VidhiAagaz
International Journal ofLaw Management & Humanities
ISSN 2581-5369 · Open access
International Journal ofLaw Management & Humanities
Open accessArticlesVol. 9 No. VI (2026)pp. 971–980

Evaluating the Scheme of Punishments under the BNS 2023 Community Service and Enhanced Punishment for Repeat Offenders

0views0downloads
Published 18 November 2026 · pp. 971–980 · Vol. 9 No. VI (2026)
Abstract

The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS) adds a sixth kind of punishment, community service, to the list of sentences that Indian criminal courts may impose, and it keeps and extends the idea that a person who offends again deserves a heavier sentence. This article examines both developments. It argues that community service is a welcome but thinly drafted reform, confined to six provisions and left without operational detail, and that the repeat-offender provisions are a patchwork that sits uneasily with settled sentencing principles. Drawing on the statutory text, Supreme Court precedent on reformative sentencing and proportionality, and Articles 14, 20, 21 and 23 of the Constitution, the article ends with concrete proposals for rules, safeguards and legislative amendment.

Keywords
Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhitapunishmentcommunity servicerepeat offendersproportionalityrehabilitationsentencing
Contents
Full text

Introduction

A penal code is judged in the end by what it does to the people convicted under it. When the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS) replaced the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC), public debate focused mostly on new offences such as mob lynching and organised crime. The changes to the scheme of punishments drew less attention, although they include one genuinely new idea and one inherited idea that has been considerably stretched: community service and enhanced punishment for repeat offenders.1

Section 53 of the IPC recognised five kinds of punishment: death, imprisonment for life, imprisonment (rigorous or simple), forfeiture of property and fine.2 Section 4 of the BNS repeats those five and adds a sixth, community service, in clause (f).3 The expression is explained not in the BNS itself but in an Explanation to section 23 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS), which describes it as work that a court may order a convict to perform, as a form of punishment, for the benefit of the community and without any remuneration.4

Section 75 of the IPC provided for enhanced punishment after a qualifying conviction for certain currency or property offences. Section 13 of the BNS carries forward that approach.5 Other BNS provisions attach specific consequences to repeat convictions or to committing an offence while under a sentence of life imprisonment. Community service can support reform and reparation, while enhanced sentences are often justified on grounds of deterrence and public protection.

This article analyses only these two features of the scheme of punishments. It asks whether community service, as drafted, can realistically work as a penal measure; whether the repeat-offender provisions are principled and proportionate; and how the two fit together. The method is doctrinal: it relies on the statutory text, decisions of the Supreme Court of India and secondary commentary.

Community service and enhanced punishment: a critical analysis

A. The scheme of punishments in outline

Chapter II of the BNS, running from section 4 to section 13, deals with punishments.6 Its basic character remains retributive and deterrent. Most of the maximum sentences are carried over from the IPC, some are raised, and several provisions, such as those on repeat rape offenders, specify life imprisonment in terms of the remainder of the offender’s natural life.7

B. Community service as a penal measure

i. Rationale and strengths

Community service is a non-custodial sanction. The offender stays in society, performs unpaid work of social value and, in theory, repays the harm done through labour rather than through confinement. The United Nations Standard Minimum Rules for Non-custodial Measures, known as the Tokyo Rules, list community service orders among the alternatives to imprisonment that States should develop.8

Community service can avoid the disruption to work and family that accompanies short custodial sentences. It may also reduce pressure on prisons when courts use it in cases that would otherwise result in custody. Its proportionality depends on the hours, conditions and practical demands of the order, as well as on the gravity of the offence.

ii. Weaknesses

(a) A narrow and unexplained selection of offences. Community service appears in only six provisions: sections 202, 209, 226, 303(2) (proviso), 355 and 356(2).9 The Code does not explain why these offences were chosen while other minor non-violent offences, such as petty public nuisance, were left out.

