Introduction
Justice in India has long been perceived as something that can only be achieved through formal courts and judicial proceedings. This conventional understanding placed an extraordinary burden on the courts, resulting in heavy caseloads and prolonged delays in resolving disputes. As a consequence, the judiciary became overstrained, and many individuals seeking redress were left waiting for justice far longer than they should have been. In modern judicial systems, the pursuit of justice is often hindered by a number of issues, including a lack of funding, complicated procedures and the adversarial character of conventional litigation.1 The search for efficient ways to administer justice has therefore led to the development and acceptance of alternative dispute resolution (ADR) as a crucial instrument to support traditional legal procedures.
The concept of ADR traces back to ancient civilisations, where informal methods were commonly used to settle disputes.2 However, meaningful progress in ADR began only in the latter part of the twentieth century, when growing recognition of the delays and shortcomings of conventional court litigation encouraged wider acceptance of these methods. As a result of increasing caseloads, drawn-out litigation and rising courtroom expenses, legislators, academics and lawyers all began to look for other dispute resolution options.
A key issue in contemporary discourse on the justice system is the guarantee of equitable access to legal remedies and procedural justice for all individuals.3 The reality, however, often falls short of this ideal, as traditional legal systems typically encounter challenges such as financial constraints, cultural disparities and geographic barriers that hinder individuals from effectively accessing justice. There is therefore an urgent need to formulate strategies that reduce these obstacles while ensuring fairness and equality within the justice system.
The constitutional framework of India further strengthens this pursuit by recognising access to justice as an essential constitutional guarantee. The safeguards contained in Articles 14 and 21, ensuring equality and personal liberty, have been judicially expanded by the Supreme Court to include fair, speedy and effective justice.4 Article 39A obliges the State to secure equal justice and to provide free legal aid, thereby endorsing accessible dispute resolution systems.5 These constitutional principles not only encourage the creation of alternatives to formal litigation but also provide a robust foundation for institutionalising ADR as a means to enhance fairness, reduce barriers and promote participatory justice. The Supreme Court, through decisions such as Salem Advocate Bar Association v. Union of India and Afcons Infrastructure Ltd. v. Cherian Varkey Construction Co. (P) Ltd., has recognised that resort to ADR is necessary to give speedy and effective relief to litigants and to reduce the burden on the courts.6
In recent years, ADR has emerged as a widely accepted approach for settling disputes outside formal courts. Processes such as arbitration, mediation, conciliation, negotiation and Lok Adalat are reshaping conflict resolution by offering practical mechanisms outside the formal court system.7 As access to justice becomes an increasingly urgent concern within many legal systems, ADR provides a promising pathway to address these challenges. It offers quicker, more affordable and often more effective dispute resolution, particularly for those who face difficulty in navigating the complexities of conventional court procedure. Reflecting this commitment to strengthening ADR, Parliament inserted Section 89 into the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC) by the Code of Civil Procedure (Amendment) Act, 1999, with effect from 1 July 2002,8 empowering civil courts to identify suitable cases and refer them to appropriate ADR forums.9 This statutory mandate has significantly strengthened the institutionalisation of ADR processes in India’s justice delivery system.
This article examines the significance of ADR in improving access to justice by lowering the financial, procedural and time-related hurdles associated with traditional litigation. It highlights how ADR empowers disputing parties and offers a fair, balanced and more inclusive method of conflict resolution.
Understanding the principles and scope of ADR
A. Meaning and definition
ADR encompasses a range of procedures aimed at resolving disputes outside the conventional judicial framework. It involves the engagement of a neutral third party who either assists the disputants in achieving a voluntary settlement or issues a decision on the matters contested.
It encompasses a wide array of techniques and procedures designed to offer disputants flexible, non-adversarial methods for resolving conflicts quickly, affordably and amicably. Unlike litigation, which depends on rigid legal procedures and judicial intervention, ADR prioritises cooperation, compromise and respect for party autonomy.10 The introduction and growth of ADR in India aim to overcome the limitations of the conventional court system, such as delays, high costs and procedural complexity. By providing more efficient avenues of dispute resolution, ADR seeks to enhance access to justice. Importantly, ADR is not intended to replace the courts; rather, it complements and strengthens the overall justice delivery system.11
Black’s Law Dictionary defines alternative dispute resolution as a procedure for settling a dispute by means other than litigation, such as arbitration or mediation.12
In simple terms, ADR refers to a range of methods used to settle disputes without resorting to formal court proceedings. Rather than relying on a judge to pronounce a decision, ADR allows parties to participate in informal, cooperative procedures designed to help them reach mutually acceptable resolutions.
B. Scope and significance of the ADR system
The scope of ADR does not extend to all categories of legal disputes, as certain matters require judicial determination because of their nature and public importance.
