Introduction
A. Rationale of the study
Greenwashing occurs when environmental communication presents a more favourable impression than the available evidence warrants. Delmas and Burbano (2011) examine drivers of misleading environmental communication, while Lyon and Maxwell (2011) model the selective disclosure of environmental performance under threat of audit.
Food labels communicate attributes that consumers may find difficult to assess at the point of purchase. Grunert et al. (2014) examine consumer motivation, understanding and use of sustainability labels on food products.
This study focuses on food products imported from China and sold through selected physical and online retailers in Ulaanbaatar. It examines how environmental claims are presented and what evidence is visible to consumers.
Mongolia’s general consumer and advertising rules apply to misleading product information, alongside specific rules for products marketed as organic. The study examines how these rules could be applied to a broader range of environmental claims.
The study identifies gaps in the treatment of environmental claims in Mongolia’s food import sector and develops policy recommendations.
B. Research aim and objectives
Research aim: To examine greenwashing practices in Mongolia’s food import sector, focusing on the ESG marketing activities of companies importing from China, in order to identify shortcomings in legal regulation and develop policy recommendations.
Research objectives:
• To define the theory, concepts and forms of greenwashing and examine the specific features of greenwashing in the food sector
• To conduct a comparative analysis of the legal frameworks of Mongolia and China on green claims and ESG marketing
• To conduct a content analysis of green claims on food products imported from China
• To examine Mongolian consumers’ attitudes towards green claims, their level of knowledge and their purchasing behaviour
• To analyse the ESG marketing practices of importing companies through case studies
• To identify shortcomings in legal regulation and develop policy recommendations
C. Research methodology
This study used a mixed-methods approach, combining qualitative and quantitative research methods (Creswell & Plano Clark, 2017).
i. Comparative legal analysis
Laws, standards and regulatory documents of Mongolia and China relating to green claims, ESG marketing and consumer protection were analysed comparatively. The legal experience of the European Union and the United States was considered as a benchmark.
ii. Content analysis
A sample of 247 food products imported from China was drawn from 8 major supermarkets in Ulaanbaatar (including Nomin, E-Mart, Orgil, Dalai Eej and Minii Delguur) and 15 online retail platforms (including Unegui.mn, Shoppy.mn and Daalguur.mn), and a content analysis of their green claims was carried out. The analysis covered the following indicators:
• Type of green claim (“organic”, “natural”, “eco”, “chemical-free”, etc.)
• Verification and certification status
• Specificity and substantiation of the claim
• Use of language, imagery and pictures
The content analysis followed the methodology of Krippendorff (2018).
iii. Consumer survey
An online and in-person survey was conducted among 520 consumers aged 18–65 in Ulaanbaatar. Respondents were selected using convenience sampling, i.e., consumers who were accessible and willing to participate online and at retail outlets. The questionnaire included the following sections:
• Consumers’ attitudes towards and trust in green claims
• Level of environmental knowledge
• Purchasing behaviour and decision-making
• Demographic information
The data were processed using SPSS 26.0, and descriptive statistics, correlation analysis and regression analysis were performed.
Ethics and consent. Participation was voluntary. For the in-person survey, respondents gave oral consent before answering. Before the online questionnaire, prospective respondents were invited to continue and answer if they agreed to participate, or to decline and exit without answering.
iv. Case studies
The documentary case studies examined 12 companies importing food products from China. The materials comprised company websites, social media posts, marketing materials and publicly available ESG reports, where available. The analysis focused on the claims, certification information and environmental disclosures visible in those materials. Public materials document companies’ communications and provide limited evidence about internal decisions or motives.
D. Limitations of the study
This study has the following limitations:
• Geographical limitation: The study focused only on Ulaanbaatar and therefore does not fully reflect the attitudes of consumers or import practices in the provinces.
• Sampling limitation: The consumer survey was based on a convenience sample of 520 respondents, and the product content analysis was limited to 247 products.
• Temporal limitation: The study is based on cross-sectional data and therefore did not track changes in greenwashing trends over time.
• The analysis was based on available materials and did not include laboratory testing. The original product-level coding records and respondent-level survey records were unavailable for this revision. The tables report aggregate results preserved in the manuscript, and independent reconstruction or reanalysis requires the original records.
