitution of India protects religious and linguistic minorities without providing a comprehensive definition of “minority.” This absence has generated an extensive jurisprudence concerning the territorial identification of minorities, the recognition of minority educational institutions, and the permissible regulation of their administration. These questions are connected but legally distinct. This article argues that uncertainty in minority protection arises partly from treating them as a single problem of definition. Article 29(1) does not require minority status; Article 30 protects religious and linguistic minorities; central legislation identifies communities for specified statutory purposes; and institutional recognition requires an inquiry into the relationship between a community and an educational institution. Through doctrinal analysis of constitutional provisions, legislation, and Supreme Court decisions, the article distinguishes these different inquiries and examines their consequences for educational autonomy. Particular attention is given to the state-based approach in T.M.A. Pai Foundation, the declaratory character of minority-status certificates, and the institutional-establishment principles articulated in the 2024 Aligarh Muslim University judgment. The article proposes a framework of reasoned recognition, accessible review, and regulation directed to demonstrable educational purposes. Effective protection requires clear and reviewable procedures through which constitutional entitlement can be established without becoming dependent on executive favour.
Abstract. Dispute boards are now a standard feature of major construction contracts, and their value rests on one idea: a board’s decision binds the parties immediately, even though it is not final, so that cash flow and progress are not held hostage to a full arbitration. That idea works only if a non-compliant party can be compelled to comply quickly. This paper asks whether Indian law supplies that compulsion. Using a doctrinal and comparative method, it analyses the enforcement gap in the 1999 FIDIC conditions, the repair attempted in the 2017 editions, the Singapore litigation known as Persero, the English decision in Peterborough, and Indian authority on dispute review boards and pre-arbitral requirements. It reaches three findings. First, Indian courts have so far treated boards mainly as a mandatory gateway to arbitration and, in the decisions examined, have not squarely decided whether a binding but non-final decision can be enforced in isolation. Second, the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 already contains the tools that Singapore used to close the gap, namely interim awards and interim measures, so legislative amendment is not strictly needed. Third, many public-sector contracts, where most Indian construction disputes arise, use boards whose output is a recommendation and not a binding decision, and recent procurement policy favouring mediation over arbitration for large contracts adds uncertainty about the final forum. The paper proposes a three-part framework: an express compliance-and-referral clause in the contract, deliberate use of interim awards by tribunals, and alignment of procurement guidelines with board practice. It concludes that India can enforce board decisions without new legislation, but only if contracts and tribunals are deliberate about doing so.
Abstract. Access to international investment arbitration in Tanzania’s natural wealth and resources sector presents a tension between permanent sovereignty over natural resources and international investment obligations. Section 11 of the Natural Wealth and Resources (Permanent Sovereignty) Act, Cap. 449 R.E. 2023, prohibits the submission of natural-resource disputes to any foreign court or tribunal, appearing to close the gateway to international arbitration. This article argues that the prohibition is formally absolute but legally ineffective as a jurisdictional bar, because tribunal jurisdiction derives from treaty-based consent that Tanzania has never withdrawn at the treaty level. Tanzania ratified the ICSID Convention in 1992 without any Article 25(4) notification excluding natural-resource disputes, and its BITs extend consent to natural-resource investments without any carve-out. The post-2017 record of ICSID claims confirms that investors continue to access arbitration despite the prohibition. Drawing on South Africa’s Protection of Investment Act, 2015, which establishes a conditional gateway prioritizing domestic remedies while preserving international recourse, the article argues that a conditional gateway adapted to Tanzania’s ICSID membership would achieve the objectives that motivated the 2017 reforms without the treaty conflict and uncertainty that the blanket prohibition generates. The article concludes that the path to sovereignty lies not in excluding international arbitration, but in conditioning access to it in a manner that is coherent, predictable, and consistent with Tanzania’s international obligations.
Abstract. Indian constitutional law has said for almost half a century that bail is the rule and jail the exception. The prisons say otherwise. At the end of 2024, nearly three of every four persons held in Indian jails had not been convicted of anything, and a significant share of them had been waiting for more than a year. This article examines the distance between the doctrine and the daily practice of pre-trial detention. It traces the constitutional foundations of pre-trial liberty in Articles 21, 22 and 39A, the statutory scheme under the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 and its successor, the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, and the line of Supreme Court decisions from Hussainara Khatoon to Satender Kumar Antil. It argues that the failure is not one of principle but of design. Monetary sureties, thin legal aid at the first production, mechanical remand, reversed presumptions under special statutes and the absence of any binding time limit on trial together convert a liberal rule into a custodial reality that falls hardest on the poor. The article closes with proposals for a dedicated bail law and for institutional changes that would make the rule enforceable rather than aspirational.
Abstract. The use of custodial torture is a pervasive problem that has gone unaddressed by the state for too long. According to parliamentary records, there were approximately 140 to 176 deaths per year in police custody during the last five years (2021–22 to 2025–26). However, independent studies indicate that no police officer was convicted for a death in custody between 2018 and 2022. The recent introduction of three new laws, the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 and the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023, which replace the Indian Penal Code, the Code of Criminal Procedure and the Indian Evidence Act, provided an opportunity to address this accountability gap. This article argues that the opportunity was missed. The new codes maintain the colonial framework for addressing custodial offences, continue to provide immunity to public officials through the “sanction” requirement for prosecution, continue to fail to define torture, and, in at least one area, the staggered police custody allowed by Section 187 of the BNSS, increase the vulnerability of individuals to custodial abuse. This article also reviews the evolution of constitutional jurisprudence under Article 21 from Sunil Batra and Nilabati Behera to D.K. Basu and Paramvir Singh Saini, and demonstrates how judicial protections have been weakened by inadequate compliance. Finally, it reviews India’s international obligations under human rights law and its continued non-ratification of the UN Convention against Torture. The article concludes that impunity in India is institutionalised rather than random, and recommends a single anti-torture law, a statutory presumption of custodial responsibility, independent investigations, and complete implementation of the Prakash Singh recommendations with emphasis on Bihar.
