INTRODUCTION
India’s socio-cultural environment is significantly shaped by religious beliefs, rituals, and long-standing traditional practices. While many of these traditions constitute the fabric of community identity and cultural heritage, certain belief-driven practices have led to the emergence of harmful forms of superstition, such as witch-hunting, ritualistic violence, and black magic-related exploitation. Such practices, on the whole, tend to target vulnerable groups, particularly women, children, and tribal communities, thereby seriously violating fundamental human rights, including the rights to dignity, equality, and personal liberty.
The Indian Constitution, through Articles 25 to 28, guarantees freedom of conscience and the right to freely profess, practice, and propagate religion. However, this freedom is not absolute; it is subject to reasonable restrictions in the interests of public order, health, morality, and the protection of other constitutional rights.
The need to balance respect for customary religious beliefs with the prevention of superstition-driven violence gives rise to complex legal and ethical issues. Courts are often required to determine which religious practices are essential and therefore warrant protection, and which are harmful and must be curtailed. This challenge is further intensified in regions where local customs and community norms exert greater influence than formal legal systems.
With increased judicial scrutiny and the enactment of state-level anti-superstition laws, the debate surrounding the permissible limits of religious freedom has gained renewed significance. This article examines the relationship between customary beliefs and constitutional liberties in India and further explores how the legal system can balance cultural autonomy with the State’s obligation to protect individuals from superstition-driven violence.
CONSTITUTIONAL PROTECTION OF RELIGIOUS FREEDOM AND ITS LIMITS
The Constitution of India is a comprehensive and intricate framework that guarantees freedom of religion in alignment with its core principles of secularism, pluralism, and individual liberty. The framers of the Constitution, recognising India’s diverse cultural and religious heritage, sought to safeguard freedom of conscience as well as the right to practice and profess one’s faith. At the same time, the Constitution empowers the State to regulate or restrict religious practices that are contrary to public welfare, infringe upon the rights of others, or threaten social harmony. India’s constitutional jurisprudence on religion is fundamentally shaped by this delicate balance between individual freedom and lawful limitations.
Individual religious freedom is primarily guaranteed under Article 25. It ensures freedom of conscience and the right to profess, practice, and propagate religion. This provision reflects India’s distinctive model of secularism; rather than establishing a rigid separation between the State and religion, it promotes equal respect for all religions (sarva dharma sambhava). This guarantee extends to both citizens and non-citizens, thereby underscoring the universal character of religious freedom.
Nevertheless, Article 25 is subject to certain limitations. It is expressly subordinate to considerations of public order, morality, and health, as well as to other fundamental rights. Consequently, religious practices cannot contravene constitutional values such as equality under Article 14, non-discrimination under Article 15, and dignity and personal liberty under Article 21. Courts have frequently relied on these grounds to balance religious freedom against potential harm and discrimination arising from such practices. For instance, in Bijoe Emmanuel v. State of Kerala, the Supreme Court upheld the right of Jehovah’s Witness students to refrain from singing the national anthem, holding that their conscientious objection did not disturb public order. This judgment illustrates that restrictions on religious freedom cannot be imposed merely due to majority disapproval but must be justified on clear constitutional grounds.
A significant doctrinal element in the interpretation of Article 25 is the Essential Religious Practices (ERP) test. This doctrine limits constitutional protection to practices that are fundamental to a religion, allowing the State to regulate non-essential or secular activities. Originating in The Commissioner, Hindu Religious Endowments v. Sri Lakshmindra Thirtha Swamiar (the Shirur Mutt case), the test has been widely applied to assess the constitutional validity of religious customs and practices. For example, in the Indian Young Lawyers Association v. State of Kerala (Sabarimala case), the Supreme Court held that the exclusion of women from the Ayyappa temple was not an essential practice and violated principles of equality and dignity. Similarly, in Shayara Bano v. Union of India (Triple Talaq case), instant talaq was declared unconstitutional on the grounds of arbitrariness and lack of protection under Article 25.
