Introduction
In the twenty-first century, population ageing has become a global trend, driving the development of the care economy. As the older population grows faster than other age groups, the care economy is creating new opportunities for employment, consumption and service provision. This development reflects a shift from viewing the family primarily in terms of its caregiving “responsibility” to recognising its broader “role” in the care economy, alongside the State’s responsibility for regulation and resource allocation. Accordingly, caregiving responsibilities should be understood as shared between the family and the State.
Vietnam officially became an ageing society in 2011. By 2024, its population aged 60 and over had reached 14.2 million, more than 14% of the total population.1 Under the classification commonly used in studies of population ageing, a country is considered to have entered the “ageing society” stage when the proportion of its population aged 60 and over reaches approximately 10%, and to have become an “aged society” when this proportion reaches 20%.2 In the care of older persons, Vietnamese families continue to play an important role in caring for parents and older family members, while care services provided by hospitals and specialised care facilities remain limited.3 Although modernisation and industrialisation have transformed the traditional functions of the family, it remains a fundamental social unit and continues to bear responsibility for caring for older persons. However, the increasingly evident trend towards intergenerational residential separation raises questions about the sustainability of this role: do families still have sufficient capacity to care for older persons? Are families necessarily the most appropriate source of support in all circumstances? And what should be done when families are unable or unwilling to assume caregiving responsibilities? These changes underscore the need to re-examine the role of the family in caring for older persons within the context of the care economy.
As families’ caregiving capacity comes under strain, formal care services, whether provided in institutions, in the community or at home, become increasingly necessary. However, formal care services cannot entirely replace the regular and direct support provided by family members. Geographical distance may also affect families’ caregiving capacity and older persons’ access to formal home-based care services. These challenges highlight the need to clarify how caregiving responsibilities should be shared between families and the State, thereby safeguarding the rights and interests of care recipients and caregivers and ensuring sustainable care provision amid population ageing. Through a doctrinal analysis of Vietnamese legislation and policy, this article examines the roles and responsibilities of the State and the family in developing the care economy amid population ageing, and proposes an approach under which caregiving responsibilities are shared between them.
The roles and responsibilities of the State and the family in developing the care economy amid population ageing
A. The development of the care economy amid population ageing
The care economy encompasses all activities involved in providing care and support services to individuals, particularly children, older persons and persons with disabilities, including both paid and unpaid forms of care. Recent demographic changes have made the care economy an increasingly significant field in both economic and social terms. On the one hand, population ageing poses challenges to economic, social and care systems; on the other, it generates new demands and creates scope for the development of industries, products and services targeting older persons. The main characteristics of the care economy are as follows.
First, the care economy is essentially a field of study concerned with the economic phenomena and principles arising from the provision of care services involving three key actors: the family, the State and the market. The family is generally the first source of care, primarily through the unpaid care work performed by its members, including caring for older persons, providing assistance with activities of daily living, offering care during illness and undertaking household tasks. The State participates by formulating policies, providing public services, implementing social welfare programmes and offering financial support to individuals in need of care and to their caregivers. The market provides an increasingly diverse range of paid care services, from home-based care and assistance with activities of daily living to long-term care facilities and professional care services.
Second, within the care economy, care services should not be understood as limited to direct care for individuals in need of care. In the context of population ageing, the care economy encompasses not only the provision of products and services directly targeting older persons but also economic activities that support preparation for and adaptation to the ageing process. The scope of this sector is relatively broad, encompassing diverse supply chains, various business models and considerable development potential. It spans multiple dimensions, including the labour market, healthcare and care systems, housing and public services.4
Third, an important characteristic of the care economy is that the value of care activities is not measured solely by their capacity to generate income or market exchange value. Under traditional economic approaches, unpaid care work within the family is often difficult to recognise fully as an activity that generates economic value. However, care activities are essential to social life, health and well-being, and also contribute to the maintenance and reproduction of the labour force. When organised as paid services, care activities become part of the service market, while also generating employment and income for service providers. Accordingly, the care economy exists in two forms simultaneously: unpaid care, provided primarily within the family, and paid care delivered through formal services. The coexistence of these two forms requires institutional support and public resources to ensure the continuity of care provision and meet the welfare needs of individuals in society.5
It is necessary to distinguish between regulating care activities for older persons and developing the care economy. Laws on older persons focus primarily on identifying the actors responsible for providing care, safeguarding the rights and interests of older persons, delivering social assistance and providing essential care services. The care economy, by contrast, has a broader scope, addressing not only care recipients but also how care resources are organised, provided and allocated among families, the State, the market and communities. From this perspective, care is not merely an activity that meets social needs; it also encompasses care work, employment, services, human resources and financial resources. The central issue of the care economy is therefore how to organise, mobilise and allocate these resources appropriately to meet growing care needs while ensuring service quality and efficiency. Only when resources are used effectively and individuals in need of care can access appropriate services can the care economy develop sustainably.
