VidhiAagaz
International Journal ofLaw Management & Humanities
ISSN 2581-5369 · Open access
International Journal ofLaw Management & Humanities
Open accessArticlesVol. 8 No. I (2025)pp. 403–418

Unveiling Financial Crimes in India: Challenges, Enforcement, Pathways to Reform

796views340downloads
Published 16 January 2025 · pp. 403–418 · Vol. 8 No. I (2025)
Abstract

Among the major drawbacks of India's economic stability and governance are financial crimes in the form of money laundering, corporate fraud, tax evasion, and cybercrime. These offences have increased in dimension and complexity with technological and globalization advances and systemic vulnerabilities despite such comprehensive legislative frameworks as the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA) and the Fugitive Economic Offenders Act (FEOA). High-profile cases of huge financial losses, such as the Nirav Modi-PNB scam and the loan default case of Vijay Mallya, highlight the need for better strategies to combat financial crimes in the country. This research has investigated all the challenges encountered while battling financial crimes in India. Such areas of investigation included sophisticated approaches taken by the perpetrators, the cross-border nature of offences, judicial inefficiencies, and corruption within the institutions involved in regulation and enforcement. It is also underlined that these are not adequate for existing enforcement mechanisms, technological limitations, and delayed judicial processes in bringing timely prosecutions and their deliveries. To address these issues, the paper advocates a multi-dimensional approach: strengthening legal frameworks, more intensive use of technology in the form of artificial intelligence and blockchain, and better coordination among regulatory bodies. International cooperation is considered indispensable to confront transnational financial crimes. Public awareness and financial literacy are deemed essential to prevent fraud at the grassroots level. It further suggests that efforts to make the enforcement agencies independent and transparent are critical to eliminating institutional corruption. This research concludes that it is a joint effort between the government, regulatory bodies, judiciary, and society that will help to minimize financial crimes in India. With technology, international cooperation, and systemic inefficiencies, India can build a more resilient and transparent financial system to deter economic offences and develop sustainable development.

Keywords
FinancialCrimeschallenges reforms
Contents
Full text

Introduction

Among the key risks threatening global and national economies is the possibility of financial crimes, mainly in the areas of money laundering and corporate fraud. By exploiting technology, globalisation, and interconnectivity in the system, financial crimes have metamorphosed into a high-tech activity. The development of financial crimes has derailed not only India's economic growth but has also shaken the people's confidence in the very regulatory and legal frameworks created to safeguard the economy. High-profile cases involving leading personalities, multi-national organizations, and big money bring these issues to the centre stage, pointing out a pressing need for effective AML and anti-fraud regulations.

Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002 forms the crux of India's AML regime. It invests the powers of investigating, prosecuting, and recovery of proceeds of crime under the Enforcement Directorate. In addition to the Companies Act, of 1956 & 2013, the Indian Penal Code, of 1860 and the Foreign Exchange Management Act, of 1999, among other complementary legislation, further provide various mechanisms in checking financial crimes. The problems remain for the government despite the framework of the law to be able to curtail such financial crimes, especially in more complex corporate frauds and cross-border money laundering.3

High-profile cases like PNB fraud with Nirav Modi and Mehul Choksi have thrown light on how systemic vulnerabilities exist within a financial institution. In the case of PNB scam, amounting to ₹14,000 crores, regulatory oversight failed; internal controls were misused by some persons with criminal minds. Again, in Vijay Mallya, involving loan defaults of ₹9,000 crores, high-profile individuals managed the financial system for their convenience and managed to escape to foreign soil from the grip of the country's justice system.

One of the challenges that face the prevention and prosecution of financial crimes relates to the increasing complexity of the networks of finance. Layering of illicit funds occurs across several jurisdictions coupled with complex transactions in most cases making the enforcement agencies incapable of traceable origin of money, thus complicating financial network traces. The case for using emerging technologies including blockchain and cryptocurrencies has complicated things as they present fresh pathways through which criminals can avoid traces of the money, hide, and launder it back.

The complexity further increases with this rising trend of cross-border financial crimes. Differences in their legal frameworks, lack of international cooperation, and also jurisdictional challenges are not allowing for effective enforcement. India entered into Mutual Legal Assistance Treaties (MLATs) and cooperated with international bodies like the Financial Action Task Force (FATF), but there is always a need for more mechanisms to be developed to address issues of transnational crimes.