Abstract. In a “digital arrest” fraud, callers posing as police, customs or central-agency officers convince a victim over video that she is under investigation and must move her savings into a “verification” account to avoid arrest. The victim makes the transfers herself. That single fact has shaped how Indian law allocates the loss. Because the payment is authenticated by the customer, it falls outside the “unauthorised transaction” framework that has governed bank liability since 2017, and the victim usually bears the whole loss. This paper examines whether that allocation can be defended and what should replace it. It combines doctrinal analysis of the Reserve Bank of India’s 2017 Circular, the Responsible Business Conduct Third Amendment Directions, 2026, consumer law and the Supreme Court’s continuing suo motu proceedings with analysis of official data placed before Parliament and the Court, and a comparative study of the United Kingdom, the European Union, Singapore and Australia. Reported digital-arrest losses rose from ₹91.14 crore in 2022 to ₹1,935.51 crore in 2024, and the average reported loss per complaint rose from about ₹22,800 to about ₹1.57 lakh. The 2026 Directions bring coerced payments within the definition of a fraudulent transaction, but a coerced customer who took reasonable care falls under none of their liability rules, and their compensation mechanism covers only negligent customers’ losses of up to ₹50,000, once in a lifetime, for a single year. The paper argues that coercion is not negligence, that banks are the cheapest avoiders of this loss, and that the bank hosting the mule account should share it. It proposes a statutory Coerced Payment Reimbursement Scheme built on a presumption of reimbursement, an equal split between sending and receiving banks, a meaningful cap and a narrow gross-negligence exception.
Abstract. Despite the role of collective bargaining in fostering industrial harmony and mutual engagement, Collective Bargaining Agreements (CBAs) in the Nigerian public sector have largely remained ‘paper tigers’, characterised by a persistent lack of enforceability. This study investigates the legal and institutional challenges responsible for this problem. Adopting a socio-legal approach that combines doctrinal legal research, semi-structured interviews with selected participants and the theoretical norms of Industrial Democracy and Marxian class struggle, the findings reveal that the unenforceability of CBAs in Nigeria is deeply rooted in the courts’ continued application of the rigid common law principle of “non-justiciability” (unenforceability in court) to collective agreements, which has resulted in conflicting pronouncements by the Supreme Court of Nigeria, the Court of Appeal and the National Industrial Court of Nigeria. In addition, the negotiation process suffers from a pervasive absence of good faith and from conflicts of interest on the part of both the government employer and the trade unions, exacerbated by the multiplicity of unions in the Nigerian labour environment. The study concludes that these challenges have continued to promote cycles of industrial unrest and agitation. It therefore recommends legislative reforms to recognise the right to enter into CBAs explicitly as a fundamental right under Chapter IV of the 1999 Nigerian Constitution and to codify their enforceability under the Trade Disputes Act 2004; judicial intervention to resolve the conflicting judgments on the enforceability of CBAs; limits on the ministerial veto over CBAs; regulation of the registration of labour unions; and standard negotiation norms and guidelines to instil a culture of good faith in collective bargaining, among others.
Abstract. The rapid digitization of public discourse in India has fundamentally transformed the dynamics of individual reputation and freedom of speech. While social media platforms serve as vital conduits for expression, they have simultaneously become prolific conduits for defamatory content. Central to this digital legal dilemma is the doctrine of ‘Safe Harbour’ codified under Section 79 of the Information Technology Act, 2000, which shields intermediaries from liability for third-party user content. This research paper critically examines the evolutionary trajectory of intermediary accountability in online defamation cases in India over the past decade. The study traces the legal jurisprudence originating from the landmark judgment in Shreya Singhal v. Union of India (2015), which established the requirement of prior court orders or administrative notifications to trigger intermediary liability, to the heightened compliance regime introduced by the Information Technology (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics Code) Rules, 2021. Furthermore, it analyzes contemporary judicial friction, particularly highlighting the constitutional challenges and litigation involving X Corp (formerly Twitter) regarding state-mandated takedown orders, user privacy, and global injunctions. Incorporating the legislative transition towards the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), 2023 and Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam (BSA), 2023, this paper evaluates the delicate constitutional balance between safeguarding personal reputation under Article 21 and preserving freedom of expression under Article 19(1)(a) in cyberspace. The paper concludes by proposing a refined framework for intermediary accountability that mitigates administrative overreach while ensuring effective and swift remedies for victims of digital defamation.
Abstract. The Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 (DPDP Act) is India's principal legislative response to the growing importance of personal data in a digitally connected society. It establishes obligations for entities that determine the purpose and means of processing digital personal data and recognises rights for the individuals to whom such data relates. The Act is also part of a larger constitutional conversation about informational privacy, dignity, autonomy, free expression and democratic accountability. The central difficulty is not whether privacy or expression should prevail in every case, but how law can protect both without allowing one interest to become an automatic veto over the other. This paper critically examines the constitutional and statutory relationship between the right to privacy under Article 21 and freedom of speech and expression under Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution of India. It focuses on the consequences of data protection regulation for journalism, public interest reporting, research, access to government-held information and the right to know. Particular attention is paid to the structure of the DPDP Act, its consent and legitimate-use framework, the exemptions in section 17, the amendment to section 8(1)(j) of the Right to Information Act, 2005 through section 44(3), and the phased commencement of the Act and the Digital Personal Data Protection Rules, 2025. The research adopts a doctrinal and analytical methodology. It studies constitutional text, legislation, delegated rules, leading judicial decisions and comparative materials, especially Article 85 of the European Union General Data Protection Regulation.
Abstract. The private sector is one of the key drivers of Vietnam’s economy; yet, amid deep international integration and global digital transformation, it faces a range of new challenges. Drawing on the theoretical foundations of the freedom to conduct business, property rights and the principle of equal competition, and combining doctrinal legal analysis with official statistical data, including the preliminary results of the 2026 Economic Census, this article analyses the current legal framework governing private sector development, identifying institutional shortcomings, inconsistencies in implementation and the internal limitations of private enterprises. In particular, it clarifies the guiding role of Resolution No. 68-NQ/TW of the Politburo and its concretisation through Resolution No. 198/2025/QH15 of the National Assembly, which introduces breakthrough policies on taxation, land, credit and administrative procedures. The article proposes solutions to improve the law, enhance the effectiveness of its implementation and strengthen the competitiveness of the private sector, thereby contributing to making the private sector the most important driver of the national economy in the era of national rise.
Abstract. India’s Designs Act, 2000 protects the look of a product for up to fifteen years. Unlike the Trade Marks Act, 1999, it says nothing about passing off. Passing off is a court-made remedy that stops one trader from pretending to be another. Because the Act is silent, the Delhi High Court has given different answers for forty years to one question: can the owner of a registered product shape also sue for passing off? This paper uses the doctrinal method. It reads the relevant laws, compares the main cases from 1983 to 2025, and checks them against scholars’ views on shape and brand identity. It finds that the silence is a gap and not a ban, because no judgment rests on an express rule against passing off. In November 2025 the Supreme Court left the question open, so the law can still change. The paper argues that Parliament should add a clear saving clause with safeguards. The safeguards would require proof that the public links the shape to one seller, keep useful shapes free for all, and fit the relief to the harm done.