B. The roles and responsibilities of the family in developing the care economy
i. The basis for the formation of the family’s role
“Family care” refers to unpaid care provided by members of the care recipient’s family, such as spouses and children. The “role of the family” in the care economy refers to the family’s position as a connecting and coordinating actor in organising, providing and accessing care activities and services to meet the needs of its members, particularly older persons. This role is reflected in the direct provision of care, the allocation of care resources, and the facilitation of access to services provided by the State and the market.
The central role of the family in the care economy has emerged from several factors.
First, cultural and social foundations. The meaning of filial piety may be defined broadly or narrowly depending on the cultural context of each country. For Vietnamese people, filial piety entails wholehearted love, respect, care and support for one’s grandparents and parents.6 Family values, intergenerational responsibilities and social norms concerning the duty to care for and support parents mean that the care of older persons is generally regarded as a responsibility to be fulfilled first within the family. This perception is influenced by traditional Confucian culture and its emphasis on filial piety, which have shaped and sustained the tradition of children caring for and supporting older family members. Beyond meeting material needs, the close relationships and strong bonds among family members also offer distinct advantages in addressing the emotional and cultural needs of older persons.
Second, the characteristics of care activities. Long-term care services include traditional health services, such as the management of chronic conditions among older persons, rehabilitation, palliative care, health promotion and preventive services. However, long-term care must also include assistive services, such as caregiving and social support for older persons. All these services need to be integrated and delivered as a continuum in accordance with the core principles of person-centred care.7 The World Health Organization (WHO) notes that approximately two-thirds of people who reach older age are likely to need care and support from others at some point to perform activities of daily living (ADLs), such as eating, moving around or bathing, and its approach to long-term care rests on the principles of integration, non-fragmentation and person-centredness, with services provided in a continuum rather than through fragmented interventions.8 Families, meanwhile, have advantages in terms of proximity, continuity and the ability to respond to individual needs, which generally makes them the first and most frequent providers of these activities.
Third, the economic basis. Most care activities are performed as unpaid care, meaning that families effectively provide a substantial amount of “care work” to the economy. Although this work is not directly reflected in market transactions, it nevertheless generates significant socio-economic value and contributes to the maintenance of the care system as a whole.
ii. Manifestations of the family’s central role in the care economy
First, the family is the primary provider of most care activities. Approximately 97% of the care received by older persons in Vietnam is provided by family members, with spouses, children and grandchildren serving as the main caregivers.9 These findings indicate that the family is not merely the living environment of older persons but also a direct provider of care, ranging from assistance with activities of daily living to care for older persons experiencing functional limitations. In most traditional families, from the perspective of household economics, the division of labour among family members has generally followed this pattern: men are primarily responsible for paid work, earning income and performing other physically demanding tasks, while women are responsible for childbirth and household duties. This division of labour has been based primarily on gender, physiological characteristics and work-related capabilities, and has been regarded as enhancing efficiency and satisfaction among family members. Under the influence of feudal ideology, women have traditionally been assigned responsibility for domestic work. Studies indicate that women take on a heavier caregiving load than men, both providing more personal care and spending more time caring.10 However, with the development of feminist movements and socio-economic change, an increasing number of women have entered the labour force and contributed to household income. Women’s increased participation in the labour market has altered the allocation of time and resources within families, but has not been sufficient to eliminate their predominant role in caregiving.
Second, the family is a user of care services. A substantial proportion of care activities are performed directly by family members as unpaid care, including assistance with eating, personal hygiene and mobility, medication management, accompanying older persons to medical appointments, and providing emotional support. Although these activities involve no monetary transactions, they nevertheless generate economic and social value by meeting care needs that might otherwise have to be met through paid services. When care needs exceed the family’s capacity to provide care independently, the family may hire home-based caregivers or use healthcare and professional care services. In this way, the family becomes a consumer of care services while simultaneously generating demand in the care market. The family’s role in the care economy is thus reflected not only on the supply side but also on the demand side of the market.
