VidhiAagaz
International Journal ofLaw Management & Humanities
ISSN 2581-5369 · Open access
International Journal ofLaw Management & Humanities
Open accessResearch PaperVol. 9 No. II (2026)pp. 2868–2887

The Evolution of the Right to Privacy in the Era of Digital Surveillance and AI: Legal and Constitutional Issues & Challenges

PG
Pranali P GanachariLL.M. Student at Christ (Deemed to be University) University, Pune, Lavasa, India
118views21downloads
Published 30 April 2026 · pp. 2868–2887 · Vol. 9 No. II (2026)
Abstract

In the modern digital era, artificial intelligence (AI) and data-driven technologies have grown rapidly, and this has completely changed the perception of the concept of privacy as per Article 21 of the Constitution of India. As the reliance on online services, smartphones, and digital platforms continues to grow, personal information has become a valuable resource, and the question of its collection, use, and misuse becomes a matter of serious concern. In that regard, informational autonomy, has become an important element of the right to privacy. This paper will follow the constitutional history of the right to privacy, emphasizing its history of judicial interpretation and the landmark ruling of Justice K.S. Puttaswamy v. Union of India (2017), where the Supreme Court recognized the right to privacy as an inseparable part of the right to life and personal liberty. Although this ruling established a firm constitutional basis, the emergence of AI technologies, including automated decision making, mass surveillance and profiling, creates new and complex challenges to the effective protection of this right. This paper examines the current legal framework in India, and specifically the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023, and compares it with the global standards like the EU General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). It argues that despite the significant steps that have been taken by India to ensure awareness of the rights to digital privacy, the existing regulatory framework remains ineffective in dealing with AI-driven systems. This paper argues in favor of the concept of right-based AI governance that would be in line with innovation and constitutional protection. It concludes by providing possible policy suggestions that could be implemented to guarantee the protection of data, accountability, and make sure that the technological advancement does not influence personal dignity, freedom and privacy.

Keywords
Right to PrivacyArticle 21Artificial Intelligence (AI)Informational AutonomyData surveillanceDigital Personal Data Protection2023
Contents
Full text

INTRODUCTION

It is difficult to define privacy within a simple term or expression. Life without privacy is difficult to imagine. People need privacy. Individual Privacy is extremely important. It is a universal desire of human beings to have their privacy and own space. The various aspects of right to privacy include right to be alone, the right to privacy with the family, the right to privacy with the house, right to safeguard the business secrets without any other person kind of monitoring or unwarranted interference. In this case, say when the letters of a person are published without his or her permission, it may be said to have been a violation of privacy. Where a neighbour peeps in the house of another, is an infringement of the right to the privacy of another, this is also an infringement of his or her right to privacy.

Meaning and Definitions of Privacy

The term privacy is very difficult to define because its meaning is influenced by the individual’s culture, location and personal circumstances. Each person is entitled to decide what details of his or her life are to be revealed to others. It includes the freedom to withdraw from society, which is the right to remain secluded and avoid taking part in society. The concept of privacy also includes the right to control the collection and dissemination of an individual’s personal information.1

Originally, the word privacy came from the term ‘Privi’, meaning something very secret. This shows that there exist particular actions or events in a person’s life where he wishes to act without interference from other individuals. Every individual is entitled to protect the privacy of their personal life, including family matters, marriage, motherhood, procreation, having children and education.

No person has the right to disclose or publish any information relating to these private matters without the concerned individual’s consent, whether the information is true or false and whether it is commendable or damaging. 2

Black’s Law Dictionary explains privacy as a right of an individual to live without unwanted interference from others. It includes various rights that protect individuals from excessive State interference in their private matters and important decisions related to their family and life.3

Webster’s Dictionary explains privacy as a condition where an individual stays away from the observation of others and enjoys seclusion.4

Need for Protecting Privacy in the Digital Age

In the digital era, protecting privacy has become very important. Technology has helped people communicate and share information easily through the internet. Despite the beneficial characteristics of these technologies, they contribute to the misuse of personal data. Therefore, the issue of privacy has been more important.

A significant cause of the increased concerns about privacy is the fact that personal information is being transferred through the electronic space through multiple digital technologies such as online banking applications, e-commerce websites, mobile applications, and social media. The information will be gathered and utilised without full knowledge of the individuals. This raises the possibility of misuse and profiling of personal data.

Privacy and Individual Dignity

Privacy is a very significant aspect in safeguarding the dignity of an individual. Privacy grants self-worth, self-respect as well as living one’s life with honour. It enables one to keep their lives confidential in order to uphold self-respect. This can damage the dignity of a person and lead to embarrassment when an aspect of his or her life is disclosed against his or her will. Privacy assists the person in making his personal decisions, managing his relationship and keeping his personal information secured. By not being monitored, the individual has freedom of expression and lives their life in the manner that they believe it should be. This makes them confident and have a sense of self-respect. Therefore, the society which protects the privacy also values its citizens. An individual has the freedom to express themselves when privacy is safeguarded only with the absence of interference. Privacy protection assists in reinforcing democracy. It also contributes to safeguarding the human dignity.