Theoretical and conceptual framework
A. The concept and forms of greenwashing
i. Definition of greenwashing
Delmas and Burbano (2011) examine how positive environmental communication can coexist with poor environmental performance at the firm or product level. Lyon and Maxwell (2011) consider how selective disclosure can produce a favourable impression of a firm’s environmental performance. De Freitas Netto et al. (2020) systematically review definitions and forms of greenwashing, distinguishing firm- and product-level practices and claim-based and executional forms.
ii. Forms of greenwashing
TerraChoice Environmental Marketing (2010) identified the “Seven Sins of Greenwashing”:
1. Sin of Hidden Trade-off: Emphasising a single environmental attribute of a product while concealing its other negative impacts (e.g., claiming to be “energy-saving” while generating large amounts of waste during production).
2. Sin of No Proof: Failing to provide evidence or certification to substantiate an environmental claim (e.g., claiming “100% natural” without any certification).
3. Sin of Vagueness: Using vague, ambiguous wording (e.g., words without a clear definition such as “eco”, “green” or “natural”).
4. Sin of Irrelevance: Providing information that is true but irrelevant to consumers (e.g., claiming to be “CFC-free” when CFCs have already been banned).
5. Sin of Lesser of Two Evils: Claiming that a product from an environmentally harmful category is “green” (e.g., “organic cigarettes”).
6. Sin of Fibbing: Making false environmental claims or citing non-existent certificates.
7. Sin of Worshiping False Labels: Using fake labels that look like official certifications.
The distinction between written claims and executional elements such as imagery helps identify environmental messages conveyed through packaging design (de Freitas Netto et al., 2020).
This study examines the product level through food labels and the company level through public marketing and ESG disclosures.
B. ESG and sustainability marketing
i. The concept and development of ESG
ESG refers to environmental, social and governance considerations in corporate conduct, investment and reporting.
Friede et al. (2015) aggregate findings from more than 2,000 studies and report that most studies find a non-negative relationship between ESG criteria and corporate financial performance.
Gillan et al. (2021) review ESG and corporate social responsibility research in corporate finance, including questions about measurement and firm outcomes.
Serafeim and Yoon (2023) examine how disagreement among ESG ratings relates to market reactions to ESG news.
ii. Sustainability marketing
Peattie and Crane (2005) examine shortcomings in green marketing practice, including the risk that environmental promotion may take precedence over changes to products or business practices.
iii. ESG marketing and greenwashing
In this article, ESG-washing refers to the use of ESG communications to give an excessively favourable impression of environmental performance. Selective disclosure, vague targets and limited evidence of results are indicators that warrant further scrutiny.
C. Greenwashing in the food sector
i. Characteristics of the food sector
Grunert et al. (2014) surveyed 4,408 consumers in six European countries. They reported limited understanding of sustainability as a concept and low use of sustainability labels in food choices.
ii. Organic certification and consumer trust
Janssen and Hamm (2012) used choice experiments and structured interviews with 2,441 organic-food consumers in six European countries. Preferences and willingness to pay varied across certification logos. Familiar logos generally attracted stronger preferences.
Thøgersen et al. (2010) studied early adoption of the Marine Stewardship Council label in Denmark using a mall-intercept survey. Motivation to buy sustainable fish and relevant knowledge were associated with the early stages of label adoption.
iii. Forms of greenwashing in the food sector
Van Loo et al. (2014) examine how consumers value different sustainability labels on meat. The present analysis uses TerraChoice Environmental Marketing (2010) to classify observable features of claims on food products.
D. Legal liability and regulation
i. International legal framework
The UN 2030 Agenda identifies responsible consumption and production as Sustainable Development Goal 12 (United Nations, 2015).
ii. Legal experience of the European Union
Unfair Commercial Practices Directive. Articles 6 and 7 of Directive 2005/29/EC address misleading actions and omissions. Under Article 12, national courts or administrative authorities may require traders to substantiate factual claims where appropriate and may treat those claims as inaccurate if the requested evidence is absent or insufficient.
Directive (EU) 2024/825 amended the consumer protection framework. Its amendments address, among other practices, generic environmental claims without demonstrable recognised excellent environmental performance and sustainability labels that lack a qualifying certification scheme or public authority basis.