Third, the family plays a connecting role between older persons, the State and the market. Older persons do not always access the care resources provided by the State and the market independently; rather, families often facilitate access to, selection of and use of these resources. Families may assist older persons in accessing social assistance, health insurance and public services, while also selecting and paying for market-based care services when necessary. In Vietnam, the public care system has yet to meet existing needs fully. As of 2024, it comprised 418 social protection centres serving only around 10,000 older persons, while the demand for care went far beyond the system’s existing capacity.11
Fourth, the family is responsible for allocating resources for the care of older persons. The allocation of care resources is clearly reflected in the need for family members to balance their time, labour and financial resources between caregiving and other family needs. When a family member provides direct care to an older person, the time available for paid employment, rest or other activities may be reduced. Depending on their economic circumstances and household conditions, families must therefore choose between providing care themselves, distributing caregiving responsibilities among family members, or using external care services. Care decisions are therefore not merely a matter of emotional bonds or family responsibility; they also involve economic choices and resource allocation. The capacity to make such choices also varies with socio-economic conditions: European survey data show that the use of informal care is concentrated among older people with lower incomes, although less markedly when wealth rather than income is used as the measure.12
C. The roles and responsibilities of the State in developing the care economy
i. The basis for the formation of the State’s roles and responsibilities
First, care needs and the limitations of family-based care provision. Population ageing increases the demand for long-term care, while the supply of informal caregivers from families and communities tends to decline. The WHO notes that many countries, particularly developing countries, rely on household and community members for most long-term care. However, as populations age, care needs increase while the supply of informal caregivers falls, necessitating alternative forms of care and a larger government role in the organisation and financing of long-term care services.13
Second, the need for an equitable allocation of caregiving responsibilities and resources. Placing the primary responsibility for care on families may exacerbate gender and income inequalities while failing to meet both current and future care needs adequately.14 At the same time, the care economy encompasses paid and unpaid care work delivered through the public and private sectors, non-profit organisations, the social and solidarity economy and households.15 The organisation and allocation of care resources are therefore no longer matters for individual families alone; they have become issues of broader social and economic significance that require State involvement.
Third, the socio-economic impacts of the care economy. When care activities are linked to employment, income, the labour market and the quality of human resources, care is no longer merely a private family matter but an issue with implications for society as a whole. This, in turn, creates a need for State involvement as a coordinating actor responsible for ensuring the conditions necessary for the development of the care economy.
ii. Manifestations of the State’s role
First, the State plays a role in establishing and ensuring the legal framework for the development of the care economy. In some countries, such as Nepal and Vietnam, legislation recognises that the primary responsibility for caring for older persons rests with their immediate family members. By contrast, other countries, such as Australia, have treated the care of older persons as a national responsibility, which the government assumes as a way of acknowledging and honouring the contributions that older persons have made to the country’s development throughout their lives.16 This difference shows that the legal framework serves not only to determine which actors bear caregiving responsibilities but also reflects the State’s choice regarding the extent and modalities of its involvement in the care economy.
Second, the State plays a role in ensuring and allocating resources for care activities. It provides support to older persons and families that lack the capacity to meet care needs independently, while ensuring access to essential services. This approach is consistent with the perspective of the International Labour Organization (ILO) on the care economy, which underscores the central role of the State in the provision, regulation and financing of care, in coordination with the private sector, families, the social and solidarity economy and communities.17 The State’s role is therefore not limited to supporting groups with limited resources; it also encompasses coordinating and allocating social resources to ensure that all individuals in need can access appropriate care.
Third, the State plays a role in developing and regulating the formal care system, thereby establishing links between family-based care and professional care services. Formal care is delivered by a workforce spanning several occupations, from personal care attendants to home health aides. Among these services, home- and community-based care plays a significant role in meeting a growing older population’s unmet need for care in the community.18 The development of these services requires policies addressing wages, training, the care workforce and accessibility, thereby generating employment opportunities and services within the care economy. In addition to establishing care facilities for older persons, the State encourages organisations and individuals to invest in such facilities and provides support to both public and non-public facilities. This mechanism shows that the State does not replace the family’s role; rather, it develops formal care arrangements to complement the family’s informal care resources.
Fourth, the State has a responsibility to support informal family caregivers. Family-based care remains an important and widely preferred form of care. Public policies should therefore create conditions that enable caregivers to fulfil their caregiving responsibilities while maintaining their employment and income. Support for caregivers is intended not only to alleviate the caregiving burden but also to sustain the family-based supply of care and ensure the sustainability of the care economy.
These manifestations show that State involvement transforms the organisation of the care economy from a model that relies primarily on families to one based on shared responsibility among different actors. The State’s role is not to replace the family, but to create conditions in which care resources are interconnected and used effectively, thereby contributing to a more sustainable care system.