In addition to the legal and procedural hurdles, institutional ones like insufficient resources, judicial delay, and untrained investigators and prosecutors are also responsible for ineffective enforcement. Some of the big cases even take years to conclude. This reduces the deterrent power of such big cases, and people also lose trust in the very system that is supposed to provide security.

The dissertation deals with the current scenario and rising tide of financial crimes, particularly money laundering and corporate fraud in India. This analysis explores the hurdles that agencies such as ED and the Central Bureau of Investigation face in enforcing anti-money laundering and anti-fraud laws. The research attempts to provide some actionable suggestions to strengthen the fight against financial crimes and economic resilience in India, based on recent case studies, the effectiveness of current frameworks, and enforcement loopholes.4

Understanding Financial Crimes in India

Financial crimes in India are very wide-ranging unlawful activities that exploit loopholes in the financial system to earn monetary benefits. These would include money laundering and corporate fraud, cybercrimes, and tax evasion posing different challenges to law enforcers, regulatory authority, and the judicial system itself. This makes financial crimes a major challenge in keeping the stability of India's economy as well as in the governance and regulatory frameworks of the nation, with globalization and technological advancement increasing the complexity of financial transactions.5

Financial crimes are activities related to the illegal use of financial systems or financial institutions to raise ill-gotten gains or hide the origins of funds. These can broadly be categorized under:

Money Laundering: The process by which criminals such as drug traffickers, corrupt officials and tax evaders legitimize their ill-gotten gains

Corporate Fraud: Actions or practices by which a business entity cheats, defrauds, or otherwise deceives the public; includes Embezzlement, false presentation of financial statements and insider trading.

Tax Evasion: The illegal activity of avoiding tax liabilities using misreporting or even non-disclosure of one's income.

Cyber Financial Crimes: Unauthorized access or use of financial systems for stealing or fraudulent purposes, with phishing and hacking being recent examples.

These crimes undermine the financial ecosystem, reduce investor confidence, and assist other illegal activities such as terrorism and organized crime.6

Prevalence of Financial Crimes in India

Indian financial crimes have undergone an incredible rise with globalization, advances in technology, and increasing sophistication of financial transactions. The list includes money laundering, corporate fraud, income tax evasion, and other cybercrimes. All of them are very devastating in terms of economic and social implications. The PNB fraud regarding Punjab National Bank, the Satyam scam, or default by Vijay Mallya has once again shown systemic vulnerabilities that exist in India's financial ecosystem.

Digital banking and cryptocurrencies have brought in new avenues of financial crimes where the wrongdoers can exploit the loopholes in the regulatory system. Cross-border crimes of the type that involve offshore accounts and tax havens make it a complicated situation and make it tough to be investigated and prosecuted by agencies such as the Enforcement Directorate and the Central Bureau of Investigation.7

Shocking are the numbers of financial crimes in India. Billions of rupees have been lost to such fraudulent activities and dented the trust of the public in the financial institutions, besides the mounting burden of NPAs in the banking system. Despite strict laws like PMLA and the Fugitive Economic Offenders Act, the institutional constraints, judicial delay, and the very sophistication of financial crimes keep cropping up as a deterrent to the process of enforcement.

The increasing rates of financial crimes can be addressed by developing better regulatory frameworks, cooperating on an international level, and spreading awareness among the public.

Legislative Framework Against Financial Crimes

India has developed a comprehensive legislative framework to combat financial crimes, especially money laundering, corporate fraud, tax evasion, and cybercrimes. The legal system of the country contains various laws that empower the enforcement agencies, ensure accountability, and safeguard financial integrity. These laws have evolved and have addressed emerging financial crime threats and reinforced India's commitment to global anti-financial crime standards.

1. Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA), 2002

The PMLA forms the core of India's anti-money laundering framework. It provides the ED with the ability to investigate and prosecute money laundering offences. The Act mandates financial institutions to report suspicious transactions and maintain records of specified financial transactions. It also provides for attachment and confiscation of property derived from proceeds of crime. Over the years, amendments to PMLA have widened its scope, incorporating more predicate offences and reinforcing measures against cross-border money laundering.89

2. Indian Penal Code (IPC), 1860

Other heads under the IPC, wherein section 420 which deals with cheating and sections 467, which deals with forgery and 409, breach of trust by public servants, etc., cover some heads of financial fraud. Continuous application is also there in the form of corporate fraud, misappropriation, and embezzlement of money under various other enactments, too.10