Organic Products Regulation. Regulation (EU) 2018/848 regulates organic production and labelling. Article 30 governs terms referring to organic production. Articles 32 and 33 govern labelling and the EU organic logo, whose use is optional for products imported from third countries. Article 45 governs conditions for organic imports.
iii. Legal regulation in China
Law on the Protection of Consumer Rights and Interests. Article 20 of China’s Law on the Protection of Consumer Rights and Interests, as amended in 2013, requires truthful and comprehensive information about goods or services and prohibits false or misleading publicity.
Organic product certification. China’s national standard GB/T 19630-2019 specifies requirements for organic production, processing, labelling and management systems.
iv. Legal regulation in Mongolia
Law on Consumer Rights Protection. Article 7.1 of Mongolia’s Law on Consumer Rights Protection of 26 December 2003 provides: “Consumers have the right to receive factual information about goods to help them make an informed choice” (authors’ translation). Article 7.2 lists information to be provided to consumers. These provisions supply a general basis for assessing the information available to consumers who encounter environmental claims.
Law on Advertising. Article 7.1 of the Law on Advertising of 30 May 2002 classifies advertising that fails to conform to reality as unlawful. Articles 7.2.3 and 7.3 address misleading practices, including omissions and misrepresentations. Article 10.1(4) of the Law on Violations (revised edition of 11 May 2017) provides fines for commissioning, creating or disseminating advertising prohibited by law. The fine is 500 units for an individual and 5,000 units for a legal entity. Article 3.4(3) sets each unit at MNT 1,000, yielding fines of MNT 500,000 and MNT 5,000,000, respectively.
Law on Food. The Law on Food (revised edition of 20 December 2012) forms part of the general food regulatory framework. Organic production, certification, registration, labelling and marketing, including imports, are specifically covered by the revised Law on Organic Products adopted on 17 January 2024 and effective from 1 January 2025. This law postdates the 2023 fieldwork. It is used here to assess the current policy framework.
United States benchmark. The US Federal Trade Commission’s Green Guides, 16 C.F.R. §§ 260.2 and 260.4, explain how general environmental benefit claims and other environmental marketing representations may be deceptive. They recommend specific, prominent qualifications and substantiation for the meanings conveyed.
Research results
A. Content analysis of green claims on food products
i. Prevalence of green claims
A sample of 247 food products imported from China was drawn from 8 major supermarkets and 15 online retail platforms in Ulaanbaatar. The products fell into the following categories: fruits and vegetables (n = 68, 27.5%), beverages (n = 52, 21.1%), dried foods (n = 43, 17.4%), condiments and preserves (n = 38, 15.4%), vegetable oils (n = 26, 10.5%) and other (n = 20, 8.1%). The results showed that 160 (64.8%) of the 247 products carried some kind of environmental claim. This indicates that green claims were widespread among the sampled food products imported from China.
| Product category | Total | With green claims | Percentage (%) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fruits and vegetables | 68 | 52 | 76.5 |
| Beverages | 52 | 38 | 73.1 |
| Dried foods | 43 | 28 | 65.1 |
| Condiments and preserves | 38 | 22 | 57.9 |
| Vegetable oils | 26 | 14 | 53.8 |
| Other | 20 | 6 | 30.0 |
| Total | 247 | 160 | 64.8 |
Table 1: Prevalence of products carrying green claims
Within the sample, the largest proportions of products carrying green claims were recorded for fruit and vegetables (76.5%) and beverages (73.1%).
ii. Types of green claims
The 160 products carrying green claims yielded 312 coded claims (1.95 per product on average). Percentages in Table 2 use 160 products as the denominator. A product could be counted in more than one claim category. Verification rates use the frequency in the corresponding row as the denominator.
| Type of claim | Frequency (n) | Percentage (%) | Verified (n) | Verification rate (%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| “Organic” (有机) | 66 | 41.3 | 8 | 12.1 |
| “Natural” (天然) | 62 | 38.8 | 3 | 4.8 |
| “Chemical-free” (无化学添加) | 45 | 28.1 | 0 | 0.0 |
| “Eco” (生态) | 39 | 24.4 | 2 | 5.1 |
| “Green” (绿色) | 34 | 21.3 | 5 | 14.7 |
| “Healthy” (健康) | 28 | 17.5 | 0 | 0.0 |
| “Pure” (纯净) | 22 | 13.8 | 1 | 4.5 |
| “Sustainable” (可持续) | 16 | 10.0 | 6 | 37.5 |
Table 2: Types and frequency of green claims
The most frequent claims were organic (66 of 160, 41.3%), natural (62 of 160, 38.8%) and chemical-free (45 of 160, 28.1%). The organic category included eight products recorded as verified (8 of 66, 12.1%).