The current legal framework in Vietnam on the roles and responsibilities of the State and the family in developing the care economy
In Vietnam, the “care economy” has not yet been recognised as an independent legal concept. Instead, care activities are regulated separately across various areas of law, including legislation on older persons, the family, healthcare, social assistance and service provision. However, as the population has aged, the legal approach has gradually expanded beyond defining responsibilities for supporting and caring for older family members and ensuring social security to promoting diverse forms of care, developing the care workforce and encouraging the participation of various social actors. The 2025 Law on Population, which took effect on 1 July 2026, devotes a separate chapter to adapting to population ageing. It provides for home-based, community-based and institutional care; support for family members in providing care through training, counselling and technical assistance; incentives for enterprises and organisations to produce and supply goods and services for older persons; and the development of long-term care insurance.19 Decision No. 1116/QĐ-TTg of 2026 expands the programme for the care of older persons by diversifying forms of care and mobilising social resources.20 Decision No. 383/QĐ-TTg of 2025 brings the development of the “silver economy” into the implementation of the National Strategy on Older Persons, while linking the development of care models to the participation of various social actors.21 These developments indicate that Vietnamese law is gradually shifting from an approach that regards care primarily as a family responsibility and a social welfare issue towards one that recognises care as a sector requiring organisation, investment and resource mobilisation from multiple actors. So far, however, this shift has emerged through policies and regulations in various areas rather than through a unified legal framework for the development of the care economy.
A. Current legal provisions on the role and responsibilities of the family in the care economy
As discussed above, family-based care arrangements can be explained by the tradition of filial piety in Vietnamese culture, and they are reinforced by constitutional and statutory provisions. First, throughout Vietnam’s Constitutions from 1959 to 2013, the family has consistently been recognised as an institution of significant importance in social life, and the responsibilities of family members towards one another have been progressively articulated and specified through legal provisions.22 Under the Law on Marriage and Family, caregiving responsibilities among family members are recognised through provisions governing the rights and obligations of children towards their parents. Article 70 provides that children have a duty to love, respect, be grateful to and show filial piety towards their parents and to support them, and Article 71 obliges children to care for and support their parents, particularly when the parents have lost civil act capacity, are ill, elderly or have disabilities.23 In addition, Article 104 provides for the rights and obligations of paternal and maternal grandparents and their grandchildren, further reflecting intergenerational caregiving and support responsibilities within the family.24 Under the 2009 Law on the Elderly, the family bears the primary responsibility for supporting and caring for older persons. At the same time, the Law establishes a mechanism for connecting families with individuals and organisations providing care services when families are unable to provide care directly. Article 10 defines such support as care for the material and spiritual life of older persons, including their health care. Article 11 allows persons with caregiving obligations who are unable to provide care directly to delegate it to individuals or organisations providing care services, subject to the consent of the older person.25
Vietnamese law thus recognises caregiving responsibilities among family members, particularly the responsibilities of children towards their parents and those between grandparents and grandchildren. However, these provisions approach care primarily from the perspective of family obligations and the protection of older persons’ rights and interests, without directly recognising the socio-economic value of unpaid care work performed by family members. Meanwhile, current labour legislation primarily regulates relationships associated with employment, wages and employers. This gives rise to a gap between the legal recognition of families’ caregiving responsibilities and the recognition and protection of those who directly undertake caregiving work within the family. This gap highlights the need to approach care activities not merely as a family obligation but also as a form of labour that holds value for individuals, families and society.
B. Current legal provisions on the role and responsibilities of the State in the care economy
The 2009 Law on the Elderly provides a direct legal basis for the State’s responsibilities in the care economy amid population ageing. Article 4 provides that the State shall allocate annual budgetary resources to implement policies on the care of older persons and the promotion of their roles, provide social protection, develop geriatric medicine and train caregivers for older persons. It also encourages and supports agencies, organisations and individuals in the care of older persons and the promotion of their roles.26 These responsibilities extend beyond ensuring the implementation of policies and are further specified through the organisation and development of care services. Article 20 provides for care facilities for older persons and stipulates that the State shall encourage organisations and individuals to invest in the construction of such facilities, while supporting public and non-public facilities in accordance with the law.27 In addition, Articles 28 and 29 allocate state management responsibilities among the Government, ministries, ministerial-level agencies and local authorities in formulating policies, developing care facilities, training caregivers and organising the implementation of legislation on older persons.28 Building on this legal foundation, the State’s role has been further specified through recent policies on older persons. Decision No. 383/QĐ-TTg of 21 February 2025 approved the National Strategy on Older Persons to 2035, with a vision to 2045, while Decision No. 1116/QĐ-TTg of 22 June 2026 amended and expanded the Programme on Healthcare for Older Persons to 2030.29
These legal provisions and policies show that the State’s role in the care economy is reflected not only in the direct provision of services and in ensuring access to them, but also in establishing the legal framework, allocating resources, organising the care system and creating conditions for non-state actors to participate in service provision.