In the Afcons case,13 the Supreme Court provided a detailed framework identifying which categories of disputes may be referred to ADR and which may not.14 ADR may function independently of the formal legal system, operate alongside it, or serve as its substitute; Justice S. B. Sinha described it as “an alternate resolution system to supplement or supplant the present judicial system”.15 It provides substitutes for conventional dispute settlement. In a few crucial areas, including criminal law and constitutional law, adjudication by the courts remains indispensable.16 ADR is considered extra-judicial in nature, as its procedures differ from the traditional methods of adjudication.17 The core objectives of ADR are the prompt and cost-effective resolution of disputes. Additionally, by emphasising amicable settlement, ADR seeks to strengthen and preserve relationships between the parties.18
According to the Law Commission of India, the reason for judicial delays is not a lack of explicit procedural norms but rather their poor application or non-observance altogether.19 In its Fourteenth Report, the Law Commission highlighted that judicial delays largely stem from the disregard of important legal provisions, particularly those intended to expedite the disposal of cases.20
The main goal of the ADR movement is to end vexation, expense and delay while advancing the idea of “equal access to justice” for everyone. The ADR system seeks to provide affordable, simple, quick and easily accessible justice. Disputes are resolved through the facilitation of a neutral third party, and the procedures are kept straightforward and, for the most part, conducted as the parties have agreed. ADR promotes speedy settlement while keeping the matter confidential and requiring comparatively little time, expertise or financial investment.21
C. Primary avenues of ADR in promoting access to justice
ADR employs multiple methods designed to resolve disputes quickly and fairly outside the formal court system. By offering diverse mechanisms suited to different types of conflict, it ensures flexibility, efficiency and inclusivity in the justice process. The following discussion outlines the primary avenues of ADR that contribute to enhancing access to justice in India.
i. Arbitration
Arbitration is a key form of ADR, providing a quasi-judicial mechanism in which disputes are resolved by a neutral arbitrator or a panel of arbitrators through a structured adjudicatory process.22 Arbitration in India is governed by the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996,23 which is based on the UNCITRAL Model Law on International Commercial Arbitration.24 Both the Model Law and the 1996 Act define arbitration as “any arbitration whether or not administered by [a] permanent arbitral institution”, which accommodates two forms of arbitration:25
1. Institutional arbitration, that is, arbitration administered by a recognised arbitral institution under its rules; and
2. Ad hoc arbitration, in which the parties themselves determine the procedure, including the appointment of the arbitrator or arbitrators and the conduct of the hearings.
An arbitral tribunal may consist of one or more arbitrators. The arbitration process typically follows these steps:26
• Agreement to arbitrate: Parties may choose to settle their disputes through arbitration, either by incorporating an arbitration clause in their contract or by entering into a separate arbitration agreement once the dispute has arisen.
• Selection of arbitrators: Parties select one or more arbitrators on the basis of their expertise, impartiality and availability.
• Preliminary meeting: A preliminary meeting is held to settle the procedural rules, the timetable and other logistics of the arbitration.
• Submission of claims and defences: Parties submit their statements of claim and defence, along with supporting evidence and documents.
• Hearings: Hearings are conducted at which the parties present their arguments, evidence and witness testimony. The hearings may be in person or virtual, depending on the agreement between the parties.
• Deliberation and award: The arbitrator or arbitrators deliberate on the evidence and arguments presented and issue a binding arbitral award, which contains the decision and the reasons for it.
An arbitral award is final, binding on the parties and enforceable.27 Unlike courts, the arbitral tribunal is not bound by the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 or by the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, which the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 has since replaced.28 Although arbitral proceedings resemble court hearings, they operate with more flexibility, as procedural rules are less rigid and the strict rules of evidence are relaxed.
ii. Conciliation
Conciliation is a prominent mode of ADR, characterised by its voluntary, flexible and confidential nature. In this process, a neutral third party known as the conciliator facilitates communication between the parties to help them arrive at a mutually acceptable settlement. Unlike an arbitrator or a court, the conciliator does not issue a binding decision; instead, the conciliator facilitates communication, minimises misunderstandings and may suggest possible terms of settlement to guide the parties toward agreement.29
In India, the legal framework for conciliation is set out in Part III (Sections 61–81) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, which is largely based on the UNCITRAL Conciliation Rules of 1980.30 The Mediation Act, 2023 will, once its Sixth Schedule is brought into force, substitute these sections and treat conciliation under the 1996 Act as mediation under the Mediation Act.31
In India, conciliation is increasingly encouraged in an effort to ease the load on the legal system, promote prompt dispute resolution and maintain personal and business relationships.
The conciliation process typically involves the following steps:
• Initiation of conciliation: Conciliation begins when one party invites the other in writing to conciliate. The proceedings commence only if the other party accepts the invitation in writing, ensuring that participation is voluntary.32
• Selection of conciliator: Parties usually select a conciliator for his or her expertise, impartiality and skill in guiding discussions. Parties may also enlist a suitable institution to recommend or appoint a conciliator. Unlike an arbitrator or a judge, the conciliator has no authority to impose a binding decision; the conciliator’s role is to help the parties communicate effectively, clear up misunderstandings and suggest possible ways to reach a mutually acceptable settlement.33
• Submission of statements: Parties submit written statements describing the general nature of the dispute and the points at issue, and may be asked for further statements of their positions supported by documents and evidence. Each party sends a copy of its statement to the other, which promotes clarity and transparency in the process.34
• Role of the conciliator: The conciliator assists the parties in an independent and impartial manner, helping them identify the key issues, resolve misunderstandings and explore solutions acceptable to both sides.35
• Meetings and exchange of information: The conciliator may meet or communicate with the parties orally or in writing, together or separately. The conciliator facilitates discussion and may suggest settlement options.36
• Settlement agreement: If the parties reach agreement, they may draw up and sign a written settlement agreement, which the conciliator may draw up or help them draw up if they so request. Once signed, the agreement is final and binding on the parties and has the same status and effect as an arbitral award on agreed terms.37
• Termination of conciliation: Conciliation proceedings terminate when the parties sign a settlement agreement, when the conciliator declares in writing that further efforts are no longer justified, when the parties jointly declare the proceedings terminated, or when one party declares them terminated.38
Despite its advantages, conciliation faces challenges such as limited awareness, hesitation to participate in a non-binding process, and power imbalances between parties. Overcoming these issues requires greater education, improved training, and supportive legal and institutional reforms that encourage collaborative dispute resolution. With increasing recognition of its value, conciliation in India is steadily moving toward a stronger role within the mainstream justice system.
