VidhiAagaz
International Journal ofLaw Management & Humanities
ISSN 2581-5369 · Open access
International Journal ofLaw Management & Humanities
Open accessResearch PaperVol. 9 No. II (2026)pp. 2687–2706

Inheritance Rights of Children Adopted under the Juvenile Justice Act: A Legal Grey Area in Indian Law

192views26downloads
Published 28 April 2026 · pp. 2687–2706 · Vol. 9 No. II (2026)
Abstract

The legal institution of adoption is a twofold process; it brings a child who needs it a family, and it means a child who needs it gets a legal heir. India Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015, as updated in 2021, is the most broad-based secular adoption law, cutting across religious lines and offering full legal recognition to all adopted children, no better than their biological siblings. This seems to be a full and full-fledged legal guarantee on paper. Practically, though, it is not.
This paper explores a controversial yet little studied conflict in Indian law: although the Juvenile Justice Act grants full filial status to adopted children, the personal succession laws of India, the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, the Indian Succession Act, 1925, and the un codified principles governing Muslim inheritance, are based on completely different legal frameworks and do not necessarily or consistently acknowledge JJ Act adoptions to the purposes The consequence is a legal grey zone where a child can be legally adopted by one statute and then legally invisible under the succession law applicable to the property of his or her adoptive family.
The paper contends that such a gap is not just a technical discrepancy, but a substantive deprivation of rights. In case of uncertainty in inheritance, the whole idea of adoption is compromised. The law only partially protects a child who has been granted family membership but not the right to property. The article critically evaluates the gap between adoption law and succession law in India, considers the pertinent judicial rulings such as Shabnam Hashmi v. Union of India and Lakshmi Kant Pandey v. Union of India and evaluates the doctrinal fault lines and proposes practical legislative and judicial amendments to make the promise of the Juvenile Justice Act not only whole, but hereditary.

Keywords
Adoption Law in IndiaJuvenile Justice Act2015Personal Laws and SuccessionInheritance Rights of Adopted ChildrenConflict of LawsChild RightsFamily Law Reform
Contents
Full text

INTRODUCTION

Adoption is among the most significant legal practices that a society can appreciate. It is not just an administrative process but it is the legal creation of a family. In the case of an adopted child, the law intervenes to state that this child is part of this family, and that he is part of it without any qualifications. It obliterates the contingency of biology and places in its stead the certitude of legality. In a nation such as India, where family identity defines not only social status, but also property rights, religious duties, and family inheritance rights, the stakes of the adoption law are out of this world.

India has the most progressive legislative outcome in child welfare with the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015 which has been amended in 2021. It forms a secular and unified adoption framework which theoretically can be adopted by all Indian citizens irrespective of their religious affiliation.1  Section 56(3) of the Act explicitly adds that an adopted child has to be considered as the child of the adoptive parents in all respects with the same rights and liabilities as that of a natural child.2 This is a clear law affirmation of equality. The promise is not whispered in the law it is plainly said. And yet the pledge is lost when one of the children tries to be heir.

There is no unified property and succession laws in India. They are still disunited on religious lines the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 covers Hindus, Buddhists, Jains and Sikhs; the Indian Succession Act, 1925 covers Christians and Parsis; and Muslim inheritance is still governed by the classical Islamic law, there being no codified statutory analog.3 None of these succession structures was geared towards the Juvenile Justice Act. All of them do not include clear clauses that a child adopted under the JJ Act will be treated as a natural-born heir when it comes to the topic of succession under the specified personal law.

This poses a legal structural issue. On the one hand, the child who is adopted under the JJ Act is informed by the adoption statute that he or she is all equal to a biological child. Conversely, at the time such child is brought before a succession dispute, the personal law in which it is incorporated may not even acknowledge the JJ Act adoption in any manner (either due to the existence of its own adoption framework (as with Hindu law), or due to the fact it does not recognise any adoption whatsoever (as with Muslim and traditional Christian law).4

The effects are not theoretical. They are evident in the courts, in family conflicts, in denying a children portions of the family property, in a adopted heir contesting an adoption in court, and in the death of an adoptive parent without any clear indication on whether they will leave their JJ Act-adopted child a bequest. The promised child is left struggling over the property of those families in the very legal system which was promising them to be members.

The specific and original argument presented in this paper is as follows: the gap in the legislation in India between the law of adoption and the law of succession is not an accident but a system failure, which requires correction by legislation. Children were given a name by the Juvenile Justice Act. The next thing to which succession law must now entitle them is to that which succeeds to that name.

ADOPTION AND SUCCESSION: TWO LEGAL SYSTEMS IN COLLISION

To know why inherited rights of children adopted under Juvenile Justice Act still remain uncertain laws in India, it is first necessary to know that adoption law and succession law in India are not just different laws but different legal worlds and they are different in the sense that they work on distinct philosophical foundations, have distinct institutional roles and are answerable to different constitutional and jurisprudential traditions. Their feud is not accidental. It is structural.

A. What Adoption Law Does

Essentially, adoption law is a status law. In the process of an adoption being done by a court or a competent authority, it is carrying out a legal transformation of the legal identity of the child. The child no longer, in the eyes of the law, is the child of their biological parents but is, absolutely and irreversibly, the child of the adoptive parents. This is complete transformation: it includes the name of the child, their nationality, their domicile and most importantly their position in a family. India, being a secular adoption system, has not shunned this transformative philosophy in its Juvenile Justice Act. According to the Statement of Objects and Reasons of the JJ Act, the necessity to offer children stable family settings and to make sure that adopted children receive equal treatment in all aspects with biological children is recognized.