At the implementation level, Decision No. 1579/QĐ-TTg of 2020 identifies relatives who directly care for older persons as one of the beneficiary groups of the Programme. It also sets objectives of providing older persons or the relatives who directly care for them with information on population ageing and on older persons’ right to health care, and of ensuring that older persons who are unable to care for themselves receive health care from their families and communities.30 By 2026, the legal basis had become more specific: the 2025 Law on Population provides for supporting family members in caring for older persons through training, counselling and appropriate technical assistance.31 At the same time, the Ministry of Health issued separate professional guidelines on the care of older persons at home and in the community, under which relatives care for older persons at home on the basis of the training, counselling and technical support organised by commune health stations.32 Through these measures, the State has taken initial steps away from merely assigning caregiving responsibilities to families and towards strengthening their capacity to fulfil those responsibilities.
In practice, these responsibilities have been implemented through programmes, networks and models for the care of older persons at both central and local levels. The Ministry of Health, in coordination with the Vietnam Association of the Elderly, organises programmes on healthcare for older persons, promotes the development of geriatric medicine, diversifies care services and coordinates inspections of implementation at local and institutional levels. The Vietnam Association of the Elderly also directs the development of health care club models for older persons, including Intergenerational Self-Help Clubs, Physical Exercise Clubs, Outdoor Health Clubs and clubs for people with chronic conditions such as diabetes and hypertension. In addition, it organises networks of volunteer caregivers to provide healthcare support to older persons who are lonely, have no one to rely on, are poor or are living in difficult circumstances.33 At the community level, the State supports the development of Intergenerational Self-Help Clubs, which provide health support, care, counselling and livelihood assistance to older persons and vulnerable groups. This model has been expanded across numerous localities, with a target of establishing the clubs or an equivalent model in at least 80% of communes by 2030.34 However, these models still approach care primarily from the perspective of social welfare and social services, while their links with family care resources and their potential to generate employment, services and economic value through care activities remain insufficiently evident. This is a gap that needs to be addressed in the transition from policies on the care of older persons towards the development of the care economy.
C. Legal issues and challenges in the allocation of responsibilities between the family and the State in the care economy
As the family continues to serve as the primary provider of care for older persons, the allocation of responsibilities between the family and the State raises several legal issues that need to be addressed to safeguard the rights and interests of older persons and caregivers, while establishing a mechanism for shared responsibility among actors in the care economy.
First, the concept and legal status of responsibility for the care of older persons at the national level have not been clearly and consistently defined. The 2009 Law on the Elderly defines its scope as encompassing the responsibilities of the family, the State and society in supporting and caring for older persons and promoting their roles. However, these provisions primarily identify the responsibilities of individual actors across different policy areas, without clarifying the substantive scope of “care for older persons” as a long-term area of social responsibility encompassing healthcare, assistance with daily living, home-based care, community-based care and care in specialised facilities. Meanwhile, the “care economy” has not yet been recognised as an independent legal concept. Instead, the relationships and activities constituting the care economy are regulated separately across various areas of law, including the Law on the Elderly, the Law on Marriage and Family, the Law on Medical Examination and Treatment, the Law on Social Insurance and the Law on Population. This creates difficulties in determining the scope of responsibility borne by the State, families and service providers, as well as the appropriate extent of intervention and support.
Second, there is a lack of long-term, systematic and effective coordination mechanisms between the State and families in organising and providing care for older persons. Current legislation identifies the family as the primary actor responsible for supporting and caring for older persons, while the State implements policies on support, social protection and the development of care services. However, this allocation of responsibilities does not necessarily entail a specific coordination mechanism between these two actors throughout the care process. In particular, the law has not fully established mechanisms through which families can regularly access, use and connect with care services provided by the State or other actors. Nor has it clearly defined the State’s responsibility to support families when care needs exceed the capacity of the household. Article 11 of the 2009 Law on the Elderly provides a legal basis only for transferring caregiving responsibilities in a specific circumstance, rather than a long-term coordination mechanism between informal family care and formal care services. The issue, therefore, is how to move beyond an approach in which the State provides support primarily when families are no longer able or willing to provide care, towards a mechanism whereby the State accompanies and supports families throughout the care process through services, information, training, financial assistance and appropriate alternative forms of care.
Third, the slow and uneven development of the long-term care service system calls for improvements to the legal framework governing the provision of and access to care services for older persons. Although the demand for care among older persons is increasing with population ageing, the network of professional care services has not developed in proportion to actual needs. Home-based care, community-based care and institutional care have yet to be integrated into a unified system, while access to services varies among groups of older persons and between urban and rural areas. The law recognises care facilities for older persons and encourages organisations and individuals to invest in them. However, the issue concerns not only expanding the number of facilities but also establishing quality standards, service provision requirements, the responsibilities of service providers and regulatory mechanisms. Mechanisms are also needed to ensure that older persons requiring care can access appropriate services without being entirely dependent on their families’ financial capacity.