iii. Mediation
Under Section 3(h) of the Mediation Act, 2023, “mediation” includes a process, whether referred to as mediation, pre-litigation mediation, online mediation, community mediation, conciliation or an expression of similar import, whereby parties attempt to reach an amicable settlement of their dispute with the assistance of a third person, the mediator, who does not have the authority to impose a settlement upon the parties.39
In simple terms, mediation is a process in which the disputing parties seek the help of a neutral mediator to reach an amicable settlement. It may take place as pre-litigation, online or community mediation, and the mediator’s role is limited to facilitating communication, without the power to impose a decision on the parties.40
In mediation, a neutral third party, the mediator, assists the disputing parties in reaching a mutually satisfactory resolution. The mediator’s role is to foster transparent communication and constructive negotiation rather than to deliver or enforce a decision. This approach allows the parties to settle their differences voluntarily while retaining control over the outcome, thereby promoting the ideals of fairness, participation and access to justice.41
Mediation is particularly effective because it emphasises collaborative problem-solving and encourages the active participation of all parties. The mediator fosters a constructive environment in which participants can express their concerns, identify shared interests and work together toward a mutually beneficial resolution.42
Mediation stands as a cornerstone of the ADR framework, offering a voluntary, confidential and cooperative means of resolving disputes. One of its key strengths lies in its ability to preserve relationships by fostering mutual understanding and collaboration, an element particularly significant in ongoing associations such as family or business relationships. It provides a faster and more cost-effective alternative to litigation, ensuring privacy while empowering parties to craft their own settlements. Through this participatory process, mediation promotes a sense of ownership and satisfaction, often leading to more lasting and harmonious outcomes. By emphasising dialogue, fairness and autonomy, mediation not only strengthens trust in the justice system but also advances the broader goal of accessible, people-centric justice that values resolution over confrontation.
iv. Negotiation
Negotiation is often considered the most preferred form of ADR because of its simplicity and efficiency in achieving mutually acceptable outcomes. Unlike other ADR mechanisms, it does not require the involvement of a neutral third party; rather, it depends on direct and voluntary discussions between the disputing parties. The objective is to reach an agreement that meets the interests of both parties.43 It is a voluntary and dynamic communication process through which two or more parties with divergent interests engage in dialogue to reach a mutually satisfactory resolution. Unlike formal adjudicatory mechanisms such as litigation or arbitration, it allows the parties to retain autonomy over both the procedure and the outcome, thereby encouraging collaboration, flexibility and the preservation of relationships.44
This method is particularly popular among businesses, non-profit organisations and individuals in personal disputes, such as divorcing couples or separated parents. Businesses often prefer negotiation for its flexibility and its ability to preserve professional relationships. Non-profit organisations may choose it to resolve internal conflicts efficiently and maintain their focus on their missions. In personal disputes, negotiation provides a private, less adversarial environment in which parties can communicate openly and collaborate to reach a fair resolution, often resulting in more sustainable and amicable outcomes.
In Afcons, the Supreme Court described the four non-adjudicatory processes under Section 89 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (conciliation, mediation, judicial settlement and Lok Adalat settlement) as “negotiatory” processes, and observed that resort to ADR processes is necessary to give speedy and effective relief to litigants and to reduce the pendency in, and burden upon, the courts.45
v. Lok Adalat
The Constitution (Forty-second Amendment) Act, 1976 introduced Article 39A, affirming the State’s obligation to secure equal justice by providing free legal aid to the weaker sections of society. This constitutional mandate was operationalised through the Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987, which established a framework to make justice accessible to all, irrespective of financial constraints.46 The Act gave statutory recognition to Lok Adalats, or people’s courts, as institutional forums for out-of-court dispute resolution, thereby advancing the objectives of ADR and promoting accessible, people-centric justice.47
The Lok Adalat system is a distinctive procedure in India. The term means “court of the people”. It is a forum in which the parties consciously try to resolve their differences through persuasion and conciliation.48
Lok Adalats, introduced in the 1980s, were among the earliest ADR mechanisms in India.49 They facilitate justice delivery in cases pending in court or at the pre-litigation stage, and their benches are presided over by serving or retired judicial officers. When the parties reach a settlement, the Lok Adalat makes an award, which is deemed to be a decree of a civil court, is final and binding on the parties, and is not subject to appeal.50 Where no settlement is reached, the record of a case referred by a court is returned to that court for disposal in accordance with law, and in a pre-litigation matter the Lok Adalat advises the parties to seek a remedy in court.51 Permanent Lok Adalats, which sit on a continuing basis to settle and, failing settlement, to decide disputes relating to public utility services, were provided for by Chapter VI-A (Sections 22A to 22E), added to the Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987 by an amendment in 2002.52
Enhancing justice accessibility through ADR
ADR processes such as mediation and arbitration are viewed favourably by users because of their ease of use, their adaptability and their capacity to enable parties to settle conflicts amicably outside the established legal system.53
ADR functions as an essential instrument for enhancing access to justice, especially for individuals who face difficulty in navigating the formal judicial system. The principal ways in which ADR accomplishes this are discussed below.