Contemporary Relevance of the Study

The rapid growth of digital technologies has changed how individuals communicate with each other and also with the state and private entities. In India, the sectors such as healthcare, education, banking, and social media collect and store huge amounts of personal data. Even though these advancements in technology have improved efficiency and accessibility, they still increase the threat related to the protection of privacy. personal information is shared through various online platforms without sufficient awareness of potential implications.

A. Statement of Problem

The rapid growth of digital surveillance and artificial intelligence has major impact on the scope of right to privacy, creating serious concerns and challenges that current legal and constitutional frameworks find it difficult to address. Although the right to privacy is recognised as a fundamental right, the rising application of data-driven technologies by State and non-State actors raises concerns about mass surveillance, lack of transparency, bias in algorithms, and the absence of regulatory protection, creating doubt on the efficiency of existing legal protections in protecting the autonomy and dignity of the individual.

B. Research Objective

To analyse the evolution of right to privacy in digital surveillance and artificial intelligence, and evaluating the adequacy of both legal and constitutional frameworks in response to the emerging challenges.

C. Research Question

Whether the current legal and constitutional framework adequate to address the challenges related with digital surveillance and artificial intelligence to the right to privacy?

D. Research Methodology

The research undertaken is doctrinal in nature. It is based on the existing laws, judicial decisions, and legal principles associated with the protection associated with the Right to Privacy in the digital age. The research is based on both primary as well as secondary sources. The primary sources consist of major laws such as the Information Technology Act 2000, the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023, the GDPR of the European Union, constitutional provisions and landmark judgements that have contributed to the right to privacy. The secondary sources consist of books, research papers, academic journals, and credible online resources. The research examines recurring issues such as digital surveillance, and the challenges that arise from the new technologies, including artificial intelligence. The research aims to evaluate the effectiveness of the existing legal framework and highlight the areas where stronger privacy protection is required in the digital age.

HISTORICAL CONTEXT OF THE RIGHT TO PRIVACY

India has always been a society of people where relationships, cooperation and togetherness are more valuable than individual competition and isolation. Because of this, few people believe that the concept of privacy is not very significant in Indian culture. But this assumption is not completely correct. The concept of privacy also existed in ancient India, and was perceived in many different ways.

Ancient writings like the Dharmashastra and the Hitopadesha depict that individuals were aware of the necessity to keep certain things private. The importance of the concept of personal space and autonomy is also expressed by scholars in ancient India, who believed in the notion of the fact that every man is a king in his own house. Though only limited research exists on the issue of privacy during that period, the manner in which people communicated and adhered to social norms indicates that there were unwritten rules that ensured the privacy of individuals.5

The right to privacy was discussed in the Constituent Assembly, although it was not yet completely accepted. In December 1946, the assembly established various committees to assist in drafting the Constitution of India. At this level, a sub-committee proposed that the right to privacy be incorporated as a fundamental right. But there were strong disagreements. Members like Alladi Krishnaswami Ayyar, B. N. Rau, and M. K. Panikkar were opposing this idea. Actually, Ayyar and Rau were quite vocal in their criticism. Ayyar felt that giving individuals the right to privacy in matters of personal communication might be problematic. He believed that personal documents would be overprotected and, therefore, interfere with court proceedings where these documents are required to be produced. B. N. Rau, on the other hand, feared that the acknowledgement of privacy as a fundamental right would make it complicated for the police to conduct an investigation.6

Due to these fears, both Ayyar and Rau were successful in persuading the Advisory Committee to delete the proposal to incorporate the right to privacy as a fundamental right in the Constitution. There were some attempts to incorporate the right to privacy in the Indian Constitution as part of the fundamental rights in the Constituent Assembly meetings. On 30th April 1947, Somnath Lahiri, an Assembly member, wanted the privacy of correspondence to be declared as a fundamental right, “the privacy of correspondence shall be inviolable and may be infringed only in cases provided by law……”7. But this proposal was not supported in the Assembly. After a year, on 3rd December 1948, the right to privacy was again sought to be added to the Constitution by Kazi Syed Karimuddin. “The right of the people to be secure in their houses, papers, persons, and effects against unreasonable searches and seizures shall not be violated, and no warrants shall issue but upon probable cause supported by oath or affirmation and particularly describing the place to be searched and the persons or things to be seized.”8

Therefore, the right to privacy was initially not considered a fundamental right in the Indian Constitution. The Supreme Court of India, over time, has played a very crucial role in addressing different cases related to privacy. The court, in a series of decisions, was able to grow and establish the concept of privacy, and was recognised as an essential part of the Right to Life and Personal Liberty under Article 21 of the Constitution of India.

