VidhiAagaz
International Journal ofLaw Management & Humanities
ISSN 2581-5369 · Open access
International Journal ofLaw Management & Humanities
Open accessArticlesVol. 9 No. II (2026)pp. 2762–2771

The Jurisdictional Gap for OTT Platforms: Governance Gaps, Cross-Border Copyright Challenges, and the Need for a Comprehensive Legal Framework

SR
Sakshi Devendra RautStudent at Christ (Deemed to be University) University, Pune, Lavasa, India
262views25downloads
Published 28 April 2026 · pp. 2762–2771 · Vol. 9 No. II (2026)
Abstract

There has been an unprecedented change in the global media landscape as a result of the emergence of Over-The-Top (OTT) service providers, which allow the seamless transmission of content across borders, making it easier for people to consume media content while at the same time revealing a glaring deficiency in current laws. Territorial jurisdictional laws have not been able to adequately regulate organizations that operate in a decentralized digital space. In this paper, we examine the jurisdictional gap in OTT governance, focusing on the problem of governance inadequacies and difficulties in enforcing copyright across borders. The study analyzes the problems with the current international and domestic laws regarding territorial licensing, content regulations, and intermediary liability, and by using the doctrinal and comparative method of analysis, proves how ineffective these laws are in regulating digital streaming services. The paper calls for an integrated and flexible framework for balancing the needs of intellectual property protection, freedom of speech, and innovation, suggesting the adoption of a co-regulatory approach that would incorporate international collaboration and enforcement via technical means. This is done through the analysis of judicial precedents and legislative initiatives reflecting the efforts made in response to the changing realities of the digital age, including the issues associated with the accountability of publishers and the liability of intermediaries, the inadequacies of territorially based systems of copyright in times of the global distribution of protected works, and the increasing tendency to resort to enforcement measures, including dynamic injunctions. The paper also takes into consideration the relevance of international instruments, namely, the WIPO Copyright Treaty, the TRIPS Agreement, and the Berne Convention, for setting cross-border copyright norms and discusses the limits of their applicability under platform-based distribution. Taking into account the impact of jurisdictional fragmentation on all concerned parties, including states, OTT service providers, and content creators, the study offers a comprehensive legal strategy for solving existing problems.

Keywords
OTT platformsjurisdictionintermediary liabilitycross-border copyrightdigital governancestreaming regulationintellectual property lawIT Rules 2021
Contents
Full text

INTRODUCTION

A radical shift in the delivery of AV content has been brought about by the advent of OTT services such as Netflix, Amazon Prime, and Disney+ services. These OTT services function globally, not having any sort of presence physically and legally in the countries in which they provide their service unlike traditional broadcast services that function within a territory and are regulated through licensing. This shift in AV distribution raises questions about the concept of jurisdiction. 2

Jurisdiction of a state helps determine its capacity to make and enforce law. However, this arrangement is challenged in the online world because people can undertake actions that transcend national boundaries. OTT platforms are a prime example of this disruption since they disseminate material all over the world while being governed by dispersed and frequently conflicting legal frameworks.3

This disruption is characterized by an important legal dilemma: although the digital content easily crosses borders of different countries, the legal framework governing such actions continues to be fragmented. The minimum standards for copyright protection and enforcement are set internationally through treaties such as the WIPO Copyright Treaty, Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights, and Berne Convention for the Protection of Literary and Artistic Works. Yet, these agreements were created prior to the emergence of the phenomenon of digital streaming, making them inadequate when considering challenges related to liability of platforms, real-time worldwide distribution, and cross-border enforcement of laws within the OTT industry.4

Enforcement arbitrage is one of the outcomes of this difference in jurisdiction. OTT platforms are legally grounded in one or a small number of jurisdictions, although they frequently operate in numerous jurisdictions concurrently. This allows businesses to strategically take advantage of regulatory lax in some areas while evading more stringent compliance requirements in other others. As a result, states have a difficult time enforcing domestic laws pertaining to intellectual property rights, taxation, consumer protection, and content standards. In addition to undermining national regulatory sovereignty, this puts domestic broadcasters and international streaming monopolies on an unfair playing field.5