(b) Missing operational detail. The BNSS requires work to benefit the community and be unpaid.10 BNS section 8(4)–(5) expressly addresses imprisonment in default of community service, but the statutes give little operational detail on placement, supervision, safe working conditions or how to distinguish deliberate refusal from inability to comply. The reference to fine amounts in section 8(5) also leaves uncertainty about how to apply the default limits to a service-only order.11

(c) The mandatory character of section 303(2). In the other five provisions, community service is an alternative that the court may select. Under the proviso to section 303(2), by contrast, where the stolen property is worth less than five thousand rupees, the accused is convicted for the first time, and the property or its value is returned, the offender “shall be punished” with community service.12 A mandatory sentence leaves no room for the court to consider the accused’s circumstances, which sits uneasily with the individualised approach to sentencing discussed below in the analysis of case law.

(d) Constitutional questions. The rule that the convict is not “entitled to any remuneration” raises a question under Article 23 of the Constitution, which prohibits forced labour.13 The better view is that court-ordered work is a lawful penal measure, since Article 23(2) allows the State to impose compulsory service for public purposes and the Supreme Court has accepted hard labour as part of rigorous imprisonment.14 Equality is a further concern. If the work assigned depends on the offender’s gender, disability, age or social standing, differential treatment may invite a challenge under Article 14.15

(e) Section 226 and mental health. The BNS omits the general offence of attempting suicide but retains a narrower offence requiring intent to compel or restrain a public servant in the discharge of official duties. Section 115 of the Mental Healthcare Act, 2017 expressly refers to IPC section 309 and separately imposes a governmental duty to provide care, treatment and rehabilitation. That provision supports a care-oriented response, while its express reference to section 309 calls for care in assessing its application to a BNS prosecution.16

C. Enhanced punishment for repeat offenders

i. Rationale and strengths

A prior conviction can support an argument for deterrence or incapacitation, particularly when the new offence shows persistent serious harm. It can also demonstrate that an earlier sanction failed to prevent recurrence, though it does not establish why. Section 13 sets out a general enhancement for specified offences.17 Section 303(2) places the repeat-theft rule in the main subsection and the first-conviction community service rule in its proviso.18 Sections 71 and 143(6) address specified repeat convictions, while sections 104 and 109(2) turn on the offender already being under a life sentence.19

ii. Weaknesses

(a) Scope of section 13. The earlier conviction must be by a court in India for an offence under Chapter X or XVII punishable by imprisonment of three years or more. The subsequent offence must also be punishable under either chapter by imprisonment meeting that threshold. The test concerns the punishment prescribed by law. The sentence actually served does not determine whether the statutory threshold is met.20

(b) No definition of a habitual offender. The Code treats the previous conviction as the only trigger. It does not distinguish between an offender who commits the same theft again and again and an offender whose two convictions are years apart and unrelated in character.

(c) Severity and proportionality. Section 71 allows death or life imprisonment for the remainder of natural life on a second conviction for specified sexual offences. Death sentences are governed by the “rarest of rare” doctrine, and life sentences without any prospect of release raise questions of proportionality and of the reformative purpose that the Supreme Court has repeatedly emphasised.

(d) Proof of the previous conviction. BNSS section 234(7) requires the fact, date and place of the previous conviction to be stated in the charge when the prosecution intends to rely on it for enhancement. In a Sessions trial, section 259 provides for evidence and a finding on a disputed prior conviction after conviction for the new offence. Section 334 provides modes of proof and requires evidence identifying the accused as the person previously convicted.21

(e) Little attention to rehabilitation. The repeat-offender provisions say a great deal about longer sentences and almost nothing about why the earlier sentence failed.

D. Likely outcomes

If community service is supported by clear rules, trained supervisors and willing host institutions, it could reduce short prison terms for petty offences and give courts a proportionate tool. On the repeat-offender side, the main risk is not under-punishment but over-reach: automatic enhancement and the severe sanctions in section 71 invite constitutional challenge and disparate application unless courts insist on reasoned, individualised sentencing. The first-conviction condition in the community service proviso and the “second or subsequent conviction” rule for theft form one ladder, and the ladder works only if criminal records are accurate and accessible.

Relevant Act and provisions

The principal enactment is the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, read with the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, which supplies the definition of community service and the procedural machinery for sentencing.