This is not a restricted or conditional status grant. It is absolute. Section 56(3) of the JJ Act does not provide that the adopted child should be treated equally with the exception of property. It states that the child will not be discriminated on any grounds.5 The speech is broad and unconditional.

B. What Succession Law Does

Succession law, on the contrary, is an entitlement law. It does not enquire who is a member of a family-it enquires who has a claim to what portion of the property of a deceased man. This law of succession works by means of precisely designed classes: heirs, legatees, coparceners, next of kin. These categories are specified by each succession statute separately, and historically, were specified in terms of blood ties, and membership in the religious community.6

The succession law in India is highly plural. The Hindu Succession Act, 1956 applies to a very large proportion of the population, and has its own system of recognising adopted children – however, this system was not intended to deal with adoptions in the secular JJ Act, but in the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956 (HAMA).7 The Indian Succession Act, 1925 that applies to Christians and Parsis defines heirs as those who are lineal and there is no such provision in it that heirship can be by way of adoption.8 The adoption as a legally transformative act is not recognised under Muslim personal law, which is based on the Quranic injunctions and classical jurisprudence, and has long been held, such that even the JJ Act has not changed the view of the Muslim personal law academicians and courts that adoption does not change the right to inheritance under the Islamic law.9

C. The Philosophical Divide

This is a deeper philosophical conflict. The legal framework of adoption, especially the secular JJ Act, is based on the constitutional principles of Article 14 (equality), Article 15 (non-discrimination), and Article 21 (right to life and dignity).10 It considers each child as equally worthy to be a member of the family, irrespective of the religion of the adoptive parents. It is prospective, child-focused and rights-based.

On the other hand, personal succession laws are based on the religious tradition, the sense of community, and the historical devolution of property. When secular adoption was not an Indian legal imagination, they were codified or in the instance of the Muslim law, were uncodified. They mirror a world view where membership of a family is done through birth, religion, and lineage rather than legal transformation that is set by a state. 11

These two systems were not meant to communicate to each other. The Hindu Succession Act was not changed under the JJ Act. It failed to make changes to the Indian Succession Act. It did not by any means supplant the Muslim personal law. It merely proclaimed complete filial status of adopted children and left the coordination issue unsolved.

D. The Result: No Legal Bridge

The outcome is a legal architecture that lacks a bridge between the two most significant pillars of the architecture. A adopted child under the JJ Act becomes a part of a family legally, but whether he or she can inherit out of that family rests on a wholly different legal system which may or may not recognize the existence of the adopted child as an heir. No such clause is to be found in a succession law, that thus states: A child adopted under the Juvenile Justice Act shall be considered a natural-born child under this Act. There is no such sentence in the Indian law. The lack of it is the main issue of this paper.

In its 110 th Report, the Law Commission of India noted that harmony in the laws regarding the rights of children in terms of religion was required but did not take any legislative steps to harmonise the structure of adoption and succession.12 This gap is even greater now, many decades later, with the expanded scope of the JJ Act.

THE LEGAL GAP WITHIN THE JUVENILE JUSTICE ACT: STATUS WITHOUT SUCCESSION

The Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015 is in any respect a groundbreaking law. It integrates child protection, juvenile justice and adoption into a single framework. It is secular in nature, universal in its application and unequivocal in its statement that adopted children will receive full equality with the biological children. And yet, on a closer look in the light of the succession law, the JJ Act is seen to have a fatal internal flaw, which it bestows status, but does not cement the legal ramifications which must follow out of that status. It constructs the door and leaves the key.

A. What the JJ Act Actually Guarantees

The main provision in the rights of the adopted children is section 56 (3) of the Juvenile Justice Act. According to it, the child will be considered the child of his or her adoptive parents and will be treated as such in all respects as of the date of the adoption order.13 The term for all purposes is constitutionally important. The broadest possible statement of equality between adopted and natural children is one of the most far-reaching ones of the legislature.

This is further enhanced by The Adoption Regulations, 2022, which was issued under the JJ Act by the Central Adoption Resource Authority (CARA) and offers a comprehensive mechanism of the procedures to be followed during adoption, registration and follow-ups after adoption.14 A formal judicial-administrative tool, the adoption order of the District Magistrate under Section 61 of the amended JJ Act (post-2021 amendment) is a succession of legal transformation of the status of the child.15 In the book it is as full a legal assurance as any law can provide.

B. What the JJ Act Does Not Do

This is where the issue lies. Although having a broad statement about its application to all purposes, the Juvenile Justice Act does not either literally or by implication alter, repeal, or harmonize the personal laws relating to succession applicable to inheritance in India. It includes no clause that a JJ Act adoption will be considered a valid adoption under the Hindu Succession Act, 1956. It lacks an amendment of the Indian Succession Act, 1925. It does not refer to personal law among the Muslims or how they treat adoptive relationships. It does not add any provision to any pre-existing succession laws that would provide by default that children adopted under the JJ Act have the right to inheritance under such laws.