A. Judicial Interpretation of the Right to Privacy in India

In the initial cases, the Supreme Court of India adopted a very narrow interpretation of privacy and focused more on what the law said. In M.P. Sharma v. Satish Chandra, 9 the court addressed the question of search and seizure by authorities. It was believed that the right to privacy was not a fundamental right, as it was not explicitly stated in the Constitution.

Ten years later, another landmark case, Kharak Singh v. State of Uttar Pradesh.10 This case dealt with police surveillance and the question of whether this infringed the fundamental rights of a person. The Court discussed the question of whether the tracking of the movements of an individual in accordance with the police regulation was illegal. The Supreme Court, in its ruling, once again indicated that the right to privacy was not a fundamental right under the Constitution. It said that merely observing or monitoring the movements of a person, although it infringes the individual’s privacy, does not necessarily amount to infringement of the fundamental right provided under Part III of the Constitution. Nevertheless, the court acknowledged that there are some personal rights under Article 21 of the Constitution of India. It also held that there exists a common law conception of privacy. Significantly, Justice K. Subba Rao has a dissenting voice and stated that the right to privacy is a subset of personal liberty, making an initial move towards its recognition.

Another case, Govind v. State of Madhya Pradesh,11 resembled the earlier case of Kharak Singh, but this time the court took a very different approach. The Madhya Pradesh Police Regulations were reasonable restrictions, and this was upheld by the Supreme Court. Also, the Court affirmed that the right to privacy exists and could be understood from the other fundamental rights given in Part III of the Constitution. The court, however, added that since there was no explicit law that regulated privacy, this right has to evolve through different cases. A single judgment cannot be used to describe the extent and boundaries of the right to privacy. This case was important as it narrowed Article 21 of the Constitution of India and paved the way to have the right to privacy as a part of it.

In ADM Jabalpur v. Shivakant Shukla,12 the Court examined whether the right to personal liberty could be restricted merely by what is written in the Constitution and laws. It proposed that although the right to privacy is not explicitly stated, it can be learned as an implied right,

particularly under the common law grounds. Justice H. R. Khanna said that Article 21 is not the only source of personal liberty, and that the right to life and liberty came from the legal principles, including common law and existing statutory laws. This gradually strengthened the concept of privacy as an aspect of individual freedom.

In the case of Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India,13 the Supreme Court of India interpreted Article 21 of the Constitution of India in a broader view. The Court said that Article 21 does not apply only to physical existence, but also to concepts of natural justice and individual freedom. This implies that the rights concerning individual freedom and safety are also safeguarded by Article 21.

In another case, R. Rajagopal v. State of Tamil Nadu,14 which developed the concept of right to privacy. The Supreme Court in this case ruled that the right to privacy is a fundamental component of the right to life and personal liberty, as stated under Article 21. The Court also stated that every person has a right to protect his or her personal life, including family, marriage, motherhood, education and other personal concerns. It also clarified that no individual can publish or disclose such personal information without the consent of the person. The court also acknowledged that the right to privacy could be exercised both as a legal claim and as a fundamental right.

Justice K.S. Puttaswamy (Retd.) v. Union of India,15 is the landmark case where the Supreme Court of India has finally recognised the Right to privacy as a fundamental right under Article 21 of the Constitution. This case was raised after the Aadhaar scheme was challenged because the government was gathering biometric information, such as fingerprints and Iris scans of the citizens. The most important question before the court was whether this kind of collection of personal information infringed on the privacy of an individual.

The Court delivered a landmark judgement and declared that the Right to Privacy is a fundamental right under Article 21 of the Constitution of India, and other rights enshrined under Part III of the Constitution. It stated that privacy is a component of personal dignity, autonomy and freedom. It is also an essential part of other rights, such as freedom of speech and expression.

This had a far-reaching impact. It provided the basis for stronger privacy laws in the country and forced the government to consider data protection. It also led to the introduction of legislation such as the Personal Data Protection Bill, 2019, to govern the collection, usage and storage of personal data.16. Puttaswamy judgment highlighted that privacy is not merely an abstract idea but a fundamental right to life, liberty and dignity.

In its 2018 ruling, the Court attempted to balance the need for identification with the right to privacy. It ruled that the use of Aadhaar to link bank accounts and mobile phone numbers was unconstitutional because it infringed the right to privacy.17

PRIVACY AND TECHNOLOGY

The relationship between privacy and technology has changed over time with the advancement of digital systems. Earlier, people used to lock their rooms and keep things private. They kept their personal life private. But now the phone screens light up the home, Information is shared instantly, and pockets hold mini computers. This has changed the meaning and scope of privacy, which refers to protecting personal data. Technology has changed the way people interact with each other and work. 18

People use technologies, like artificial intelligence, big data analytics, biometric systems, cloud computing, and social media platforms, which rely on a huge amount of data to function efficiently. These technologies are executed by a steady process of data creation and processing, predicting decision-making, personalisation, and automation. Though these changes have brought efficiency, convenience, and innovation in various sectors, the boundaries between the public and private spaces have been blurred. People often share personal information unknowingly, making it difficult to control privacy in a highly connected digital network.