iii. Verification status
The verification status of the 160 products carrying green claims was classified as follows:
| Type of verification | Number (n) | Percentage (%) |
|---|---|---|
| Unverified | 125 | 78.1 |
| Chinese national certificate | 18 | 11.3 |
| International certificate | 12 | 7.5 |
| Company’s internal standard | 5 | 3.1 |
| Total | 160 | 100.0 |
Table 3: Verification status of green claims
Of the 160 products with green claims, 125 (78.1%) were recorded as unverified. The coding also recorded 18 Chinese national certificates, 12 international certificates and five company internal standards. A lack of visible verification indicates a substantiation concern and warrants further checking.
iv. Specificity of claims
The specificity of green claims was assessed within the framework of the “seven sins” of TerraChoice Environmental Marketing (2010):
| Form of greenwashing | Number (n) | Percentage (%) |
|---|---|---|
| Sin of Vagueness | 98 | 61.3 |
| Sin of No Proof | 87 | 54.4 |
| Sin of Hidden Trade-off | 52 | 32.5 |
| Sin of Irrelevance | 34 | 21.3 |
| Sin of Worshiping False Labels | 18 | 11.3 |
| Sin of Lesser of Two Evils | 12 | 7.5 |
| Sin of Fibbing | 7 | 4.4 |
Table 4: Prevalence of forms of greenwashing
Note: A single product may contain more than one form of greenwashing.
The Sin of Vagueness (61.3%) was the most common. For example, “natural” claims did not specify which ingredients they referred to, the word “eco” was not explained in terms of what environmental benefit it denoted, and it was unclear by what criteria “healthy” claims had been assessed. The Sin of No Proof (54.4%) was also high. Most products claimed to be “organic” or “natural” but provided no certificate, laboratory test results or third-party verification.
v. Use of imagery and colour
Among products carrying green claims, 142 (88.8%) predominantly used green, 118 (73.8%) displayed nature imagery, 67 (41.9%) used symbols associated with environmental themes and 54 (33.8%) displayed agricultural imagery. These design features can suggest environmental benefits to shoppers. The analysis assessed the imagery appearing on the packaging and did not measure its effect on consumers.
B. Results of the consumer survey
i. Sample characteristics
The survey was conducted among 520 consumers aged 18–65 in Ulaanbaatar. The demographic characteristics of the sample are as follows:
| Characteristic | Category | Number (n) | Percentage (%) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gender | Male | 218 | 41.9 |
| Female | 302 | 58.1 | |
| Age | 18–25 | 142 | 27.3 |
| 26–35 | 198 | 38.1 | |
| 36–45 | 112 | 21.5 | |
| 46–65 | 68 | 13.1 | |
| Education | Secondary | 87 | 16.7 |
| Higher (bachelor’s) | 356 | 68.5 | |
| Master’s or above | 77 | 14.8 | |
| Monthly income | Up to MNT 1 million | 124 | 23.8 |
| MNT 1–2 million | 218 | 41.9 | |
| MNT 2–3 million | 112 | 21.5 | |
| Over MNT 3 million | 66 | 12.7 |
Table 5: Demographic characteristics of the sample
ii. Attitudes towards green claims
Consumers’ attitudes towards green claims were measured on a 5-point Likert scale (1 = strongly disagree, 5 = strongly agree):
| Statement | Mean | Standard deviation | Agreement (%) (score 4–5) |
|---|---|---|---|
| I pay attention to green claims | 4.12 | 0.87 | 73.5% |
| I trust green claims | 3.68 | 1.02 | 58.3% |
| Green claims influence my purchasing decisions | 3.89 | 0.94 | 65.2% |
| I am willing to pay more for green products | 3.45 | 1.15 | 48.7% |
| I am able to check certificates | 2.34 | 1.08 | 17.9% |
Table 6: Consumers’ attitudes towards green claims
In the sample, 73.5% agreed that they pay attention to green claims, and 17.9% agreed that they are able to check certificates. The latter is a self-assessment.