Conflicts of law also result from the lack of a single jurisdictional framework, especially where copyright infringement and content control are involved. Similarly, content considered within the scope of “fair use” doctrine in one region can infringe on “fair dealing” principles in another, creating confusion for the platforms and rights holders alike. Technical measures such as virtual private networks (VPNs), which facilitate bypassing regional restrictions, contribute to the issue, weakening territorial licensing systems and causing further financial losses for copyright holders. 6

The introduction of the Information Technology (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics Code) Rules, 2021 represents a significant move toward controlling the OTT platforms in India. Still, such regulation usually overlooks broader jurisdictional concerns, focusing on content categorization and complaint handling instead of cooperation across borders, platform classification, and enforcement beyond the national borders. 7 Due to the lack of clarity in these areas Both regulators and stakeholders continue to face difficulties.

In light of this, the main question this article aims to answer is: how can legal systems balance the territorial character of jurisdiction with the intrinsically borderless functioning of OTT platforms?

Therefore, by looking at governance flaws and cross-border copyright issues, this study conducts a critical analysis of the jurisdictional gap in OTT regulation. It also examines the deficiencies within existing legal systems, both national and international, and argues the necessity for the establishment of an integrated legal system. In the contemporary world, especially during the digital age, this legal system must be versatile, technologically adept, and capable of balancing competing interests.

JURISDICTIONAL VAGUENESS AND GAP IN GOVERNANCE IN OTT REGULATION

One of the areas that demonstrate the difference between traditional legal principles and contemporary practice is the emergence of OTT platforms. Due to their decentralization and lack of boundaries, OTT systems are hard to govern for organizations responsible for the regulation of broadcast systems that previously operated within geographic boundaries only. One of the main problems faced is the uncertainty regarding jurisdiction because the system may work in several jurisdictions simultaneously.8

Due to the difficulty in determining the jurisdictional limits of each state in deciding, governing and enforcing their laws against individuals/entities conducting business over the internet, the courts have created a new standard to establish jurisdiction, i.e., "purposeful targeting". For a court to gain jurisdiction over an online user, it must be determined that the user is specifically targeting the citizens of that particular jurisdiction and that there is a nexus between the user and forum state/citizens. A court's ruling in Banyan Tree Holding (P) Limited v. A. Murali Krishna Reddy9, concerning whether jurisdiction exists for an internet dispute, established the "purposeful targeting" condition for establishing jurisdiction. Therefore, as was the case in Banyan Tree Holding (P) Limited v. A. Murali Krishna Reddy, the lack of a general standard has resulted in continued inconsistency in the application of these concepts to cases involving internet users committing illegal activities from outside the jurisdiction where the activity occurred.

Due to unclear jurisdictional restrictions, OTT platforms can function with very little accountability because a regulatory vacuum exists. This is also made more challenging because multiple regulatory agencies might claim overlapping authority, leading to the fragmentation of regulatory authority, with the result that users often find themselves confused by how various laws and rules apply10. The Information Technology (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics Code) Rules, 2021, introduced to regulate OTT platforms, attempt to address some of these jurisdictional issues, but they fall short, particularly regarding international jurisdiction11. Also, the issue of regulating content requires a greater emphasis on balancing the power of the state against the rights guaranteed to every citizen under the Constitution, including the right to free speech and expression. The case of Shreya Singhal vs. Union of India be. received judicial recognition for the importance of protecting free speech (within cyber space) from excessive state agency intervention12. Nevertheless, the need to restrict vulgar or dangerous material, often politically sensitive in nature, suggests that some level of oversight by government may be necessary.

Another significant issue with governance in relation to OTT (over-the-top) services is whether they are classified as intermediaries or publishers. Intermediaries are afforded safe harbour protections under Section 79 of the Information Technology Act of 2000, but OTT providers often exercise editorial control over content that they curate, which sets them apart from being merely passive intermediaries. The uncertainty surrounding how OTT services should be classified has led to inconsistent rulings by the courts; one example can be found in Super Cassettes Industries Ltd v. MySpace Inc13 - the court imposed upon intermediaries a set of proactive obligations once the intermediary becomes aware of a copyright infringement. The absence of clarity on how to classify platforms creates uncertainty about how to hold them accountable for violations, as well as giving rise to benefits of arbitrage in regulation, where platforms can take advantage of differences in law in various jurisdictions to minimize their compliance obligations14.