It is not a significant drafting oversight. It is a failure of substance in the legislation. Section 56(3) that what is said about the child in Section 56 being adopted applies to all purposes cannot, in isolation, have the effect of relegating certain provisions of other statutes. The statutory interpretation principle that generalia specialibus non derogant that general provisions do not prevail over specific ones implies that general declaration of equality in JJ Act cannot be interpreted to imply an automatic amendment of the specific rules of inheritance that are contained in personal succession legislation. All the succession laws would have to be amended separately to include JJ Act adoptions as part of their system of heirship.

C. The Problem of Non-Hindu Adoptions

This is most acute and most consequential when a non-Hindu adopts a child under the JJ Act. Take the case of a Christian couple who adopts a child under CARA under JJ act. They are legally adopted. Their child is, under Section 56(3), their child “for all purposes.” However, in case of the death of the adoptive parents, succession will apply the Indian Succession Act of 1925. That Act describes heirs as biological descendants a term of biological origin. The Indian Succession Act does not contain any clause to provide that the adoptive relationships formed under the JJ Act are those which result in the rights of inheritance.16 The adopted child is thus at a legally precarious position of where biological family members of the deceased adoptive parents take possession of the estate on the basis that, with some statutory support, the adopted child is not the lineal descendant under the 1925 Act.

It is even more complicated when the adoptive parents are Muslims. The fact that Muslim personal law does not accept adoption as legally transformative relationship, means that a Muslim adoptee under the JJ Act which the Supreme Court affirmed is legally permissible in Shabnam Hashmi v. Union of India poses a serious legal paradox.17 According to the JJ Act, the child is their heir. Muslim personal law states that the child is not entitled to inheritance. No statute, no judicial precedent, no regulatory mechanism makes this contradiction obviously clear-cut.

D. Status Without a Property Framework

This is most acute and most consequential when a non-Hindu adopts a child under the JJ Act. Take the case of a Christian couple who adopts a child under CARA under JJ act. They are legally adopted. Their child is, under Section 56(3), their child “for all purposes.” However, in case of the death of the adoptive parents, succession will apply the Indian Succession Act of 1925. That Act describes heirs as biological descendants a term of biological origin. The Indian Succession Act does not contain any clause to provide that the adoptive relationships formed under the JJ Act are those which result in the rights of inheritance.  The adopted child is thus at a legally precarious position of where biological family members of the deceased adoptive parents take possession of the estate on the basis that, with some statutory support, the adopted child is not the lineal descendant under the 1925 Act.

This is not just an academic issue. In the country where intestate succession is the order of the day, whereby the family-related property disputes are regularly subject to litigation, and where the adopted children are often the representatives of economically unstable families, the lack of an effective inheritance system exposes them to a significant risk.18 The identity of children was provided by the JJ Act. Lack of succession completeness means that identity is not complete.

PERSONAL LAWS AND THE ADOPTION PARADOX: A RELIGION-BASED BARRIER TO INHERITANCE

One of the most ingrained legal systems in India is its personal laws that control succession. They are not just laws but manifestations of religious identity, the tradition of a community and centuries of norms of property devolution. These personal laws were not supplanted when the Juvenile Justice Act entered this scene with its secular, religion-neutral adoption framework. It just coexisted with them, uneasily, making the religion of the adoptive parents instead of the legal soundness of the adoption as such the determinant of whether an adopted child will inherit. This is not only legally anomalous. It is constitutionally disturbing.

A. Hindu Law: The Most Accommodating Framework

Hindu law is the most accommodative of adoption of all the personal law systems in India. Adoption amongst Hindus is given a comprehensive statutory framework in Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956 (HAMA) and the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 clearly acknowledges adopted children as legitimate heirs.19 Section 12 of HAMA states that an adopted child shall be considered to be the child of the adoptive parents in all aspects and effectually beginning on the date of adoption and all the relationship with the biological family is cut off.20 The language of this provision is a close reflection of the language of Section 56(3) of the JJ Act which is not accidental, as HAMA was a model of a legislative language used in the adoption provisions of the JJ Act.

An adopted son or daughter is under Hindu Succession Act, a Class I heir, having an equal share of the estate of the adoptive father and adoptive mother.21 When a Hindu is under JJ Act instead of HAMA, the legal status though not absolutely clear is much more practical. The courts have tended to make JJ Act adoptions by Hindu parents on par with HAMA adoptions to facilitate succession because both statutes are based on the same underlying legislative intent22 Nevertheless, here too, the fact that there is no explicit statutory cross-reference implies that the equivalence is based on judicial inference and not legislative certainty, a weak basis upon which to base such a fundamental right.

B. Muslim Law: Adoption Does Not Exist

The JJ Act adoption framework is the most basic, and irresolvable conflict with Muslim

personal law. Adoption tabanni is not a legally transformative institution in Islamic jurisprudence as practised by Indian courts as codified in classical texts.  This is expressly covered in Surah Al-Ahzab (33:45) which says that adopted children must be named after their biological fathers and that adoption does not give rise to the legal relationships in biological parenthood.23 Indian legal practice has been continuously influenced by this theological standpoint: the Indian Muslim personal law only allows kafala a type of foster care or guardianship that do not change the legal status or inheritance rights of the child.