iii. Level of environmental knowledge
Consumers’ level of environmental knowledge was assessed with a 10-question test (e.g., the definition of organic food, types of certificates and environmental impact assessment):
| Level of knowledge | Score (out of 10) | Number (n) | Percentage (%) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Low | 0–3 | 156 | 30.0 |
| Medium | 4–6 | 268 | 51.5 |
| High | 7–10 | 96 | 18.5 |
| Mean score | 4.82 | 520 | 100.0 |
Table 7: Level of environmental knowledge
The majority of consumers (51.5%) had a medium level of knowledge, while only 18.5% had a high level of knowledge. This indicates a need to raise consumer awareness.
iv. Ability to recognise greenwashing
Consumers were shown examples of TerraChoice’s “seven sins” and their ability to recognise whether these constituted greenwashing was assessed:
| Form of greenwashing | Correctly recognised (%) |
|---|---|
| Sin of Fibbing (fake certificate) | 68.5 |
| Sin of No Proof | 42.3 |
| Sin of Vagueness | 31.7 |
| Sin of Hidden Trade-off | 28.5 |
| Sin of Irrelevance | 24.2 |
| Sin of Lesser of Two Evils | 19.8 |
| Sin of Worshiping False Labels | 52.1 |
Table 8: Ability to recognise greenwashing
Consumers recognised blatantly false claims (the Sin of Fibbing, false labels) relatively well, but their ability to recognise more subtle forms (vagueness, hidden trade-offs) was low.
v. Purchasing behaviour
Consumers’ behaviour in purchasing green products was examined:
| Frequency | Number (n) | Percentage (%) |
|---|---|---|
| Always | 68 | 13.1 |
| Often | 187 | 36.0 |
| Sometimes | 198 | 38.1 |
| Rarely | 52 | 10.0 |
| Never | 15 | 2.9 |
Table 9: Frequency of purchasing green products
Of the 520 respondents, 255 (49.0%) reported that they always or often buy green products. In the separate self-assessment item, 17.9% agreed that they are able to check certificates.
| Reason | Number (n) | Percentage (%) |
|---|---|---|
| Good for health | 412 | 79.2 |
| Environmentally friendly | 298 | 57.3 |
| Safe, chemical-free | 356 | 68.5 |
| Good quality | 287 | 55.2 |
| Suitable for children in the family | 234 | 45.0 |
| Fashion, trend | 98 | 18.8 |
Table 10: Reasons for choosing green products (multiple responses)
In this sample, health (79.2%) and safety (68.5%) were selected more frequently than environmental protection (57.3%).
vi. Relationship between knowledge and behaviour
A correlation analysis was conducted between the level of environmental knowledge and the ability to recognise greenwashing:
| Variable | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Environmental knowledge | 1 | |||
| 2. Ability to recognise greenwashing | 0.624** | 1 | ||
| 3. Certificate-checking behaviour | 0.518** | 0.587** | 1 | |
| 4. Trust in green claims | −0.412** | −0.523** | −0.468** | 1 |
Table 11: Results of the correlation analysis
Note: ** p < 0.01.
Environmental knowledge was positively correlated with recognition of greenwashing (r = 0.624) and negatively correlated with trust in green claims (r = −0.412). Recognition was positively correlated with certificate-checking behaviour (r = 0.587). All three reported correlations had p < 0.01. These are associations within the survey sample.
vii. Regression analysis
A multiple linear regression examined associations with self-reported trust in green claims.
| Explanatory variable | B | SE | β | t | p |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Constant | 4.856 | 0.234 | – | 20.75 | <0.001 |
| Environmental knowledge | −0.187 | 0.042 | −0.268 | −4.45 | <0.001 |
| Age | −0.012 | 0.008 | −0.089 | −1.50 | 0.134 |
| Education | −0.156 | 0.067 | −0.142 | −2.33 | 0.020 |
| Income | 0.034 | 0.045 | 0.045 | 0.76 | 0.449 |
| Frequency of purchasing green products | 0.234 | 0.056 | 0.256 | 4.18 | <0.001 |
Table 12: Results of the regression analysis
Note: R² = 0.387, F(5, 514) = 64.82, p < 0.001.