Furthermore, Article 25(2) empowers the State to regulate or restrict secular activities associated with religious practice. For instance, the State may administer temple management, levy taxes on religious institutions, or regulate the use of public spaces for religious purposes. It also authorises the enactment of laws aimed at social welfare and reform, even where such laws incidentally affect religious practices. Prominent examples include the abolition of untouchability, the prohibition of the Devadasi system, and legislative measures penalising harmful customary practices under anti-superstition laws. These measures demonstrate that freedom of religion cannot serve as a shield for practices that undermine human dignity or perpetuate structural inequalities.
Articles 26, 27, and 28 complement Article 25 by conferring rights upon religious denominations and reinforcing the secular character of the State. Article 26 grants religious groups autonomy in matters of religion, including the establishment and management of religious institutions, subject to public order, morality, and health. Article 27 prohibits the compulsion of any person to pay taxes for the promotion of a particular religion, thereby ensuring State neutrality. Finally, Article 28 guarantees freedom from religious instruction in State-funded educational institutions, thereby safeguarding individual freedom of belief.
The limitations on religious freedom become particularly significant when customary practices result in harm, discrimination, or violence. In cases such as witch-hunting, black magic rituals, and superstition-driven assaults, perpetrators often claim adherence to tradition or local belief systems as a defence. However, such practices violate fundamental rights, particularly Article 21, and therefore cannot be protected under the Constitution. Courts have consistently held that religious freedom does not extend to conduct that endangers life and human dignity. Accordingly, the State is obligated to intervene, under its police powers and Article 25(2), to prevent exploitation and violence, even where such acts are justified in the name of religion.
In conclusion, the Indian constitutional framework on religious freedom reflects a careful balance: it protects individual religious belief and practice while empowering the State to restrict practices that contravene public order, morality, health, or other fundamental rights. This balance is further reinforced by the principle that constitutional morality must prevail over social or traditional morality, thereby ensuring that individual dignity remains paramount. Such an approach enables India to uphold its rich religious diversity while simultaneously fulfilling its commitment to justice, equality, and the protection of human rights.
CUSTOMARY BELIEFS AND SOCIAL PRACTICES LEADING TO SUPERSTITIOUS VIOLENCE
For the most part, indigenous beliefs and social customs have significantly shaped community identity, cultural cohesion, and traditional knowledge systems in India. However, certain traditions, when rooted in fear, ignorance, or patriarchal dominance, manifest as harmful practices that violate fundamental rights and expose vulnerable groups to serious risks. Among such forms of superstition-driven violence, witch-hunting, accusations of black magic, ritualistic violence, and the persecution of individuals believed to possess supernatural powers represent some of the most severe consequences of the intersection between tradition and social anxiety. Understanding the point at which customary beliefs transform into violence is essential for assessing their legal implications and for developing effective constitutional and legislative safeguards.
Superstitions remain deeply embedded in the social fabric of many rural and tribal communities in India. Practices such as spirit worship, witchcraft, curses, and beliefs in divine punishment are often regarded not merely as religious expressions but as inherited customs preserved across generations. The concept of the daain (witch), for instance, is deeply entrenched in the folklore of regions such as Jharkhand, Assam, Odisha, and Chhattisgarh. These beliefs are frequently invoked to explain misfortunes such as illness, crop failure, family disputes, or unexplained deaths, attributing them to supernatural causes. In the absence of adequate access to education, healthcare, and scientific awareness, superstition may become normalized, thereby enabling the targeting and persecution of individuals labelled as sources of misfortune.
Gender plays a significant role in shaping the dynamics of superstition-driven violence. Most victims of practices such as witch-hunting are women, particularly widows, elderly women, or those who do not conform to patriarchal norms. Women who are strong-willed, economically independent, or possess property are often targeted, as such characteristics may be perceived as threatening within traditional power structures. Accusations of witchcraft frequently serve as a pretext for underlying socio-economic motives, including disputes over land, property, personal rivalries, and community tensions. In such cases, superstition operates as a convenient justification, masking the real causes of persecution.