Abstract. Section 3(k) of the Patents Act, 1970 excludes mathematical and business methods, computer programmes per se and algorithms from patentability. But it is not an absolute restriction. The 2002 Amendment Act added the suffix “per se” to computer programmes. Many judicial precedents have taken a progressive and positive view where a technical effect, contribution or advancement is involved. Since 2013, the Indian Patent Office has also issued four sets of Guidelines for Computer-Related Inventions (CRI), the most recent in July 2025, in an attempt to bring clarity to CRI patents. This paper undertakes a critical analysis of the CRI Guidelines, 2025. It analyses whether the Guidelines’ treatment of business methods is consistent with the Delhi High Court’s holding in OpenTV Inc. v. Controller of Patents and Designs that the business-method exclusion is absolute. Second, it examines whether the disclosure obligations the Guidelines impose on algorithm and computer-programme claims, particularly for AI, machine-learning and blockchain inventions, exceed the sufficiency standard contemplated under Section 10(4) and the Patents Rules, 2003.
Abstract. Emergency powers are intended to uphold a constitutional order, yet in both Germany and India they have been used at times against the order they were designed to uphold. This article explores the abuse of the emergency provisions in each system and how each re-established its safeguards. The purpose is to establish which protections are the most effective. It employs a comparative doctrinal method to evaluate constitutional and statutory texts, judicial decisions, official reports and literature from both countries. It discusses how Article 48 of the Weimar Constitution, vague and without a regulating statute, enabled rule by presidential decree, the Reichstag Fire Decree and the Enabling Act of 1933, and how Articles 352 and 356 of the Indian Constitution enabled the Emergency of 1975–77 and repeated misuse of President’s Rule. It then considers the corrective measures adopted: in Germany, the Basic Law of 1949, the emergency constitution of 1968 and the oversight of the Federal Constitutional Court; in India, the Forty-fourth Amendment and the judicial doctrine developed through Kesavananda Bharati, Maneka Gandhi and S.R. Bommai. The comparison reveals that both regimes collapsed through ambiguous triggers, inadequate political balances and courts that did not restrict the executive in time, and that both now rely on legislative supermajorities, temporal limits and a protected core of rights. German protections are largely enshrined in the constitutional text, but India’s are based more on judicial theory, and emergency-type authorities are increasingly exercised through ordinary law, as in the case of ordinances and communication shutdowns. The paper concludes that no single measure is sufficient. The best defence is a layering of a clear constitutional trigger, a supermajority in the legislature, time restrictions, entrenched rights, and an independent court ready and able to evaluate emergency action on the merits.
Abstract. “Digital arrest” scams are among the fastest-growing cybercrimes today. A scammer appears on a video call dressed as a police officer, judge or government official, flashes fake arrest warrants, makes frightening legal threats and keeps the victim on the call for hours, sometimes days. Cut off from family and friends, frightened and exhausted, victims end up paying large sums of money to avoid going to jail. Indian law does not recognise “digital arrest” at all. The phrase does not appear in the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), 2023, the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), 2023, or the Information Technology (IT) Act, 2000; it is simply a popular label. When these cases reach the police, several different provisions therefore have to be pieced together: Section 204 BNS (personating a public servant), Section 308 BNS (extortion), Section 318 BNS (cheating), Section 336 BNS (forgery), Section 66C of the IT Act (identity theft) and Section 66D of the IT Act (cheating by personation using a computer resource). These provisions were written for ordinary crimes. Each covers only a piece of the scam, and none covers the crime as a whole. There is no offence of “digital confinement” either: the wrongful confinement provision (Section 127 BNS) was written with physical detention in mind, and so does not fit a victim held captive over a video call. Cases are also often charged as cheating (Section 318), even though they look more like extortion (Section 308): victims do not pay because they were promised a gain, but because they are afraid of being arrested. Reliance on so many scattered provisions leads to confusion and gaps in the law. It slows the freezing of stolen money and often results in weak punishment for the organised gangs behind these scams.
Abstract. Farmers have been saving seeds for ages. Since time immemorial, they have saved their seed for the following crop. But there is no room for saving seeds in patent laws. When an invention is patented, the owner of the patent can prevent others from using, selling or manufacturing it. Seeds will be infringing every time they grow. Hence, the farmer is left with no option but to purchase the seed from the patentee every time. This is the point of conflict: farmers have the right to save seeds which they want to grow again, whereas the patentee has an exclusive right to sell them. This article seeks to examine the conflict between farmers’ rights to save seeds and patentees’ rights, with special reference to India. Seeds are excluded from patent protection under Section 3(j) of the Patents Act, 1970, but biotechnological companies have been granted patents for the genes or characters possessed by seeds. Certain rights exist for farmers under the Protection of Plant Varieties and Farmers’ Rights Act, 2001 and various international treaties. Farmers are in safe hands where rights over a plant variety are concerned, but the rights that exist for a patent on a seed leave them exposed to infringement claims. This article concludes with suggestions to help bridge the gap between the two.
Abstract. Institutional records can be accurate yet insufficient to justify consequential judgments about a person’s character, credibility, or future capacity. This article asks when that gap amounts to wrongful institutional misrecognition rather than ordinary evidential uncertainty. Using a purposive critical-interpretive synthesis of narrative identity, recognition theory, epistemic injustice, classification studies, privacy, and reasoned administration, it develops the Principle of Narrative Non-Exhaustion (PNE). The principle holds that an institution must justify the inferential distance between a purpose-bounded record and the wider conclusion on which it acts. Its distinctive concern is inferential overreach, including implicit generalizations through repeated decisions, not mere record inaccuracy or the duration of an algorithmic label. A refined Narrative Non-Exhaustion Review differentiates consequentiality and generalization gateways and evaluates scope, warrant, voice, revisability, and proportionality. A hypothetical professional-safeguarding case involving proven misconduct, subsequent remediation, uncertain risk, and third-party safety demonstrates how a restrictive decision may remain justified without treating a historical finding as an immutable identity. The paper situates this proposal alongside administrative reasonableness, contextual integrity, procedural fairness, and temporal authorship, acknowledging substantial overlap rather than asserting a new positive-law right. Its contribution is an operationally precise specification of what reasoned, non-exhaustive institutional judgment demands, together with decision standards and limitations requiring future empirical testing.
Abstract. Dark patterns, namely manipulative interface designs that influence users’ decisions by exploiting cognitive biases, have emerged as a major challenge to consumer protection in the digital economy. While the European Union (EU) has developed a comprehensive regulatory framework for addressing dark patterns, Vietnamese law still lacks explicit legal provisions specifically governing these practices. Against this background, this paper examines the EU’s legal approach to dark patterns and explores its implications for Vietnam. Employing doctrinal legal research together with legal analysis and comparative legal methods, the study analyses the concept, characteristics and harmful impacts of dark patterns, examines the interaction among the EU’s principal regulatory instruments, and identifies the key features of the EU regulatory model. The findings indicate that the EU does not regulate dark patterns through a single legislative instrument. Instead, it has established an integrated regulatory framework that combines consumer protection law, data protection law and digital platform regulation to safeguard consumer autonomy. Nevertheless, challenges remain in distinguishing legitimate persuasive design from unlawful manipulative design and in ensuring coherent application across different regulatory instruments. Building on these findings, the paper proposes several recommendations for Vietnam in developing an appropriate legal approach to dark patterns. Academically, the study contributes to the growing scholarship on digital consumer protection by offering a systematic analysis of the EU regulatory model and demonstrating its value as a reference for future legal development in Vietnam.