The landmark decision of the Supreme Court in Shabnam Hashmi v. Union of India (2014) stated that any individual, irrespective of religion, is entitled to adopt a child under the JJ Act and this right cannot be thwarted on the basis of personal law. It was a constitutional court decision. However, the Court, although affirming the right to adopt, took care not to say anything about the inheritance implications of such an adoption under the Muslim personal law. The issue as to whether a child of a Muslim who had adopted JJ Act would be heir to a Muslim by Islamic principles of succession was not touched at all. 24

The practical outcome is a great contradiction. A couple of Muslims adopts a child on the JJ Act through CARA. The adoption is legally valid the State endorses it, the District Magistrate orders it, and Section 56(3) declares the child their legal heir “for all purposes.” However, when the adoptive parents die intestate, the personal law of the Muslims that regulates their succession allocates the property to asabat (agnatic heirs) and Quranic sharers, and there is no such category of heir as an adopted child. There is no inheritance to the adopted child. The promise of the JJ Act crumbles at the time when it is needed most.

C. Christian and Parsi Law: Silence as a Barrier

The Indian Succession Act, 1925 regulates Christian and Parsi succession. However, unlike HAMA, this Act had been passed well before the legal consideration of secular adoption in India, which includes no mention of adoptive relationships as a basis of inheritance.25 The Act allocates the estate of an intestate between a spouse, lineal relatives and kindred all of which are defined in terms of blood ties. An adopted child who receives JJ Act coverage cannot easily be categorised into any of these under the literal meaning of the statute.

Christian theology does not outlaw the concept of adoption, as is the case with the Islamic law. The Christian adoptions have been practiced over time and some states in India have documented them. But such traditional adoptions are legally ambiguous in the Indian Succession Act, and JJ Act adoptions with Christian guardians are no better than statutory silent. Parsi Law, in its turn, is based on the closed community model, which does not consider the adoption of heirs.26

D. The Religion Paradox

The result of this survey is a very uncomfortable paradox. The JJ Act was created specifically to cross religious lines in adoption to make sure that no child is deprived of a family due to the religious beliefs of the potential parents. But the consequences of the inheritance of a JJ Act adoption are fully dependent on the religion of the adoptive parents. A Hindu child born into Hindu parents inherits fairly safely. The same child which has been adopted by a Muslim or a Christian family inherits with much less legal security. The secular adoption law, therefore, yields consequences of religion-determined inheritance which is both uncomfortable to Article 14 guarantee of equality and the spirit of the JJ Act.27 The personal law system, in brief, is a conversion of what ought to be a legal right, uniform on all, into a religious lottery.

JUDICIAL RESPONSES: RECOGNITION WITHOUT RESOLUTION

Should legislation have fallen short in closing the gap between the adoption law and the succession law, it can be reasonably anticipated that the judiciary has intervened. A long and proud history of progressive constitutional interpretation has after all existed in Indian courts, especially in the area of child rights and family law. And in fact, the judiciary too has not been silent on the issue of JJ Act adoptions. India has had a number of historic rulings to support the legality and inclusiveness of secular adoption. However, a close examination of these cases shows a disturbing trend: courts have been ready to acknowledge the right to adopt and have invariably drawn the line at this point as to the order of consequences of that adoption in the matter of inheritance. Courts are in favour, but the doctrine is vague.

A. Lakshmi Kant Pandey v. Union of India: The Foundation

Even the most established and fundamental judicial intervention in Indian adoption law was not a statutory controversy but a letter addressed to the Supreme Court by advocate Lakshmi Kant Pandey, highlighting the malpractices in inter-country adoption. The Supreme Court in a succession of directions in Lakshmi Kant Pandey v. Union of India (1984) provided detailed principles of the process of adoption, defined the role of recognised social welfare agencies, and restated the parens patriae role of the state towards familially deprived children. Lakshmi Kant Pandey v/s. Union of India, (1984). The Court stated that the best interests of the child were the most important factor in any adoption proceedings a doctrine that has since become the cornerstone of Indian adoption law.28

Although the main focus of this decision was on procedural protection and inter-country adoption, its importance to the current discussion is that it laid down philosophical foundations that adoption is a child-focused institution, and that the law is to be construed in a manner that promotes the best interests of the child. This rule, when followed uniformly, would naturally be applied to the right of adopted children to inheritance. The Court in Lakshmi Kant Pandey however made no reference to succession law, and no other court since has adopted the welfare principle expressed in this case to determine positively in favour of adopted children ambiguities in inheritance cases.29

B. Shabnam Hashmi v. Union of India: The Secular Mandate

The most notable court decision on the adoption of the JJ Act was in the case of Shabnam Hashmi v. Union of India (2014), a Muslim woman who had fostered a child was seeking a declaration that she had a right to adopt the child under secular provisions of the JJ Act despite the fact that adoption was prohibited under Muslim personal law. In a unanimous case, the Supreme Court through Justice K.S. Radhakrishnan, ruled that the right to adopt and to be adopted under the JJ Act is a statutory right to all Indian citizens irrespective of religious beliefs. The Court found that personal law could not serve as the obstacle to exercising this statutory right, and that the JJ Act, being a secular act enacted with the intent of promoting constitutional values, ought to be applied in its entire sense. 30

This was a constitutionally brave ruling. It clearly established the JJ Act to override personal law objections in the right to adopt. The Court stated that the right to a family of the child could not be held as a ransom to the religious affiliation of the would-be parents.

But and this is where the matter is critical the Court in Shabnam Hashmi failed to consider inheritance. The Court petition was about the right to adopt and not about the property implications of adoption. There is no consideration in the judgment as to whether a child adopted by a Muslim under the JJ Act would inherit under the Muslim personal law, whether Section 56(3) of the JJ Act conflicts with classical Islamic rules of inheritance, or whether Parliament should harmonise the law on adoption and succession.31 The Court left the right to adopt and the right to inherit quite undisposed, half-a-piece.