The model accounted for 38.7% of the variance in reported trust. Environmental knowledge (β = −0.268, p < 0.001) and education (β = −0.142, p = 0.020) were negatively associated with trust. Green purchasing frequency was positively associated with trust (β = 0.256, p < 0.001). The cross-sectional design limits causal interpretation.
C. Case studies of importing companies
i. Case study sample
Twelve companies importing food products from China were selected for study. The companies’ profiles are shown in Table 13.
| Code | Years in operation | Import volume (USD million) | Number of employees | ESG report |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| C1 | 15+ years | 8–10 | 50–100 | Yes |
| C2 | 10–15 years | 5–8 | 30–50 | No |
| C3 | 10–15 years | 5–8 | 30–50 | No |
| C4 | 8–10 years | 3–5 | 20–30 | No |
| C5 | 8–10 years | 3–5 | 20–30 | Yes |
| C6 | 5–8 years | 2–3 | 10–20 | No |
| C7 | 5–8 years | 2–3 | 10–20 | No |
| C8 | 5–8 years | 1–2 | 10–20 | No |
| C9 | 3–5 years | 1–2 | 5–10 | No |
| C10 | 3–5 years | <1 | 5–10 | No |
| C11 | 3–5 years | <1 | 5–10 | No |
| C12 | <3 years | <1 | <5 | No |
Table 13: Profiles of the case study companies
Two of the 12 companies (16.7%) had a publicly available ESG report in the materials examined.
ii. ESG marketing practices
The results of a content analysis of the companies’ websites, social media and marketing materials are shown in Table 14.
| ESG marketing element | Number of companies | Percentage (%) |
|---|---|---|
| Use environmental claims | 10 | 83.3 |
| Claim to be organic/natural | 9 | 75.0 |
| Mention certificates | 4 | 33.3 |
| Provide detailed certificate information | 2 | 16.7 |
| Provide supplier information | 3 | 25.0 |
| Conduct environmental impact assessments | 1 | 8.3 |
| Publish ESG reports | 2 | 16.7 |
Table 14: ESG marketing practices of the companies
Ten of the 12 companies (83.3%) used environmental claims in the examined materials. Two (16.7%) displayed detailed certificate information.
iii. Examples of environmental claims and disclosures
In Case C2, company materials described imported vegetables as organic. The materials examined did not display a certificate or explain the basis of the claim.
In Case C4, a packaging label made a USDA organic certification claim. The materials examined did not show a certificate number or date. The available information was insufficient to confirm the certification status.
In Case C7, the company highlighted packaging as an environmental benefit. The materials examined offered limited information about the scope of that benefit and other stages of the product lifecycle.
In Case C1, the public ESG report gave general environmental commitments. The materials examined provided limited measurable targets, performance results and information on external assurance.
iv. Scope of the documentary findings
The cases show what claim and certificate information was visible in the public materials reviewed. The availability of public evidence varied across companies. The documentary evidence does not establish the companies’ reasons for using environmental claims.
Discussion
A. Interpretation of the key findings
i. Prevalence and substantiation of claims in the sample
The sample included 160 of 247 products (64.8%) carrying green claims. Of those 160 products, 125 (78.1%) were classed as unverified in the materials analysed.
The results identify a gap between the environmental messages visible to shoppers and the substantiation available to them. Verification requires checking the scope, validity and issuer of a certificate against the specific product and claim.
ii. Characteristics of the forms of greenwashing
Vagueness (61.3%) and lack of visible proof (54.4%) were the most frequent categories in the sample. These classifications identify claims that would benefit from closer review. They describe features of the materials examined and do not constitute administrative findings that a specific product violated the law.
iii. The consumer knowledge gap
The survey showed a gap between attention to environmental claims and confidence in checking certificates. Environmental attributes may be difficult for buyers to assess directly. This information asymmetry can make it harder for buyers to distinguish substantiated claims from other claims (Akerlof, 1970).
Knowledge and education were negatively associated with trust in the survey. This result supports examining consumer education and access to verification tools in future intervention studies.
iv. Companies’ ESG-washing practices
The case studies illustrate the value of measurable environmental targets, reporting on performance against those targets and access to supporting evidence. The limited number of public ESG reports prevents inference about reporting practices in the wider import sector.