Abstract. The Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 is India’s first comprehensive statute on the processing of digital personal data, enacted in response to the Supreme Court’s recognition of privacy as a fundamental right in 2017. This paper examines whether the provisions of the Act that favour the State, namely its exemption for notified instrumentalities, its non-consensual “legitimate use” ground, its power to call for information, and the accompanying amendment to the Right to Information Act, 2005, satisfy the proportionality standard that the Court laid down for restrictions on privacy. The study is doctrinal and comparative. It reconstructs the constitutional standard from the Court’s privacy and Aadhaar decisions, applies its components of legality, legitimate aim, necessity and procedural safeguards to the statutory text, and draws on European and American authority to test its conclusions. The paper argues that the aims pursued are constitutionally acceptable, but that the Act fails the tests of necessity and procedural safeguards. It disapplies the entire statute by executive notification, retains no baseline security or accountability duties for exempted bodies, provides no independent prior authorisation or post-facto notice, and entrusts oversight to a Board whose members are appointed by the executive. The paper concludes that these defects are architectural rather than incidental, and proposes statutory reforms, including tailored exemptions, an express necessity standard, independent authorisation, transparency reporting and a restored public-interest override, together with an interpretive route open to the courts.
Abstract. Environmental degradation and climate change have emerged as critical challenges to constitutional governance, human dignity and sustainable development. In India, the constitutional recognition of environmental protection has progressively evolved through judicial interpretation, particularly by expanding the scope of Article 21 of the Constitution to encompass the right to a clean and healthy environment. This paper examines the emergence of eco-centric jurisprudence in India and analyses the transformation of environmental protection from a legislative and policy-oriented concern into an enforceable dimension of fundamental rights. It explores the contribution of constitutional provisions, particularly Articles 14, 21, 48A and 51A(g), in establishing environmental protection as a shared responsibility of the State and citizens. It further examines the role of environmental legislation, judicial activism and Public Interest Litigation in strengthening environmental governance. Through an analysis of landmark judicial pronouncements, the paper traces the evolution of environmental jurisprudence and the incorporation of fundamental environmental principles, including sustainable development, the Public Trust Doctrine, the Precautionary Principle, the Polluter Pays Principle, Common but Differentiated Responsibilities and Intergenerational Equity. Particular attention is devoted to the Supreme Court’s evolving approach towards climate justice, especially its recognition in M.K. Ranjitsinh v. Union of India of the constitutional right to be free from the adverse effects of climate change under Articles 14 and 21. The paper argues that climate-related harm disproportionately affects economically disadvantaged and vulnerable communities, thereby raising concerns of substantive equality, human dignity and constitutional accountability. It also identifies institutional weaknesses in environmental enforcement and the limitations of existing regulatory mechanisms. Finally, it advocates comprehensive climate change legislation, stronger institutional accountability, effective environmental adjudication and enforceable ecological safeguards. The paper concludes that India’s transition towards eco-centric constitutionalism requires a rights-based and intergenerational approach that reconciles developmental priorities with ecological preservation and advances substantive climate justice for present and future generations.
Abstract. The Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 (‘LARR Act’ or ‘the Act’) was enacted as India’s constitutional and legislative answer to more than a century of State-centric, compensation-poor land acquisition under the colonial Land Acquisition Act, 1894. It sought to fuse two guarantees, a quantified right to fair compensation and a procedural right to transparency through Social Impact Assessment, public hearing and consent, into a single rights-based framework for eminent domain. This article undertakes a doctrinal and critical evaluation of that framework. It traces the constitutional trajectory from the extinguishment of the fundamental right to property in 1978 to the residual protection under Article 300-A; examines the architecture of compensation, rehabilitation and resettlement, and transparency under the 2013 Act; analyses the principal judicial pronouncements interpreting the Act, in particular the Constitution Bench ruling in Indore Development Authority v. Manoharlal; and interrogates the systematic legislative dilution of the Act through the 2014-15 Amendment Ordinances and a wave of State amendments upheld by the Supreme Court in G. Mohan Rao v. State of Tamil Nadu. The article argues that although the LARR Act represents a significant normative advance over its predecessor, the gap between its transformative text and its administrative and political implementation has produced a fragmented and increasingly hollowed-out regime of land acquisition, and concludes with proposals for statutory and institutional reform.
Abstract. Social media platforms have become important retail channels for informal traders in Tanzania, yet customers must judge product quality from photographs and written descriptions without physical inspection. This study assessed the influence of perceived product quality on customers’ purchase decisions in a digital retail environment, using the Mtu Outfit Association at Kariakoo Market, Dar es Salaam, as a case. Guided by the Theory of Perceived Risk, a quantitative, descriptive–explanatory case study was conducted. A structured five-point Likert-scale questionnaire was administered to 100 customers selected by simple random sampling; 90 valid questionnaires (90.0%) were analysed in SPSS version 26 using descriptive statistics, Pearson correlation and multiple linear regression. The quality scale was reliable (Cronbach’s α = 0.80). Perceived product quality recorded a high mean score (M = 3.69, SD = 0.66); 73.3% of respondents agreed that the clothing items were of good quality, but only 57.8% agreed that online images and descriptions reflected the actual product and 53.3% that advertised and delivered items differed little. Perceived product quality was positively correlated with purchase decision (r = 0.487, p < 0.001) and remained a significant independent predictor after controlling for perceived trust and perceived risk (β = 0.279, p = 0.003). The findings indicate that product quality perceptions shape purchase decisions, and that the gap between online presentation and delivered products is the main weakness. Traders should improve the accuracy of photography and descriptions, and the Association should adopt a shared standard for digital product presentation.
Abstract. The Constitution protects queer expression, yet, the authors contend, the state continues to police queer expression. This dichotomy forms the central contradiction explored in this paper. This paper also explores the belief that “media influence” is misinterpreted as indoctrination or propaganda and argues that visibility challenges normative power dynamics rather than “creating identities”. In India, through mechanisms of legal and algorithmic data regulations in the guise of morality and protection, content suppression through bureaucratic ethics and technical adherence is now, the authors contend, passively used to regulate social media queer expression. The authors argue that the legislature’s reluctance to codify provisions to secure equal protection for achieving equality has resulted in constitutionally void promises. This study argues that the Indian state persists in regulating LGBTQ++ visibility while denying any intention to discriminate, through examination of important judicial rulings, regulatory frameworks and case studies.