A. Cost-effectiveness
Litigation is often prohibitively costly, with legal expenses escalating rapidly and placing justice beyond the reach of many individuals. ADR, in contrast, offers a more affordable avenue for resolving disputes. Mediation, for example, often requires minimal fees compared with the cost of hiring lawyers and paying for court appearances. Arbitration, while more formal than mediation, is typically still more affordable than a full trial.54
For those in financial distress or from economically disadvantaged backgrounds, ADR can offer an affordable means of resolving disputes. Many jurisdictions also have initiatives that offer subsidised ADR services so that low-income individuals can use these options.
B. Speedy resolution and efficiency
Traditional litigation often stretches over months or even years, causing hardship for those seeking timely justice. ADR, in contrast, offers a faster path to settlement. Processes such as mediation and negotiation can resolve disputes within days or weeks, while arbitration typically concludes far sooner than a full court trial, ensuring quicker and more efficient justice delivery.55
This prompt resolution not only serves the interests of the parties but also eases the strain on overburdened courts, allowing the judiciary to devote greater attention to complex and high-priority matters.
C. Empowering parties
In traditional litigation, parties have limited control over outcomes, with final decisions resting with the judge. ADR, however, empowers parties to shape their own settlements. Through mediation or negotiation, disputants, assisted where necessary by a neutral facilitator, work collaboratively toward mutually acceptable solutions, reflecting the constitutional ideals of fairness, participation and accessibility.56
This active participation fosters outcomes that are both satisfactory and enduring. When parties themselves contribute to shaping the resolution, they develop a sense of ownership and commitment, making them more inclined to honour and uphold the terms of the agreement.
D. Preserving relationships
One of the key advantages of ADR, particularly mediation, is its capacity to preserve and strengthen the relationship between the parties. In litigation, the adversarial process often leads to lasting animosity between the parties. This is particularly problematic in family disputes, workplace conflicts and business relationships, where ongoing interaction may be necessary.57
ADR, in contrast, fosters cooperation. The goal is not to “win” against the other party but to reach a mutually acceptable solution. This collaborative process helps maintain a respectful and constructive dialogue, which can preserve relationships after the dispute has been resolved.
E. Flexibility and informality
ADR is more flexible and informal than litigation. While court procedures are rigid, ADR processes allow greater adaptability. For example, mediation sessions can be scheduled at the convenience of the parties, and the terms of settlement can be tailored to the particular needs of the situation. This flexibility enables creative and customised solutions that are often unattainable within the constraints of a traditional courtroom.58
Moreover, the informal and flexible nature of ADR helps minimise the stress and rigidity typically associated with courtroom procedure, making it more approachable for individuals who may perceive the formal judicial process as daunting.
F. Access for marginalised and vulnerable groups
ADR plays a crucial role in extending justice to marginalised and vulnerable groups who often face barriers in accessing formal courts. Tailored ADR programmes have been established to support economically weaker sections, indigenous communities and individuals in remote or rural areas. By offering affordable or free dispute resolution services, these mechanisms promote inclusivity and equity in justice delivery, ensuring that financial hardship or geographical isolation does not impede the right to fair redress.59
G. Specialised and neutral third person
ADR enhances access to justice by placing the process in the hands of a specialised and neutral third person who guides the parties toward resolution. With professional training in communication and conflict management, the mediator or conciliator helps simplify discussions, reduce tension and safeguard each party’s right to be heard fairly. This impartial guidance makes ADR more approachable and effective, allowing disputes to be resolved efficiently without the barriers of the formal court system.60
H. Confidentiality and privacy
ADR facilitates access to justice by providing a confidential and private space for resolving disputes. Since the proceedings are not open to the public, parties can discuss sensitive issues with greater ease and openness, especially in commercial and family matters. This privacy encourages honest communication and helps the parties work toward a more effective and comfortable resolution than is often possible in a courtroom.61
I. Convenient scheduling
ADR strengthens access to justice through flexible and convenient proceedings that allow parties to participate at times suitable to them. Unlike formal courts with fixed schedules, mediation and conciliation sessions can be arranged quickly, reducing delays and making the process easier for individuals with time or work constraints. This flexibility helps disputes reach timely and efficient resolution, improving the overall accessibility of the justice system.62
J. Freedom of the parties
ADR advances access to justice by allowing parties to exercise greater control over the resolution process. They can choose their mediator or arbitrator, set convenient timelines and shape the proceedings to suit their needs. This autonomy creates a more cooperative environment and allows parties to develop solutions that genuinely reflect their interests, making ADR a more accessible and flexible alternative to formal court procedure.63
K. Freedom from the procedural codes
ADR offers a significant advantage in that its proceedings are not constrained by the strict procedural requirements of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 or by the rules of evidence. Section 19 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 provides that arbitral tribunals are not bound by the Code of Civil Procedure or the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, now replaced by the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023; Section 66 of that Act extends the same freedom to conciliators, and Section 15(5) of the Mediation Act, 2023 will do so for mediators once it is brought into force. This fosters a more flexible, efficient and accessible mechanism aimed at the substantive resolution of disputes rather than mere procedural compliance.64
By providing a more accessible and equitable forum for dispute resolution, ADR helps narrow the gap in access to justice. Its flexible procedures, lower costs and user-friendly approach enable individuals from diverse socio-economic backgrounds to participate effectively in resolving their disputes. Unlike the formal court system, ADR reduces procedural barriers and offers parties greater control and comfort, allowing conflicts to be settled fairly and efficiently.