Fourth, the absence of a dedicated and stable financing mechanism for long-term care raises questions about the allocation and sharing of financial responsibilities among families, the State and service providers. As most care activities continue to be performed within families, a substantial proportion of direct care costs and the opportunity costs associated with time, employment and income are also borne by households. As life expectancy increases and the period during which care and support are required tends to lengthen, these costs may become a significant burden for households with limited financial resources. The Law on the Elderly establishes the State’s responsibility to allocate annual budgetary resources and provide social assistance to older persons, but it has not established a dedicated financing mechanism for long-term care needs. It is therefore necessary to define clearly the scope of State support, the mechanisms for mobilising social resources and the extent of service users’ financial contributions, so that an excessive share of care costs is not borne by families. The financing mechanism should also be designed to support individuals with high care needs or limited ability to pay, rather than relying solely on the financial capacity of individual households.
Fifth, family-based care has not been fully recognised as a form of labour with socio-economic value, giving rise to the need for a legal framework to recognise and protect caregivers. Most unpaid care activities are performed within the family and are difficult to capture through traditional economic indicators. In legal scholarship on care, feminist scholars have pointed out that traditional labour law tends to focus on paid employment while overlooking unpaid care and domestic work, despite their essential contribution to social life and the reproduction of the labour force.35 However, the legal challenge does not necessarily lie in establishing an employment relationship for all caregiving activities performed within the family. Rather, it lies in recognising the value of such activities and establishing mechanisms to protect caregivers through training, access to substitute care services, caregiving leave, social security and other appropriate support policies. This approach is also consistent with the view that care work should be addressed within the broader context of public service provision and social responsibility, rather than solely by expanding the concept of the employment relationship to encompass all forms of unpaid care.36
Policy recommendations
On the basis of the foregoing analysis, developing a high-quality and sustainable care economy amid population ageing requires coordination among families, the market and the State in its regulatory capacity.
First, the legal framework for the development of the care economy should be gradually strengthened. Legislation should provide greater clarity regarding the respective responsibilities of, and relationships among, families, the State, communities and service providers, based on an approach in which the State guarantees care provision, the family serves as its foundation, and multiple actors participate. On this basis, a coordination mechanism should be established to link informal family care with formal care services, rather than allowing these two forms of care to operate in relative isolation. This mechanism should clearly identify the circumstances in which families provide care directly, those in which support from community-based services is required, and those in which a transition to professional care is necessary. It should also specify the responsibilities of state agencies and service providers in supporting, advising and connecting with families. The standardisation of home-based care, community-based care, day care and care in specialised facilities should likewise be incorporated into a unified legal framework, thereby ensuring continuity throughout the care process and enabling the selection of care arrangements suited to the needs of older persons.
Second, a legal framework should be developed to support families and protect caregivers within the care economy. Maintaining the central role of the family should not mean that families must bear the entire burden of the time, health and income costs arising from caregiving. Legislation should therefore progressively recognise the socio-economic value of unpaid care and establish support mechanisms for caregivers, such as skills training, counselling, respite care services, assistance in accessing healthcare services and appropriate forms of social security protection. At the same time, links between care-related legislation and labour law should be strengthened to reduce conflicts between caregiving responsibilities and employment. Mechanisms concerning working hours, caregiving leave, flexible working arrangements and employment protection should be considered, so that workers with family caregiving responsibilities can remain in employment without having to choose between earning an income and providing care. For professional care workers, regulations on training, occupational standards, wages, working conditions and social security protection should be further developed, thereby improving service quality and the sustainability of the care workforce. This approach would also help prevent caregiving responsibilities from remaining disproportionately concentrated among women and promote a more equitable distribution of care responsibilities within families and society.
Third, the State’s role in guaranteeing, coordinating and overseeing the care economy should be strengthened. As care needs increase with population ageing, the State needs to establish mechanisms for mobilising and allocating resources appropriately among the state budget, family resources and social resources. Priority should first be given to developing a stable financing mechanism for long-term care, with particular support for older persons who have substantial care needs but limited ability to pay, while creating favourable conditions for private-sector entities and social organisations to participate in service provision. The socialisation of care provision should be accompanied by licensing mechanisms, quality standards, inspection and supervision to ensure that greater market participation does not undermine access to or the quality of services. In addition, coordination among state agencies and between central and local authorities should be strengthened in the formulation, implementation and evaluation of policies on the care of older persons, together with the integration of public and social resources currently dispersed across different programmes and policy areas. Under this approach, the State would not only act as a direct provider of certain services but also assume responsibility for establishing the legal framework, coordinating resources, setting standards and safeguarding the rights of older persons and caregivers. This would provide the basis for an integrated care system in which families, the State, the market and communities participate while performing distinct functions.