Another crucial aspect of superstition-driven violence is the role of traditional healers, such as ojhas, tantriks, and other faith practitioners. These individuals often wield significant influence within rural and tribal communities and are regarded as intermediaries between the supernatural and the human world. In situations involving unexplained illness, misfortune, or death, community members frequently turn to them for guidance. However, such practitioners may, at times, identify vulnerable individuals as the source of misfortune, thereby instigating suspicion and hostility. Their pronouncements, often treated as authoritative, can mobilize entire communities and lead to acts of collective violence. In such contexts, the support or acquiescence of local authority figures, combined with entrenched beliefs, can further escalate these incidents into serious violations of human rights.
Group psychology and social cohesion also play a significant role in perpetuating superstition-driven violence. Many community practices are collective in nature, where individuals participate not solely out of personal belief but due to social pressure and the need for conformity. The fear of social exclusion, stigma, or even retaliation discourages individuals from opposing such practices. Consequently, victims accused of witchcraft are often subjected to ritual humiliation, social ostracism, forced confessions, physical assaults, and, in extreme cases, death. These acts are frequently legitimised by the community as necessary measures to restore social balance, eliminate perceived evil, or appease supernatural forces. In this manner, customary beliefs provide moral justification for acts that are both illegal and unconstitutional.
Additionally, factors such as poverty, lack of formal education, weak law enforcement, and limited State presence significantly contribute to the persistence of superstition-driven violence. Such practices are more prevalent in regions where State institutions are ineffective or absent, allowing local customs and belief systems to override formal legal frameworks. In many tribal areas, informal mechanisms of dispute resolution prioritise community harmony over individual rights, thereby limiting access to justice for victims. Women who are branded as witches often face lifelong stigma, dispossession of property, forced displacement, and, in some cases, sexual exploitation. Their experiences frequently remain unaddressed within both customary and formal legal systems.
The intersection of superstition and medical beliefs often creates a cycle that perpetuates violence. This is particularly evident where traditional healing practices and spiritual diagnoses become intertwined, leading individuals to attribute illnesses to supernatural forces rather than medical causes. During outbreaks of disease or public health crises, such beliefs tend to intensify, resulting in increased suspicion and violence against individuals accused of causing the illness. These patterns underscore the urgent need for greater scientific awareness and improved access to healthcare services.
In essence, customary beliefs contribute to superstition-driven violence when they operate without accountability, transparency, or openness to scientific scrutiny. Although cultural practices are protected under the Constitution, they cannot override fundamental rights such as the rights to life, dignity, equality, and personal liberty. The persistence of such practices reflects deeper structural issues, including gender inequality, lack of education, weak governance, and economic marginalisation. Addressing superstition-driven violence therefore requires a holistic approach that not only preserves cultural identity but also eliminates practices that violate human rights.
CONFLICT BETWEEN CUSTOMARY PRACTICES AND CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS OF VULNERABLE GROUPS
Traditional customs rooted in heritage, folklore, and communal belief systems continue to exert significant influence on individual behaviour across various regions of India. While such customs constitute an important source of law and cultural identity, their interaction with the Constitution becomes problematic when they result in discrimination, violence, or the exclusion of vulnerable groups. In the context of superstition-driven violence—such as witch-hunting, accusations of black magic, and ritualistic harm—the tension between customary practices and constitutional rights becomes particularly evident. This conflict highlights deeper structural issues, including gender inequality, caste hierarchies, tribal marginalisation, and unequal power relations, all of which stand in direct contradiction to the fundamental rights guaranteed under Articles 14, 15, 19, and 21 of the Constitution of India.
