Introduction
The SARFAESI Act was passed in 2002, to rescue the country from an ongoing crisis of stressed assets and Non-Performing Assets. It provided a speedy and efficient mechanism for the recovery of defaulted loans by providing greater autonomy in the hands of financial creditors to surpass the traditional judicial proceedings of recovery suits and take suitable actions through possession of the secured collateral by banks and financial institutions in cases where borrowers pledge valuable assets, without any intervention of courts. However, this dealing is only suitable in cases involving individual creditors and, seemed incapable of managing an extremely complex corporate insolvency situation where multiple creditors make conflicting claims on the assets of the corporate debtor.
On the other hand, the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (hereinafter referred to as the Code), which came into effect in the year 2016, is definitely a more inclusive, more holistic framework for resolution of a complex corporate insolvency. The Code allows for a debtor-centric approach whereby the debtor's management still continues to manage the company under the supervision of a resolution professional except in cases when the resolution process is leading to the debtor's liquidation. One of the salient features of the Code is the moratorium period under Section 14, when all proceedings pending in the law courts, including actions for the enforcement of security interests under SARFAESI, come to a halt. This moratorium provides an opportunity to the debtor to either restructure or rehabilitate himself, but it does place the secured creditors in an unenviable position where they cannot enforce their rights over the assets of the debtor during the period.
Evolution of Debt Recovery Laws
The problem of increasing Non-Performing Assets in the Indian financial markets was long felt and urged the government to take steps in areas of consolidated stability leading to an increase in healthy enterprises and stable economy. The country has moved itself from a quite rudimentary framework of insolvency years back to what is seen today as a more organized and comprehensive system. Some major milestones in this evolutionary journey are the Presidency Town Insolvency Act, 1909, the Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, 1985, the Recovery of Debts Due to Banks and Financial Institutions (RDBDFI) Act, 1993, the Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act (SARFAESI), 2002, and the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC), 2016. Each of these laws have proved to be rather an attempt at solution for meeting the challenges out of recovery of debts with a growing economy.
Presidency Town Insolvency Act, 19092
The Presidency Town Insolvency Act, 1909 was one of the earliest attempts to deal with insolvency and bankruptcy in India. It was enforced to deal with individual insolvency in the major towns of India, namely Calcutta, Bombay, and Madras. The Act enabled creditors to file law suits for recovery of debts due from individuals under a well-established scheme for the liquidation of assets. However, it applied only to individuals and kept the corporate bodies and other sophisticated financial mechanisms out of its spectrum. Some of the drawbacks of this Act included the judicial processes that took enormous amount of time to implement and insufficient measures taken towards corporate default.
Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act (SICA), 19853
During the 1980s, growing anxieties regarding the health of industrial enterprises in India, more particularly PSUs, resulted in the introduction and implementation of the Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act in 1985, which has come to be popularly known as SICA. It attempted to find a remedy for industrial sickness through provisions of rehabilitation of such enterprises. The Act established the Board for Industrial and Financial Reconstruction (BIFR), that could decide whether a sick company was to be rehabilitated or wound up. Although this law provided a platform for the resolution of corporate debt issues, it was largely criticized as being slow and ineffective. The long-drawn decision-making process of the Board for Industrial and Financial Reconstruction led to delay in recovery, and many companies remained in a state of financial stress without a timely resolution. This led to the eventual repeal and replacement of SICA in 2002 with SARFAESI Act, for a more dynamic and time-bound measures for corporate debt recovery.
Recovery of Debts Due to Banks and Financial Institutions (RDBDFI) Act, 19934
Another important milestone was the introduction of the Recovery of Debts Due to Banks and Financial Institutions (RDBDFI) Act in 1993. This Act established the Debts Recovery Tribunals (DRTs), which would settle debt recovery disputes in a quicker and more specialized manner. The RDBDFI Act enabled financial institutions to seek redressal from the DRTs on recovery of dues from defaulting borrowers while bypassing the slower process of traditional judicial procedure. This, however, gave a better concentration in debt recovery by DRTs, that is, for the amount owed by a person or a company to the banks. Yet, it had not overcome the deficiencies like backlogs, delayed judgments, and lack of efficiency in its enforcing capabilities that crippled the effectiveness of the Act.
Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 20025
The SARFAESI Act was enacted with the objective of increasing the banks' and other financial institutions' ability to recover debt in 2002. SARFAESI transformed the entire mechanism used by creditors for recovery through the seizure and sale of property pledged as collateral, thereby giving them the freedom from drawn-out court procedures. Under SARFAESI, banks and financial institutions could take possession of a borrower's property, either to sell it or to restructure the loan, if the borrower defaulted. This act marked a significant departure from earlier frameworks by providing the financial creditors with direct powers to enforce their rights. While the SARFAESI Act hastened the process of recovery, it mostly addressed secured creditors and, thereby, did not give appropriate consideration to the complexities relating to corporate insolvency whereby more than one creditor may have various kinds of interests.
Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 20166
It was realized that the existing laws were not capable of handling the complexities of corporate insolvency. Therefore, the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, IBC, was introduced in 2016. IBC is a broad framework governing insolvency and bankruptcy in India. The debtor-in-possession approach allows the debtor to run its business during the moratorium period at the start of insolvency resolution process. However, the creditors through the Committee of Creditors can take the proceedings further if there is a need to do so. The crucial feature of the IBC is the moratorium period provided under Section 14, which puts a cessation to all creditor actions, including SARFAESI proceedings, during the ongoing resolution processes. The intent of the IBC is to lock time confined to the resolution of insolvency either towards the revival of a debtor or an orderly liquidation of the debtor's business. The time period has decreased dramatically and it has provided a single-window legal system for creditors to recover dues.
Over time, the debt recovery laws of India have moved from a mere individual insolvency debt recovery laws to a quite sophisticated and complete one dealing with both individual and corporate defaults. Each footstep taken over the years, from Presidency Town Insolvency Act till the Insolvency Code has led to a positive outlook towards increasingly complex insolvency issues in a rapidly progressing economy. A shift in the way of dealing with financial distress in India has been caused by timely processing, efficiency, and the balance between debtor protection and creditor rights, moving from a court-driven framework to more creditor-centric frameworks, like SARFAESI and the Insolvency Code.
SARFAESI v. IBC: A Comparative Analysis
The legal framework for Insolvency and Bankruptcy in India has significantly evolved in recent decades in its approach to insolvency and debt recovery. Two emerging and major legislative instruments among those are the Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act 2002 and the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code 2016. These legislative frameworks are intended for the addressing of issues concerning Non-Performing Assets and corporate defaults, but they operate on different principles and thus offer different methodologies for resolution. The SARFAESI Act is basically a creditor-driven mechanism that focuses on the recovery of loans by enforcing the security interests, whereas the Insolvency Code provides for a broad insolvency resolution process based on the rehabilitation of the business and giving a time-bound resolution of insolvency.
(A) SARFAESI Framework
It has the SARFAESI Act to specifically enable the recovery of their loans by the secured creditors directly without resorting to court or litigation proceedings in most of the instances, except when it's under any specific limitation or restriction, mainly being utilized by the banks and financial institutions as an efficient mechanism for recovery of assets in cases relating to individual borrowers or smaller corporate borrowers. Under SARFAESI, the debtor's assets, secured with the bank as collateral, can be seized and sold, with the proceeds being used to recover the dues.
SARFAESI is highly advantageous to the secured creditors because it gives them a quicker route outside the traditional judicial process. Rather than repeated knocking at doors of the judiciary, and waiting for the court orders, the creditors can take immediate possession of the secured assets of the borrower after serving a notice under the provisions of the Act. The Act enables the financial institutions to sell the collateral in case the borrower fails to repay the loan, and the amount retrieved from the sale of the collateral can be used to recover the dues.
a. Key Benefits of SARFAESI:
• Speed and Efficiency: SARFAESI is faster than the traditional court-based method, and it is highly beneficial when creditors need to recover loans quickly, thus maintaining the market value of the secured assets without much losses.
• Direct Control by Creditors: Creditors are in control of the recovery process and can act directly without requiring court intervention in most cases. The courts play the role of a mere facilitator for actions of the creditor.
• Less Expensive: SARFAESI proceedings involve lesser legal expenses as it bypasses judicial process in most cases.
Nevertheless, SARFAESI cannot be ignored with its limitations which are seen in corporate insolvency. The Act basically is drafted for the occasion when the defaulting borrower has mortgaged its tangible assets and does not provide an all-inclusive solution to cases involving corporate insolvency wherein several creditors with conflicting claims. In addition, SARFAESI does not provide any formal procedure for corporate restructuring or rehabilitation of the business of the debtor, which often results in asset liquidation instead of recovery.
b. Limitations of SARFAESI:
• Non-applicability in Complex Corporate Insolvency: SARFAESI is primarily meant for individual or small corporate borrowers. It does not address complex insolvency situations involving multiple creditors, operational creditors, or corporate debtors.