3. Companies Act, 2013

The Companies Act provides a legal framework for the formation, regulation, and dissolution of companies. It contains provisions that would prevent corporate fraud through false financial statements, insider trading, and misrepresenting company performance. The Ministry of Corporate Affairs is authorized by the Act to regulate corporate governance and take action against fraudulent practices in the corporate sector. The Act also obliges internal auditing and disclosing financial statements to bring out transparency.11

4. Foreign Exchange Management Act, 1999

FEMA regulates foreign exchange dealings and also aims to further promote the orderly development and maintenance of the foreign exchange market in India. It provides a legal framework to prevent and curb violations related to foreign exchange and remittance of illicit funds, money laundering, tax evasion, and hawala dealings.12

5. Income-tax Act, 1961

The Income Tax Act is perhaps the most vital legislation for the prevention of tax evasion, one of the commonest financial crimes. The law provides for the taxation of income, penalties, and investigation for undisclosed income or fraudulent tax practices. The Black Money (Undisclosed Foreign Income and Assets) and Imposition of Tax Act, 2015 are against individuals who have undisclosed foreign assets for tax evasion.13

6. Information Technology Act, 2000

The Cyber Act deals with cybercrime such as frauds dealing in online financial transactions and even hacking, identity theft and phishing. With financial services being increasingly adopted at a digital platform, it furnishes the basic frameworks through which dealing and protection of data coupled with digital transactions in a banking sector can be had.14

7. Fugitive Economic Offenders Act 2018

The Fugitive Economic Offenders Act serves to deal with offenders who run away from the country to avoid prosecution. In this regard, it authorizes the government to acquire the assets of those whose financial crimes amount to more than ₹ 100 crore and are found absconding from courts in India. This Act is significant in dealing with various high-profile cases, as is the case with that of Vijay Mallya and Nirav Modi.15

Major Financial Crimes in India

The financial crimes in India have had quite a deep impact on the economy, but the history would lead towards systemic reforms and legal strengthening. High-profile corporate frauds, money laundering cases, and banking scams drew into their limelight many deep-rooted vulnerabilities lying inside India's financial and regulatory systems. These cases involved big money and influential persons, corporate leaders, and public officials in the fray, and hence questions about governance and oversight regulations become valid.

1. Punjab National Bank (PNB) Fraud Case (2018)

This is considered the biggest financial bank scam in India. This emerged as a landmark case wherein all vulnerabilities of the Indian banking sector could be viewed. In February 2018, the Enforcement Directorate and Central Bureau of Investigation detected that one of the famous diamond merchants, Nirav Modi, along with his uncle Mehul Choksi, had cheated PNB for the amount of ₹14,000 crore. The modus operandi included unauthorized issuance of Letters of Undertaking (LoUs) and Foreign Letters of Credit (FLCs) to the companies of Modi and Choksi without any proper collateral. These LoUs were then sold to the overseas branches of other Indian banks without the knowledge of the bank.

This scam exposed major loopholes in the internal controls inside the bank and the working of the regulatory authorities. At a time when PNB was one of India's largest public sector banks, it could not even suspect such fraudulent activities until they reached an enormous scale. The case led to major reforms in the banking sector with stricter checks and balances, enhanced monitoring mechanisms, and the adoption of the Fugitive Economic Offenders Act, 2018. The scam also reflected the weakness in the oversight of high-value transactions and international financial operations in India.16

2. The Satyam Scandal (2009)

It has often been termed the India "Enron moment". It was in January 2009 when news came as a shock to the Indian corporate world that Satyam Computers founder and then chairperson Ramalinga Raju had perpetrated one of the biggest corporate frauds in the country. Admitted intent to cheat, the then chairman of India's fourth largest software firm inflated the balance sheet of the company to the tune of Rs7,000 crore and put into account some fictitious amounts to portray profits well over the company's figures for two straight years.

The scam came into light when Raju attempted to buy the Maytas competitor company which also brought this to the notice of the shareholders and the analysts. It was further found that revenues, profits, and the firm's assets were generally false and that the firm was involved in huge financial misreporting. Raju and his co-conspirators were sent behind bars, and the corporate governance laws witnessed fundamental changes in the form of much more stringent audits and the oversight of companies that are traded publicly.