In many tribal and rural communities, customary practices have led to the labelling of individuals—particularly women, widows, and socially marginalised persons—as “witches” (daain, tonahi, ojha), often in response to misfortunes such as illness, crop failure, natural disasters, or personal disputes. Although these practices are sometimes justified as part of local traditions, they frequently result in serious human rights violations, including physical assault, social ostracism, dispossession of property, forced displacement, and even lynching. Such actions, rooted in fear and superstition, stand in stark contrast to the constitutional guarantee of dignity, equality, and personal liberty. The right to life under Article 21 encompasses the right to live with dignity and free from violence; therefore, any custom that causes or legitimises harm to the human body constitutes a violation of this fundamental and non-derogable right.
Gender lies at the core of superstition-driven violence. The practice of witch-hunting overwhelmingly targets women, particularly widows, elderly women, girls without familial protection, and those lacking male support. In many communities, customary beliefs are manipulated to resolve property disputes, remove unwanted household members, or reinforce patriarchal control. Such practices violate Article 14, which guarantees equality before the law, and Article 15, which prohibits discrimination on the basis of sex. Courts have consistently held that customs which demean women cannot be granted constitutional protection, even if they are deeply rooted in tradition. The Supreme Court’s jurisprudence in cases such as Joseph Shine v. Union of India and Shayara Bano v. Union of India affirms that personal laws or customs that discriminate against women lack constitutional validity. The same reasoning applies to superstition-driven violence: no tradition can justify discrimination under the guise of cultural practice.
From another perspective, the caste and tribal background of victims is equally significant. A large number of witch-hunting cases occur in tribal-dominated regions, where customary dispute resolution mechanisms, often administered by village councils, either sanction or tacitly permit acts of violence in the name of community welfare. Individuals from marginalised castes or remote tribal groups, when accused of witchcraft, are frequently subjected to forced eviction, social exclusion, and restrictions on their freedom of movement and expression, thereby infringing Article 19 rights. While the Constitution recognises and protects tribal autonomy and cultural rights, such protection is not absolute. Customs that violate fundamental human rights cannot claim legal legitimacy. As observed in State of Bombay v. Narasu Appa Mali, practices contrary to constitutional morality must yield to fundamental rights. This principle forms a critical foundation for challenging superstition-based violence.
Another dimension of the issue lies in the misuse of social morality to suppress constitutional morality. Harmful customs are often defended by communities on grounds of tradition, collective belief, or perceived social order. However, the Supreme Court in Navtej Singh Johar v. Union of India and Indian Young Lawyers Association v. State of Kerala (Sabarimala) has affirmed that constitutional morality prevails over social morality. Under this doctrine, the State is obligated to intervene where customary practices infringe upon individual autonomy, liberty, and dignity. Accordingly, even if practices such as witch-branding or accusations of black magic are socially accepted, they cannot override the fundamental rights to equality, liberty, and dignity.
However, judicial intervention remains inadequate due to challenges such as difficulties in evidence collection, community silence, and fear of retaliation. Many victims are unable to access judicial remedies owing to illiteracy, patriarchal control, economic dependence, and geographical remoteness. At times, police and administrative authorities treat such violence as “community matters,” thereby contributing to the persistence of these violations of constitutional rights. This weak institutional response highlights the gap between the guarantees enshrined in the Constitution and the lived realities of vulnerable groups.
Ultimately, the conflict between customary practices and constitutional rights reflects a broader tension between tradition and modern constitutionalism. While the Constitution protects cultural identity and religious freedom, it simultaneously imposes a duty upon the State to prevent practices that undermine dignity, equality, and liberty. Superstition-related violence, particularly witch-hunting, cannot seek refuge behind the façade of custom; it constitutes a direct assault on the foundational values of the Constitution.
A rights-based approach grounded in constitutional morality is therefore essential to address this conflict. The legitimacy of customary practices must be assessed not by their antiquity but by their conformity with fundamental rights. Legal reforms, victim rehabilitation, community awareness, and strict enforcement of laws are indispensable to ensure that vulnerable groups are protected not only in law but also in practice. The constitutional vision ultimately envisages a society in which dignity is non-negotiable, and no custom or belief—however deeply rooted—can justify its violation.
