INTRODUCTION
In a recent case renowned music composer Illaiyaraja claimed royalty from the producers of Manjummel Boys for using his music “ Kanmani Anbodu Kadhalan”, without his consent while the producers have asserted to have purchased the rights from the music recording company who owns the rights of the song.3
The question which arose here is whether the music composer was right in his action to claim royalty?
Actions/cases like these when instituted triggers the query who has rights over the songs composed.
The ownership of Intellectual Property Rights (IPR) in a song generally depends on the specific contributions of various individuals involved and the contractual arrangements between them.
A song typically comprises two main elements: lyrics and musical composition, and the rights associated with them are governed by Indian laws such as the Copyright Act, 1957.
• Lyricist: Owns the copyright for the literary work (lyrics).
• Composer: Owns the copyright for the musical composition (melody).
Section 14 of the Copyright Act defines Copyright
Meaning of the word Copyright.—
“A copyright is the exclusive right a person has over a specific work such that he can authorise the doing of certain acts to the work or to a substantial part of it.
(a) in the case of a literary, dramatic or musical work, not being a computer programme,—
(i) to reproduce the work in any material form including the storing of it in any medium by electronic means; For the purposes of this Act, “copyright” means the exclusive right subject to the provisions of this Act, to do or authorise the doing of any of the following acts in respect of a work or any substantial part thereof, namely:—
(ii) to issue copies of the work to the public not being copies already in circulation; (iii) to perform the work in public, or communicate it to the public; (iv) to make any cinematograph film or sound recording in respect of the work; (v) to make any translation of the work; (vi) to make any adaptation of the work; (vii) to do, in relation to a translation or an adaptation of the work, any of the acts specified in relation to the work in sub-clauses (i) to (vi);” 4
“The copyrights conferred under Section 14 of the Act consists of a bundle of rights. The owner of a copyright is entitled to assign and licence each of those rights separately or in bundles. The bundle of rights could vary in complexity depending upon the nature of the work - literary, dramatic, musical recording or cinematographic films”5.
JUDICIAL POSITION REGARDING THE OWNERSHIP RIGHTS OVER THE SONGS
In the case of “Indian Performing Rights Society v. Eastern India Motion Pictures Ltd”.6 a dispute arose over whether a producer can be a copyright owner when engaging composers to create a composition for his film. The Indian Performing Right Society (IPRS) claimed royalties for literary works used in cinematograph films broadcasted on radio, which was contested by the Cinematograph Exhibitors Association stating that the production houses are the true owners of the copyrighted songs which were composed by the composer under the contract of service.
The Court held the film producers are the first and absolute owners of copyrights if they commission composers or lyricists under a contract of service for valuable consideration, as per Section 17(c) of the Copyright Act, 19577. The resulting composition automatically becomes part of the film, and the composer loses all rights, making IPRS ineligible to claim royalties8.
(A) Contract of service or contract for service
A significant distinction is to be drawn between the terms “contract of service” and “contract for service”, a Contract of Service is an arrangement amidst an employer and an employee, whereas a Contract For Service establishes a client-contractor engagement instead of an employer-employee relationship. Variations depend on control, ownership, and economic factors. A contract of service exists if the employer controls recruitment, dismissal, work provision, production, tools, workplace, and assumes economic risks, while a contract for service applies when the individual manages these aspects and bears the risks9.
“Indian Performing Rights Society v. Eastern India Motion Pictures Ltd.”10 was a landmark Supreme Court Judgement which many production houses relied upon to deny the rights of the lyricist and composers from royalties when their creation was subsequently commercially utilised.
Subsequently in 2005 the “Amar Nath Sehgal v. Union of India”11, case established a foundational interpretation of moral rights of the original creator, introducing unprecedented remedies like returning copyrighted works to the author. It widens the scope for future understanding of an author's moral and residual rights.
Inorder to protect the original creators interest there was an Amendment to the Copyright Act to its section 17 in the year 2012, which acknowledged and recognised the rights of the lyricist and composers. It was laid that in case of any work incorporated in a cinematograph film, the right of the author in the work of original literary, dramatic, musical and artistic works as under Section 13 will remain undefeated.