The Satyam scam led to a massive revamping of the Companies Act, 1956, and corporate governance features were brought into the new Companies Act, 2013, like independent directors sitting on the board, having an audit committee within companies, much more, and this kind of reform ensure fraud is not practised again, neither are finances mismanaged.17

3. Vijay Mallya Case (2016)

The well-known face of financial crimes in India for defaulting on loans of around ₹9,000 crores is Vijay Mallya, a powerful businessman and owner of Kingfisher Airlines. Kingfisher Airlines, which was grounded back in 2012, defaulted on their financial commitments but it is known that it was money from the bank consortiums that were abused, resulting in heavy losses to the respective banks. He is also accused of siphoning money from the loan funds meant for repayment of dues towards banks, to personal expediencies and assets held abroad.18

This drama goes further, as in 2016, Mallya moved to the UK, so the case would be the most challenging to prosecute. The government of India launched extradition cases against Mallya in the UK; it was cases of money laundering and fraud apart from other related financial scams. The case is, as of writing in 2024, still judicially ongoing as Indian authority demands his deportation to the country for facing trial.19

This case not only brought out the issue of corporate default and the culture of non-repayment but also exposed the weakness in the functioning of public sector banks in India and slack lending practices. The government brought in the Fugitive Economic Offenders Act, which enables the confiscation of the assets of economic offenders who flee the country.

4. Nirav Modi and Mehul Choksi – Banking Fraud (2018)

In the case of India, one time the scam was so much directly linked to the names of the diamond traders Nirav Modi and Mehul Choksi also in the PNB scam. Here, Modi and Choksi have been stated to have indulged in multi-crore scams; both have made the banking system operational to their wrong activities, by using Letters of Undertaking (LoUs) for unauthorized purposes they were able to get credit from foreign banks where the adequate collaterals which in turn approximated the ₹14,000 crore siphoned through the system of falsehood.20

The two businessmen have been out of the country since early 2018. They have been at the centre of extradition proceedings all along. The case brought up both the misuse of banking systems and brought out the need for stronger controls better auditing processes and cross-border cooperation, which would have helped in settling financial frauds. Its weakness in implementation also came out in the PMLA (Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002) when it proved to be hard to get back the siphoned money.21

5. Agusta Westland Chopper Scam (2013)

Agusta Westland helicopter scam is a term coined for allegations of kickbacks by Italian aerospace company Agusta Westland paid to Indian officials for VVIP helicopters. The contract worth ₹3,600 crore was supposed to be for the supply of helicopters to the Indian Air Force to ferry the president, prime minister, and other senior functionaries. It has now been found that the Indian politicians and officials were paid bribes for the contract.22

When the scam was exposed in 2013, some of the high officials involved in the case were former Indian Air Force Chief S.P.T. Paul and others. This was one of the finest examples of the nexus between defence procurement and corruption in India. The efforts made by the government to remove defence-related corruption brought major reforms in the procedures followed in defence procurement.23

6. The National Herald Case (2012)

The National Herald case is the most politically charged financial crime connected with the Congress Party. Its leaders are nothing but Sonia Gandhi and Rahul Gandhi. In a nutshell, the case puts focus on allegations that there has been financial misappropriation in the procurement of assets of the newspaper National Herald, transmuted into the company Young Indian Ltd., whose work is taken care of by the Gandhi family.24

They have been charged with embezzlement on grounds of finance as they grabbed the newspaper assets and properties without anyone's permission and not in a very transparent manner. Though the case is still in court, the whole affair, owing to the politics involved with financial crimes, has thrown light on how politics could be used for financial activities in such a big way.25

Challenges in Combatting Financial Crimes

Financial crimes, such as money laundering, corporate fraud, tax evasion, and cybercrime, have been a continued serious concern to India's economy and the country's financial institutions. Although a robust legal and regulatory framework exists, these crimes are constantly developing; hence, it is becoming highly challenging for enforcement agencies, regulators, and the judiciary to handle such crimes. A few of the principal problems in the fight against financial crimes in India include

1. Complexity and Sophistication of Financial Crimes

The greatest challenge of fighting financial crimes is that such crimes are becoming increasingly complex and sophisticated. Financial offenders usually utilize convoluted schemes, including shell companies, offshore accounts, and international cross-border money laundering systems to veil illicit activities. They employ loopholes in the law, weak regulation, and technology to blur the fact that they are doing something wrong. This complicates the enforcement as these digital platforms and cryptocurrencies allow anonymity and worldwide access, which makes it quite difficult to trace transactions for agencies.