C. Other Judicial Voices

Outside these historic cases, there are other cases that Indian High Courts have had to grapple with concerning inheritance matters involving adopted children, with mixed outcomes. In Smt. The Supreme Court had ruled earlier in Rohini Kumari v. Narendra Singh (1972) that a child adopted under HAMA has a complete right to inheritance just like a normal child.32 However, this ruling was over a HAMA adoption, not a JJ Act adoption and its applicability to secular adoptions under the JJ Act may not be presumed until legislatively or judicially affirmed.

This question of whether JJ Act adoptions by non-Hindu parents give rise to inheritance rights under the personal law applicable has been debated by several decisions of the High Court, with courts in various jurisdictions giving varying answers. In a series of cases concerning Christian adoptive families, the Bombay High Court has recognised the legal vacuum but refuted to fill the vacuum with judicial legislation, urging the Parliament to intervene. At least one case has been decided by the Delhi High Court using the welfare of the child principle to imply a right to inheritance into a JJ Act adoption, although this is not consistently the case.33

D. The Doctrinal Gap

What this case study of court rulings shows is a sympathetic, but structurally handicapped, judiciary. The courts have realised the moral and constitutional necessity to safeguard the rights of adopted children. They have affirmed the secular nature of the JJ Act. They have appealed to the principle of welfare on more than one occasion. Yet they have not generated a coherent, consistent and binding body of doctrine which can solve the intersection of JJ Act adoption and personal succession law. The cases are determined on their facts. The High Courts do not deal with the problem in the same manner. The Supreme Court has not yet explicitly tackled the issue of inheritance in the JJ Act adoptions.34

The consequence is that thousands of children adopted in India lead a life of legal insecurity whose status as dependent does not depend on any one definite legal rule, but on which court hears the case, which judge has a application of this or that principle, and whether he or she can afford the litigation itself. A paternal sympathy in the judiciary, unilluminated by dogma, is chilly comfort to a child whose legacy is being fought over.

THE CORE PROBLEM: LEGAL ADOPTION, ILLEGAL UNCERTAINTY

At the cynos of this paper is a contradiction which is as juridical as it is humanly debilitating. A child who is adopted under the Juvenile Justice Act is unquestionably adopted. The order of adoption is valid. The adoptive parents are recognised under the law. The new identity of the child is a legal one. Whatever this is, is not disputed. What people are arguing about that is still very hazardously not determined is whether that legal adoption is a legal right to an inheritance. According to the current legal system in India, the answer is: it depends. And in a nation where the law reigns, it does not depend, is not a response that the fundamental rights of a child should be based on.

A. The Adoption-Inheritance Disjunction

The issue may be formulated accurately. JJ Act provides legal status through adoption. The laws of personal succession to the inheritance need to be recognized in the laws of those countries. The former is given in the JJ Act. It alone does not assure the latter. The consequence is a disjunction child of a legal adoption, but legal uncertainty as an heir.

This disjunction is not purely an abstraction. It has tangible, quantifiable implications. In the case where an adoptive parent dies without a will the distribution of the estate is then regulated solely by the personal succession law in force. Without the JJ Act adoption being specifically acknowledged in that law, biological relatives of the deceased brothers, cousins, parents can claim the total estate, leaving the adopted child with no inheritance. The child not only loses property, but the material basis of the family life which adoption was intended to cement.

In a case where an adoptive parent dies testate to the will the problem changes but remains. A will is subject to challenge. Biological relatives may challenge the will on the basis that the so-called adopted child is not a legal heir according to the relevant law of succession and that bequest to such a child is a gift to a stranger but not a transfer to an heir. In certain systems of succession, heirs have secured shares parts of the estate which cannot be devised and the issue as to whether an adopted child is a protected share beneficiary is once again a matter of personal law, rather than the JJ Act.35

B. The Human Cost of Legal Insecurity

One must go beyond statutory analysis to be able to understand the full weight of this problem by looking at what legal insecurity entails to a child. Those children that have been adopted under the JJ Act are greatly disproportionately recruited into the ranks of the most vulnerable of Indian society children who are either abandoned, orphaned, or surrendered by families who are in economic distress, or taken out of abusive and neglectful situations.36 Such children have already undergone great instability. Adoption is supposed to put an end to that instability in order to provide them with more than love and care, legal security. One of the core elements of that security is property rights.

The effects run out when a child knows or a court concludes that they cannot be sure of their inheritance or when a court concludes that their rights to inheritance are uncertain. Adoptive families might not be willing to make the adopted child a part of estate planning because any arrangement can be invalidated in court. The adopted child can be raised with a tacit consciousness of his/her legal precariousness as a second-class member of the family to which adoption was meant to eradicate. The inheritance litigation is not only economic suicide; it is also psychologically suicidal because it compels children to make court cases over their own belonging to their families.37

C. The Constitutional Dimension

This legal gap is not only a matter of private law that has brought about uncertainty in inheritance. It is a problem of the constitution. The right to life with dignity is ensured in Article 21 of the Constitution.38 The Supreme Court has always understood Article 21 in a broad way to incorporate the right to livelihood, the right to shelter, the right to dignified existence. Any child deprived of the right to inheritance is being deprived of a dignified existence by being denied the property that forms his or her material security. The equality provision in Article 14 of the constitution is also involved: two children in the same adoptive family, one biological and one adopted under the JJ Act, could potentially have completely different inheritance rights, not due to the explicit discrimination in the law itself, but because the silence of the law has discriminatory effects.39