Conclusion
Improving the legal framework for the care economy should aim to establish a model in which the State guarantees and coordinates care provision, the family retains its central role in informal care, and social actors participate in the provision of services. The primary objective of this process is not to replace the family’s responsibilities but to establish legal mechanisms for sharing caregiving responsibilities and resources equitably. This approach would both safeguard the role of the family and reduce the care system’s excessive reliance on household resources, while creating conditions for the development of the care workforce and care services within a care economy that is emerging and expanding alongside population ageing.
Rather than regarding the family as the primary actor or advocating that the State assume full responsibility for the care economy, this article contends that the most effective strategy for developing the care economy amid population ageing in Vietnam is to combine the efforts of both the State and the family. Only when these two actors complement one another can older persons receive the best possible care.
*****
Footnotes
1. General Statistics Office of Vietnam, Press Release on the Results of the 2024 Mid-Term Population and Housing Census (Jan. 6, 2025), https://www.nso.gov.vn/du-lieu-va-so-lieu-thong-ke/2025/01/thong-cao-bao-chi-ket-qua-dieu-tra-dan-so-va-nha-o-giua-ky-nam-2024/.
2. United Nations in Viet Nam, Applying Foresight to Curate a Care Economy for Older Persons in Viet Nam (2026), https://vietnam.un.org/en/308595-applying-foresight-curate-care-economy-older-persons-viet-nam.
3. Nguyen Thi Thu Thuong, Does Health Insurance Affect Healthcare Services Utilization and Protect Citizens from Catastrophic Health Expenditure in Vietnam? Evidence from Household Living Standard Survey 1, 39 (Sept. 2019) (M.P.H. thesis, KIT Royal Tropical Institute & Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam), https://www.bibalex.org/baifa/Attachment/Documents/nEzJ0f8Gmn_20210525162823434.pdf; see also Phong Manh Phi, Long Thanh Giang & Tham Thi Hong Pham, Unmet Needs for Care for Activities of Daily Living Among Older Adults with Functional Disabilities in Vietnam, 11 Frontiers in Public Health 1216785 (2023), https://doi.org/10.3389/fpubh.2023.1216785 (most care for older adults in Vietnam comes from family members, while other sources of care, such as hospitals and other institutions, are limited).
4. European Commission, The Silver Economy: Executive Summary 3–6 (2018), https://publications.europa.eu/resource/cellar/2dca9276-3ec5-11e8-b5fe-01aa75ed71a1.0002.01/DOC_1.
5. Rafael Encinas de Muñagorri, Labour Law for Care and Wellbeing, in Labour Law Utopias: Post-Growth & Post-Productive Work Approaches 155, 155–75 (Nicolas Bueno, Beryl ter Haar & Nuna Zekic eds., Oxford Univ. Press 2024), https://doi.org/10.1093/oso/9780198889755.003.0009, https://academic.oup.com/book/58011/chapter/477420144.
6. Thiều Chửu, Han–Vietnamese Dictionary 137 (Ho Chi Minh City Publishing House 1991).
7. World Health Organization, Providing Access to Long-Term Care for Older People, https://www.who.int/teams/maternal-newborn-child-adolescent-health-and-ageing/ageing-and-health/integrated-continuum-of-long-term-care/providing-access-to-long-term-care-for-older-people (last visited Nov. 16, 2026).
8. Id.; World Health Organization, WHO Launches New Framework to Support Countries Achieve Integrated Continuum of Long-Term Care (Mar. 14, 2022), https://www.who.int/news/item/14-03-2022-who-launches-new-framework-to-support-countries-achieve-integrated-continuum-of-long-term-care.
9. Vietnam Women’s Union, Vietnam Aging Survey (VNAS) 2011: Key Findings (Women’s Publishing House 2012), as reported in Phi, Giang & Pham, supra note 3.
10. Marianne Sundlisæter Skinner & Maren Sogstad, Social and Gender Differences in Informal Caregiving for Sick, Disabled, or Elderly Persons: A Cross-Sectional Study, 8 SAGE Open Nursing 1, 1–11 (2022), https://doi.org/10.1177/23779608221130585.
11. World Bank, How Intergenerational Self-Help Clubs Transform Elderly Care in Viet Nam (May 28, 2024), https://www.worldbank.org/en/news/feature/2024/05/28/how-intergenerational-self-help-clubs-transform-elderly-care-in-viet-nam.
12. Ricardo Rodrigues, Stefania Ilinca & Andrea E. Schmidt, Income-Rich and Wealth-Poor? The Impact of Measures of Socio-Economic Status in the Analysis of the Distribution of Long-Term Care Use Among Older People, 27 Health Economics 637, 637–46 (2018), https://doi.org/10.1002/hec.3607.