Following which in the case of IPRS v. Music Broadcast Private Limited12 and IPRS v. Rajasthan Patrika Pvt Limited 13 “It was established that when a lyricist or composer authorizes a producer to use their work in a sound recording for a cinematographic film, the producer owns rights in the cinematographic film as a whole and not in the underlying works individually. The lyricist or composer retains the right to enforce the moral rights vested in their original works. This interpretation aligns with the amended Section 17 of the Copyright Act, 1957, which recognizes that the copyrights in original works subsist with the creators, enabling them to claim royalties and enjoy the monetary benefits when their works are used outside the scope of the sound recordings or cinematographic films”14.
UNCONVENTIONAL RULINGS
What’s an Indian Wedding without the use of unpermitted music? Unheard of and illegal, is what.
In Phonographic Performance Ltd. v. State of Goa15 A writ petition before the Bombay High Court was filed by the Petitioner under Article 226 of the Indian Constitution, challenging a circular issued by the Respondent. The circular declared that performances of music played at religious functions, inclusive of weddings, does not violate the Copyright Laws. The Petitioner, a copyright owner in sound recordings via public performance rights through assignments from music labels, argued that the circular undermined its ability to collect royalties and enforce statutory rights against infringement. The Respondent justified the circular, claiming that requiring permissions for such performances negatively impacted citizens and economic/tourism activities in the state.
The Court criticized the act of the Respondent in assuming an interpretative status and adding the word “wedding” alongside “marriage” in the impugned circular. The circular being illegal and bad at law was quashed and ordered to be set aside accordingly. “The Court relied on “Eastern Book Company v. D.B. Modak” 16, the Supreme Court reckoned that “when a person produced something with his skill and labour, it normally belonged to him and the other person would not be permitted to make a profit out of the skill and labour of the original author and it was for this reason that the Act gave to the authors certain exclusive rights in relation to certain works referred in the Act.”17
Televisions of Hotel Rooms being guilty of infringement!
In yet another case, “Supercassette Industries v. Nirulas Corner House (P) Ltd”.18, the Plaintiff was a copyright holder of a variety of literary and musical works, sound recordings, music videos and cinematographic videos. The Plaintiff was engaged in manufacturing and selling VCDs, DVDs and Cassettes containing these works and also licensed the right to exploit its works. The Defendants were engaged in the business of hotels/restaurants in New Delhi. The dispute arose as the Defendant’s hotel rooms contained Television sets that played audio clippings of songs in which the Plaintiff owned copyrights. “Plaintiff alleged that such transmission of works, without a license amounts to infringement of the copyright as the Defendants communicated the works to the public.”19
It was contended by the Plaintiff that the hotel’s guests were viewing copyrighted content which was directly provided by the Defendant amounting to “communication to the public” instead of through any cable operator
The Defendant in its turn submitted that the Plaintiff neither asserted that the broadcast was unlicensed nor included the broadcaster as a party to the proceedings.The Defendant further stated that it was receiving signals transmitted by the cable operator and that the Plaintiff has no locus standi to file the infringement suit as an independent copyright of the Broadcast. The Defendant also stated that the same fare was charged from the guests whether or not they viewed the Television and that the Defendant does not gain any financial benefit from whether or not guests watch the television.
The court examined the Copyright Act to clarify itself of “infringement”, “communication to the public” and “certain acts not amounting to infringement” and held that the Plaintiff had been able to show that the Defendant was using cable connection and extending facilities of Television to their guests in hotel rooms. It said that prima facie, the content of songs and videos broadcast are “communications to the public” amounting to infringement .
Therefore analysing the laws and the judgement we can understand: “The object of The Copyright Act was to protect the author of the copyright work from unlawful reproduction or exploitation of his work by others”20. “Under Section 14, the rights to reproduce, perform, adapt, translate, make copies of these works exists. Each of these rights could be assigned, reassigned and licensed. For example, the owner of the rights in a cinematographic film, can licence the literary and musical rights in the lyrics to a radio channel to be aired, and also assign the license to make copies of the cinematographic films on cassettes and CDs, etc. to a person and so on. The work thus follows a trail of licences”21.