Abstract. Community-based forest management plays an important role in promoting sustainable forest management, enhancing local participation in forest governance, conserving biological diversity and improving the livelihoods of forest-dependent communities. In Cameroon, the introduction of the concept of community forestry under Law No. 94/01 of 20 January 1994 to lay down Forestry, Wildlife and Fisheries Regulations was intended to decentralize forest management by granting local communities access to and responsibility for managing forest resources. This initiative made Cameroon one of the first Congo Basin countries to legally recognize community forests. However, community forestry in Cameroon continues to face significant legal, administrative and financial challenges. Adopting an analytical and doctrinal legal research approach, this article examines the legal and administrative framework governing the exploitation of community forests in Cameroon, with particular attention to community forests in the Mount (Mt.) Cameroon region. It identifies the key requirements that must be fulfilled before exploitation may commence and analyses the constraints that hinder compliance, particularly lengthy administrative procedures, high transaction costs, inadequate technical and financial capacity, weak accountability mechanisms and elite capture of community forest resources and benefits. The article concludes by recommending legal, administrative and institutional reforms aimed at enhancing the effective implementation and long-term sustainability of community-based forest management in Cameroon.
Abstract. This article critically examines the legal and institutional frameworks governing the enforcement of mediated settlement agreements in commercial insurance disputes within Mainland Tanzania, offering a comparative analysis with the legal system of England and Wales. It evaluates whether the statutory architecture anchored in the Constitution of the United Republic of Tanzania, the Insurance Act, the Arbitration Act, and the Civil Procedure Code provides an effective, binding, and directly executable pathway for policyholders and commercial actors when underwriters default post-settlement. The analysis demonstrates that while Tanzania possesses constitutional and legislative encouragement for Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR), the enforcement framework suffers from structural fragmentation. Settlements reached before administrative bodies such as the Tanzania Insurance Ombudsman lack direct statutory executive force and are downgraded upon default to simple contracts under the common law doctrine of accord and satisfaction. Consequently, aggrieved parties are legally compelled to institute fresh, protracted breach-of-contract lawsuits under Order VII of the Civil Procedure Code rather than securing direct execution under Order XXI. Drawing upon doctrinal analysis, comparative legal principles, and access-to-justice theory, the article assesses England’s integrated framework under the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 and the Civil Procedure Rules, which grant statutory finality and direct summary execution to ombudsman awards and mediated agreements. It concludes that statutory reform establishing a direct summary court-registration mechanism is indispensable to realizing commercial certainty and procedural justice in Tanzania.
Abstract. Scheduled Tribe populations in Jharkhand face disproportionately high rates of child undernutrition due to socioeconomic disadvantage, geographical isolation, cultural norms and poor access to healthcare. This systematic literature review, conducted under the PRISMA 2020 guidelines, examines the effectiveness of community health and social work interventions in improving Infant and Young Child Feeding (IYCF) practices among these communities. Fourteen English-language studies published since 2019 were appraised using the Mixed Methods Appraisal Tool (MMAT) and synthesised thematically into five themes: community health worker-led interventions; nutrition education, behaviour change communication and social work approaches; home visits, community participation and integrated support; effects on IYCF practices; and barriers to effectiveness. Interventions led by community health workers, combined with breastfeeding education, home-based counselling and integrated service delivery, improved maternal knowledge, breastfeeding, complementary feeding and service use. Sustained change, however, requires culturally relevant, community-based interventions supported by stronger health systems and action on the social determinants of health. The findings offer guidance for policy, professional practice and research on maternal and child nutrition in vulnerable tribal communities.
Abstract. The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS) adds a sixth kind of punishment, community service, to the list of sentences that Indian criminal courts may impose, and it keeps and extends the idea that a person who offends again deserves a heavier sentence. This article examines both developments. It argues that community service is a welcome but thinly drafted reform, confined to six provisions and left without operational detail, and that the repeat-offender provisions are a patchwork that sits uneasily with settled sentencing principles. Drawing on the statutory text, Supreme Court precedent on reformative sentencing and proportionality, and Articles 14, 20, 21 and 23 of the Constitution, the article ends with concrete proposals for rules, safeguards and legislative amendment.
Abstract. Property offences under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 distinguish dishonest taking, compelled delivery, violence associated with appropriation, and conjoint participation in robbery. This article examines theft, extortion, robbery and dacoity through a doctrinal comparison of sections 303, 308, 309 and 310. It argues that their relationship is best understood as a framework of distinct ingredients rather than a mechanical ladder of increasing seriousness. The analysis considers possession, consent, the causal role of fear, immediacy of danger and proof of participation. Earlier decisions under the Indian Penal Code remain useful where the relevant language is materially retained, but must be applied with attention to statutory differences. Accurate classification requires proof of each aggravating circumstance, particularly the connection between violence and taking and the numerical threshold for dacoity.
Abstract. This research analyses the evolution of trademarks from source-identifying signs into commercial assets that lead to business growth and brand recognition and help businesses to trade globally. Trademarks help to differentiate and identify goods, which makes choice easier for the consumer. This builds trust and loyalty, and also safeguards the goodwill and reputation of the business. A trademark acts as a shield against infringement, deceptive similarity and counterfeiting. The paper refers to judicial decisions such as Starbucks Corporation v. Sardarbuksh Coffee & Co. and the Puma counterfeiting litigation. These examples show how crucial it is to keep unique brand marks safe from unauthorised use, since such misuse can confuse customers or damage the goodwill tied to a well-known business. The study also looks at how trademarks have grown in importance in e-commerce and digital spaces, where buyers often depend on brand names, logos and other recognisable signs when they choose what to purchase, at a time when commercial dealings cross national borders more than ever before. The paper further explores the economic side of trademark protection. It examines how trademarks connect to what people want to buy, how loyal they stay to a brand, what they are willing to pay, competition in the market and how a company grows. A trusted trademark reduces uncertainty for consumers and makes it easier for them to find the right products and services. For businesses, it gives a reason to invest in quality, reputation and market growth. The paper therefore treats trademark protection as more than a rule of intellectual property law: it is a tool that helps markets to work better and keeps commerce running smoothly. From an international trade perspective, the study discusses two major agreements: the Paris Convention for the Protection of Industrial Property and the World Trade Organization’s Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS). It considers principles such as national treatment, priority rights and the protection of well-known marks under the Paris Convention, and the basic rules of trademark protection that TRIPS sets out, especially in Articles 15, 16 and 20. The paper also considers how domestic trademark laws interact with the shifting demands of global trade. It argues that a good trademark system protects a business’s goodwill, builds consumer trust, encourages fair competition and gives companies greater legal certainty when they seek to grow in domestic or international markets. The journey of a trademark from a simple product label to a valuable business asset shows how much it matters at the crossroads of intellectual property, commerce and global trade.