Limitations of alternative dispute resolution
Despite its many advantages, ADR is not without its challenges:
1. Power imbalances: In some instances, disparities in bargaining power may arise, for example in employment disputes or in conflicts between large corporations and individual consumers. Without sufficient procedural safeguards, ADR may struggle to ensure equality between the parties.65
2. Enforceability: The binding force of a settlement depends on the process that produced it. A settlement agreement signed in conciliation under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 is final and binding and has the status of an arbitral award on agreed terms. The Mediation Act, 2023 provides that a mediated settlement agreement signed by the parties and authenticated by the mediator is final and binding and enforceable in the same manner as a judgment or decree of a court, subject to a limited challenge; those provisions, however, have yet to be brought into force. A settlement reached by direct negotiation binds the parties only as a contract. Arbitration, though binding, may still raise apprehension among parties who perceive risks of bias, unequal bargaining power or procedural inequity, concerns that often stem from doubts about the neutrality of arbitrators, the transparency of the proceedings or the influence of stronger parties.66
3. Not suitable for all disputes: ADR is not appropriate for all types of legal conflict, particularly cases involving criminal matters or where public policy is at stake. Some cases may also require a judge’s intervention, particularly where the dispute involves complex legal issues or violations of fundamental rights.67
How can ADR mechanisms be strengthened?
Since the doors of justice cannot be shut, the influx of cases cannot be stopped. There is, however, an urgent need to increase the outflow, either by creating new outlets or by improving the capacity of the existing system, both qualitatively and quantitatively. ADR can provide such an outlet, and three factors are important to its success:
• Compulsory referral to ADR processes;68
• Effective judicial case management;69 and
• Dedicated teams of judges and legal professionals.
A fundamental tenet of the entire system of justice administration is equal justice for all.70 The idea of justice is so deeply ingrained in both common law and civil law jurisprudence that it shapes the whole of each system.
It is inconceivable to envisage a system of justice that lacks fairness and equality. Consequently, in contemporary egalitarian legal frameworks, effective access to justice has been acknowledged as both a fundamental prerequisite and an essential human right.71 Its objective extends beyond the mere proclamation of legal rights to ensuring their concrete protection and realisation.
Judicial recognition and advancement of ADR in India
When a disagreement arises between two people in the same country, the first and most common way to settle it is through the legal system, that is, through the courts established by the country’s laws. This has been the most common and significant means used by Indian citizens to settle their conflicts with one another.72
Justice stands as the cornerstone and ultimate objective of every civilised society, and humanity has long aspired to attain it. The resolution of disputes is one of the primary functions of the Indian judiciary and is integral to sustaining social cohesion. The State, through its legal framework, has evolved institutions and procedures aimed at ensuring justice, maintaining order and offering structured pathways for conflict resolution.73 Among the organs of the State, the judiciary holds a distinct position as the body directly entrusted with the administration of justice.
The Indian judiciary serves as the primary forum for the actual delivery of justice. Conflict resolution remains a fundamental element in sustaining a peaceful and orderly society. Among the various mechanisms of dispute resolution, arbitration has been duly recognised and upheld by the Indian judicial system.
In Guru Nanak Foundation v. Rattan Singh & Sons,74 the Supreme Court noted that interminable, time-consuming, complex and expensive court procedures had driven jurists to search for an alternative forum, less formal, more effective and speedy, for the resolution of disputes. This search led to the Arbitration Act, 1940.75 However, the Court observed that the way in which proceedings under that Act were conducted, and challenged in the courts without exception, had “made lawyers laugh and legal philosophers weep”. Experience and the law reports, the Court remarked, showed that arbitration proceedings had become highly technical and marked by unending prolixity, at every stage providing a legal trap for the unwary. What the parties had chosen as an informal forum for the expeditious disposal of their disputes had, through the decisions of the courts, been clothed in legalese of unforeseeable complexity.
In Oil and Natural Gas Commission v. Collector of Central Excise, a dispute arose between a government department and a public sector undertaking. Noting that such litigation was conducted at considerable public expense and wasted valuable court time, the Supreme Court directed the Government of India to set up a committee to monitor disputes between public sector undertakings, and between them and the Government, so that no such litigation reached a court or tribunal without the committee’s clearance; pursuant to these directions, a Committee on Disputes headed by the Cabinet Secretary was constituted.76 The Court’s approach reflected the view that public sector undertakings should endeavour to resolve their disputes amicably, whether through mutual consultation, the assistance of designated government bodies or arbitration, in order to prevent avoidable litigation.