For instance, the Nirav Modi-PNB scam was an intricate network of fraudulent Letters of Undertaking (LoUs) issued by Punjab National Bank to drain funds in different countries. Again, in corporate fraud, for example, in the case of the Satyam scam, falsification of financial statements is being done, which regulators and auditors can hardly track until it has taken gigantic proportions.

2. Cross-Border Nature of Financial Crimes

Most financial crimes, especially money laundering and fraud, involve a transnational dimension. Here, the criminals would shift illicit funds across borders through offshore bank accounts, tax havens, and shell companies to hide their assets. It is very challenging for Indian law enforcement agencies to trace such crimes since they are restricted by their jurisdiction and resources in investigating such crimes outside the country.

For example, the case of Vijay Mallya: A business magnate fled to the UK after allegedly defaulting on loans worth ₹9,000 crore. It is only because an inadequate extradition structure and weak international cooperation in managing financial crimes ensure that perpetrators will go scot-free and further pillage international financial systems.

India has entered into several treaties with other nations to share the investigation of financial crimes. However, there are some delays in the procedure, which is due to the international procedure, the legal systems of the countries, and inadequate reciprocal arrangements.26

3. Lack of Technological Infrastructure and Expertise

Technologically and professionally well-equipped ED and the CBI enforcement agencies regularly seem to lack the advanced structure of investigation and prosecution of a sophisticated financial crime. These financial basis-related crimes generally consist of difficult statistical examinations and forensic accountancy allied to footprints of computer systems and so cannot be performed except at the hands of suitable special knowledge about such skills together with modern technology. On the other hand, the majority of Indian investigating agencies are yet short of such equipment related, for instance, to trace, analysis and prosecution work.

More complexities in digital banking, e-commerce, and even the existence of cryptocurrencies add up to the complexity. Most cybercrime and fraudsters employ such a media platform, making it impossible to trace for follow-up or investigation and other procedures needed to expose culprits.27

4. Slow Judicial Process and Delays in Trials

Indian judiciary is wide but with much backlog especially regarding cases of financial crimes. It generally undermines the deterrence effect of prosecutions due to long periods of trials with lengthy investigations. Such cases involve many complex legal and financial matters that can only be resolved in a court after a long time.

This delay only goes in to weaken justice as the criminals exploit this procrastinated procedural weakness and trial protraction to run away from consequences or prolong the proceedings themselves and even more recent controversies like the PNB scam and the one in Satyam case, took ages with some of the culprits running to neighbouring countries and some even living large until date on the back of their loot.28

5. Political Influence and Corruption

Financial crimes always involve political influence, corruption, and abuse of power. Most celebrities who commit this crime usually have politics and economies which aid them in manipulating the system while trying to go scot-free. In that way, they get to prolong the probes by law enforcement agencies. For instance, in the Agusta Westland chopper scam, many key political figures were indicted to be part of the defence contracts' kickbacks thus making the investigators slow up.

The other dimension of the problem is that corruption in the regulatory bodies and financial institutions fuels the problem. Some cases involved officials who have overlooked suspicious activities or even collaborated with criminals to facilitate illicit financial activities. This dilutes the potency of the laws already in existence and undermines the efforts of agencies that work towards ensuring that offenders are brought to book.29

6. Weak Implementation of Existing Laws

Even though the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002, Fugitive Economic Offenders Act, 2018, and the Income Tax Act, 1961, have grand legislative structures, the enforcement part is a very weak system. There seems to be a lack of coordination in the central agencies, from the Enforcement Directorate (ED), Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI), and Income Tax Department, which is then reflected in the inefficiency involved in the investigation and prosecution process. Overlapping jurisdictions involving these agencies delay and confuse their handling of financial crime cases.

First, the laws, such as the PMLA, have been termed to be very impractical since tracking the proceeds of crime is not so easy. The other is the non-conviction rate in money laundering cases; the case of a direct link between the crime and the proceeds usually requires an exhaustive knowledge of law and finance.30

7. Public Awareness and Education

There is also the challenge of lack of information on the part of the public about financial crimes, their consequences, and reporting mechanisms. Most of the cybercrimes and frauds target unsuspecting people. Such people do not have warning signs of such crimes nor an understanding of the legal ways to report them. Phishing, identity theft, and other internet frauds are generally emerging to be an increasing threat for people who are less digitally literate, as such persons are more easily caught unguarded.31

Education and awareness generation through outreach programs, in the form of specific financial crime helplines, would allow the citizens to identify and bring frauds to notice. This is an area of great concern for India while fighting against financial crimes.32

Financial Crimes in India: Overcoming the Challenges

Financial crimes, ranging from money laundering to corporate fraud and tax evasion, not only threaten economic stability but also have a dent in public trust and integrity damage financial systems. India has a very robust legal structure in place, but the very same presents challenges in dealing with such crimes due to their complexity, cross-border character, and systemic gaps in enforcement. Still, the approach has to be multifaceted and coordinated for the challenges to be curtailed and financial crimes to be effectively minimized.