Section 4 BNS lists the six punishments, with community service in clause (f).22 Section 23 BNSS (Explanation) defines community service.23 The Probation of Offenders Act, 1958 continues to offer release on probation or after admonition.24

Section Offence Community service
202 Public servant unlawfully engaging in trade Alternative to simple imprisonment (up to one year), fine or both
209 Non-appearance in response to a proclamation under section 84 BNSS Alternative to imprisonment (up to three years), fine or both; a heavier punishment applies to a declared proclaimed offender
226 Attempt to commit suicide to compel or restrain the exercise of lawful power by a public servant Alternative to simple imprisonment (up to one year), fine or both
303(2) proviso Theft of property worth less than ₹5,000, first conviction, property or its value returned Mandatory: the offender “shall be punished” with community service
355 Misconduct in public by a drunken person Alternative to simple imprisonment (up to 24 hours), fine (up to ₹1,000) or both
356(2) Defamation Alternative to simple imprisonment (up to two years), fine or both

Table 1: BNS provisions prescribing community service

Two points about this table deserve emphasis. First, only the proviso to section 303(2) makes community service compulsory; elsewhere the court chooses. Second, the maximum prison terms attached to these offences are short, confirming that community service is intended for the lower end of the offence hierarchy.

Section Trigger Enhanced consequence
13 Prior Indian conviction for an offence under Chapter X or XVII punishable by at least three years, followed by an offence under either chapter meeting the same threshold Life imprisonment or imprisonment of either description up to ten years
303(2) Second or later conviction under section 303 Rigorous imprisonment of one to five years and fine
71 Earlier conviction under sections 64, 65, 66 or 70 (rape and related offences) followed by a conviction under any of them Life imprisonment (remainder of natural life) or death
104 Murder committed by a person already under sentence of life imprisonment Death or life imprisonment (remainder of natural life)
109(2) Attempt to murder by a person under sentence of life imprisonment, where hurt is caused Death or imprisonment for the remainder of natural life
143(6) Convicted of trafficking a child on more than one occasion Imprisonment for the remainder of natural life and liability to a fine

Table 2: Selected enhancement provisions and life-sentence provisions

Theft illustrates the distinction between an offence-specific enhancement and section 13. Section 303(2) provides for up to three years of imprisonment, a fine or both in ordinary cases, subject to its community service proviso. A second or later conviction under that section attracts one to five years of rigorous imprisonment and a fine.25 Section 13 has its own conditions, and any reliance on it alongside the specific theft provision requires a separate legal analysis.26 Article 20(1) bars retrospective imposition of a greater penalty. BNS section 358 preserves relevant liabilities and proceedings under the repealed IPC.27

Analysis of relevant case law

The following Supreme Court authorities concern sentencing under earlier legislation and related constitutional principles. They provide a framework for evaluating the BNS provisions.

Reformative and individualised sentencing. In Mohd. Giasuddin v. State of Andhra Pradesh, the Supreme Court, speaking through Krishna Iyer J., stressed that sentencing should look to the offender’s personal and social circumstances and treat punishment as an instrument of reform, and not merely of retribution.28 This approach supports community service as a policy, but it also exposes the weakness of the mandatory wording in section 303(2): a rule that removes the judge’s discretion is hard to reconcile with a case-by-case, reformative approach.

Proportionality. Soman v. State of Kerala collects the principles of sentencing and insists that a sentence must be proportionate to the gravity of the offence, with the court weighing aggravating and mitigating circumstances.29 For community service, it justifies a gentler response where the harm is small. For repeat offenders, it requires that enhanced punishment be explained in terms of the facts and not applied as a formula.

Death penalty and mandatory sentences. In Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab, the Constitution Bench upheld the death penalty but confined it to the “rarest of rare” cases and required the court to weigh the circumstances of the offender as well as the crime.30 Mithu v. State of Punjab then struck down section 303 of the IPC, which had made death mandatory for a murder committed by a person already serving a life sentence, because a mandatory death sentence denied the court any chance to consider the circumstances.31 Section 104 of the BNS deals with the same category of offenders, and section 71 with repeat sexual offenders, but both allow the court a choice between death and life imprisonment, and not a mandatory death sentence. Read with Mithu, that wording is the constitutionally safer course.