In Babar Ali v. Union of India,77 the constitutionality of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 was challenged on the ground that, under the Act, the question of an arbitrator’s jurisdiction could be examined by the court only after the arbitral award was made, and not during the pendency of the proceedings. The Delhi High Court rejected this contention, and a Special Leave Petition was filed before the Supreme Court to challenge that decision.
The Supreme Court dismissed the Special Leave Petition, holding that there was no question of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 being unconstitutional or violating the basic structure of the Constitution. Agreeing with the High Court, the Court held that judicial review remains available for challenging an arbitral award, in accordance with the procedure laid down in the Act, and that the time and manner of such judicial scrutiny can legitimately be laid down by an Act of Parliament.
In Salem Advocate Bar Association v. Union of India (2002), the Supreme Court noted that Section 89 was inserted so that cases filed in court need not necessarily be decided by the court itself. In view of the law’s delays and the limited number of judges available, the Court considered it imperative to resort to ADR mechanisms to bring litigation to an end at an early date. When the parties agree to arbitration, the provisions of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 apply and the case goes outside the stream of the court. Resort to conciliation, mediation or judicial settlement, however, does not ipso facto take the case outside the judicial system. The object is to make genuine efforts to bring about an amicable settlement; if settlement is not possible despite these efforts, the case will ultimately go to trial.78
In Afcons Infrastructure Ltd. v. Cherian Varkey Construction Co. (P) Ltd., the Supreme Court undertook a detailed analysis of Section 89 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, which obliges courts to promote the settlement of disputes through ADR processes. Although the Court observed that Section 89, read with Order X, was imperfectly drafted and contained certain anomalies, it applied principles of statutory interpretation to make the provision workable. The Court also identified the types of cases suitable for referral to ADR, having regard to the nature of the disputes.79 It further noted that “Section 89 refers to five types of ADR procedures, made up of one adjudicatory process (arbitration) and four negotiatory (non adjudicatory) processes - conciliation, mediation, judicial settlement and Lok Adalat settlement.”80
These landmark judgments underscore the crucial role of the judiciary in promoting arbitration and mediation as effective alternatives to conventional court litigation. They have opened the path for the broader use of ADR methods across different legal settings, enhancing the efficiency, accessibility and equity of dispute resolution.
Conclusion
This study highlights the growing importance of ADR in improving access to justice within India’s evolving legal system. Over time, ADR has become an essential element of the justice delivery framework, offering practical solutions to enduring problems such as judicial backlog, procedural rigidity and barriers to accessibility. Legislative measures such as the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 and the Mediation Act, 2023, together with judicial recognition in landmark decisions such as Salem Advocate Bar Association, Afcons Infrastructure and Guru Nanak Foundation, have firmly embedded ADR within India’s formal legal structure.
ADR’s flexible, affordable, confidential and participatory processes allow parties to settle disputes efficiently while maintaining greater control over the outcome, something rarely possible in traditional court proceedings. As this study shows, ADR not only supports the judicial system but also strengthens it by fostering cooperation, minimising adversarial confrontation and helping to preserve relationships between parties.
At the same time, the long-term success of ADR depends on strengthening institutional frameworks, improving the training and accreditation of neutrals, raising public awareness and ensuring adequate protection for vulnerable and marginalised groups. With continued legislative refinement, judicial support and systematic capacity-building, ADR holds the potential to reshape India’s justice landscape profoundly, making dispute resolution more inclusive, efficient and consistent with the constitutional values of fairness, equality and meaningful access to justice.
*****
Footnotes
1. Anna Nylund, Access to Justice: Is ADR a Help or Hindrance?, in The Future of Civil Litigation: Access to Courts and Court-Annexed Mediation in the Nordic Countries 325 (Laura Ervo & Anna Nylund eds., 2014), https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-04465-1_16.
2. Jacqueline M. Nolan-Haley, Foreword: Achieving Access to Justice Through ADR: Fact or Fiction?, 88 Fordham L. Rev. 2111 (2020).
3. Shantanu Pachahara & Chandan Maheshwari, Dispute Resolution on Blockchain: An Opportunity to Increase Efficiency of Business Dispute Resolution?, 39 Conflict Stud. Q. 63, 64 (2022).
4. Anita Kushwaha v. Pushap Sudan, (2016) 8 SCC 509, ¶¶ 28–30 (India).
5. India Const. art. 39A (inserted by the Constitution (Forty-second Amendment) Act, 1976).
6. Salem Advocate Bar Association v. Union of India, (2003) 1 SCC 49, ¶ 9 (India); Salem Advocate Bar Association v. Union of India, (2005) 6 SCC 344 (India); Afcons Infrastructure Ltd. v. Cherian Varkey Construction Co. (P) Ltd., (2010) 8 SCC 24, ¶ 7 (India).
7. Anshita, Evolution and Growth of ADR in India: A Legal and Socio-Economic Perspective, 7 Int’l J. Legal Sci. & Innovation 724 (2025), https://ijlsi.com/article/view/evolution-and-growth-of-adr-in-india-a-legal-and-socio-economic-perspective.
8. The Code of Civil Procedure (Amendment) Act, 1999, § 7, No. 46, Acts of Parliament, 1999 (India) (inserting Section 89 into the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, with effect from July 1, 2002).