In addition to this, the growing dependence on electronic technologies has made both the State and individual companies more powerful, raising legal and ethical challenges. Surveillance technologies can be used by governments in the name of national security and law and order, but without proper protections, they can compromise the rights of citizens. Meanwhile, the majority of user data is managed by private organisations that have monopolies and raise significant commercial risks. Lack of clear awareness, effective regulation and enforcement mechanisms also worsens the risks. As a result, the emerging technologies and privacy require the establishment of a firmly grounded legal framework that would guarantee responsibility, disclosure and safeguarding of personal freedom in the digital era.19

A. Nature of Digital Surveillance

State surveillance is no longer limited to certain individuals, but it has evolved into a massive, technology-oriented system in India. Government agencies can now gather and process large volumes of personal information, such as communication history, financial transactions, travel history, and biometric data, with the assistance of laws such as the Information Technology Act, 2000 as well as systems like Aadhaar. Such actions are normally explained using reasons such as national security, crime prevention, and maintain law and order in the society. However, the absence of transparency, poor protection of the way in which data is exploited, and minimal autonomy of independent control are of significant concerns. The digital era has erased the difference between target and mass surveillance, which can increase the potential over-use of state power. This is especially problematic in the case of constitutional imperatives laid down in Justice K.S. Puttaswamy (Retd.) v. Union of India20 by stating that any interference with privacy needs to be legal, necessary, and proportional.

Simultaneously, private companies have taken up significant surveillance roles too. Through daily online activities, social media platforms, telecom firms, fintech firms and data analytics businesses collect and process vast volumes of personal data. This is usually done through user consent but in reality, there are complex privacy agreements and ambiguous terms that make it hard to entirely find out or manage the manner of usage of their information. As a result, private surveillance tends to be a grey area where business interests override the rights of privacy. This may cause other problems such as discriminatory profiling, data leakages, and even transfer of data to government bodies and this further escalates our privacy concerns without adequate accountability and effective redressal mechanism for individual.

B. Artificial Intelligence

In India, artificial intelligence is being extensively applied in government work, businesses and even social services. It assists in matters like giving welfare benefits, predicting crimes, giving loans, recruiting workers, and controlling online material. Although AI is faster, more efficient, and makes the decision-making process more productive, its increased applications raise significant concerns regarding equity, transparency, and accountability. Systems are not so easy to understand and make important decisions influencing the lives of people, such as employment, access to services, or even the legal consequences. These systems are not very clean, and as a result, people do not understand how decisions are made and how to challenge them, bringing questions of justice and trust. 21

Through the automated decision-making systems, the individuals are often in a hard position to question or control decisions that directly affect their lives, particularly in credit scoring and recruitment, where the use of AI is widely used. Even in cases like predictive policing, the systems have the ability to influence basic rights, and there might not be any human intervention to challenge such results. In order to address such issues, legislative protection has been introduced. In Europe, Article 22 of the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), has limited the making of decisions based on automated processing and provides individuals to challenge such decisions. Likewise, the Digital Personal Data Protection (DPDP) Act 2023 in India gives individuals rights to access their personal data, learn the manner in which such data is processed, and challenge the judgment of an automated system. 22

To address transparency, the GDPR in Articles 1323, 1424, 1525, and 1626 guarantees that individuals have the right to access their data, have a proper understanding of how their information is being utilised, and demand its correction in case of inaccuracies. These provisions allow people to gain more knowledge about automated procedures and have control over their own data. Similarly, in India, the DPDP Act allows individuals to have access to their data and remedies against the misuse of their data in case of misconduct, which protects the transparency and responsibility of the AI system under sections 1427 and 1928.

The artificial intelligence systems are based on huge amounts of data, and when that data already has previous biases, it may result in reinforcing discrimination, particularly against the disadvantaged groups. In India, this may be in the form of caste/gender- based bias, which impacts important areas like employment, policing, and financial services. The second issue is that most AI systems are not transparent, and they cannot be easily understood, making it challenging to understand how decisions are made. This accountability adds to the inequality further because individuals fail to question, challenge, or rectify unfair results in most cases. Even regulations such as the ‘right to explanation’ under the GDPR might not be sufficient to protect individuals and tackle the problem AI causes, highlighting the need for more effective regulations. 29

Currently, no law in India directly regulates Artificial Intelligence, although there are other laws and policies that regulate AI and decision- making algorithms indirectly. The Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023, is one of the major acts that establishes significant guidelines, where section 11(1)30 states that the data fiduciaries are required to handle personal data fairly and transparently. Section 14 gives individuals the right to access and rectify their personal data, as well as the right to appeal the decisions made by automated systems. In addition, section 19 provides people with remedies in situations of misuse of their personal information, thereby strengthening their control over personal information. 31

Besides this, there is another act, the Information Technology Act, 2000, that contributes to the regulation of AI. For instance, in section 43A32, there is an obligation on the organisations to adopt reasonable security practices to secure data, which is important because the AI systems rely heavily on such data. Section 66C33 covers the issue of identity theft, which is especially applicable when AI finds application in impersonation or misuse of data, and the problem of informational integrity emerges. In addition, the Information Technology (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics Code) Rules, 202134 require intermediaries to establish redressal of grievances systems and accountability in context management, even when automated systems are used.

