Introduction
A Uniform Civil Code means that all sections of the society irrespective of their religion shall be treated equally according to a national civil code, which shall be applicable to all uniformly.
They cover areas like- Marriage, divorce, maintenance, inheritance, adoption and succession of the property. It is based on the premise that there is no connection between religion and law in modern civilization.
Genesis of the Concept of UCC
• Romans have Jus Civile, a legal contemporary term that upholds all the rules and principles of law derived from the laws and customs of Rome.
• Uniform Civil Code is followed in countries like UK, France, US (California has a Family Code that applies to all citizens, regardless of their religion). Pakistan, Bangladesh, Malaysia, Turkey, Indonesia, Egypt and Ireland. All these countries have one set of personal laws for all religions and there are no separate laws for any particular religion or community.
• In India, the Lex Loci Report of October 1840 emphasized the importance and necessity of uniformity in codification of Indian law, relating to crimes, evidences and contract but it recommended that personal laws of Hindus and Muslims should be kept outside such codification.
• Divide and Rule policy of the British Empire.
• Hindu’s-brahamanical customs accepted-fear of opposition from higher castes.
• Muslims-diverse local customs so a uniform Sharia law of 1937 enacted to govern all Muslims.
• However local customs were allowed to outweigh the written text of law.
• After independence Hindus have to follow the Hindu code bill 1956, in the form of four separate acts, the Hindu Marriage Act, Succession Act, Minority and Guardianship Act and Adoptions and Maintenance Act.
• Muslims and other religions were given the liberty to follow their own respective laws. For Muslims, the Shariat prevails and All India Muslim Personal Law Board keeps attempting to regulate their laws.
(A) Need a UCC
• Rights based society
• India is a democratic, secular and socialist country. A modern welfare state cannot permit regressive practices against women in the garb of religion.
• Cultural practices must align with substantive equality and gender justice goals.
• Opposition to UCC stems from the reluctance to shed patriarchal notions and traditions.
• Shah Bano Begum v. Mohammad Ahmed Khan (1985)- The Supreme Court upheld the right of a Muslim woman to claim maintenance from her husband under Section 125 of the Criminal Procedure Code, even after the expiry of the Iddat period.
• Danial Latifi v. UOI (2001)- Correct interpretation of ‘Reasonable and fair provision for future of wife’.
• Ms Jorden Diengdeh v. S.S. Chopra (1985)- The court raised the issue of uniformity in personal marriage. The Apex Court observed that the laws that are related to marriage such as judicial separation or divorce are not uniform at all. It also emphasized the need for the uniform provisions like an irretrievable breakdown of marriage and mutual consent for divorce to be applied in all cases irrespective of religion. The need for framing the Uniform Code for marriage and divorce was raised by the Court as the Court directed to send a copy of its judgment to be sent to the Ministry of Law and Justice.
• Sarla Mudgal v. Union of India (1995)- The Supreme Court held that a Hindu husband cannot convert to Islam and marry another woman without dissolving his first marriage.
• It also stated that a UCC would prevent such fraudulent conversions and bigamous marriages.
• John Vallamattom v. Union of India- A Priest from Kerala, John Vallamatton filed a writ petition in the year 1997 stating that Section 118 of the Indian Succession Act was discriminatory against the Christians as it imposes unreasonable restrictions on their donation of property for the religious or charitable purpose by will. The bench struck down the Section declaring it to be unconstitutional. Further, the court observed that, it is a matter of great regrets that Article 44 of the Constitution has not been given effect to. Parliament is still to step in for framing a common civil code in the country. A Common Civil Code will help the cause of national integration by removing the contradictions based on ideologies.
• Shayara Bano v. Union of India (2017)- The Supreme Court declared the practice of triple talaq as unconstitutional and violative of the dignity and equality of Muslim women.
• UCC was proposed in November 2019 and March 2020.
• Withdrawn in face of opposition from religious groups and tribals.
• Fresh call for UCC in June, 2023 has rekindled the discussion. The 22nd Law Commission of India had recently sought fresh suggestions from various stakeholders on the Uniform Civil Code.
(B) Inconsistencies in Various Personal Laws
• Hindu Undivided Families are exempted from taxes
• Muslims are exempted from paying stamps duty on gift deeds
• Muslim law doesn’t permit adoption
• Hindus practice Dowry, Muslims practice Dower
• Muslim Law permits polygamy
• No uniformity in succession laws
• No uniformity in grounds of divorce
• Differences in marriageable age
• Muslim women cannot remarry before expiry of ‘iddat’
• Reprehensible custom of ‘halala’
The Way Forward
• We need to identify discriminatory and oppressive issues and consider progressive views that align with the constitutional goals of equality and justice.
• By UCC, the existing inequalities can be rectified, ensuring that women from all religious backgrounds are granted equal rights and opportunities.
• Issues like child marriages, polygamy, triple talaq, right to maintenance, inheritance and property rights can effectively be addressed by the way of Uniform Civil Code.
• UCC has the potential to foster national integration and secularism by establishing a shared identity and a sense of unity among all Indians.
• It would address the communal and sectarian conflicts such as Love Jihad and honour killings that arise due to the existence of distinct personal laws.
• It would streamline the legal system by eliminating the complexities and contradictions that stem from multiple personal laws.
• It would harmonize civil and criminal laws, eliminating any anomalies and loopholes that arise due to the diverse personal laws.
• UCC would modernize and reform outdated and regressive practices prevalent in certain personal laws. It would eliminate practices that infringe upon human rights and values enshrined in the Constitution of India, such as triple talaq, polygamy, child marriage, and others.
Conclusion
India has a unique blend of codified personal laws of Hindus, Muslims, Christians, Parsis. There exists no uniform family-related law in a single statute book for all Indians which is acceptable to all religious communities who co-exist in India. However, a majority of them believe that UCC is definitely desirable and would go a long way in strengthening and consolidating the Indian nationhood. The differences of opinion are on its timing and the manner in which it should be realized.
Instead of using it as an emotive issue to gain political advantage, political and intellectual leaders should try to evolve a consensus. The question is not of minority protection, or even of national unity, it is simply one of treating each human person with dignity, something which personal laws have so far failed to do.
*****