Life imprisonment and the remainder of natural life. In Gopal Vinayak Godse v. State of Maharashtra, the Supreme Court explained that a life sentence ordinarily lasts for the remainder of the convict’s life, subject to lawful remission.32 Swamy Shraddananda (2) v. State of Karnataka and Union of India v. V. Sriharan concern the superior courts’ power to impose special-category life sentences that restrict statutory remission.33 Express natural-life language in the BNS must be examined on its own statutory terms.

Unpaid labour and Article 23. People’s Union for Democratic Rights v. Union of India interpreted forced labour broadly in the context of workers paid below the minimum wage.34 State of Gujarat v. High Court of Gujarat addressed hard labour in prison and equitable wages for prisoners.35 The BNSS expressly defines community service as unpaid. Article 23(2), which permits compulsory service for public purposes subject to its non-discrimination rule, offers a possible justification. The prison-labour cases do not directly decide the validity of unpaid community service under the BNSS.

Offence-specific cases. On defamation, Subramanian Swamy v. Union of India upheld the constitutional validity of criminal defamation, treating reputation as part of the right to life under Article 21.36 Section 356(2) of the BNS keeps the offence while offering community service as a softer alternative. On attempted suicide, Gian Kaur v. State of Punjab held that the right to life does not include a right to die and upheld the IPC offence, but Parliament later narrowed criminal liability through section 115 of the Mental Healthcare Act, 2017, and the BNS dropped the general offence.37 In that light, a narrow offence under section 226 with community service as a sanction should be applied with great caution.

Suggestions and conclusion

A. Suggestions

1.  Framing uniform rules for community service. The Central Government and the States should frame rules under the new procedural law that fix the maximum hours of work, the nature of suitable work, supervising officers, host institutions, a procedure for default or non-compliance, and insurance or safety cover.

2.  A pre-sentence report. Before community service is ordered, the court should be able to call for a short social inquiry report from a probation officer covering the offender’s age, health, occupation, family responsibilities and the suitability of the work.

3.  Restoring discretion in section 303(2). Parliament should consider replacing “shall” with “may” in the proviso, or allow the court to record reasons for choosing another sentence.

4.  Dignity and Article 23 safeguards. The rules should prohibit work that is degrading, hazardous or public in a humiliating way.

5.  Principled expansion and review. The list of eligible offences should be reconsidered against a stated principle, such as minor, non-violent offences with low maximum sentences.

6.  Rethinking section 13. The general provision on enhanced punishment should either be widened or replaced by a clear and principled habitual-offender provision that sets out when an earlier conviction counts, requires reasons for enhancement, and leaves room for discretion.

7.  Sentencing guidelines. India still lacks statutory sentencing guidelines. The Committee on Reforms of Criminal Justice System (2003), chaired by Justice V.S. Malimath, recommended structured sentencing guidance, and the introduction of community service and a new set of enhancements makes that recommendation more pressing.38

8.  Rehabilitation for repeat offenders. Courts and prison authorities should be encouraged to pair longer sentences with counselling, education and release planning, so that the enhanced sentence is not the only response to recidivism.

B. Conclusion

The BNS has made two choices in its scheme of punishments that point in opposite directions. By adding community service, it has accepted, for the first time, that not every offender needs a prison cell or a fine. By retaining and extending the enhanced punishment of repeat offenders, it has reaffirmed that persistence in crime deserves a sterner response. Community service is confined to six provisions, defined in a single Explanation in another statute, and left without rules for its operation, while one provision makes it mandatory in a way that sits uneasily with the Supreme Court’s insistence on individualised, reformative sentencing. The repeat-offender provisions, for their part, range from a dated general rule that covers only two chapters to severe sanctions that depend on the discretion of the sentencing court.

If the executive builds the machinery for community service, and if courts apply the enhancement provisions with reasoned, proportionate and evidence-based sentencing, the BNS could move Indian criminal justice a modest but real step from punishment as mere suffering towards punishment as a response that is proportionate, reformative and accountable. If not, the new sanction will remain a statutory curiosity, and the enhanced penalties will remain a source of litigation and uneven justice.