It can be inferred from above that the scope of the original creators in a song is enhanced, making them qualified to receive royalties when their work is commercially used, replicated etc. Hence in the case instituted by Mr. Illaiyaraja, the Music composer seeking compensation seems valid and the producers opted for an out- of- court- settlement acknowledging the same.
CONCLUSION
The quote “it's like music to one’s ears” to describe a pleasant situation is befitting given that it is an important source of entertainment. Music is defined by song, and to create a song it takes a village, it is only fair that the many players behind the creation are duly credited. The Copyright Act was established to prohibit the unauthorized use of a creation and to safeguard the interests of the various creators behind a piece of work, the many case laws analysed above lay down the importance of courts to implement the Copyright law and rightly so. A step in the direction of educating the public about the permissions to be taken when using a piece of work and against infringement is the need of the hour to protect and further encourage the creativity resting with the artists of our country.
*****
Footnotes
3. Arul George Scaria, The Ilaiyaraaja Copyright Dispute Must Draw Our Attention to Issues Lyricists, Music Composers Face, The Wire (June 4, 2024), available at https://thewire.in/law/the-ilaiyaraaja-copyright-dispute-must-draw-our-attention-to-issues-lyricists-music-composers-face.
4. The Copyright Act, 1957, No. 14 of 1957, India Code (2023), available at https://indiacode.nic.in.
5. Gramophone Co. of India Ltd. v. Super Cassette Indus. Ltd., 1995 SCC OnLine Del 154 (India).
6. Indian Performing Rights Soc’y v. E. India Motion Pictures Ltd., AIR 1977 SC 1443 (India).
7. The Copyright Act, 1957, No. 14 of 1957, India Code (2023), available at https://indiacode.nic.in.
8. Vivek B. K., Indian Performing Rights Society v. Eastern India Motion Pictures Ltd., BananaIP Blog (Aug. 26, 2011), available at https://www.bananaip.com/indian-performing-rights-soceity-v/.
9. Lexagle, The Difference Between a Contract of Service and a Contract for Services, Lexagle (Apr. 6, 2021), https://www.lexagle.com/blog-en-sg/the-difference-between-a-contract-of-service-and-a-contract-for-services.
10. Indian Performing Rights Soc’y v. E. India Motion Pictures Ltd., AIR 1977 SC 1443 (India).
11. Amar Nath Sehgal v. Union of India, 2005 (30) PTC 253 (Del) (India).
12. Indian Performing Rights Soc’y v. Music Broad. Pvt. Ltd., IA No. 1213 of 2022 (India).
13. Indian Performing Rights Soc’y v. Rajasthan Patrika Pvt. Ltd., IA No. 9452 of 2022 (India).
14. Analysis and Effect of IPRS v. Music Broadcast Ltd. and Rajasthan Patrika Pvt. Ltd., Mondaq (June 9, 2023), available at https://www.mondaq.com/india/copyright/1327792/analysis-and-effect-of-iprs-vs-music-broadcast-limited-and-rajasthan-patrika-private-limited.
15. Phonographic Performance Ltd. v. State of Goa, 2024 SCC OnLine Bom 2713 (India).
16. E. Book Co. v. D.B. Modak, (2008) 1 SCC 1 (India).
17. Simranjeet, Bombay High Court Quashes Circular Exempting Music at Weddings from Copyright Infringement, SCC OnLine Blog (Aug. 22, 2024), available at https://www.scconline.com/blog/post/2024/08/22/bomhc-quashes-circular-exempting-music-at-wedding-from-copyright-infringement/.
18. Ankit Rastogi, Super Cassettes Indus. Ltd. v. Nirulas Corner House (P) Ltd., Indian Case Laws (July 18, 2014), available at https://indiancaselaws.wordpress.com/2014/07/18/super-cassettes-industries-ltd-vs-nirulas-corner-house-p-ltd/.
19. ibid
20. Eastern Book Company v. D.B. Modak, (2008) 1 SCC 1
21. Gramophone Co. of India Ltd. v. Super Cassette Indus. Ltd., 1995 SCC OnLine Del 154 (India).