B. Shortcomings of legal regulation
i. Problems in Mongolia’s legal framework
Mongolia’s advertising and consumer protection laws address misleading information generally. The revised Law on Organic Products provides a more specific regime for organic claims. A priority for further regulation is to specify what qualifies as adequate evidence for broader environmental claims, who must retain it and how authorities can request it. In the EU, Article 12 of Directive 2005/29/EC provides an example of a procedural power to require evidence. Article 13(3) of that Directive, inserted by Directive (EU) 2019/2161, requires Member States to provide, for penalties imposed in coordinated enforcement actions against widespread cross-border infringements, fines whose maximum is at least 4% of the trader’s annual turnover in the Member State or States concerned. The threshold applies only in those circumstances.
ii. The influence of China’s legal framework
The cross-border supply chain creates practical questions about which entity holds supporting records and whether an overseas certificate covers the product marketed in Mongolia. China’s consumer information rules and organic standard provide relevant reference points. Mongolian importers can request the evidence needed to substantiate the claims they use in Mongolia.
iii. Applying international legal experience
The EU framework combines general misleading-practice rules, procedural powers to request substantiation and specific organic-product rules. The Mongolian framework could use this distinction to build general guidance for environmental claims while implementing its existing organic-product requirements.
C. Policy recommendations
The following measures address the documentation, oversight and consumer-information issues identified by the legal analysis and the descriptive results.
Recommendation 1. Define substantiation requirements for environmental claims.
Measure 1.1. Develop food labelling guidance for claims such as natural, eco and chemical-free. Require a clear description of the attribute claimed and evidence that supports the meaning consumers are likely to infer. Apply the existing organic-product rules to claims made under that regime.
Measure 1.2. Develop environmental-claims guidance under the Law on Advertising (2002). Address misleading omissions, unqualified claims, imagery that implies unsubstantiated benefits and comparisons with an unspecified baseline.
Measure 1.3. Review international benchmarks during Phase 1 (2026–2027). The Ministry of Food, Agriculture and Light Industry and the Mongolian Agency for Standardization and Metrology (MASM) should consider Regulation (EU) 2018/848, Codex CXG 32-1999 and ISO 14021 when developing proposals suited to the Mongolian market.
Recommendation 2. Improve the accessibility of verification and certification information.
Measure 2.1. Implement the certification and registration provisions of the revised Law on Organic Products. Develop guidance for importers on documenting the identity, scope and validity of certificates for imported products.
Measure 2.2. Clarify when overseas organic certificates may be accepted under Mongolian law. Set transparent criteria for evaluating the issuing body and matching the certificate to the product.
Measure 2.3. Improve public access to the existing organic-product register and accompanying certificate information. Where feasible, link labels to searchable entries showing the product, issuing body, validity period and scope.
Recommendation 3. Strengthen oversight of food advertising and labelling.
Measure 3.1. Assign responsibilities for environmental-claim reviews among the authorities administering food, organic-product, advertising and consumer protection rules. Train inspectors to distinguish vague or unsubstantiated claims from confirmed misrepresentations.
Measure 3.2. Use risk-based surveillance of retail packaging, online listings and advertisements. Prioritise claims that are consequential for consumers or that imply official certification, and request documentary evidence or tests where appropriate.
Measure 3.3. Provide a complaints channel through which consumers can submit a photograph or link, identify where the claim appeared and receive information about how the complaint was resolved.
Recommendation 4. Improve consumer access to practical verification guidance.
Measure 4.1. Provide examples of common claims, explain what a certificate establishes and show how to check its issuer, validity and scope.
Measure 4.2. Use consistent consumer-facing descriptions of official marks and the information available through the organic-product register.
Measure 4.3. Evaluate consumer education using measures of claim recognition and ability to verify a certificate.
Recommendation 5. Tighten liability for violations.