*****

Footnotes

1. Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, No. 45, Acts of Parliament, 2023 (India) [hereinafter BNS]; Ministry of Home Affairs, Notification S.O. 850(E) (Feb. 23, 2024) (appointing July 1, 2024 for the commencement of the Sanhita, except section 106(2)).

2. Indian Penal Code, 1860, No. 45, Acts of Parliament, 1860 (India) [hereinafter IPC], § 53.

3. BNS § 4.

4. Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, No. 46, Acts of Parliament, 2023 (India) [hereinafter BNSS], § 23, Explanation.

5. IPC § 75; BNS § 13.

6. BNS §§ 4–13; see also West Bengal Judicial Academy, Primer on New Criminal Laws (2024), https://calcuttahighcourt.gov.in/Notice-Files/general-notice/11707 (listing Chapter II as covering sections 4 to 13).

7. BNS § 71.

8. G.A. Res. 45/110, annex, United Nations Standard Minimum Rules for Non-custodial Measures (The Tokyo Rules), r. 8.2(i) (Dec. 14, 1990).

9. BNS §§ 202, 209, 226, 303(2) proviso, 355, 356(2); see also Vageshwari Deswal, Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) 2023 – An Overview, Taxmann (Mar. 6, 2024), https://taxmann.com/post/blog/analysis-bharatiya-nyaya-sanhita-bns-an-overview.

10. BNSS § 23, Explanation.

11. BNS § 8(4)–(5).

12. BNS § 303(2) proviso.

13. India Const. art. 23.

14. India Const. art. 23(2); State of Gujarat v. High Court of Gujarat, (1998) 7 SCC 392 (India).

15. India Const. art. 14.

16. BNS § 226; Mental Healthcare Act, 2017, No. 10, Acts of Parliament, 2017 (India), § 115.

17. BNS § 13.

18. BNS § 303(2).

19. BNS §§ 71, 104, 109(2), 143(6).

20. BNS § 13. Chapter X comprises sections 178 to 188 and Chapter XVII comprises sections 303 to 334.

21. BNSS §§ 234(7), 259, 334.

22. BNS § 4(f).

23. BNSS § 23, Explanation.

24. Probation of Offenders Act, 1958, No. 20, Acts of Parliament, 1958 (India).

25. BNS § 303(2).

26. BNS § 13.

27. India Const. art. 20(1); BNS § 358.

28. Mohd. Giasuddin v. State of Andhra Pradesh, (1977) 3 SCC 287 (India).

29. Soman v. State of Kerala, (2013) 11 SCC 382 (India).

30. Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab, (1980) 2 SCC 684 (India).

31. Mithu v. State of Punjab, (1983) 2 SCC 277 (India).

32. Gopal Vinayak Godse v. State of Maharashtra, AIR 1961 SC 600 (India).

33. Swamy Shraddananda (2) v. State of Karnataka, (2008) 13 SCC 767 (India); Union of India v. V. Sriharan, (2016) 7 SCC 1 (India).

34. People’s Union for Democratic Rights v. Union of India, (1982) 3 SCC 235 (India).

35. State of Gujarat, supra note 14.

36. Subramanian Swamy v. Union of India, (2016) 7 SCC 221 (India).

37. Gian Kaur v. State of Punjab, (1996) 2 SCC 648 (India).

38. Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India, Report of the Committee on Reforms of Criminal Justice System vol. I, ¶ 14.4 (2003).

How to cite

J.Vaishnavi & Lekshmi VS, Evaluating the Scheme of Punishments under the BNS 2023 Community Service and Enhanced Punishment for Repeat Offenders, 9 Int'l J.L. Mgmt. & Human. 971 (2026), https://doi.org/10.63108/IJLMH.13122.

Cite this article

J.Vaishnavi & Lekshmi VS, Evaluating the Scheme of Punishments under the BNS 2023 Community Service and Enhanced Punishment for Repeat Offenders, 9 Int'l J.L. Mgmt. & Human. 971 (2026), https://doi.org/10.63108/IJLMH.13122.
Chat with us