LEGISLATIVE AND JUDICIAL RESPONSES TO REGULATE HARMFUL CUSTOMS
Superstitious practices, witch-hunting, black magic rituals, and harmful customary beliefs continue to result in significant violence and systemic discrimination in India. While faith and tradition are protected under Article 25 of the Constitution, this freedom is not absolute; it is subject to limitations based on public order, health, morality, and the fundamental rights of others. Both the legislature and the judiciary have, over time, sought to regulate such harmful practices by drawing a clear legal distinction between protected religious freedom and criminal acts disguised as tradition. These legislative and judicial responses reflect a gradual shift from the acceptance of customary practices to a rights-based approach grounded in constitutional morality.
A. State Level Legislative Responses
At present, India lacks a comprehensive national law addressing violence arising from superstitions. Consequently, various states have enacted legislation targeting different aspects of the problem. The Maharashtra Prevention and Eradication of Human Sacrifice and Other Inhuman, Evil and Aghori Practices and Black Magic Act, 2013 is among the most comprehensive, criminalising a wide range of inhuman ritual practices, including human sacrifice, occult exploitation, and fraudulent claims of supernatural healing. The Act recognises that such practices are not matters of faith but forms of social exploitation.
Similarly, the Karnataka Prevention and Eradication of Inhuman Evil Practices and Black Magic Act, 2017 prohibits practices such as black magic, witchcraft, forcing individuals to perform dangerous acts, and public humiliation, including parading individuals naked. The legislation adopts a rights-based approach, emphasising human dignity and bodily autonomy. States such as Jharkhand, Assam, Bihar, and Odisha have also enacted laws prohibiting witch-hunting, criminalising accusations of witchcraft, instigation of violence, and social ostracism. These laws were introduced in response to recurring incidents of murder, sexual violence, and social exclusion linked to such accusations.
However, the effectiveness of these state laws varies significantly. Many of these statutes lack adequate provisions for enforcement, victim compensation, witness protection, and proper investigation. Police authorities often dismiss witch-hunting as a “local custom,” leading to underreporting and inadequate investigation of such crimes. Furthermore, the absence of a uniform central law results in inconsistencies across states, leaving victims in regions without specific legislation to rely primarily on general criminal law, such as the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), for legal recourse.
B. Use of BNS and BNSS in the Absence of Special Laws
In regions where specific laws addressing superstition or witch-hunting are absent, authorities rely on general criminal law provisions. These include offences such as Section 101 (murder), Section 109 (attempt to murder), Section 74 (outraging modesty), Section 117(2), Section 125 (causing hurt), Section 351 (criminal intimidation), as well as provisions relating to unlawful assembly. While these laws are capable of penalising acts of violence, they remain largely silent on the socio-cultural dimensions of superstition-based crimes. They also fail to adequately address specific forms of coercion, including social boycott, public humiliation, forced parading, and branding associated with such practices. As a result, many perpetrators escape with lesser charges or receive comparatively lenient sentences. Furthermore, the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS) lacks specialised mechanisms to address challenges such as collective hysteria leading to violence, witness intimidation, and the need for long-term rehabilitation of victims.
C. Judicial Responses: Striking Down Harmful Customs
The judiciary has played a significant role in shaping the regulation of harmful customary practices. Although courts have rarely addressed witch-hunting directly, they have, through several landmark constitutional decisions, laid down principles that restrict practices infringing fundamental rights.
In Indian Young Lawyers Association v. State of Kerala (2018) (Sabarimala case), the Supreme Court affirmed that customs cannot override constitutional guarantees of equality, dignity, and non-discrimination. The Court held that exclusionary religious practices must be tested against constitutional principles, particularly where they discriminate against women. This reasoning is equally applicable to witch-hunting, where women—especially from marginalised communities—constitute the primary victims.