13. Sarah L. Barber, Paul Ong & Zee A. Han, Long-Term Care in Ageing Populations, in Handbook of Global Health (Ilona Kickbusch et al. eds., Springer 2025), https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-05325-3_65-3.
14. Rhonda J. V. Montgomery, The Family Role in the Context of Long-Term Care, 11 J. Aging & Health 383 (1999), https://doi.org/10.1177/089826439901100307.
15. International Labour Organization, Care Economy, https://www.ilo.org/topics-and-sectors/care-economy (last visited Sept. 27, 2026).
16. Kabin Maleku, Who Should Take Care of the Elderly, the State or the Family?, Age Care Nepal (Oct. 12, 2023), https://www.agecarenepal.org/blog/who-should-take-care-of-the-elderly-the-state-or-the-family/ (Nepal’s Senior Citizens Act, 2006, and Australia); see National Assembly of Vietnam, Law on the Elderly, No. 39/2009/QH12, art. 5(3) (Nov. 23, 2009) (Vietnam) (the family of an older person bears the primary responsibility for supporting that person).
17. International Labour Organization, Care, Decent Work and Social Protection: ILO Analyzes Key Elements to Build Comprehensive and Sustainable Systems (Mar. 3, 2026), https://www.ilo.org/resource/news/care-decent-work-and-social-protection-ilo-analyzes-key-elements-build.
18. MaryBeth Musumeci, How Could $400 Billion New Federal Dollars Change Medicaid Home and Community-Based Services?, KFF (July 16, 2021), https://www.kff.org/medicaid/issue-brief/how-could-400-billion-new-federal-dollars-change-medicaid-home-and-community-based-services/.
19. National Assembly of Vietnam, Law on Population, No. 113/2025/QH15, arts. 7(5), 16–19, 30 (Dec. 10, 2025) (Vietnam).
20. Prime Minister of Vietnam, Decision No. 1116/QĐ-TTg Amending and Supplementing Decision No. 1579/QĐ-TTg of October 13, 2020 Approving the Healthcare Programme for Older Persons Through 2030, art. 1 (June 22, 2026) (Vietnam).
21. Prime Minister of Vietnam, Decision No. 383/QĐ-TTg Approving the National Strategy on Older Persons Through 2035, with a Vision to 2045 (Feb. 21, 2025) (Vietnam).
22. Hiến Pháp [Constitution] art. 24 (1959) (Vietnam); Hiến Pháp [Constitution] art. 64 (1980) (Vietnam); Hiến Pháp [Constitution] art. 64 (1992) (Vietnam); Hiến Pháp [Constitution] arts. 36(2), 37(3) (2013) (Vietnam).
23. National Assembly of Vietnam, Law on Marriage and Family, No. 52/2014/QH13, arts. 70(2), 71(2) (June 19, 2014) (Vietnam).
24. Id. art. 104.
25. Law on the Elderly, supra note 16, arts. 5(3), 10, 11.
26. Id. art. 4.
27. Id. art. 20(3).
28. Id. arts. 28–29.
29. Decision No. 383/QĐ-TTg, supra note 21; Decision No. 1116/QĐ-TTg, supra note 20.
30. Prime Minister of Vietnam, Decision No. 1579/QĐ-TTg Approving the Healthcare Programme for Older Persons Through 2030, art. 1, §§ I(2)(b), (đ), II(2)(a) (Oct. 13, 2020) (Vietnam).
31. Law on Population, supra note 19, art. 18(3)(b).
32. Ministry of Health of Vietnam, Decision No. 1976/QĐ-BYT Promulgating the Professional Guidelines on the Care of Older Persons at Home and in the Community, Guidelines ch. I, § 1.3(b) (July 1, 2026) (Vietnam).
33. Population Department, Ministry of Health of Vietnam, Signing Ceremony of the Programme of Coordination Between the Ministry of Health and the Vietnam Association of the Elderly on Health Care for Older Persons for the 2024–2028 Period (Sept. 27, 2024), https://vnpa.moh.gov.vn/le-ky-ket-chuong-trinh-phoi-hop-giua-bo-y-te-va-hoi-nguoi-cao-tuoi-viet-nam-ve-cham-soc-suc-khoe-cho-nguoi-cao-tuoi-giai-doan-2024-2028.
34. World Bank, supra note 11 (Vietnamese-language version at https://www.worldbank.org/vi/news/feature/2024/05/28/how-intergenerational-self-help-clubs-transform-elderly-care-in-viet-nam).
35. Judy Fudge, Feminist Reflections on the Scope of Labour Law: Domestic Work, Social Reproduction, and Jurisdiction, 22 Feminist Legal Stud. 1 (2014), https://doi.org/10.1007/s10691-014-9256-2.
36. Encinas de Muñagorri, supra note 5.