Abstract. This study examines greenwashing in Mongolia’s food import sector through the ESG marketing activities of companies importing from China, with the aim of identifying shortcomings in its legal regulation and developing policy recommendations. The study used a mixed-methods approach combining quantitative and qualitative research methods, including a comparative analysis of the Mongolian and Chinese legal frameworks, a content analysis of green claims on 247 food products from 8 major supermarkets and 15 online retail platforms in Ulaanbaatar, a survey of 520 consumers, and case studies of the marketing materials of 12 importing companies. In the product sample, 160 of 247 items (64.8%) carried claims coded as green claims. Of those 160 items, 125 (78.1%) were classified as unverified in the materials examined. The most frequent categories were organic (41.3%), natural (38.8%), chemical-free (28.1%) and eco (24.4%). In the Ulaanbaatar convenience sample, 73.5% agreed that they pay attention to green claims and 17.9% agreed that they know how to check certificates. Mongolia’s consumer protection and advertising laws provide a general basis for addressing misleading claims, and its organic-products legislation establishes sector-specific certification and labelling rules. The article proposes clearer substantiation requirements for other environmental claims, better access to certification records, risk-based oversight and guidance for consumers and importers.
Abstract. Indian corporate governance rests largely on imported architecture: the English law of directors’ duties, Anglo-American agency theory and the independent-director model. Recurring failures, from Satyam to IL&FS, suggest that structural borrowing has not by itself secured ethical conduct. This paper asks whether the Mahabharata and Kautilya’s Arthashastra can serve as a principled interpretive resource for Indian corporate law, focusing on the directors’ duty of good faith towards stakeholders under Section 166(2) of the Companies Act, 2013. Using a doctrinal, comparative and textual-interpretive method, it examines rajadharma (office-holding as trust), the Arthashastra’s systems of accounting control, informant-based vigilance and calibrated enforcement (danda), and the Mahabharata’s account of governance failure in the Dyuta Sabha, Vidura’s counsel, and the Gita’s idea of purposeful action (loka-sangraha). These ideas are mapped onto the statutory provisions on independent directors, vigil mechanisms, related-party transactions, auditors’ duties and corporate social responsibility, and compared with the UK model of enlightened shareholder value and the OECD Principles. The paper argues that Section 166(2) is conceptually closer to a trusteeship model than to shareholder primacy, and that the texts illuminate a recurring gap between legal compliance and ethical responsibility, particularly in the position of gatekeepers who remain silent. It also argues that the texts cannot be treated as sources of enforceable law, and it addresses their hierarchical, authoritarian and contested elements. The paper concludes that indigenous thought is best used as a critical aid to interpretation, director education and the reform of enforcement, and it proposes specific measures to give Section 166(2) practical effect.
Abstract. Gendered violence in India is a problem of law, institutions and social attitudes at once. This paper examines how the criminal justice system responds to it, with attention to women and to transgender and other gender-diverse persons. It begins by clarifying the concept of gender and the social roots of abuse, then maps the main settings in which violence occurs (the family, the community and the state) and reviews selected offences: sexual violence, dowry-related deaths, domestic violence, acid attacks, honour crimes and trafficking. The paper then outlines the constitutional, statutory and institutional framework, including the Criminal Law (Amendment) Act, 2013, the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 and the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019, and traces judicial developments through Vishaka, NALSA, Joseph Shine and State of Jharkhand v. Shailendra Kumar Rai. Using a doctrinal method supported by national survey and crime data (NFHS-5 and NCRB), it concludes that existing protections remain inadequate and unevenly enforced, and it proposes measures on enforcement, awareness, counselling, rehabilitation and research.
Abstract. Artificial intelligence (AI) is widespread throughout the world and is used, knowingly and unknowingly, because of the speed of its services. People live under an illusion about AI’s advancement, which creates profound barriers to human security in the digital world, harms people in the real world and creates risks to fundamental human rights. In response to this risk, the European Union has adopted a significant regulatory model, Regulation (EU) 2024/1689 (the EU AI Act). The Act prohibits several AI practices, such as manipulation, and provides risk-based protection so that AI systems are transparent and accountable to people and governments. As a result, AI systems can be reconciled with human safety, security and the protection of fundamental rights. However, incidents of AI manipulation have occurred, including the violation of a child’s right to life, and many other incidents are taking place, especially affecting vulnerable AI users, because many countries lack binding legal protection. Legislation on AI is not limited to technological innovation but also concerns human security, transparency and accountability. Bangladesh produced the draft National Artificial Intelligence Policy 2024 (NAIP) and later the National AI Policy 2026–2030 (Draft v2.0), which provides some important protections for human lives against AI manipulation, including data protection and cybersecurity, grounded in Bangladeshi culture. However, the policy focuses on public services, innovation and economic growth, primarily to fulfil the technological ambitions of Vision 2041 in line with the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). Consequently, human security and protection from AI remain an option rather than a primary goal among the policy’s commitments. Not only Bangladesh but most South Asian countries lack protection for people, especially the vulnerable, against AI manipulation. This qualitative legal research therefore examines the adequacy of AI governance and enforcement in Bangladesh in protecting digital security and fundamental rights. Drawing comparative insights from the EU AI Act, it examines gaps in Bangladesh’s digital legislation and institutional practice and identifies best practices. It also compares practice in the neighbouring countries of India and Pakistan to assess Bangladesh’s position within South Asia’s regional AI governance framework. Through a critical analysis of primary and secondary sources, it finds that Bangladesh and its neighbours have adopted policies but lack adequate protections and binding laws to govern AI systems, leaving people living blindfolded.
Abstract. The international protection of environmental defenders remains fragmented, insufficient, and unevenly applied across regions. This article analyses the bases and limitations of existing protection and demonstrates how an interpretative extension of current legal instruments can strengthen safeguards without awaiting a new treaty. The approach adopted is primarily legal and analytical, based on an examination of relevant international texts. It also relies on doctrinal and critical analysis of international human rights law and environmental law. The analysis shows that the current protection of environmental defenders remains fragmented, insufficient, and unevenly applied across regions. The absence of a specific international legal status, the growing criminalisation of their activities, and the persistence of impunity for violence constitute major obstacles. The study concludes that the international protection of environmental defenders must evolve toward a more dynamic and effective interpretation of existing norms. Interpretative extension makes it possible to respond to contemporary emergencies without relying exclusively on lengthy treaty negotiations. It therefore offers a pragmatic solution for better protecting those who work to safeguard the environment and, ultimately, humanity itself. The study recommends strengthening the evolving interpretation of existing instruments so that the situation of environmental defenders is explicitly taken into account. States should improve cooperation, ensure better implementation of their international commitments, and end impunity for violence. Finally, the Escazú experience should inspire other regions of the world toward the adoption of more effective regional or universal protection mechanisms.