• Absence of Rehabilitation Mechanism: SARFAESI primarily deals with recovery and liquidation and has no formal instruments for business restructuring and rehabilitation.
• Conflicting Creditors: If a corporate debtor has different stakeholders holding secured and unsecured claims, SARFAESI proceedings turn out to be complex since no concerted efforts are there to resolve claims of all the parties involved.
The effectiveness of SARFAESI proceedings with regard to the recovery of assets is often defeated when dealing with larger corporate structures or complex cases involving multi-creditors. Building on this aspect, SARFAESI does not provide a resolution for those cases where liquidation of debtor assets involves creditors whose claims are different from each other and require a formal insolvency resolution process for resolution7. On a further note, SARFAESI proceedings are often hampered when the debtor is undergoing insolvency proceedings under IBC, as the IBC moratorium freezes all creditor actions, including SARFAESI8.
(B) IBC Framework9
The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC), introduced in 2016, is a much more comprehensive legal framework designed to address both corporate and individual insolvency. It shall help provide structured, time-bound processes for insolvent entities towards maximal value achievement and rehabilitation of distressed business. One of the prime features under the Insolvency Code has been the section 1410 moratorium, once insolvency proceedings start, all creditor actions- including SARFAESI proceedings- have come to an end.
Under the Insolvency Code, on the filing of an application for insolvency, a Resolution Professional, or RP, is appointed to take charge of the debtor's affairs. The management of the debtor may continue to run the business, but they are always under the supervision of the RP, and it is the Committee of Creditors, or CoC, which will decide on the resolution plan. If the resolution plan is accepted, then the business may be restructured or rehabilitated. If no consensus is achieved within 180 days, extendable to 330 days, then the company gets liquidated.
One of the key points of contention in the interaction between SARFAESI and Insolvency Code is the moratorium under Section 14 of the Insolvency Code 11. Although the Insolvency Code provides a comprehensive framework for insolvency resolution, it effectively freezes all creditor actions during the insolvency resolution process, which means that secured creditors cannot initiate or continue proceedings under SARFAESI during this period.
a. Key Features of Insolvency Code:
• Holistic Resolution: Insolvency Code provides a holistic framework for the resolution of insolvency, offering both corporate restructuring and liquidation options.
• Time-Bound Process: The Insolvency Code mandates a time-bound resolution process, which provides clarity to all stakeholders about the timeline for debt recovery and business restructuring.
• Protection for Debtors: The moratorium provides the debtor with a breathing space to work on a resolution plan without the pressure of immediate creditor action.
Nevertheless, the moratorium has presented complications for creditors, particularly for secured creditors who may have their ability to recover assets grossly compromised during the resolution process. The moratorium can lead to a deadlock situation where creditors are not able to recover their dues even when valuable assets are at risk of being dissipated or undervalued.12
b. Case Law
Many landmark cases have clarified the interplay between SARFAESI and Insolvency Code, mainly relating to the moratorium and the effects on creditor activities.
• Innoventive Industries Ltd. v. ICICI Bank (2018)13: In this case, it was held by the Supreme Court of India that the Section 14 moratorium places a blanket bar on any action against the debtor during the moratorium period including the exercise of security rights under SARFAESI. It clarified that upon admission of an insolvency application, the moratorium bars the exercise of autonomy by secured creditors to recover their dues. This judgment confirmed the operation of the moratorium so as to supersede all ongoing proceedings under SARFAESI, creating further complexity in the relationship between the two frameworks.
• Punjab National Bank & Ors. v. Mohit Indrayan (2022)14: In this landmark judgment, the Supreme Court dealt with a question of law whether the Insolvency Code moratorium under Section 14 is applicable to proceedings under SARFAESI. The Court held that though the SARFAESI proceeding can be done without judicial intervention, Insolvency Code moratorium prevails. The judgment further clarified that secured creditors cannot proceed under SARFAESI when a debtor is undergoing Insolvency Code proceedings. This case highlighted the supremacy of the Insolvency Code moratorium, making it clear that Insolvency Code’s holistic resolution framework takes precedence over the asset recovery mechanism provided by SARFAESI.