The National Strategy on Artificial Intelligence, published by NITI Aayog in 2018, supports the idea of ethical development of AI, the significance of human control and the necessity to reduce bias in AI systems. Collectively, these legal and policy measures try to establish a code of conduct that leads to transparency, accountability, and the safeguarding of the digital rights of individuals, despite the absence of a comprehensive AI-specific law in India.

Despite these efforts, the regulatory framework in India regarding AI is quite void. In comparison to the GDPR of the European Union, India lacks clear and specific regulations regarding mandatory impact assessments on algorithms, the accountability of AI systems, explainability in high-risk decisions, or even compensation for the harm caused by discriminatory or incompetent algorithms. The GDPR in Articles 13 to 16, 21 and 22 and Recital 71 deal with issues such as transparency, the right to challenge decisions and the necessity of human control; the current framework in India does not offer such detailed protection.35

CONTEMPORARY CHALLENGES AND ISSUES TO PRIVACY PROTECTION

Here a critical question can be raised on whether the national and international provisions, are effective enough to safeguard privacy against rising digital threats, and how privacy may be truly safeguarded. The growing intricacy of the technological advancement has rendered the use of the usual legal tools are inadequate hence there was more necessity of a comprehensive and dynamic approach to privacy protection.

The main component of the enforcement mechanism of the act is the creation of the Data Protection Board of India (DPBI) under the 2025 Rules. Some of the functions that the Board includes adjudication of disputes, enforcement of compliance and penalties against violations. Despite the relevance of the institutional design of the DPBI, there are major concerns about its effectiveness, independence, and accountability. One of the key problems concerns the low enforcement power. The magnitude and size of the digital ecosystem demand a strong regulatory body with enough resources, technical skills, as well as force. However, these requirements are not adequately tackled by the existing framework. The DPBI has a strong executive influence on appointments and operation through the structure, which can weaken its independence. In cases involving government agencies, this raises doubts about Board’s ability to act impartially. It is necessary to have an independent regulator who will make sure that the private entities as well as the State are responsible in the presence of the law. There is also a lack of checks and balances in the institutional structures which is necessary to safeguard the rights of the individual. In the absence of the proper judicial or independent checks, the people are likely to struggle to get remedy in case of privacy breaches. The absence of a strong grievance redressal mechanism further weakens the effectiveness of the Board.36

The Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 has been proposed to provide a broad approach to regulate the processing of digital personal data and they have an attempted to strike a balance between the right to privacy of the individual and the legitimate interests of the State. One of the major concerns is how power is distributed under the Act. On the one hand, individuals are entitled to some rights as data principals, but the State is also endowed with extensive powers, not necessarily accompanied by appropriate guarantees on the other hand.

Section 1737 of the DPDP Act which gives the Central Government with the power to provide immunity under the Act to some of the instrumentalities of the State. The main problem is the vagueness and oversufficiency of these words. Traditional and historical understanding of the terms like “public order” and “security of the State” tend to entail a broader meaning than include only threats to present security but also political dissent, protests, and other activities involving civic engagement. The second issue of concern is the lack of procedural safeguards. Section 17 provides that exemptions may be provided by executive notification without prior consideration of the necessity or proportionality. Such exemptions are not subject to independent authorization, like judicial authorization or parliamentary examination. This simply leaves the authority to override privacy protections in the hands of executive without sufficient checks and balances.

Section 3638 of the DPDP Act gives the Central Government substantial authority to issue rules and to seek information of various entities for the purpose of the Act. The concern in Section 36 is that the government has the authority to request information on an open-ended basis. The provision allows authorities to compel data fiduciaries, intermediaries and even the Data Protection Board to provide such information as may be requested without outlining explicit limits or requirements. No condition exists that such demands must be reasoned on the basis of necessity or proportionality nor is there a condition that they must be accorded before an autonomous body. This raises the possibility that the provision could be used as a tool for indirect or regulatory surveillance. Section 36 does not include such protections as many international systems do, where a judicial warrant or independent authority or periodic review is necessary.39

The second major challenge follows the amendments made to the Right to Information Act, 2005 by Section 44(3)40 of the DPDP Act. This clause amends Section 8(1)(j)41 of the RTI Act that addresses the disclosure of personal information and has received a lot of criticism on undermining the mechanisms of transparency and accountability. The amendment in Section 44(3), connects the disclosure of personal information to the provisions of the DPDP Act. In fact, now the public authorities have the ability to deny information the access because such release information will threaten the data protection norms. This significantly strengthens the exemption and in mitigating the disclosure in situations where the information is of great public interest.