Abstract. Amid population ageing, current policies and practices concerning the care of older persons are largely premised on the assumption that the family is, and should remain, primarily responsible for caring for older persons who require support, with women serving as the principal caregivers. Under this approach, the State assumes fewer responsibilities, while families are expected to shoulder a greater share of the care burden. However, economic, social and demographic changes are undermining families’ capacity to fulfil their caregiving responsibilities, while giving rise to a “triple dilemma” involving the State’s limited capacity, the weakening of the family’s caregiving function, and the underdevelopment of the care economy market. This article examines the functioning of the care economy and the relationship between the family and the State, with particular attention to the roles and responsibilities of these two actors in organising, providing and developing care activities within the framework of existing legislation. On this basis, the article proposes an alternative approach to the allocation of caregiving responsibilities between families and the State, and identifies policy directions that warrant consideration in light of this approach. This shift is expected to contribute to building a more sustainable and equitable care economy capable of responding to growing care needs while expanding women’s employment opportunities and economic participation amid population ageing.
Abstract. Copyright plays a fundamental role in protecting intellectual property in the media and entertainment industry. Films, television programmes, music, literary works, photographs, digital videos and other creative productions depend on copyright protection to safeguard the rights of creators and support commercial exploitation. The rapid growth of digital platforms, online streaming services and social media has transformed the production, distribution and consumption of creative content. At the same time, these developments have intensified challenges relating to digital piracy, unauthorised reproduction, ownership disputes, royalty distribution and the use of copyrighted works in artificial intelligence systems. This paper examines the legal framework governing copyright in the media and entertainment industry, with particular emphasis on India’s Copyright Act, 1957, and relevant international principles. It analyses the protection available to authors, performers, producers, music composers, broadcasters and other stakeholders. It also evaluates challenges associated with digital distribution, licensing agreements, fair dealing and emerging technologies. It argues that an effective copyright regime must balance the commercial interests of rights holders with freedom of expression, public access to knowledge and the legitimate interests of audiences.
Abstract. The increasing complexity of commercial transactions has made the resolution of cross-border commercial disputes more challenging. Such disputes often involve financial irregularities, disputed contractual documents, electronic communications and allegations of fraud, where establishing the facts becomes particularly important. In this context, forensic science can play a useful role in supporting the mediation process. Techniques such as forensic accounting, digital forensics and document examination can help parties understand the nature of a dispute and arrive at more informed decisions. This paper examines the relevance of forensic evidence in resolving cross-border commercial disputes through mediation. It focuses on how the collection, preservation and examination of scientific and digital evidence can help clarify disputed facts, reduce uncertainty and facilitate meaningful settlement discussions. At the same time, it considers practical concerns relating to the authenticity of evidence, confidentiality, data protection and the unequal availability of forensic expertise. The paper further examines the legal framework governing mediated settlements under the Singapore Convention on Mediation and India’s Mediation Act, 2023. It explores whether the effective use of forensic expertise, combined with an appropriate legal framework, can make commercial mediation more reliable and accessible, particularly in disputes involving parties from different jurisdictions. It also highlights the need for suitable safeguards to maintain the integrity of evidence and protect the interests of the parties involved. The paper argues that a meaningful integration of forensic science and mediation can strengthen confidence in alternative dispute resolution and contribute towards a more effective system of international commercial justice.
Abstract. The rising delays, costs, and procedural burdens of the traditional court system have intensified the need for accessible and efficient dispute-resolution mechanisms. Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR), including arbitration, conciliation, mediation, negotiation, and Lok Adalat, has emerged as a practical complement to formal litigation. This article explores how ADR enhances access to justice by offering flexible procedures, lower expenses, greater party autonomy, and confidential, solution-oriented processes. It examines India’s constitutional commitment to equal justice and analyses the statutory framework supporting ADR, particularly Section 89 of the Code of Civil Procedure, the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, and the Mediation Act, 2023. This study also reviews key judicial decisions that have strengthened the foundation and growth of the ADR framework in India. Although ADR has been effective in easing court congestion and encouraging fair, participatory settlements, the study recognizes that challenges remain. It emphasizes the importance of greater public awareness, capacity development, and stronger institutional mechanisms. A comprehensive and inclusive ADR system is vital to building a justice process that is efficient, accessible, and responsive to the needs of all citizens.
Abstract. Debates on artificial intelligence (AI) and patent law have concentrated on two questions: whether an AI system can be an inventor, and whether AI-related inventions fall within patentable subject matter. A third question has been largely neglected: who benefits from AI inventions, and on what terms? This article examines that question through the human right to participate in and enjoy the benefits of scientific progress and its applications, recognised in Article 27 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and Article 15 of the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, and authoritatively interpreted by the Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights in General Comment No. 25 (2020). The article argues that AI patents have a dual character. They can advance the right to science by attracting investment, compelling disclosure and diffusing useful applications in health, disability access and education. They can also undermine it by concentrating control over AI in a small number of firms, restricting access to essential applications, limiting follow-on research and offering only thin disclosure of opaque models. Patent filings in generative AI have grown sharply and are dominated by a handful of large enterprises, which sharpens these concerns. The article then shows that Indian law already contains the materials to read the right to science into patent practice. These include Articles 21, 51(c) and 51A(h) of the Constitution; the purposive approach of the Supreme Court in Novartis; the principles in Section 83 of the Patents Act, 1970; the exclusions in Sections 3(b) and 3(k); the disclosure requirement in Section 10 as elaborated by the Computer Related Inventions Guidelines, 2025; the research exemption in Section 47; and the compulsory licensing and government use provisions. The article concludes with recommendations for examination practice, disclosure standards, research exemptions, access mechanisms and a human rights impact lens in AI patent policy.
Abstract. Generative artificial intelligence has destabilised an assumption embedded in copyright doctrine: that the person who communicates instructions to a machine is also the person who creates the resulting expression. This article examines where Sri Lankan copyright law should draw the line between AI-generated and AI-assisted literary and artistic works. Employing doctrinal and comparative methods, it analyses the Intellectual Property Act, No. 36 of 2003, leading Sri Lankan originality decisions and approaches adopted in the United States, the United Kingdom, the European Union and India. It argues that the statutory requirement of a physical-person author prevents attribution of authorship to an autonomous system, but does not preclude protection for sufficiently original human contributions embodied in an AI-mediated work. It proposes a five-stage Human Creative Contribution Test, proceeding through attribution, expressive specification, effective control and causation, originality, and protection and allocation. The proposed model avoids both automatic copyright for every prompt and indiscriminate denial of protection whenever AI has assisted a human creator. It further recommends evidential disclosure, clarification of partial protection and carefully framed statutory guidance rather than the immediate introduction of machine authorship.