D. The Systemic Nature of the Failure

It is especially problematic that this issue is not an isolated case but a systemic one. In one odd instance, it does not have any effect on a child. It may apply to all children adopted by non-Hindu parents under the JJ Act and even Hindu adoptions under the JJ Act bear residual doubt because of the absence of any explicit statutory cross-reference between the JJ Act and the Hindu Succession Act. As stated in the annual report 202223 of CARA, 3,970 in-country adoptions were finalised this year alone. The uncertainty of inheritance that this paper discusses is present, to a greater or lesser extent, in each of those children. Apply that figure to the number of years that the JJ Act has existed and you have the magnitude of the issue.

E. Why a Will Is Not a Sufficient Answer

Others might say that the answer is plain and straightforward: adoptive parents ought to make a will, and the will could handle the inheritance of the adopted child. Though a practical and sensible idea, this argument as a systemic response is legally inadequate. To start with, high percentage of Indians dying intestate is the rule rather than the exception, especially in rural and semi-urban region where there is a lack of legal knowledge.40 Second, as indicated in the foregoing discussion, wills are subject to challenge and the lack of clarity in the heirship by personal law undermines the legal standing of the adopted child even in testate succession. Third, and most importantly, the right to inheritance of a child should not be subjected to legal foresight of his/her parents. Liberty does not depend on documents. The law should assure security as it is not a result of prudent estate planning, but it is an automatic result of legal adoption.

The JJ Act assured that the child would be legally complete upon adoption. The succession gap makes promise broken. This is the central issue of the matter and it requires a legislative rather than a personal solution.

THE PATH FORWARD: LEGISLATIVE REFORM AND JUDICIAL UNIFORMITY

The legal loophole observed in the above sections is not predetermined. It is the by-product of legislative carelessness a neglect of to pursue the logic of progressive adoption law to its logical conclusion in succession law. The answer is not radical, then. It does not entail the destruction of personal laws or the establishment of a standard civil code. It demands specific, surgical legislative action that seals the particular gap between the JJ Act adoption and the personal succession law, without undue tampering with the larger structure of the plural legal system of India. These reforms suggested in this section are feasible, constitutional and long overdue.

A. An Explicit Amendment to the JJ Act

The quickest and simplest reform that would have a direct impact would be to amend the Juvenile Justice Act itself, adding a provision that explicitly covers the succession implications of JJ Act adoptions. The amendment ought to declare (in clear and unambiguous terms) that a child adopted under this Act shall be considered to be a natural-born child of the adoptive parents as regards to all laws concerning succession and inheritance that applies to the adoptive parents, irrespective of the religion, personal law or community of the adoptive parents.41

This would operate as a statutory override a straightforward legislative directive to all succession systems to consider JJ Act adoptions to be legally comparable with biological parenthood in regard to inheritance. It would not directly alter Hindu Succession Act, or Indian Succession Act or Muslim personal law. Rather, it would provide a legal bridging provision in the JJ Act itself which links the adoption framework to the succession framework, so that the proclamation in Section 56(3) of the JJ Act that the child is adopted, and is adopted, to all purposes, is given actual, operative weight in succession cases.42

This method is constitutionally sound. The legislative competence of parliament under Entry 5 of the Concurrent List (marriage and divorce; infants and minors; adoption) and Entry 7 (wills, intestacy and succession) is to enact such a provision.43 No constitutional obstacle to Parliament stating, by statute, that a certain type of legally recognised adoption will produce a right of heredity, in all the succession laws applicable.

B. Targeted Amendments to Succession Statutes

Besides the JJ Act amendment, specific amendments of the particular succession statutes would be the most lasting solution. The Hindu Succession Act, 1956 needs to be revised so as to clearly incorporate those adopted under the JJ Act as children under all the provisions under that Act and there may be no confusion that JJ Act adoptions by Hindu parents are comparable to HAMA adoptions.44 This amendment would be quite a simple one, as Hindu law already has adoptive children as heirs, and the amendment will only have to explicitly apply this to the JJ Act adoptions.

Indian Succession Act, 1925 needs to be amended more substantially. New section must be added based on the patterns of Section 12 of HAMA to state that a child adopted under the JJ Act shall be considered a lineal descendant of the adoptive parents in all respects under the Act, and that this shall have effect as of the date of the adoption order.45 This would eliminate the uncertainty in inheritance enjoyed by Christian, Parsi and other non-Hindu adoptive families that adopt the JJ Act.

C. The Muslim Personal Law Question

The politically and constitutionally most complicated aspect of this reform agenda is that of Muslim personal law. Reform of Muslim personal law by way of Parliamentary legislation is a matter of deep sensitiveness in India, as it raises issues of religious identity, minority rights and the question of whether or not to adopt the Uniform Civil Code. The suggested paper is not in support of a complete overhaul of Muslim personal law. What it does recommend is a more specific, limited intervention.

