VidhiAagaz
International Journal ofLaw Management & Humanities
ISSN 2581-5369 · Open access
International Journal ofLaw Management & Humanities
Open accessArticlesVol. 8 No. I (2025)pp. 499–506

Trade Law and Environmental Justice: Indian Scenario

388views247downloads
Published 22 January 2025 · pp. 499–506 · Vol. 8 No. I (2025)
Abstract

Environment and trade are interconnected with each other. The past experience has revealed that development of trade without due consideration to the environment can have a devastating impact on the environment, which in some cases might also be irreversible. Climate Change is one of the biggest problems that the world faces today. We lack behind in fulfilling the sustainable development goals that were set way back in 1992 in the Rio Declaration. Therefore, it is essential to look at environmental laws from the lenses of trade and economy. India being one of the leading developing countries has a big role to play in sustainable development. This paper analyses the various environmental laws and regulations and how they impact the Indian economy and the world trade. It also aims to understand the effectiveness of these laws in achieving sustainable development goals. More specifically, it analyses the compliance of these laws to the various commitments that India has made at the international forums in relation to environment conservation and climate change. The paper makes suggestions as to what changes can be brought in the laws to make the path of sustainable development for India a reality.

Keywords
Environmenttradesustainable developmentenvironmental justice
Contents
Full text

Introduction

The tremendous size of environmental problems has been seen as a result of industrialization and urbanisation, as well as population growth and poverty. The escalating level of pollution has led to a significant deterioration in the environment, both in terms of quantity and quality. This has posed a major threat to the life support system of current and future generations. In order to address environmental issues as a global obligation, various legal and regulatory initiatives were implemented at several levels. The proliferation of environmental measures is also complicated by the establishment of many bodies tasked with ensuring the successful execution of these measures.3 Despite the significant involvement of regulatory bodies in the formulation and execution of measures, several assessments emphasise the insufficiency in addressing development and environmental concerns.

The environment justice movement over time has expanded its scope and appeal among grassroots organisations as a vocabulary for mobilization. Governments and dominant institutions have also adopted the vocabulary of environmental justice, but in these contexts, understandings of the term have tended to be positioned within rather than against market processes and conventional definitions of property rights. There is no critique of the underlying relations of production that lead to such social inequities and environmental damage, despite the fact that these measures are progressive in the sense that they acknowledge that certain groups and communities shouldn’t be discriminated.

Since independence, the state has played a significant role in displacing the underprivileged from their land through its own development projects and in upsetting their way of life (for instance, by severely restricting or prohibiting access to forests). The state has also taken steps to skew the economy in favour of business, modern, intensive agriculture, and the extraction of resources for profit. They contend that as a result, many individuals who might have benefited from sustainable lifestyles based on their local natural resource base found themselves alienated from it and/or compelled to engage in destructive relationships with the few resources remained at their disposal. To use their purposefully inflammatory language, government policies are causing ecosystem people to become ecological refugees.

These tendencies may have been hastened by India's economy's deregulation from the middle of the 1980s, which has also aided in the new middle classes rapidly expanding. Economic liberalisation has greatly benefited this increasingly vocal and prominent segment of society, which is defined as being excessively materialistic, greatly influenced by global consumption habits, and unconcerned with social justice.

The post-colonial state in India is still dominated by economic and social elites and is still dependent on economic growth at (almost) any cost. Without minimizing the changes that come with a second democratic push, in most states the poor are excluded, both politically and culturally from centers of power. The experience of citizenship in India is still far more unequal than reading its beautiful Constitution would suggest.

Today, there are many different places and practices through which different views of environmental justice are contested in India, and any generalization runs the risk of oversimplification.

The present inquiry has prompted a substantial questioning of the inclusion of legal components pertaining to the notion of Sustainable Development within the framework of environmental governance in India. In order to ascertain the level of commitment, this paper undertakes an analysis of constitutional and legislative norms pertaining to the preservation of resources in the pursuit of environmental sustainability, with a focus on the needs of both current and future generations. This paper further examines the role of the court in addressing trade and development as well as environmental disputes, with the aim of elucidating the current understanding of the idea of Sustainable Development in India.