Abstract. Digital markets in the Global South are expanding faster than the legal and institutional safeguards meant to govern them. This paper asks whether the consent-based model of consumer and data protection, which Bangladesh adopted in the Personal Data Protection Act 2026, can protect people whose participation in digital life is shaped by convenience, habit and design rather than deliberate choice. Using Neil Postman’s Huxleyan account of control through pleasure, it argues that consent has become a formal act detached from autonomy: standard-form terms are drafted not to be read, interfaces make acceptance effortless and refusal costly, and the individual has no power to bargain. The study is doctrinal and comparative. It analyses the Contract Act 1872, the Sale of Goods Act 1930, the Consumers’ Right Protection Act 2009 and the Bangla text of the 2026 Act, and compares them with the GDPR, the EU Digital Services Act and India’s data protection and dark-pattern rules. It finds that the 2026 Act perfects the form of consent, requiring affirmative, specific and withdrawable consent, barring contractual waiver of rights and placing the burden of proof on the data-fiduciary. In the provisions examined, however, it does not address conditioned consent or manipulative design, leaves the form of notices to future regulations, relies on fixed fines and allows government direction of the regulator. With uneven digital literacy and a consumer statute built for the sale of goods, these features make imported consent rules weakest where they are most needed. The paper proposes a statutory duty of care for platforms, combining design obligations, prohibited manipulative practices, turnover-linked penalties and regulatory independence.
Abstract. Formal amendment procedures are designed to allow a constitution to change, but they have been repeatedly used to dismantle checks and balances, capture judiciaries and extend executive tenure. This paper examines three responses to that problem: Germany’s express eternity clause in Article 79(3) of the Basic Law, India’s judicially developed Basic Structure Doctrine, and Colombia’s Substitution Doctrine. It also traces the journey of these models to Bangladesh and Malaysia. The study finds that the three doctrines are founded on the same premise: a power derived from a constitution cannot be used to destroy or supersede the original constituent power from which it is derived. They vary in the source of the limit, the identification of the protected core and the institutional risks they pose. Germany gives textual certainty, but the clause still needs to be interpreted. India provides flexibility at the cost of an open-ended list and the prospect of judicial supremacy, as the NJAC verdict demonstrates. Colombia provides a structured test, but its fundamental notion of an “essential element” is vague. The paper takes seriously the counter-majoritarian objection that unelected courts invalidate amendments. It concludes that such limits are defensible only where courts employ them sparingly to protect the democratic order itself. It proposes a “Democratic Minimum Test”, under which a court can strike down an amendment only if it poses a clear threat to the open political processes necessary to challenge and change the law at a later time. The paper concludes with some practical proposals for judicial restraint.
Abstract. Artificial Intelligence (AI) is transforming criminal investigation and forensic science by enabling the rapid analysis of large volumes of digital and physical evidence. The integration of AI into criminal investigations enhances the efficiency of digital forensics, video and image analysis, biometric identification, DNA analysis, ballistic examination and cybercrime detection. Machine learning, computer vision and natural language processing assist investigators in identifying patterns, detecting anomalies, correlating evidence and reducing the time required for manual examination. Compared with traditional forensic methods, AI-driven systems offer greater scalability and automated evidence processing, although their accuracy and reliability depend on data quality, algorithmic design and expert validation. In India, provisions of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS), particularly Sections 173, 176(3) and 185, provide a relevant procedural framework for electronic reporting, forensic crime-scene examination and the audio-video recording of searches. However, the adoption of AI in criminal investigations raises significant concerns regarding algorithmic bias, privacy, transparency, evidentiary reliability and legal admissibility. This study examines the major applications, benefits, limitations and legal implications of AI in criminal investigation, emphasising the importance of human oversight, scientific validation and procedural safeguards. It concludes that AI should function as an assistive investigative technology rather than a replacement for professional judgment and established forensic procedures.
Abstract. Gender neutrality in personal law remains one of the most contested questions in Indian constitutional jurisprudence. Personal laws governing marriage, divorce, succession, maintenance, guardianship, and adoption evolved within patriarchal structures and are deeply tied to religion, custom, and community identity. Although Articles 14, 15, and 21 guarantee equality, non-discrimination, and dignity, these laws continue to contain provisions that are either overtly discriminatory or that perpetuate inequality in practice. This paper critically examines whether Indian personal law has evolved sufficiently to reflect constitutional morality, dignity, and inclusiveness. The paper begins with the constitutional framework, highlighting the tension between equality guarantees and religious freedom under Articles 25 and 26. It traces the judicial journey from State of Bombay v. Narasu Appa Mali (1952), which placed personal laws outside Article 13, to Joseph Shine and Navtej Singh Johar (2018), which emphasised constitutional morality over patriarchal and customary norms. The analysis then turns to Hindu personal law. Despite codification, patriarchal traces persist in the restitution of conjugal rights under Section 9 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 (T. Sareetha; Saroj Rani), in the “natural guardian” provision of the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956 (Githa Hariharan), and in the historical exclusion of daughters from coparcenary rights, remedied by the 2005 Amendment and Vineeta Sharma (2020). The paper observes that formal reform has not always produced substantive equality, as social pressure often prevents women from claiming their rights. In relation to Muslim personal law, the paper discusses polygamy, instant triple talaq (Shayara Bano, 2017), and its criminalisation under the 2019 Act. It also traces the maintenance debate from Shah Bano (1985) through the Muslim Women (Protection of Rights on Divorce) Act, 1986, Danial Latifi (2001) and Mohd. Abdul Samad (2024), and asks whether maintenance frameworks should recognise need and capacity rather than presume that financial dependency and responsibility follow gender. The exclusion of LGBTQ+ individuals is identified as a major limitation. While Navtej Singh Johar decriminalised homosexuality, same-sex couples remain without recognition in marriage, adoption, guardianship, and succession. In Supriyo Chakraborty v. Union of India (2023), the Supreme Court acknowledged discrimination but deferred to Parliament, exposing the limits of judicial activism in family law reform. The paper also considers the Uniform Civil Code debate under Article 44, weighing the argument that a UCC would remove discriminatory practices against the concern that uniformity may impose majoritarian norms and does not by itself guarantee justice, as the Goa civil code illustrates. The paper concludes that gender neutrality must avoid simplistic binaries. Gender-specific protections arose from historical disadvantage and cannot be withdrawn without addressing structural inequality, yet reliance on stereotypes about providers, caregivers, guardians, and heterosexual family forms conflicts with constitutional values. Courts have acted largely incrementally, and political and religious sensitivities slow reform. Genuine gender neutrality therefore requires both legal and social transformation, grounded in human dignity rather than gender stereotypes.