1. Strengthen Legislative Frameworks and Enforcement

India has a body of laws, comprising the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA) and the Fugitive Economic Offenders Act. The problem lies, however, in their very weak enforcement. Strong enforcement of these legislations will require strengthening them to prevent loopholes and ambiguity. For instance, if an amendment in PMLA makes the recovery process for the assets and the conviction process less hectic, it may become a more potent deterrent. This can be further aided by granting more autonomy and resources to agencies like ED and CBI with an assurance that the investigation is unbiased and properly done.

Further introduction of specialized financial crime units in the agency by forensic accountants, data analysts, and legal experts would also support a quality investigation. There should be a cohesive response by way of a joint task force for such crimes, represented by the ED, CBI, and Income Tax Department.33

2. Technology and Data Analytics

Technology is at the core of the detection and prevention of financial crimes. Tools such as Artificial Intelligence, Machine Learning, and big data analytics are helpful because they enable one to notice trends and anomalies that represent fraudulent activities.

Financial institutions and regulatory agencies must ensure that real-time monitoring systems are established to identify suspicious transactions.

It can also become more effective with the Aadhaar-linked financial ecosystem and central databases for detecting high-risk entities and eliminating identity fraud. Blockchain is going to be an open, distributed ledger technology that will lead to accountability and fewer scopes of manipulation in any kind of financial transaction.34

3. Improvement International Collaboration

The majority of money laundering-type financial crimes have transboundary elements. Hence international cooperation should be developed upon treaties, agreements and partnering through widely accepted organisations that encompass the FATF as well as the Interpol as there is a need to speed extradition process, where so far has been done on those cases with Vijay Mallya and Nirav Modi type amongst others.

India should also join and be included in networks of information exchange to trace the flow of money laundering. It would mean that with, for example, a tax information exchange agreement with other countries, it would make known specific offshore accounts and untaxed income.35

4. Delays in the courts.

Judicial inefficiency is a huge impediment to the prevention of financial crimes. A dedicated economic offences court can do its bit in the acceleration of financial crime cases and hence delay reduction. Alternative dispute resolution mechanisms in some of the financial disputes will reduce pressure on courts. Training judges and prosecutors on complex financial matters will ensure a better and more efficient dispensation of justice.36

5. Public Awareness and Financial Literacy

Public education and awareness are the tools to eradicate financial crimes. Financial education will empower people to recognize scams and phishing sites and report suspected ones. This way, institutions should be transparent to regain public trust and reduce bad behaviour. Financial crime reporting lines, as well as whistleblower protection policies, are an efficient invitation to report without revealing or compromising identities.37

6. Politic Influence and Corruption Minimization

Corruption and political influence on the regulatory and law enforcement bodies need to be eradicated. It is possible through proper appointment procedures along with provision for accountability and performance evaluation for maintaining institutional autonomy. Protection for whistleblowers and enhancement of civil society participation in the decision-making process shall ensure the same for future generations.38

Conclusion

An upsurge in the case of financial crime is faced by the legal and regulatory framework of the country today. Some of these are money laundering, corporate fraud, tax evasion, cybercrimes, etc. The country has been well-endowed with strong laws such as the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA), the Companies Act, and the Fugitive Economic Offenders Act; however, enforcement has remained a persistent problem in light of the complexity, sophistication, and cross-border nature of financial crimes. Such offences usually involve rather complex mechanisms, which include bank accounts, shell companies, and electronic platforms, all of which cannot be tracked.