CROSS-BORDER COPYRIGHT CHALLENGES AND ENFORCEMENT CONSTRAINTS

The global reach of OTT services (over-the-top services) severely contrasts with the customary, territorial nature of international copyright law, making for complex legal jurisdictions and issues when they cross borders; for example, copyright enforcement is normally performed and protected only within the confines of a particular jurisdiction according to the Entertainment Network (India) Ltd versus Super Cassette Industries Limited case15. Netflix, among others, contradicts this model by allowing subscribers to immediately access, distribute and thus violate their copyright by using technology (such as VPNs or "Virtual Private Networks") to gain access to content legally bound by a territorial agreement from anywhere in the world; as a result, both the terms and conditions or contracts entered into by the parties creating the artistic work, and the Copyright Owner’s right to receive financial compensation for the work they have created are compromised as well as being financially damaged by the breach of contract and all rights associated with it16.

Another interesting example of regulation in the European Union in the area of cross-border issues is the Directive on Copyright in the Digital Single Market. Through putting pressure on the online content-sharing service providers, this Directive is a progressive measure to modernize copyright regulation in light of digital content distribution. Indeed, the mechanism of liability will be radically modified by Article 17 because it imposes upon the platforms a requirement either to obtain permission from the rights owner or to demonstrate the maximum effort to prevent infringing content17. Thus, there is an additional compliance burden imposed by the Directive, which differs from the safe harbor approach typically adopted when dealing with Internet-based liability questions. Despite concerns regarding potential over-filtering and restrictions of user-generated content, the main purpose of this legislation is to provide better protection of copyright rights holder across borders.

While the European Union takes a proactive framework with platform accountability as its main emphasis, the US takes a reactive one focused on intermediary immunity and innovation. Unlike the European Union's regime, the American Digital Millennium Copyright Act, on the other hand, is platform-friendly in terms of its safe harbour provisions under Section 512. So long as service providers take down infringing content as soon as they get notice from the owner of the copyrights, then they will be granted safe harbour protection from liability. Decisions made in landmark cases like Viacom International Inc. v. YouTube Inc., in which it was reiterated that accountability comes only upon “actual knowledge,” not simply awareness, of the violation, have had a huge impact on the application of this clause18. Although this approach has spurred innovation and has insulated platforms from excessive liability, it is also very taxing on copyright holders who must keep watch for any violations committed.

Another major issue facing the OTT environment is digital piracy. Peer-to-peer networks and unauthorised streaming websites continue to disseminate copyrighted content without permission, hurting reputable platforms. The idea of dynamic injunctions, which was proposed in UTV Software Communication Ltd. v. 1337X. permits the blocking of mirror and rogue websites19, is one example of how courts have tried to solve this problem through creative remedies. Because of jurisdictional limitations and the anonymity of online actors, enforcement is still restricted despite these efforts. Although international treaties offer a framework for copyright protection, the scope and speed of digital infringement frequently make their enforcement methods insufficient.

MOVING TOWARDS AN ALL-INCLUSIVE AND UNIFIED LEGAL SYSTEM

OTT Platform has become a major part of our lives. However, the continued growth of OTT platforms has created a number of issues and concerns for their future and the need to develop a legal framework that provides for good governance and that provides for sufficient regulation in order to regulate OTT platforms both domestically and internationally. State-specific laws concerning OTT platforms do not adequately provide for the international aspect of digital platforms and therefore20, require an international regime of law to provide sufficient regulation. There are currently some international legal instruments in place that would provide at a minimum basis for copyright protection such as The Copyright Treaty of the World Intellectual Property Organization, Trade Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Agreement and The Berne Convention for the Protection of Literary and Artistic Works.