9. The Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, § 89, No. 5 of 1908 (India). Where it appears to the court that there exist elements of a settlement which may be acceptable to the parties, the court formulates the terms of settlement, may reformulate them after receiving the parties’ observations, and refers the dispute for arbitration, conciliation, judicial settlement (including settlement through Lok Adalat) or mediation. A reference to arbitration or conciliation is governed by the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996; a reference to Lok Adalat or for judicial settlement by the Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987; and, for mediation, the court effects a compromise between the parties following such procedure as may be prescribed. Id. § 89(1)–(2).
10. S. I. Strong, Applying the Lessons of International Commercial Arbitration to International Commercial Mediation: A Dispute System Design Analysis, in Mediation in International Commercial and Investment Disputes 39, 48 (Catharine Titi & Katia Fach Gómez eds., 2019), https://doi.org/10.1093/law/9780198827955.003.0003.
11. N. Aggarwal, Alternative Dispute Resolution: Concept and Concerns, 7 Nyaya Deep 68 (2006).
12. Black’s Law Dictionary 194 (Bryan A. Garner ed., 11th ed. 2019) (defining “alternative dispute resolution”).
13. Afcons, supra note 6, ¶¶ 18–19.
14. In Afcons, the Supreme Court listed as normally unsuitable for ADR: representative suits under Order I Rule 8 of the Code of Civil Procedure; disputes relating to election to public offices; cases involving grant of authority by the court after enquiry, such as suits for probate or letters of administration; cases involving serious and specific allegations of fraud, fabrication of documents, forgery, impersonation or coercion; cases requiring the protection of courts, such as claims against minors, deities and mentally challenged persons and suits for declaration of title against the government; and cases involving prosecution for criminal offences. It listed as normally suitable: cases relating to trade, commerce and contracts; cases arising from strained or soured relationships, including matrimonial causes, maintenance and custody of children; cases where a pre-existing relationship needs to continue, such as disputes between neighbours or between employers and employees; cases of tortious liability, including claims for compensation in motor accidents; and consumer disputes. The Court described both lists as illustrative, not exhaustive. Afcons, supra note 6, ¶¶ 18–19.
15. S. B. Sinha, Mediation: Constituents, Process and Merit 1, https://www.patnahighcourt.gov.in/bslsa/pdf/Publication/6.pdf.
16. P. C. Rao, Alternatives to Litigation in India, in Alternative Dispute Resolution: What It Is and How It Works 24 (P. C. Rao & William Sheffield eds., 1997).
17. Rao, supra note 16, at 24.
18. Henry J. Brown & Arthur L. Marriott, ADR Principles and Practice 13 (2d ed. 1999).
19. Law Commission of India, Seventy-Seventh Report on Delay and Arrears in Trial Courts 1 (1978).
20. Law Commission of India, Fourteenth Report on Reform of Judicial Administration vol. 1, ch. 11, at 252 (1958).
21. B. D. Singh, Alternative Dispute Resolution System 8 (Central Law Publ’ns 2023).
22. Juan Pablo, Effectiveness of Mediation and Arbitration as Alternative Dispute Resolution Methods in Mexico, 4 J. Conflict Mgmt. 38, 39 (2024), https://doi.org/10.47604/jcm.2383.
23. The Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, No. 26, Acts of Parliament, 1996 (India).
24. U.N. Comm’n on Int’l Trade L., UNCITRAL Model Law on International Commercial Arbitration (1985).
25. UNCITRAL Model Law, supra note 24, art. 2(a); Arbitration and Conciliation Act §§ 2(1)(a), 10, 11(2), 19(2).
26. Rao, supra note 16, at 24.
27. Arbitration and Conciliation Act §§ 35–36.
28. Id. § 19(1); The Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023, § 170, No. 47, Acts of Parliament, 2023 (India) (repealing the Indian Evidence Act, 1872).
29. Singh, supra note 21, at 260.
30. U.N. Comm’n on Int’l Trade L., UNCITRAL Conciliation Rules (1980).
31. The Mediation Act, 2023, No. 32, Acts of Parliament, 2023 (India), § 61 & sch. 6 (substituting sections 61 to 81 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996). Of the Mediation Act, only sections 1, 3, 26, 31 to 38, 45 to 47, 50 to 54, 56 and 57 were brought into force, on October 9, 2023; section 61 and the Sixth Schedule await commencement.
32. Arbitration and Conciliation Act § 62.
33. Id. §§ 63–64.
34. Id. § 65.
35. Id. § 67.
36. Id. § 69.
37. Id. §§ 73–74.
38. Id. § 76.
39. Mediation Act § 3(h), https://egazette.gov.in/WriteReadData/2023/248775.pdf (Gazette of India, Extraordinary, Sept. 15, 2023).
40. Singh, supra note 21, at 340.
41. Avtar Singh, Law of Arbitration and Conciliation: Including Other Alternative Means of Dispute Settlement 347 (11th ed. 2018).
42. Shreejanya Upreti, Impact of Alternative Dispute Resolution on India’s Legal Framework: Enhancing Efficiency and Access to Justice, 6 Indian J.L. & Legal Rsch. 3586 (2024), https://www.ijllr.com/post/impact-of-alternative-dispute-resolution-on-india-s-legal-framework-enhancing-efficiency-and-access.