One of the major hurdles in the struggle against financial crimes is the slow judicial process. Years have passed, some to be concluded, and with the backlogs in the courts and the long investigations involved, the perpetrators end up going free. Political influence and corruption sometimes undermine effectiveness in investigations and enforcement due to corrupt influences within regulatory bodies. The lack of technological infrastructure and skills in financial crime investigations is a major deterrent in the detection and prosecution of sophisticated crimes.39

For such problems, India requires institution building, technological development, and better coordination between the various regulatory agencies. Along with this, international cooperation related to cross-border financial crimes needs to be enhanced. Public awareness programs for financial literacy and fraud prevention can prove very effective in enabling the general public to take proactive steps to prevent themselves from being victims of financial crimes, especially those perpetrated through digital channels. All these would enhance India's legal structure, enforcement practices, and, above all, a secure financial system. Vigilance, innovation, and collaboration by all stakeholders will be required to sustain this fight against these financial crimes.40

*****

Footnotes

3. Ani, 59% of Indian companies suffered financial fraud in 24 months, The Economic Times (Dec. 18, 2024), https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/company/corporate-trends/59-of-indian-companies-suffered-financial-fraud-in-24-months/articleshow/116435203.cms?.

4. Reuters.Com, https://www.reuters.com/world/india/anti-money-laundering-watchdog-urges-india-speed-up-prosecutions-2024-09-19/.

5. https://www.hindustantimes.com/business/indians-report-nearly-800-online-financial-fraud-cases-a-day-are-you-protected-report-101719309683432.html?

6. https://ssrana.in/ufaqs/financial-frauds-india-legal-action/.

7. Sandhya Keelery, India: number of bank fraud cases 2024, Statista (Aug. 30, 2024), https://www.statista.com/statistics/1012729/india-number-of-bank-fraud-cases/?.

8. (Jan. 16, 2004), https://dea.gov.in/sites/default/files/moneylaunderingact.pdf.

9. Introspecting PMLA, 2002, (Apr. 2, 2024), https://www.drishtiias.com/daily-updates/daily-news-editorials/introspecting-pmla-2002.

10. What are economic offences and financial fraud?, Aran Law Firm (Apr. 12, 2023), https://aranlaw.in/blog/criminal-law/what-are-economic-offence-and-financial-fraud/.

11. https://www.mca.gov.in/content/mca/global/en/data-and-reports/reports/other-reports/report-company-law/investigation-under-the-companies-act.html.

12. What is Foreign Exchange Management Act? UPSC CSE, https://chahalacademy.com/fema-act.

13. Kotak Life, What is Tax Evasion? Meaning, Methods & Penalties, (July 3, 2024), https://www.kotaklife.com/insurance-guide/savingstax/what-is-tax-evasion-methods-and-penalties.

14. https://dhsgsu.edu.in/images/Reading-Material/Law/UNIT-IV-Second.pdf.

15. Fugitive Economic Offenders Act, 2018, (July 9, 2020), https://www.drishtiias.com/daily-news-analysis/fugitive-economic-offenders-act-2018.

16. After Vijay Mallya, Nirav Modi: Who is a ‘fugitive economic offender’?, The Indian Express (Dec. 7, 2019), https://indianexpress.com/article/explained/after-mallya-nirav-modi-who-is-a-fugitive-economic-offender-6152543/.

17. https://www.5paisa.com/blog/satyam-scam.

18. Khushboo Narayan, What is Vijay Mallya accused of?, The Indian Express (Mar. 11, 2016), https://indianexpress.com/article/explained/what-is-vijay-mallya-accused-of/.

19. https://www.business-standard.com/india-news/vijay-mallya-assets-recovered-nirmala-sitharaman-ed-124121800573_1.html.

20. Economic Times, Explainer: How Nirav Modi cheated PNB of Rs 14,000 crore through fraudulent LoUs, The Economic Times (Nov. 9, 2022), https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/india/explainer-how-nirav-modi-cheated-pnb-of-rs-14000-crore-through-fraudulent-lous/articleshow/95410291.cms?from=mdr.

21. Jo, Government of India v Modi judgment, (Feb. 24, 2021), https://www.judiciary.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/GOI-v.-Nirav-Modi-judgment.pdf.

22. Economic Times, AgustaWestland VVIP chopper scam: All about India's biggest defence scam after Bofors & what SC said about it, The Economic Times (Mar. 18, 2024), https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/defence/agusta-westland-vvip-chopper-scam-all-about-indias-biggest-defence-scam-after-bofors-what-sc-said-about-it/articleshow/108591961.cms?from=mdr.