Both the exploitation of the underprivileged and the destruction of the environment feed the materialism and greed of the omnivores in some way. According to this interpretation, the state is unable and unwilling to work for environmental justice because it represents the interests of a wealthy segment of society that, for the most part, is successful in shifting the costs of its environmentally destructive lifestyles to the underprivileged while savouring the material benefits of highly unequal growth.4 A neo-Gandhian struggle for ecology and equity is the alternative development path advocated in their critique. It is centred on downscaling development projects to the local level, defending common property resources, and reviving (or reintroducing) community-based, participatory methods of environmental management. This description of environmental deterioration and potential repair has undergone extensive critical examination both within and outside of India.

Its depiction of the state as a monolithic entity almost entirely controlled by the omnivores, its supposition that ecosystem people prefer a simple existence devoid of the evils of materialistic consumerism, and its implicit positioning of the precolonial era as one of ecological balance and social harmony all call for serious consideration.5 The Forest Department co-manages forests with communities under joint forest management in a manner that, in principle, reflects local objectives, needs, and rights as well as the Department's own conservation and income aims. This is a sign of a larger shift towards participatory governance, both in terms of revitalising local government at the village and municipal levels and in terms of collaboration with NGOs and other members of civil society.

There is therefore evidence that local participation in resource management has made progress in terms of environmental equity, with new ways of participation facilitating greater dialogue and rebalancing. needs and rights.

India played a significant role in the Stockholm Declaration (UNCHE) and shown its commitment by becoming a signatory to nearly all Multilateral Environmental Agreements (MEAs).6 Indeed, these Multilateral Environmental Agreements (MEAs) possess characteristics of soft law, since they provide a comprehensive legislative and administrative framework aimed at safeguarding the environment. Before the implementation of the Forty Second Amendment, there existed no explicit legislation pertaining to the preservation, management, and conservation of the environment.

In light of the notable importance and dedication of the United Nations Conference on the Human Environment (UNCHE), it is noteworthy to mention that in 1976, the 42nd Amendment to the Constitution incorporated a new provision, namely Article 48-A, into the Constitution's Part IV and Part IV A. This particular article mandates the state to assume the responsibility of safeguarding and enhancing the environment. Likewise, Article 51 (A) (g) imposes a comparable obligation on each citizen to save and enhance the natural environment. In the late 1980s, the Parliament established the Environmental Protection Act in order to establish a collective and coordinated strategy. The inclusion of Article 48-A and 51-A (g) in the constitution does not grant citizens the entitlement to assert a right to a clean environment. The principle of harmonic construction posits that environmental statutes are considered advantageous legislation, and it is the responsibility of the court to establish interpretations that support ecological preservation.

During the late 1970s, Constitutional courts encountered the 'environment versus development' dispute, which encompassed various issues including development projects, mining and quarrying activities, litigation related to large dams, gas leak disasters, hazardous wastes generated by industries, pollution from animal slaughterhouses, preservation of wetlands, water pollution, noise pollution, access to environmental information, coastal zone development, protection of livelihoods, and the prevention of pollution.

The legal perspective on Sustainable Development has notably emphasised the recognition of the right to a healthy environment as an integral aspect of individuals' lives and livelihoods. This recognition has resulted in the inclusion of constitutional provisions that promote the rational use of resources. In a seminal case, the court in Society for Protection of Silent Valley v. Union of India7 established that the implementation of a hydroelectric project results in the eradication of numerous endangered species of fauna and avifauna, as well as deforestation, which in turn impacts climatic conditions and disrupts the equilibrium of the natural environment. The case of Kinkri Devi v. State8 shed light on the interplay between Article 14, Article 19, and Article 21 of the Constitution of India in the context of environmental conservation. The current issue involves a challenge to the government's discretionary allocation of grants for mining activities, which is said to be in contravention of Article 14. The court ruled that the constitutional protection of the basic freedom to engage in any vocation, trade, or business, as stated in Article 19(1) (g), is subject to reasonable limitations outlined in Article 19(6) of the Constitution.