Another major concern raised in the constitutional challenges is the absence of strong safeguards against surveillance and the concentration of power in the hands of the executive. The DPDP Act gives the government substantial power to access and process personal data, though it lacks sufficient measures to provide that such powers be used responsibly. In particular, there is no requirement for prior judicial approval before data is accessed, nor is there a system of independent oversight to review such actions. This absence of protection is particularly problematic when it comes to the modern digital technology, where it has become easy to gather and process large volumes of personal information.42

CONCLUSION AND SUGGESTIONS

The history of the right to privacy in India shows how constitutional concepts have changed over time. The Supreme Court has interpreted it and made it an essential element of Article 21 in the Puttaswamy case. This change indicates the way the judiciary has adapted to evolving needs and realities in society. Privacy is no longer a luxury, but a concept closely linked to human dignity, individual liberty and autonomy. Today, existing data protection legal frameworks such as the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023, in India are not sufficiently effective to address contemporary digital threats. This is mainly because these laws are based on an older model of privacy protection that focuses on notice and consent. Although such approach was efficient in the old times when data was gathered in simple and observable ways, it is not compatible with the current digital world. Artificial intelligence, big data and continuous monitoring technologies are much bigger and work in many ways without the knowledge of users. Although the introduction of DPDP Act in India has been a key move, the current structure still requires a lot of enhancement, to be in a position to ensure privacy within a fast-changing digital world. To attain successful protection, the current regime needs to be enhanced by adding more definite protective methods, more independent and competent institutions, and such legislation that reacts to the new technologies directly. Until these improvements are implemented, the existing system will not be a full efficient way of safeguarding privacy in a more complicated digital world, it will be just a first step towards safeguarding it.

A. Suggestions for Reform of Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023

The close reading of the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 and the Digital Personal Data Protection Rules, 2025 reveals the specific structural and interpretational gaps within the Act and Rules. The following suggestion aims to fill these gaps with a view to make both the Act and rules properly enforceable.

Section 5 of the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023: It deals with the “Notice”. It states that the Data collector has to provide Notice informing the Data Principal about the consent, Data processing etc.

However, this section is practically useless. The Data Fiduciaries usually end up with excessively long and complex privacy policies which the Data principal cannot comprehend easily and often ignores going through such notices.

An effective reform would be:

•  To introduce a standardized form which requires the notices to be clear, concise and notice to be presented in a standardized manner.

•  Notice to be presented in the regional language to Data principal along with English Language.

This will ensure that the Data Fiduciaries are actually complying with the Section 5 of the Act and not merely discharging the duty to inform.

Section 6 of the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023: It deals with “Consent”. It appears strong and effective at the first glance. Section 6 of the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023, states that consent has to be free, informed, specific and unambiguous. In real world practice the consent is often reduced to single “Accept All” tick to provide the consent of the user.

An effective reform would be:

•  The provision should require that consent should be obtained separately for every distinct data processing.

•  Instead of accepting bundle of permission at once, a clear short summary using the language which the Data Principal can easily comprehend and interpret as to what he/she is consenting to and how his/her data is processed.

•  The short summary must be presented before the Data Principal to describe the consent the Data Principal is providing and how the data will be processed in summary to avoid going through large documents which an average Data Principal often avoids and fails to understand such complex language.

Such a change would transform consent from just a checkbox to rightful and meaningful exercise of choice.

Section 7 of the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023: It deals with the “Legitimate uses of the Personal Data”. Such permission introduces ambiguity into the framework when there is absence of a clear test to determine what constitutes legitimate uses which will lead to misuse of the personal data by Data Fiduciaries.

An Effective reform would be:

•  Section 7 should be amended to include the principles of necessity and proportionality.

•  It must be clarified as to what is legitimate uses

•  Usage of personal data must be strictly limited to what is necessary and not affect the rights of Data Principal.

•  The Burden of showing the necessity should lie on the Data Fiduciary.

Such amendments would be in line with the constitutional principles recognized in Justice K.S. Puttaswamy V. Union of India,43 which safeguarded against the excessive intrusion of state and private.

Section 8 of the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023: It deals with the “usage of personal data” by Data Fiduciary. It establishes that data of the user must only be used for the purpose it was collected and cannot randomly use it for something else. That the companies should delete it and not keep the data forever. The companies have to take reasonable security safety safeguards.

Issues with this Provision

•  The problem with this provision is that it does not clearly establishes strict data

minimization and users extra data is collected just in case which is not at all necessary.

•  The law does not mention the time-limit where the companies have to delete data after such time period is expired.

•  The companies collect data mentioning that it’s for improvising their service but such purpose never ends. Basically, the companies just not keep the data forever but also continue to collect the data until the consent has been withdrawn.