In Shafin Jahan v. Asokan K.M. (2018) (Hadiya case), the Supreme Court emphasised the centrality of personal autonomy and rejected societal control exercised under the guise of paternalism or custom. Similarly, in Shayara Bano v. Union of India (2017) (Triple Talaq case), the Court invalidated a long-standing religious practice on the ground that it was inconsistent with constitutional morality. These decisions reflect an emerging judicial trend: practices that result in discrimination or violence cannot claim protection under Article 25.
In cases specifically concerning witch-hunting, courts have condemned the practice and directed State authorities to ensure stricter enforcement of the law. The Gauhati High Court and the Jharkhand High Court have, on multiple occasions, emphasised the need for sensitised police personnel, prompt registration of First Information Reports (FIRs), and effective protection of victims who continue to face threats from their communities.
D. Uniform Central Law is Necessary
Although significant legislative and judicial interventions have been made, the fragmented legal landscape remains insufficient. A comprehensive central law addressing superstition and witch-hunting is necessary to ensure uniformity, facilitate the establishment of specialised courts, set consistent standards for investigation, and provide comprehensive protection and rehabilitation for victims. Such a law must be aligned with the principles of constitutional jurisprudence to ensure that cultural autonomy does not become a cover for violence.
TOWARDS A BALANCED REGULATORY FRAMEWORK: RECONCILING BELIEF WITH PROTECTION
Balancing India’s diverse cultural and religious heritage with the constitutional obligation to prevent superstition-inspired violence presents a complex challenge for the State. Article 25 guarantees freedom of conscience and the right to profess, practice, and propagate religion. However, this freedom is expressly subject to limitations based on public order, morality, health, and other fundamental rights. The objective is not to curtail religious or customary practices, but to ensure that such beliefs do not become instruments of discrimination, exploitation, or violence against vulnerable groups, including women, children, and members of Scheduled Tribes. A balanced legal framework therefore requires a nuanced understanding of faith, alongside a firm commitment to addressing its harmful manifestations.
A central task of such a framework is to establish clear legal standards distinguishing protected religious practices from harmful superstition-based activities. Courts have historically relied on the Essential Religious Practices (ERP) doctrine to identify core elements of religion. However, its application has been inconsistent and often inadequate in addressing practices rooted in local customs rather than formal religious doctrine, such as witch-branding or ritualistic exorcisms. Consequently, a statutory definition of “harmful superstition” is essential. Such a definition should be broad enough to encompass acts involving physical violence, coercion, public humiliation, and property dispossession, while remaining sufficiently precise to avoid undue interference with legitimate cultural and spiritual practices. This balance would both safeguard cultural autonomy and empower authorities to intervene effectively in cases involving violence or coercion.
Secondly, India requires a well-crafted national law to effectively address superstition-related violence. At present, only a few states—namely Maharashtra, Karnataka, Assam, Jharkhand, and Bihar—have enacted specific anti-superstition or anti-witch-hunting legislation. This fragmented approach has resulted in significant gaps, with several regions lacking adequate legal mechanisms to address deeply entrenched harmful practices. A comprehensive central law, or at least a model law adopted uniformly by the states, would ensure consistency in definitions, penalties, preventive measures, and standards for victim protection. Such legislation should explicitly prohibit practices such as witch-branding, fraudulent black magic claims, ritualistic exploitation, and violence arising from supernatural accusations. At the same time, it should recognise the psychological, social, and economic dimensions of harm suffered by victims. Penalties must be sufficiently stringent to deter community participation and disrupt cycles of collective persecution.