In conclusion, Both SARFAESI and Insolvency Code render excellent services in India's insolvency and debt recovery ecosystem but have an integration into different purposes, procedures, and applicability. On the one side, SARFAESI is a fast and even more direct mechanism for secured creditors to recover against liquidating assets, but on the other side, it comes with built-in limitations in the case of corporate insolvency or when several creditors step in. In contrast, Insolvency Code densifies the timeline, stage-wise entry, and all-round corporate restructuring, rehabilitation, and liquidation with a primary focus on just and fair recovery by all stakeholders. However, the moratorium under Insolvency Code may delay the quick recovery of dues by secured creditors and create a tension between the two frameworks.
c. Drawbacks of IBC
The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC), despite its positive points, has been facing a lot of criticism from stakeholders, especially regarding delayed proceedings and interim moratorium. These would create frustration among creditors and defeat the very purpose of quick and fair resolution of the insolvency process under the Insolvency Code.
i. Delayed Proceedings
The insolvency cases take a long time for resolution. While the Insolvency Code mandates that the resolution process be time-bound at 180 days, extendable to 330 days, their practice is otherwise. These delays are rather upsetting for secured creditors as they may face uncertainty for an extended period in relation to asset recovery.15 Another article further criticizes the delays, noting that they can lead to the erosion of debtor assets, decreasing their value and making it more difficult for creditors to recover their dues16.
Factors contributing to delays include legal challenges, a lack of consensus among creditors, and inefficiencies in decision-making. This is especially problematic for banks and financial institutions that are heavily exposed to NPA accounts. The long duration of resolution timelines increases the risk for creditors, as assets tend to lose their value because of stagnation or mismanagement. Furthermore, the backlog of cases in courts adds to the duration of resolution of insolvency, making the IBC process less efficient than what was envisioned.
ii. Interim Moratorium
The interim moratorium under Section 14 of the Insolvency Code restricts creditors from filing or continuing any legal proceedings, including enforcement proceedings under SARFAESI. The moratorium, although intended to give a breathing space to debtors, often goes against the interest of secured creditors. They cannot recover or sell the collateral during the insolvency resolution process, which may lead to asset dissipation.
Another article observes that such a delay in asset recovery hurts creditors, especially when the assets of the debtor are time-sensitive or perishable17. In such cases, the moratorium can let the assets become worthless and give little to recover for the creditors. Furthermore, the moratorium freezes all creditor actions, even when the urgency for recovery is evident, such as in the case of secured creditors.
This problem was addressed in Kiran Gupta v. State Bank Of India Another18 when the Delhi High Court refused to permit the actions for SARFAESI in view of a moratorium, wherein this Court specifically emphasized the moratorium under the Insolvency Code overrides actions under SARFAESI and hence the burden and hardship during the process become more stringent. It adds to the legal sanctity of the moratorium. What it shows is the uphill task for creditors when navigating Insolvency Code 's framework.
Delayed proceedings and the concept of an interim moratorium under the Insolvency Code also go against some major disadvantages where primarily secured creditors suffer. At times when the Insolvency Code aims towards a structured and fair recovery process, it results in uncertainty and financial loss of a creditor. The erosion of valuable assets due to prolonged delays and freezing of creditor actions under the moratorium makes it more difficult for the creditors to recover their dues in a timely manner. These issues underscore the need for reform in the Insolvency Code framework to balance the interests of debtors and creditors, so that the resolution is achieved more efficiently and creditors' rights are protected.
Analysis and Recommendations
(A) The Balance of SARFAESI and Insolvency Code
Another most critical issue in the landscape of insolvency and debt recovery of India is the balance required between SARFAESI and Insolvency Code. Both the frameworks have their importance, and the need is to have them more harmoniously integrated so that the creditors, especially the secured creditors, can recover their dues effectively without undermining the goals of corporate restructuring and rehabilitation.
SARFAESI has proved to be a very effective tool for secured creditors in the speedy recovery of assets. It is, however, of little use in complex corporate insolvencies involving multiple stakeholders and competing claims. The Insolvency Code provides a comprehensive framework for corporate rehabilitation, but the moratorium under Section 14, which freezes all creditor actions, can cause undue delay and result in the erosion of valuable assets.