•  The provision only mentions reasonable safety safeguards. The term ‘reasonable safety safeguards’ introduces ambiguity. In case of breach the companies will argue that they had taken ‘reasonable safety safeguards.

An Effective Reform would be:

•  Strict data minimization so that data is not collected more than it is required.

•  Time-limit for the companies to delete the data after fulfilling of the purpose it was collected for.

•  Clear establishing of what security measures, technology to be adapted by the companies to avoid data breach.

Section 8 of the DPDP Act, imposes responsibility but it effectively allows the Data Fiduciaries to decide the extent of their compliance with this provision.

Section 11 and 12 of the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023: It deals with the “Right to access and the right to erasure” which is very significant as it ensures user empowerment.

However, these only remain theoretical as there are no clear timelines or consequences for failure of compliance by the Data Fiduciary. Such a right without any remedy in effect is only an illusion.

An effective reform would be:

•  Strict timelines must be implemented for compliance such as mandatory response within 15 days.

•  Failure to comply with this section, Data Fiduciary should be attracted with heavy fines and penalties and other consequences.

Such reforms would bring this right into reality rather than it just theoretical. This would ensure that the section 11 and 12 of the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 is properly enforced.

Section 17 of the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023: It deals with the “Exemptions to the State regarding the usage of personal data”. The Exemptions to the state in this section are justified in the interest of sovereignty, security and public order but the absence of procedural safeguards weakens the accountability.

The effective reform would be:

•  Conditions should be introduced for exercise of such exemptions.

•  Such exemption be supported by a written and reasoned order.

•  Incorporate principles of necessity.

This would ensure that these exemptions are not exercised arbitrarily.

Section 33 of the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023: It deals with “Penalty Framework”. It is very important as it maintains law and order and reduces the violations of this Act.

However, the violations and corresponding penalties are not clearly defined in category which leads to inconsistent enforcement. It is of the discretion of the concerned authority to decide the penalty. Such provision would lead to arbitrariness.

An effective reform would be:

•  Introducing graded penalty system distinguishing between minor, serious and repeated violations.

•  Nature of breach and the harm caused should decide the size of the penalties.

This would ensure that there is no arbitrariness in the findings of the authority or court of law and penalty imposed for the violations committed.

Section 36 of the Digital Data Protection Act, 2023: needs to be revised so as to curb the growth of misuse of the government in retrieving data.

It is proposed to reform the following:

•  No government request of the data provided should take place without judicial approval.

•  The requests have to be specific, scope limited and time bound.

•  Such requests should be examined and controlled by the Data Protection Board.

These actions would contribute to averting arbitrary access to data and bring the provision into the line with the constitutional protection.

B. Suggestions for reform of Digital Personal Data Protection Rules, 2025

The Digital Personal Data Protection Rules, 2025 operationalize the framework laid down in the Digital Personal Data Protection Data, 2023. The following things require reformation to ensure that the rules are enforced effectively.

Rule 3 of Digital Personal Data Protection Rules, 2025: It deals with the “Notice” that is to be issued by the Data Fiduciary to the Data Principal. This rule mentions that notice has to be clear and written in simple language.

This rule though mentions the clarity in language, however, it does not address the format in which the notice has to be provided which would make it easier for the user to understand. Lack of standardized format will still allow the companies to create a lengthy notice which the user will fail to understand.

An effective reform would be:

•  Mandate a layered Notice format which contains essential details only which will be easy for the Data Principal to understand to what he/she is consenting to.

Rule 7 of Digital Personal Data Protection Rules, 2025: It deals with the “Personal Data Breach Notification”. This rule mandates that, the Data Fiduciary has to notify about the Data Breach of the Personal Data of Data Principal within a specified time.

However, this rule fails to mandate the mentioning of the content and level of detail that has to be notified.

An Effective Reform would be:

•  Prescribe a standardized disclosure format where the nature of breach, potential harm to the Data Principal, data which has been breached and what measures has been undertaken to reduce the risk of harm to user.

Such clarity would ensure that the companies take accountability for failing to protect the data of the user and user is aware of the risks, so he/she can take precaution before any harm is caused.

•  Finally, these rules work in a reactive way, which means that the action can only be taken after the data is breached. There is very less focus on how to prevent such data breaches or misuse of the data. This is why the system depends on violations being discovered first when they could’ve been prevented in the first place.

•  To make the rules more effective, the system must be adopted where the companies have to regularly check and submit compliance reports and where the authorities can conduct audit to verify if the rules are being followed.

•  If such measures are undertaken and a stricter approach towards the protection of personal data is adopted, then the violations could be prevented before the damage is caused.

Lastly, improving social consciousness, digital literacy, and inclusive protection of vulnerable groups shall also play an important role in making privacy protection not only a theoretical concept but a practical policy. Through such an approach of constituting a balanced and holistic approach, India will be able to reinforce its data protection regime and, at the same time, guarantee that innovation, national security, and fundamental rights can coexist in a constitutionally clear way.