Thirdly, the regulatory framework must strengthen institutional mechanisms for prevention and early intervention. Cases of witch-hunting and superstition-driven violence often escalate due to weak policing, lack of community trust, and fear of social retaliation. The law should mandate the establishment of district-level vigilance committees in vulnerable areas, comprising police officials, social workers, tribal leaders, and medical professionals. These bodies should be tasked with monitoring at-risk communities, conducting awareness and outreach programmes, and intervening at early stages of emerging tensions. Additionally, police personnel and prosecutors must be provided with specialised training, as the prosecution of such offences frequently fails due to inadequate evidence collection, witness intimidation, and a limited understanding of underlying socio-cultural dynamics.
Fourthly, at the core of any balanced regulatory framework lies a victim-centric approach. Individuals who have survived witch-hunting or superstition-related violence often suffer severe trauma, loss of livelihood, social exclusion, and, in some cases, forced displacement. Consequently, the law must provide for comprehensive rehabilitation measures, including temporary shelter, psychological counselling, relocation assistance, medical care, and the restoration of property rights. It is equally essential to establish robust compensation mechanisms with clear accountability, ensuring that victims are not burdened with complex bureaucratic procedures. Furthermore, effective witness protection measures must be implemented to safeguard victims and witnesses from intimidation by perpetrators or community members.
Fifthly, any reform strategy must prioritise education, awareness, and community participation as long-term solutions. Legal measures alone are insufficient to eradicate deeply entrenched superstitious beliefs. Promoting scientific temper, raising awareness about the harmful consequences of such practices, and empowering vulnerable groups are critical, particularly in rural and tribal areas. Educational institutions, panchayats, local NGOs, and healthcare workers should play an active role in fostering awareness, distinguishing harmless traditions from harmful superstitions, and providing community support. These initiatives must also address underlying structural issues such as gender inequality, property disputes, and social marginalisation, which often contribute to accusations of witchcraft.
Ultimately, the guiding principle of this framework must be constitutional morality, which requires both the State and society to uphold values of equality, dignity, and individual liberty over harmful social or religious norms. While recognising cultural diversity, the Constitution mandates State intervention where customs result in discrimination or violence. A balanced regulatory framework must therefore reconcile respect for belief systems with the imperative of protecting fundamental rights, ensuring that individual dignity is never compromised.
In conclusion, India must adopt a layered, rights-based regulatory model that balances religious freedom with the constitutional obligation to protect individuals from superstition-driven violence. Only through precise legislation, effective enforcement, community engagement, and a victim-centred approach can belief systems be aligned with the fundamental rights and protections guaranteed under the Constitution.
CONCLUSION
The tension between traditional cultural norms and constitutional rights in India reflects a broader conflict between the preservation of cultural identity and the protection of fundamental human rights. Article 25 guarantees the freedom to profess, practice, and propagate religion; however, this right is not absolute and is subject to limitations based on public order, health, morality, and the rights of others. Superstition-driven practices—particularly those associated with witch-hunting, such as accusations of black magic, ritualistic violence, and related assaults—demonstrate how customs can be misused to oppress vulnerable groups, especially women, children, and members of tribal communities in remote areas.
The judiciary has consistently emphasised that constitutional morality must prevail over social morality, affirming that no custom or belief can justify violence or discrimination that undermines human dignity and safety. While state-level legislation represents an important step, enforcement remains weak due to factors such as social acceptance of harmful practices, reluctance on the part of law enforcement authorities, evidentiary challenges, and the absence of robust victim protection mechanisms. There is therefore a pressing need for a comprehensive national law to harmonise existing frameworks and establish uniform standards for the identification, prevention, and punishment of superstition-related violence.
In addition to legal reform, public awareness, education, and community participation are essential to dismantle deeply entrenched beliefs that sustain such practices. The Indian Constitution ultimately embodies a commitment to dignity, equality, and individual liberty. It is therefore imperative to reaffirm that religious freedom cannot extend to practices that violate the fundamental rights to life and equality. The way forward lies in strengthening legal protections, enhancing accountability, and promoting constitutional values to ensure that cultural identity does not become a vehicle for perpetuating violence or discrimination.