Main recommendations are that while SARFAESI should remain the recourse available to secured creditors to receive quick recovery, the framework for Insolvency Code should be tweaked appropriately for the concerns of creditors such as the extended period for which they are kept in a prolonged moratorium. Extended timelines in Insolvency Code affect the interests of secured creditors further when the assets are evaporating. Thus, there is an imperative need to harmonize these two frameworks so that creditor recoveries take place without vitiating the resolution process under Insolvency Code.
(B) Addition of Safeguards
To prevent the abuse of the moratorium and to ensure that it does not cause undue harm to secured creditors, safeguards should be incorporated into the Insolvency Code process. Secured creditors should be allowed to continue enforcement actions during specific stages of the resolution process, particularly in cases where assets are being dissipated or are at risk of devaluation.
For example, if the assets of the debtor are fast disappearing or mismanaged in some other way, then the Insolvency Code moratorium could be changed to permit actions by creditors such as taking possession through SARFAESI or interim injunctions, which would allow Insolvency Code to retain its focus on resuscitating business while equipping creditors with their weapons to safeguard their interests. That would create much balance because both debtor protection and creditor rights would be adequately safeguarded.
Conclusion
Myriads intricacies connect SARFAESI and Insolvency Code leaving the condition of insolvency and debt collection in India somewhat ambiguous with the two regimes upholding the different yet complementary options. SARFAESI, enacted in 2002, provides for the speedy recovery of loans extended by secured creditors through the enforcement of security interests. Most individual and small corporate borrowers tend to avail this route. Thus, it applies very little in more complicated stages of corporate insolvencies, in which many creditors have various claims against a company. In these instances, Insolvency Code acts more like an all-inclusive time-bound framework for requisite processes of corporate rehabilitation or liquidations.
The main challenge with Insolvency Code, however, is its Section 14 moratorium, which freezes all creditor actions, including under SARFAESI. The moratorium is intended to provide an opportunity for the debtor to restructure and rehabilitate; however, it places the secured creditors in a very vulnerable position where they are not able to enforce their rights over the debtor's assets. Prolonged delays in the resolution process also result in the erosion of valuable assets and huge financial losses to the creditors.
To address these issues, both the frameworks need to be balanced. SARFAESI must continue as the preferred tool for secured creditors when quick recovery is concerned; however, Insolvency Code must be further streamlined to address the issues concerning the creditors, particularly in the length of the moratorium. Safeguards must be built in the Insolvency Code framework, allowing secured creditors to continue enforcement actions during some steps of the resolution process, particularly where assets risk devaluation or dissipating.
Finally, a more harmonious integration of SARFAESI and Insolvency Code would ensure that creditors are able to recover their dues efficiently without undermining the broader goals of corporate restructuring and rehabilitation. That balance will provide a fairer and more effective insolvency resolution process, in turn benefitting all stakeholders in the long run.
*****
Footnotes
2. Presidency Town Insolvency Act No. 5 of 1909 (India).
3. Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, No. 1 of 1986 (India)
4. Recovery of Debts Due to Banks and Financial Institutions Act, No. 51 of 1993 (India)
5. Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, No. 54 of 2002 (India)
6. Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, No. 31 of 2016 (India)
7. Reed Law. (2023). Moratorium under IBC: Its Effect on Parallel Proceedings. Retrieved from https://reedlaw.in
8. Esher, J. A., Katz, E. I., & Fenning, L. H. (2009). The ABI Guide to Bankruptcy Mediation. American Bankruptcy Institute.
9. Supra note 5
10. Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016, No. 31 of 2016, § 14 (India).
11. Id.
12. IBCLaw. (2023). Moratorium under IBC: Its Effect on Parallel Proceedings. Retrieved from https://ibclaw.in.
13. Innoventive Industries Ltd. v. ICICI Bank, (2018) 1 SCC 407
14. Punjab National Bank & Ors. v. Mohit Indrayan, (2022) 6 SCC 478
15. Supra note 8
16. IndiaCorpLaw. (2023b). Resolving the Conundrum Surrounding Applicability of Moratorium under Section 141A of IBC. Retrieved from https://indiacorplaw.in
17. Panday, A. (2023). Interpretation of Parallel Proceedings during Moratorium under IBC. 12 Pages. Posted: 18 May 2023. Retrieved from https://delhihighcourt.in.
18. Kiran Gupta v. State Bank of India & Another, 2020 SCC ONLINE DEL 1390.