When implementing new laws or regulations, all levels of government should create comprehensive authorities that will oversee regulation, establish consistency in how those laws or regulations will be administered, and clarify what OTT services are and what are the obligations of those OTT services. A co-regulatory approach is an ideal model for the regulation of OTTs in that it will allow for an appropriate level of regulatory flexibility. The experience of UK Communication Authority (Ofcom) and the Australian eSafety Commissioner provide examples of harmonising regulation at the state level with regulatory obligations of OTTs in order to impose compliance. Technology-based solutions such as Artificial Intelligence (AI), digital rights management (DRM), and Geo-blocking can also be used as means of compliance and enforcement. However, care needs to be exercised not to violate user rights and private information.21.

It is necessary to develop jurisdiction-sensitive regulatory frameworks, which address international activities of OTT platforms while remaining true to national sovereignty. This involves establishing clear criteria for determining jurisdiction based on factors such as target audience, economic presence, and the extent of control over content. Additionally, given the increasing need for a shared responsibility regime, we have a need to develop a framework of shared responsibility across platforms, content owners, and users, rather than relying on traditional liability models. A regime of shared responsibility would allow for a higher degree of accountability on the part of active participants than passive intermediaries, and would recognise that OTT platforms play an increasingly active role in the curation and monetisation of content. The development of such a regime would also prevent disproportionate accountability from being placed on any one party, which could impede technological innovation or create overly stringent filters of content.22.

The inclusion of technical governance instruments requires a level of prudence and confidence. Concerns surrounding algorithmic bias and algorithmic blocking as well as transparency issues are all related to artificial intelligence and automated content recognition systems; however, these technologies have the potential to be utilised as enforcement mechanisms through identification of copyright infringement or filtering out illegal content. Over-reliance on technology could represent an undue limitation on free speech; especially in cases where one is producing parodies or exercising criticism or transformative use. To protect against the possibility that technological enforcement undermines fundamental rights, legal frameworks should incorporate procedural safeguards that include: human oversight, standards of transparency, and accessible grievance redressal systems. In proposing digital regulation, the principles of justice, accountability, and proportionality must serve as guiding principles, in addition to efficiency and enforcement objectives.

CONCLUSION

Over-the-top (OTT) platforms have exploded in popularity over the last few years and, in doing so, have exposed doctrinal/structural flaws in existing legal systems, particularly with regards to jurisdictional competence and international enforcement. There are documented gaps in governance, inconsistencies in how content is regulated, and the territorial limitations of copyright laws that illustrate the inability of traditional legal frameworks to adequately manage a borderless digital landscape. These issues are not simply procedural; they are also systemic because of the mismatch between internationally structured digital platforms and territorially based legal concepts.

Although changes to these issues are occurring, judicial solutions remain fragmented and are often reactive in nature. Judges from different jurisdictions have attempted to update traditional definitions of intermediary liability, actual knowledge, and jurisdictional connection to deal with the impact of digital realities; however, the lack of consistency amongst these definitions has created inconsistent enforcement results and created legal uncertainty. Moreover, the lack of standardised regulations makes it difficult for rights holders to effectively protect their intellectual property rights on a worldwide basis while also increasing the difficulty for Ottoman Platforms operating in multiple jurisdictions to comply with such regulations.

To address the complex issues referenced above requires an all-inclusive and forward-thinking regulation strategy that goes beyond the traditional limits of domestic law. There is also an urgent need for more international collaborative efforts to develop uniform standards of jurisdiction, platform liability, and cross-border enforcement in order to ensure uniformity across all platforms23. In addition, domestic legal systems must be reformed in such a manner that the legal status, as well as the obligations, of OTT platforms are clearly defined to create accountability without stifling innovation. Finally, while the use of technology tools for enforcement has great potential, they also must have adequate protections, to prevent overreach and the violation of fundamental rights.

Ultimately, bridging the gap between different jurisdictions is essential to create legitimate platforms and support the sustainability of the digital content industry; closing that gap will not only help with regulatory efficiency but also create an equitable environment in which OTT services can thrive. In order to do accomplish this, a cohesive legislative framework, which will create a stable and equitable OTT marketplace that is ready for the future, must be created that considers different regulatory regimes, future innovation and protection of rights within those regimes. If there is no reform of the jurisdictional fragmentation now present in digital governance, then the benefits tied to creating both legal assurance and having a more global, integrated digital economy will continue to be at risk.