*****

Footnotes

1. Madhavi Diwan, The Right to Privacy in the Age of Information and Communication, 4 SCC J. 12 (2002).

2. R. Rajagopal v. State of Tamil Nadu, AIR 1995 SC 264 (India).

3. Eriola Cakrani, Technology and Privacy, Internet Effects on Privacy, 4 Medit. J. Soc. Sci., no. 9, at 279, 280 (2013).

4. Id.

5. Arpana Sharma, Navigating the Digital Frontier: Safeguarding the Right to Privacy in Cyberspace, 5 Int’l J. Multidisciplinary Rsch. 6 (2023).

6. Id. at 7.

7. Information Technology Act, 2000, No. 21, Acts of Parliament, 2000 (India), https://www.indiacode.nic.in/bitstream/123456789/13116/1/it_act_2000_updated.pdf

8. Id.

9. M.P. Sharma v. Satish Chandra, (1954) SCR 1077(India).

10. Kharak Singh v. State of U.P., (1964) 1 SCR 332 (India).

11. Govind v. State of Madhya Pradesh, AIR 1975 SC 1378 (India).

12. Additional Distt. Magistrate, Jabalpur v. Shivkant Shukla, AIR 1976 SC 1207 (India).

13. Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India, AIR 1978 SC 597 (India).

14. R. Rajagopal v. State of T.N., (1995) 1 SCC 1 (India).

15. Justice K.S. (Retd.) Puttaswamy (Retd.) v. Union of India, (2017) 10 SCC 1 (India).

16. Agam Sharma, Evolution of Right to Privacy in India, 3 Int’l J. L. Mgmt. & Hum. 92, 94 (2020).

17. Id.

18. Muskan Sharma, A Critical Analysis of Privacy Implications in the Digitalized India, 12 Int’l J. Creative Rsch. Thoughts 204, (2024).

19. Manas Gulati, Right to Privacy in the Digital Age: A Critical Analysis, 2 White Black Legal Int’l. L.J., 2023, https://www.whiteblacklegal.co.in/details/right-to-privacy-in-the-digital-age-a-critical-analysis-by—manas-gulati.

20. supra note 15.

21. Malavika Manivannan, Surveillance, AI and Synthetic Media: Reclaiming Digital Dignity in the Age of Algorithmic Governance, 7 Indian J. & Legal Rsch. 5772 (2026).

22. Id. at 5773.

23. Regulation (EU) 2016/679 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 27 April 2016 on the Protection of Natural Persons with Regard to the Processing of Personal Data and on the Free Movement of Such Data, and Repealing Directive 95/46/EC (General Data Protection Regulation), 2016 O.J. (L 119) 1, art. 13

24. Id, art. 14.

25. Id, art. 15.

26. Id, art. 16.

27. Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023, § 14 (Ind.).

28. Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023, § 19 (Ind.).

29. Regulation (EU) 2016/679 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 27 April 2016 on the Protection of Natural Persons with Regard to the Processing of Personal Data and on the Free Movement of Such Data, and Repealing Directive 95/46/EC (General Data Protection Regulation), 2016 O.J. (L 119) 1, arts. 13–16, 21–22, recital 71.

30. Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023, § 11(1) (Ind.).

31. supra note 59, at 5774.

32. Information Technology Act, 2000, § 43A (Ind.).

33. Information Technology Act, 2000, § 66C (Ind.).

34. Information Technology (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics Code) Rules, 2021, G.S.R. 139(E), Gazette of India, pt. II, § 3(i), Feb. 25, 2021 (Ind.).

35. supra note 59, at 5775.

36. Shikha Bhatnagar, Right to Privacy and Data Protection, 11 Int’l J. L. 58 (2025).

37. Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023, No. 57 of 2023, § 17 (Ind.).

38. Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023, No. 57 of 2023, § 36 (Ind.).

39. Sajad Hussain Tantrey, Rounak Singh & Ajaz Afzal Lone, The Changing Dynamics of the Concept of Right to Privacy in Digital World: A Constitutional Perspective, 10 Int’l J. L. 207 (2024).

40. Digital Personal Data Protection Act, No. 22 of 2023, § 44(3) (Ind.).

41. Right to Information Act, No. 22 of 2005, § 8(1)(j) (Ind.).

42. Id.

43. supra note 15.

How to cite

Pranali P Ganachari, The Evolution of the Right to Privacy in the Era of Digital Surveillance and AI: Legal and Constitutional Issues & Challenges, 9 Int'l J.L. Mgmt. & Human. 2868 (2026).

Cite this article

Pranali P Ganachari, The Evolution of the Right to Privacy in the Era of Digital Surveillance and AI: Legal and Constitutional Issues & Challenges, 9 Int'l J.L. Mgmt. & Human. 2868 (2026).
Chat with us