In the case of Rural Litigation and Entitlement Kendra v. State of UP9, the court addressed many legal issues pertaining to rural litigation and entitlements. The Supreme Court addressed issues pertaining to the environment and the maintenance of ecological equilibrium, P. The case of Sachidanada Pandey v. State of West Bengal10 underscored the significance and sacredness of the natural environment, as emphasised by the Court. In the case of State of Tamil Nadu v. Abu Kavur Bai,11 it is noteworthy that the court made an observation on the expansive scope of material resources. The court recognised that this term encompasses not only natural or physical resources, but also includes both moveable and immovable goods. The inalienability of property rights held by the state is a fundamental principle.

In the case of Subhash Kumar v. State of Bihar,12 Justice Kuldip Singh made an observation that "Article 21 encompasses the entitlement to access unpolluted water and air for the purpose of enjoying one's life."

The repercussions of such intervention can result in significant ramifications on a broad scale and perhaps set back progress for a considerable period of time. The potential disruption of the rationalisation of economic weaknesses poses a significant risk. Consequently, it is imperative that, when addressing economic legislation, the Court should exercise its jurisdiction to prevent arbitrary action or unconstitutional legislation. However, it should only intervene in exceptional cases where the perspective reflected in the legislation is entirely untenable.

The Environment Impact Assessment (EIA) is a process that evaluates the potential environmental effects of a proposed project or development. It is a systematic analysis that aims to identify,

The Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) is a component of the cautious approach. Principle 7 and Agenda 21 of the Rio Declaration emphasise the need of public cooperation and public engagement in environmental decision-making processes across many levels. Environmental Impact Assessments (EIAs) play a crucial role in facilitating the convergence of environmental and economic considerations, as well as in proactively identifying and addressing any negative consequences arising from trade and development activities. The Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) is a compulsory component of the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) in India. The term EIA, which stands for Environmental Impact Assessment, is also known as Social Impact Assessment (SIA) and Sustainability Impact Assessment (SIA). The Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) encompasses a multitude of phases and processes.

The draft Environment Impact Assessment Notification was issued by the Ministry of Environment and Forest Conservation. The draught for the year 2020 suggests a reduction in the duration of the notice time for public hearings, namely from 30 days to 20 days. Moreover, by the categorization of various projects into groups A, B1, and B2, a multitude of projects are granted exemption from public examination.

Projects falling under Category B2 are exempt from the requirement of obtaining required Environment Clearance (EC), in contrast to Category A and B1 projects. The projects falling within the exempted category encompass a range of activities, such as offshore and onshore oil, gas and shale exploration, hydroelectric projects with a capacity of up to 25 MW, irrigation projects covering an area between 2,000 and 10,000 hectares, small and medium-sized cement plants, acids other than phosphoric or ammonia, sulphuric acid, micro, small and medium enterprises (MSMEs) engaged in dye and dye intermediates, bulk drugs, synthetic rubbers.

The revised version of the Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) draught suggests an annual submission of compliance reports, in contrast to the previous requirement outlined in the 2006 notice, which mandated a submission every six months. The EIA Notification of 2020 does not encompass the requirement for the public to report infractions and non-compliance. In contrast, the government will consider reports exclusively from entities such as the violator-promoter, government authority, Appraisal Committee, or Regulatory Authority. One significant proposition outlined in the draught of 2020 is to the provision of "post-facto clearance." This provision would enable projects that have been functioning without obtaining prior environmental clearance to be either regularised or permitted to seek for such clearance. In the case of Alembic Pharmaceutical vs. Rohit Prajapati13, the judiciary has established that the field of environmental law does not support the concept of retroactive approval.