*****

Footnotes

2. JACK L. GOLDSMITH & TIM WU, WHO CONTROLS THE INTERNET? ILLUSIONS OF A BORDERLESS WORLD 3–12 (Oxford Univ. Press 2006).

3. Dan Jerker B. Svantesson, Jurisdictional Issues in Cyberspace, 19 Computer L. & Sec. Rev. 169, 170–73 (2003).

4. Mihály Ficsor, The WIPO “Internet Treaties”: Interpretation, Implementation and Impact, 37 Colum. J.L. & Arts 3, 5–9 (2013);

5. Anupam Chander, How Law Made Silicon Valley, 63 Emory L.J. 639, 657–60 (2014).

6. Jane C. Ginsburg, Extraterritoriality of Copyright Law in the Digital Information Age, 37 Vand. J. Transnat’l L. 1, 5–8 (2004).

7. Information Technology (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics Code) Rules, 2021, Gazette of India.

8. Dan Jerker B. Svantesson, Jurisdictional Issues in Cyberspace, 19 Computer L. & Sec. Rev. 169, 170–73 (2003).

9. Banyan Tree Holding (P) Ltd. v. A. Murali Krishna Reddy, 2010 SCC OnLine Del 378.

10. Jack L. Goldsmith & Tim Wu, Who Controls the Internet? Illusions of a Borderless World 42–48 (Oxford Univ. Press 2006).

11. Information Technology (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics Code) Rules, 2021, Gazette of India.

12. Shreya Singhal v. Union of India, (2015) 5 SCC 1.

13. Super Cassettes Indus. Ltd. v. MySpace Inc., 2016 SCC OnLine Del 6382.

14. Anupam Chander, How Law Made Silicon Valley, 63 Emory L.J. 639, 657–60 (2014).

15. Entm’t Network (India) Ltd. v. Super Cassette Indus. Ltd., (2008) 13 SCC 30.

16. Jane C. Ginsburg, Extraterritoriality of Copyright Law in the Digital Information Age, 37 Vand. J. Transnat’l L. 1, 5–8 (2004).

17. Directive (EU) 2019/790 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 17 Apr. 2019 on Copyright in the Digital Single Market, 2019 O.J. (L 130) 92.

18. Viacom Int’l, Inc. v. YouTube, Inc., 676 F.3d 19 (2d Cir. 2012); Digital Millennium Copyright Act, 17 U.S.C. § 512 (2012).

19. UTV Software Commc’n Ltd. v. 1337X.to, 2019 SCC OnLine Del 8002

20. Mihály Ficsor, The WIPO “Internet Treaties”: Interpretation, Implementation and Impact, 37 Colum. J.L. & Arts 3, 8–12 (2013) Berne Convention for the Protection of Literary and Artistic Works, Sept. 9, 1886, as revised July 24, 1971, 828 U.N.T.S. 221; Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights, Apr. 15, 1994, 1869 U.N.T.S. 299 WIPO Copyright Treaty, Dec. 20, 1996, S. Treaty Doc. No. 105-17

21. Martin Senftleben et al., The Recommendation on Measures to Safeguard Fundamental Rights in the Framework of the EU Copyright Reform, 40 Eur. Intell. Prop. Rev. 149, 150–52 (2018).

22. Anupam Chander, How Law Made Silicon Valley, 63 Emory L.J. 639, 657–60 (2014).

23. Graeme B. Dinwoodie, A New Copyright Order: Why National Courts Should Create Global Norms, 149 U. Pa. L. Rev. 469, 480–85 (2000).

How to cite

Sakshi Devendra Raut, The Jurisdictional Gap for OTT Platforms: Governance Gaps, Cross-Border Copyright Challenges, and the Need for a Comprehensive Legal Framework, 9 Int'l J.L. Mgmt. & Human. 2762 (2026).

Cite this article

Sakshi Devendra Raut, The Jurisdictional Gap for OTT Platforms: Governance Gaps, Cross-Border Copyright Challenges, and the Need for a Comprehensive Legal Framework, 9 Int'l J.L. Mgmt. & Human. 2762 (2026).
Chat with us