Measure 5.1. Consider graduated administrative remedies proportionate to the nature and repetition of the violation. Table 15 presents options for legislative consideration. Articles 10.1(4) and 3.4(3) of the Law on Violations specify the existing penalties for advertising prohibited by law, as discussed in Part II.D.iv.
| Type of violation | First violation | Repeat violation | Additional measures |
|---|---|---|---|
| Vague claim | MNT 5–10 million | MNT 10–20 million | Warning |
| Unsubstantiated claim | MNT 10–20 million | MNT 20–50 million | Product withdrawal |
| Fake certificate | MNT 50–100 million | MNT 100–200 million | Temporary suspension of operations |
| False claim harmful to health | MNT 100–500 million | MNT 500 million+ | Revocation of licence |
Table 15: Proposed administrative penalties
Any turnover-based sanction should specify its calculation base, conditions of application and safeguards against disproportionate penalties.
Measure 5.2. Clarify how consumers can seek redress for loss associated with misleading environmental claims and what evidence a seller or advertiser must provide in a dispute.
Measure 5.3. Refer suspected forgery or fraud to the competent authorities where the facts warrant review under the applicable law.
Recommendation 6. Strengthen international cooperation.
Measure 6.1. Explore cooperation with Chinese regulators and certification bodies to verify documents and clarify product traceability.
Measure 6.2. Develop procedures for exchanging information on overseas issuers and certificates when assessing imported products.
Measure 6.3. Identify opportunities for cooperation on cross-border surveillance and notification of invalid or withdrawn certificates.
Contributions and implementation
A. Contribution of the study
The study links the visibility of environmental claims on imported foods to two conditions that affect consumer choice: access to supporting documents and the ability to interpret them. In a cross-border supply chain, importers are positioned to obtain documentation from suppliers and make product-specific evidence accessible to retailers, authorities and consumers.
B. Proposed implementation schedule
The timetable in Table 16 starts with drafting and standards work, including Measure 1.3. Subsequent phases address implementation and evaluation.
| Phase | Measures to be implemented | Duration | Responsible bodies |
|---|---|---|---|
| Phase 1 (2026–2027) | Drafting amendments and claim guidance, including review of international benchmarks under Measure 1.3 | 12–18 months | State Great Khural, Ministry of Food, Agriculture and Light Industry, MASM |
| Phase 2 (2027–2029) | Improving access to organic certification records, strengthening inspection capacity and developing overseas certificate verification procedures | 24 months | Food and consumer protection authorities, MASM |
| Phase 3 (2029–2031) | Implementing the liability system; consumer education campaigns; launching a digital certificate platform; monitoring and evaluation of results | 24 months | Government, civil society organisations, private sector |
Table 16: Implementation timeline for the policy recommendations
C. Comparative regulatory summary
Table 17 summarises the rules discussed in Part II.D. The comparison concerns the scope of the cited instruments and does not rank enforcement performance.
| Indicator | Mongolia | European Union | China | USA |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| General environmental claims | General misleading-advertising and consumer information rules | Directive 2005/29/EC, as amended by Directive (EU) 2024/825 | General rule against false or misleading publicity under Article 20 | FTC Green Guides address misleading environmental marketing claims |
| Organic products | Revised Law on Organic Products (2024), effective 2025 | Regulation (EU) 2018/848 on organic production and labelling | GB/T 19630-2019 on organic production, processing, labelling and management | USDA National Organic Program (7 C.F.R. Part 205) |
| Substantiation | General advertising and consumer protection provisions and product-specific organic rules | Authorities may request evidence under Article 12 of Directive 2005/29/EC | Truthful and comprehensive product information under Article 20 | FTC Green Guides address substantiation of environmental representations |
| Selected enforcement provision | Law on Violations, Art. 10.1(4) | Directive 2005/29/EC, Art. 13, as amended by Directive (EU) 2019/2161 | Article 20 is the information duty discussed here | FTC Green Guides explain how the FTC evaluates environmental claims |
Table 17: Comparison of green-claim regulation in Mongolia, the EU, China and the USA
Conclusion
Environmental claims were frequently observed on sampled foods imported from China. Many of the sampled products with green claims lacked visible verification in the materials analysed. The consumer survey also showed a gap between attention to claims and self-reported ability to check certificates.
Mongolia can build on its consumer protection, advertising and organic-products legislation by specifying what evidence businesses must retain for broader environmental claims, how importers should document claims originating abroad and how consumers and authorities can check the evidence.
The empirical results are limited to the samples and period studied in Ulaanbaatar. Future research should retain the product-level coding and anonymised survey data, use transparent sampling and investigate whether access to verification information changes consumer decisions.
*****