Parliament ought to make a certain provision either as part of the JJ Act amendment or independent of the JJ Act, but under the title of a separate statute providing Muslim adoptive parents with the choice to register, at the time of adoption, a declaration that the JJ Act-adopted child will be treated as their legal heir to succession, and that the legal effect of such a declaration would be subject to the Indian Succession Act, This voluntary system would honor the religious status of Muslim families who are willing to abide by the Islamic norms in inheritance, and offer legal redress to Muslim adoptive parents who want to establish the right to inheritance of his adopted child within the secular system. It is a paradigm that reconciles religious freedom and children rights without foisting a homogenous solution on a heterogeneous society.

D. CARA’s Institutional Role

Reform must not be restricted to laws. The nodal body dealing with adoption in India should be obligated to give every adoptive family when finalising the adoption order with express and easily available information concerning the inheritance implication of JJ Act adoption under the personal law which should apply to their family.46 Legal gaps that exist should be brought to the attention of adoptive parents; they should be advised to prepare a will in case their own law does not automatically secure the inheritance of the adopted child and referred to legal aid services where needed. Such an institutional reform would not fix the legislative gap but would greatly minimise the damage done by it in the meantime.

E. Judicial Uniformity Through Supreme Court Guidance

Lastly, the Supreme Court of India can make a significant contribution. The Court ought to consider, either on a suo motu basis or by receiving a relevant petition, the issue of the right of inheritance of the children who are adopted under the JJ Act under different personal succession laws. An all-inclusive constitutional bench decision to this question which utilises the principle of the welfare of the child, the right to equality, and the right to a dignified life under Articles 14 and 21 would give the doctrinal clarity that is currently lacking in lower courts.47 Judicial uniformity is the best mechanism that can be used to safeguard the inheritance of JJ Act-adopted children until a legislation is enacted.

The highway to reform is evident. The means of law are available. The constitution requires it. The only thing lacking has been the legislative desire to see the promise of the law of adoption to its last, which is also its most needed, fulfilment the right to inherit.

CONCLUSION: IDENTITY WITHOUT INHERITANCE IS AN INCOMPLETE PROMISE

At the best, law is not a system of rules. It is a framework of commitments commitments to the most vulnerable citizens of the state that will see their rights being recognised, safeguarded, and enforced. One such promise was the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015, which shouted it out: all children adopted under its provisions will be in all respects equal to children born, so far as all matters are concerned. It was a pledge based on constitutional principles, charged with the noblest principles of child welfare jurisprudence, and long overdue in a nation where millions of children are raised without the protection of a legal family. This paper has argued that that promise has only been half-fulfilled.

The above passages have followed with a methodical attention the fault line which runs through the Indian law between adoption and inheritance. The JJ Act establishes a legal status that it provides the child with a name, a family, and a legal identity. It does not, however, of itself, establish the inheritance rights which must necessarily and morally derive out of that status. No amendments were made to personal succession laws, such as the Hindu Succession Act, the Indian Succession Act, or the unaltered rules of Muslim personal law at the time of the JJ Act. They were not updated when it was amended in 2021. They still act according to their own rules, determining who is heir differently and without necessarily or consistent inclusion of children adopted within the secular provisions of the JJ Act.

The implications of this gap are not abstract and trivial. These most succumb to those who are least capable of affording them children of poor background who were placed in a family by law only to discover that the law is not entirely on their side when property is involved in a family. They are seen in the courts where the adopted children are compelled to bring cases against themselves in terms of belonging to their families. They come in the form of estates shared by biological relatives as adopted children are not given anything. They are existing in the silent fear of families that understand that their legal provisions are placed on shaky grounds.48

The judiciary has been empathetic yet inadequate. Shabnam Hashmi approved the right to interreligious adoption. The welfare principle is a principle that was set up by Lakshmi Kant Pandey as the foundation of adoption jurisprudence. However, neither decision or since has resulted in the definitive, consistent, binding doctrine that would have finalized the question of inheritance in JJ Act-adopted children in all the personal law communities. Even the sincerity of judicial sympathy cannot take the place of clarity in law.49

The reforms, which are presented in this paper, are not radical or impractical. They do not insist upon a standard civil code. They do not demand the demolition of individual laws. They merely request that Parliament should take such action as logic and justice dictate that it implement the promise of adoption law through to its inevitable outcome by expressly guaranteeing that children adopted under JJ Act inheritance rights under all available succession models. Modifications in the JJ Act, specific modifications in the Hindu Succession Act and the Indian Succession Act, an opt-in system in the case of Muslim adoptive families, institutional direction by CARA, and an ultimate Supreme Court decision all these are feasible, proportional, and constitutionally required measures.50

The argument of this paper is straightforward. A child is not adopted half way. The law should introduce a child into a family as a whole not only into the world of home and hearth, but also into the law of the rights and entitlements of the family. Property does not play a peripheral role in the life of a child. It is security. It is the material way of being belonging. It is the distinction between a child who is conscious of his or her belonging to a family, and a child who somewhere in the back of his or her legal life bears the seed of the recognition that he or she may one day be dispossessed of his or her membership.

The Juvenile Justice Act provided children with identity. The law of succession now must render them what the identity requires the right to bequeath of the family which the law has established to them. Adoption is not achieved by legal recognition but lacks certainty of inheritance. It only postpones the day of exclusion.

The adoption law in India is liberal. Its law of succession is falling behind. Their distance is not a technicality but a failure to keep a promise to the children to whom the law was supposed to be a promise. Now the time is come that promise should be kept, to the uttermost.

*****

Footnotes

1. The Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015 (Act No. 2 of 2016), as amended by the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Amendment Act, 2021.