23. What is AgustaWestland VVIP choppers case?, The Indian Express (Dec. 4, 2018), https://indianexpress.com/article/india/christian-michel-extraidted-from-dubai-what-is-agusta-westland-vvip-choppers-case5478545/.

24. Zoya Mateen, Rahul and Sonia Gandhi: What is the National Herald case?, (June 12, 2022), https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-61741818.

25. Haritha Sharly Benjamin, Explained | What's the National Herald case haunting Gandhis, Manorama English (July 28, 2022), https://www.onmanorama.com/news/india/2022/07/28/explained-national-herald-case-sonia-gandhi-rahul-timeline.html.

26. Financial Crime: challenges and trends in the digital era, Management Solutions https://www.managementsolutions.com/en/microsites/whitepapers/financial-crime.

27. White-collar crimes present formidable challenge to judicial, economic systems: SC judge Hima Kohli, The Indian Express (July 10, 2024), https://indianexpress.com/article/india/white-collar-crimes-formidable-challenge-judicial-economic-systems-sc-judge-hima-kohli-9445381/.

28. Shivani Bazaz, FATF: India must address low convictions in money laundering cases, enhance court and ED capacity, CNBC TV18 (Sept. 19, 2024), https://www.cnbctv18.com/india/fatf-india-must-address-low-convictions-in-money-laundering-cases-enhance-court-and-ed-capacity-19479362.htm.

29. Sigi Peter, IPF 11.indb, (May 9, 2016), https://www.ncaer.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/d4.pdf.

30. Shivani Bazaz, FATF: India must address low convictions in money laundering cases, enhance court and ED capacity, CNBC TV18 (Sept. 19, 2024), https://www.cnbctv18.com/india/fatf-india-must-address-low-convictions-in-money-laundering-cases-enhance-court-and-ed-capacity-19479362.htm.

31. Puja Sharma, Is the fight against financial crime failing? experts call for radical change!, https://ibsintelligence.com/ibsi-news/is-the-fight-against-financial-crime-failing-experts-call-for-radical-change/.

32. https://www.business-standard.com/finance/news/fintech-suraksha-dlai-s-initiative-to-raise-awareness-about-cyber-frauds-124012600637_1.html.

33. Puja Sharma, Is the fight against financial crime failing? experts call for radical change!, https://ibsintelligence.com/ibsi-news/is-the-fight-against-financial-crime-failing-experts-call-for-radical-change/.

34. https://www.business-standard.com/technology/tech-news/indian-businesses-turn-to-data-analytics-ml-to-fight-fraudulent-practices-124122500384_1.html.

35. Just a moment..., https://www.orfonline.org/research/india-s-challenges-in-extraditing-fugitives-from-foreign-countries.

36. Live Law, How Many Financial Scam Cases Came To Logical End? Whenever CBI Or ED Comes, There Is Delay : Supreme Court, (Jan. 5, 2023), https://www.livelaw.in/top-stories/how-many-financial-scam-cases-came-to-logical-end-whenever-cbi-or-ed-comes-there-is-delay-supreme-court-218172.

37. Puja Sharma, Is the fight against financial crime failing? experts call for radical change!, https://ibsintelligence.com/ibsi-news/is-the-fight-against-financial-crime-failing-experts-call-for-radical-change/.

38. Thomas Bock, 2024 Elections and Financial Crime: Navigating 2024’s Shifting Landscape, (Dec. 19, 2024), https://www.kroll.com/en/insights/publications/elections-financial-crime-navigating-2024-shifting-landscape.

39. Omkar Gokhale, PMLA cases pendency | Collective responsibility of the prosecuting agencies, defence lawyers to make system work: HC, Mumbai News (Apr. 10, 2024), https://indianexpress.com/article/cities/mumbai/pmla-cases-pendency-collective-responsibility-of-the-prosecuting-agencies-defence-lawyers-to-make-system-work-hc-9261212/.

40. India's measures to combat money laundering and terrorist financing, https://www.fatf-gafi.org/en/publications/Mutualevaluations/India-MER-2024.html.

How to cite

Aditya Pratap Singh & Abhya Varma, Unveiling Financial Crimes in India: Challenges, Enforcement, Pathways to Reform, 8 Int'l J.L. Mgmt. & Human. 403 (2025).

Cite this article

Aditya Pratap Singh & Abhya Varma, Unveiling Financial Crimes in India: Challenges, Enforcement, Pathways to Reform, 8 Int'l J.L. Mgmt. & Human. 403 (2025).
Chat with us