43. Roger Fisher, William Ury & Bruce Patton, Getting to Yes: Negotiating Agreement Without Giving In 3 (2d ed. 1991).
44. Roy J. Lewicki, David M. Saunders & Bruce Barry, Negotiation 5 (7th ed. 2015).
45. Afcons, supra note 6, ¶¶ 7, 20.
46. India Const. art. 39A; The Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987, No. 39, Acts of Parliament, 1987 (India).
47. Singh, supra note 21, at 316.
48. P. B. S. Rao, Establishment of Permanent Lok Adalats: A Bane or Boon?, 31 Indian Bar Rev. 53 (2003).
49. Sarfaraz Ahmed Khan, Lok Adalat: An Effective Alternative Dispute Resolution Mechanism 2 (2006).
50. Legal Services Authorities Act § 21.
51. Id. § 20(5)–(7).
52. Id. §§ 22A–22E (Chapter VI-A, inserted by the Legal Services Authorities (Amendment) Act, 2002, § 4, No. 37, Acts of Parliament, 2002 (India)).
53. Chitra Singh & Manvendra Singh Gurjar, The Significance of Alternative Dispute Resolution in Facilitating Justice Administration, 1 Int’l J. Legal Stud. 9 (2024).
54. Elisabeth Wilson-Evered & John Zeleznikow, Case Study: The Development and Evaluation of Relationship Australia Queensland’s Online Family Dispute Resolution System, in Online Family Dispute Resolution: Evidence for Creating the Ideal People and Technology Interface 63, 64 (2021), https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-64645-5_4.
55. G. Singh, Alternative Dispute Resolution: A Mechanism for Settlement of Commercial Disputes, 18 Delhi L. Rev. 238 (1996).
56. Chetna Upadhyay, Alternative Dispute Resolution Mechanism 24 (2016).
57. Khan, supra note 49, at 14.
58. Upadhyay, supra note 56, at 24.
59. Obafemi D. Akintayo, Chinazo Nneka Ifeanyi & Okeoma Onunka, Enhancing Domestic Peace Through Effective Community-Based ADR Programs, 2 Glob. J. Advanced Rsch. & Revs. 1, 3 (2024), https://doi.org/10.58175/gjarr.2024.2.2.0054.
60. Mediation Act §§ 3(h), 8, 10, 15(2) (sections 8, 10 and 15 not yet in force, see supra note 31); Arbitration and Conciliation Act § 67.
61. Bhavesh H. Bharad & Sandeepkumar R. Pandya, The Evolution of Justice: Assessing the Effectiveness and Its Acceptance of Alternative Dispute Resolution System in India, 105 Annals Bhandarkar Oriental Rsch. Inst. 99, 105 (2024).
62. Arbitration and Conciliation Act §§ 19(1)–(2), 24(1); Mediation Act §§ 15(4), 18 (not yet in force, see supra note 31).
63. Arbitration and Conciliation Act §§ 7, 11, 19(2), 28; Mediation Act §§ 4, 8, 18(2) (not yet in force, see supra note 31).
64. Arbitration and Conciliation Act §§ 19(1), 66; Mediation Act § 15(5) (not yet in force, see supra note 31); Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam § 170.
65. Caesar Roy, Alternative Dispute Resolution and Its Mechanism: A Critical Analysis in the Light of Access to Justice in India, 4 Int’l J. Crim. Common & Stat. L. 25, 28–29 (2024).
66. Mediation Act §§ 27–28 (not yet in force, see supra note 31); Arbitration and Conciliation Act §§ 12, 31, 34–35, 73–74.
67. Robert J. Condlin, ADR: Disputing with a Modern Face, or Bargaining for the Bargaining Impaired?, 21 Cardozo J. Conflict Resol. 291, 318 (2020).
68. Afcons, supra note 6, ¶ 17 (holding that a hearing after the completion of pleadings to consider recourse to ADR is mandatory, though actual reference is not required in excluded categories of cases).
69. Salem Advocate Bar Association (2005), supra note 6 (setting out model case flow management rules for trial courts, first appellate subordinate courts and High Courts, for the High Courts to examine and adopt).
70. India Const. arts. 14, 39A.
71. Anita Kushwaha, supra note 4, ¶ 9.
72. R. C. Lahoti, A Conspectus of Indian System, 6 Nyaya Deep 8–9 (2005).
73. Anita Kushwaha, supra note 4, ¶ 30 (the State must provide an effective adjudicatory mechanism that is reasonably accessible, speedy and affordable).
74. Guru Nanak Foundation v. Rattan Singh & Sons, AIR 1981 SC 2075 (India).
75. The Arbitration Act, 1940 was repealed by the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. Arbitration and Conciliation Act § 85(1).
76. Oil and Natural Gas Commission v. Collector of Central Excise, 1995 Supp (4) SCC 541 (India); see also Northern Coalfields Ltd. v. Heavy Engineering Corp. Ltd., (2016) 8 SCC 685, ¶ 15 (India) (recounting the directions and the constitution of the Committee on Disputes).
77. Babar Ali v. Union of India, (2000) 2 SCC 178 (India).
78. Salem Advocate Bar Association (2003), supra note 6, ¶¶ 9–10.
79. Afcons, supra note 6, ¶¶ 7–19.
80. Id. ¶ 20.