The judiciary has consistently recognised the significance of Environmental Impact Assessments (EIA) in the context of conservation in a series of judgements. The cases of Narmada Bacho Andolan v. Union of India14 and Lafarge Umiam Mining (P) Ltd., v. Union of India15 provided clarification on the applicability of the Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) Notification. It was determined that the EIA Notification of 1994 is applicable only in a forward-looking manner, and the courts instructed for retrospective clearance in the form of ex post facto permission. In the case of Alaknanda Hydro Power Company Ltd v. Anuj Joshi16 and Others, the court emphasised the importance of implementing comprehensive safety standards that instill public confidence and protect individuals from perceived risks. This is crucial in order to prevent significant and enduring environmental consequences that may be irreversible. There need of avoiding excessive demands to do excessively complex Environmental Impact Assessments (EIAs), as they may have negative implications for trade and divert attention from ongoing endeavours in India to include environmental considerations into the process of economic policy formulation. In accordance with the prescribed legal mandates, it is imperative that the exercise of delegated governmental authority be subject to scrutiny and responsibility, particularly with regard to the promotion of environmental preservation on a worldwide scale, irrespective of the specific location and timing of such actions.

An assessment of India’s legal framework and environmental institutions also suggests that while improvements have certainly been made, caution still needs to be taken when assuming the state's leadership role in promoting inclusiveness, environmental sustainability and environmental justice.17 Reform initiatives such as the JFM challenge the image of a purely oligarchic state and, in some cases, provide an opportunity to also recognize the environmental justice claims of the disadvantaged. and some (albeit limited) improvements in the allocation of environmental costs and benefits.

India’s rank in Ease of Doing Business is 63.18 It ranks 168 in environment performance index.19 India ranks 52 in sustainable development index.20 These ranks are indicative of the fact that India has made considerable progress in improving the trade but it lacks behind in improving the environment. The recent changes that have been brought to the environmental laws indicate a shift towards economic development from sustainable development. India is amongst the top 5 economies in the world and hence there is a need to play a more proactive role in shaping and strengthening the environment law. Under no circumstances there should be relaxations in laws relating to the environment. The proposed EIA amendments run contrary to the goal of sustainable development and hence they should not be brought into effect.

The trade schemes and incentives need to be closely aligned with the SDGs and those who breach the environmental standards should be penalized. The development projects need a better environmental assessment as the changes that they bring to the environment are irreversible. Moreover, environmental bodies such as the National Green Tribunal, Pollution Control Boards, Wildlife Boards, Coastal Management Authorities need to be strengthened so that they can perform their duties effectively.

*****

Footnotes

3. Agyeman, J., Bullard, R., Evans, B. (Eds.), 2003. Just Sustainabilities: Development in an Unequal World. Earthscan Publications/MIT Press, London.

4. Boyce, J, Shelly, Barry., (eds). 2003. Natural Assets: Democratizing Ownership of Nature. Washington, DC: Island Press.

5. Mukherji, R. 2014. Globalization and Deregulation: Ideas, Interests and Institutional Change in India. New Delhi, London, and New York: Oxford University Press.

6. Baviskar, A., 2002. The Politics of the City Seminar, 516: A Symposium of the Changing Contours of Indian Environmentalism.

7. O.P Nos. 2949 and 3025 of 1979, Kerela High Court.

8. AIR 1987 HP 4 at para 9.

9. 1985 SCR (3) 169

10. AIR 1987 SC 1109.

11. AIR 1984 SC 326.

12. AIR 1990 SC 420.

13. 2020 SCC OnLine SC 347

14. (2000) 10 SC 664.

15. (2011) 7 SCC 338.

16. (2013) MLJ 579.

17. Rajan, S.R., 2006. Modernizing Nature. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

18. https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/688761571934946384/pdf/Doing-Business-2020-Comparing-Business-Regulation-in-190-Economies.pdf

19. https://epi.yale.edu/epi-results/2020/country/ind

20. https://www.sustainabledevelopmentindex.org/

How to cite

Dr Smriti Singh & Shrimayee Puhan, Trade Law and Environmental Justice: Indian Scenario, 8 Int'l J.L. Mgmt. & Human. 499 (2025).

Cite this article

Dr Smriti Singh & Shrimayee Puhan, Trade Law and Environmental Justice: Indian Scenario, 8 Int'l J.L. Mgmt. & Human. 499 (2025).
Chat with us