2. Section 56(3), Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015.

3. Werner Menski, Hindu Law: Beyond Tradition and Modernity (Oxford University Press, 2003) 412–415.

4. Tahir Mahmood, Muslim Law of India (3rd edn, LexisNexis Butterworths, 2002) 89–93.

5. Section 56(3), Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015.

6. Paras Diwan, Law of Intestate and Testamentary Succession (3rd edn, Universal Law Publishing, 2010) 23–27.

7. Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956 (Act No. 78 of 1956), Sections 12–16.

8. Indian Succession Act, 1925 (Act No. 39 of 1925), Sections 29–56.

9. Tahir Mahmood, Muslim Law of India (3rd edn, LexisNexis Butterworths, 2002) 91.

10. Constitution of India, Articles 14, 15, and 21.

11. Flavia Agnes, Family Law Volume 1: Family Laws and Constitutional Claims (Oxford University Press, 2011) 201–205.

12. Law Commission of India, 110th Report on Adoption of Children (1985) para 3.7.

13. Section 56(3), Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015.

14. Central Adoption Resource Authority, Adoption Regulations, 2022, Ministry of Women and Child Development, Government of India.

15. Section 61, Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Amendment Act, 2021.

16. Indian Succession Act, 1925 (Act No. 39 of 1925), Sections 29–33.

17. Shabnam Hashmi v. Union of India, (2014) 4 SCC 1, para 18.

18. Ministry of Women and Child Development, Annual Report 2022–23, Government of India, 67

19. Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956 (Act No. 78 of 1956).

20. Section 12, Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956.

21. Section 8 read with Schedule, Class I Heirs, Hindu Succession Act, 1956 (Act No. 30 of 1956).

22. Paras Diwan, Law of Adoption, Minority, Guardianship and Custody (5th edn, Universal Law Publishing, 2015) 178–181.

23. The Holy Quran, Surah Al-Ahzab, 33:4–5.

24. Ibid, para 19.

25. Indian Succession Act, 1925 (Act No. 39 of 1925), Sections 29–56.

26. Indian Succession Act, 1925, Sections 50–56 (Parsi intestate succession).

27. Constitution of India, Article 14.

28. Ibid, para 12.

29. J.N. Pandey, Constitutional Law of India (52nd edn, Central Law Agency, 2015) 334.

30. Ibid, para 18.

31. Ibid, para 19–21.

32. Smt. Rohini Kumari v. Narendra Singh, AIR 1972 SC 459.

33. Usha Ramanathan, ‘Child Rights and the Law in India’ (2003) 38 Economic and Political Weekly 1632, 1638.

34. Arvind Datar, Commentary on the Constitution of India (2nd edn, Wadhwa and Company, 2007) 512.

35. Poonam Pradhan Saxena, Family Law Lectures: Family Law II (3rd edn, LexisNexis, 2011) 234–237.

36. Central Adoption Resource Authority, Annual Report 2022–23, Ministry of Women and Child Development, Government of India, 12–15.

37. Shantha Sinha, ‘Child Rights in India: Challenges and Prospects’ (2005) 40 Economic and Political Weekly 1813, 1817.

38. Constitution of India, Article 21.

39. Constitution of India, Article 14; see also Anuj Garg v. Hotel Association of India, (2008) 3 SCC 1.m

40. Law Commission of India, Report No. 247: Wrongful Prosecution (Miscarriage of Justice): Legal Remedies (2014) — referencing patterns of intestate succession in India; see also Flavia Agnes, Family Law Volume 1 (Oxford University Press, 2011) 289.

41. Proposed amendment modelled on Section 12, Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956, extended to secular context.

42. Section 56(3), Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015; see also Law Commission of India, 110th Report on Adoption of Children (1985) para 6.2.

43. Constitution of India, Seventh Schedule, List III (Concurrent List), Entries 5 and 7.

44. Hindu Succession Act, 1956 (Act No. 30 of 1956), Section 3(1)(j) (definition of “heir”).

45. Indian Succession Act, 1925 (Act No. 39 of 1925), Section 29; cf. Section 12, Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956.

46. Central Adoption Resource Authority, Guidelines for Adoption of Children, 2015, Ministry of Women and Child Development, Government of India, para 8.

47. In Re: Exploitation of Children in Orphanages in the State of Tamil Nadu v. Union of India, (2017) 9 SCC 737 — demonstrating Supreme Court’s willingness to use suo motu jurisdiction in child rights matters.

48. Shantha Sinha, ‘Child Rights in India: Challenges and Prospects’ (2005) 40 Economic and Political Weekly 1813, 1819.

49. Shabnam Hashmi v. Union of India, (2014) 4 SCC 1; Lakshmi Kant Pandey v. Union of India, (1984) 2 SCC 244.

50. Law Commission of India, 110th Report on Adoption of Children (1985) para 7.1; Constitution of India, Articles 14, 21, and 39(f).

How to cite

Vasisti Singh & Shailja Khosla, Inheritance Rights of Children Adopted under the Juvenile Justice Act: A Legal Grey Area in Indian Law, 9 Int'l J.L. Mgmt. & Human. 2687 (2026).

Cite this article

Vasisti Singh & Shailja Khosla, Inheritance Rights of Children Adopted under the Juvenile Justice Act: A Legal Grey Area in Indian Law, 9 Int'l J.L. Mgmt. & Human. 2687 (2026).
Chat with us