Introduction
"Regulators are in the best position to regulate when they are intimately knowledgeable about the activities they are regulating." - John Thain (CEO of the CIT Group) 3
The government derives its power from the self determination of the people and the powers has been exercised by the will of the people. Powers of the government or its bodies aren’t absolute, it is subjected to check and balance. The concept of absolute power traces back to the history when Louis XIV said “ I am the state”4, which triggered the Montesquieu to come up with the separation of power of the government , so it shows the different functions of government and how they are different and still related with each other. So always there is a check and balance between these powers to curb the unreasonableness in the governing system.
The concept of checks and balance in the administrative law is a vi333 tal concept because the entire constitutionalism is protected by following the norms but the problem arises when regulatory bodies exercise all those powers because there is no clear demarcation of those powers in the legal system. When we see the governmental function then there is a comparatively a good demarcation of powers but in the regulatory bodies that is subjected to debate because all the regulatory bodies are the creation of the statutes which is drafted and passed by the legislative power and it confers the powers of other organ powers to facilitate the regulatory body, so when a regulatory body is endowed with all three powers of the government won’t it be a violation of separation of power principle, if no then what is the limitation of the regulatory body to wield the power and to regulate the specific area.
The regulatory bodies are given special privileges because of the fact it’s a technical area more than a administrative power it requires the technical knowledge and quasi-judicial & legislative powers to regulate it wholly. The regulatory bodies are the creations of law and especially through the statutes, where there will be separate act will be passed in a parliament unlike their constitutional counterpart like election commission which derives its power from constitution.5 These regulators are different from their working system because it has been gifted with all the government powers so there are higher chances of misusing it.
SEBI- The Regulatory Body
SEBI is the regulatory body which regulates the securities market in India, it was created by the SEBI act 1992, it’s been conferred with the all quasi-judicial, quasi-legislative and quasi-executive powers6 but the powers aren’t absolute its always restricted in the eyes of laws. There are appellate tribunal set from the statute so which oversee the decision passed by the SEBI. But the lines of demarcation of these functions are questionable because when we comes to the power of different organs the functions are well defined by when a regulatory body does varies function at same point it is required to know the pith and marrow of the function that has been carried out and this paper focuses on the judicial power of the SEBI and the need of the judicial powers for regulatory bodies. It is also important to know whether there is a sufficient quasi-judicial power given to SEBI and it’s in par with the counter parts of other common wealth countries like USA. There are many grey areas when it comes to the jurisdiction of appellate tribunal over the orders of regulatory body. So there is gap in this area because it hasn’t well dealt when it comes to judicial nature or function of the proceeding. This study tries to explore the boundaries of the nature of the appellate tribunal.
(A) History of SEBI:
The SEBI act was passed on 1992 but it came into existence on 1988 by repealing the Capital Issues (Control) Act, 1947 (CICA)7. This CICA and SCRA both came after world war and was drafted in a way to suit the situation of that time , though in long run it lost its significance so to combat that SEBI act was passed. Moreover all the economic legislation like SEBI Act, Competition Act and many were passed after the liberalization privatization globalization era8. In order to become more suitable these regulations came to power for the accelerating changes in the economic environment.
The SEBI act gone through many amendments but the major change happened was in 1995 where the chapter 6A9 was introduced in the act which deals about the penal and etc, this in turn widened the scope of the quasi-judicial nature of the board so which gave enormous power to adjudicate their own problems which is against the administrative law principle. So this gives an image that the SEBI as a mini state with the all three governmental powers10. SEBI has evolved into more strong regulator than it was originally to be, it established many new concepts like gatekeepers and regulating them it shows that the scope of the SEBI is been widening.
(B) Judicial function of SEBI:
The judicial function is one of the primary organs of the government where the duty of the organ is to interpret law and adjudicate the proceeding. There are certain attributes of the judiciary that is been mentioned also in Victor Fernandes and Anr. vs Sebi11, where it says (1) there must be a legal authority (2) authority must be to determine questions affecting the rights of the citizens, and (3) there must be a duty to act judicially etc. but a quasi judicial decision is the decision which inclines towards administrative in terms of discretion and near the judiciary in terms of the proceeding of its end process.
In order to prevent the abusive powers there are many commission report which throws a light on this subject like commission on minster’s power and in India there is Financial Sector Legislative Reforms Commission headed by Justice B.N. Srikrishna12 where the report stress on the division of powers like distinguished quasi judicial from the executive function and legislative function which says “Once an investigation has taken place, and the supervisory team within a regulator believes there have been violations, the principles of public administration suggest that the actual order should be written by disinterested party. A systematic process would operate within the regulator, where administrative law officers and the administrative law member would be presented with evidence and write orders”13. It is importance to draw boundaries because according to the act where in the preamble it’s been stated that ‘interest of the investor’ so it is the vast area and almost everything falls under the vague power ,so if there is no demarcation of powers then it will be a chaos.
(C) Research Questions
1. Whether is there is clear demarcation of powers of SEBI in the act?
2. Is SEBI quasi judicial power different from other regulatory bodies in India?
3. What is the impact of quasi judicial power wielding by the body?
4. Whether SEBI’s quasi judicial power in par with SEC regulatory body of United States of America?
Data and Methods
The current research is proposed to be a doctrinal study based on primary and as well as secondary sources. The primary sources include SEBI act 1992, Securities Exchange Act of 1934 and SEBI ( Prohibition of Fraudulent and Unfair Trade Practices relating to the Securities Market) Regulations, 2003 and the secondary sources may include articles, research work, text books, journals etc that will help in conducting this research study. The study will mostly be descriptive and as well as analytical. In the descriptive part, the study will focus on detailed explanations of the existing regulations that deal with quasi-judicial power of SEBI and appellate jurisdiction of the SAT. The analytical part will contain a critical analysis of the application of the mentioned legislation regulation and its influence on working of SEBI an SAT
(A) Cut and dried distinction between various powers mentioned in SEBI Act 1992
SEBI was created by the statute which traces its origin from the constitution Art 53 which confers a power on parliament to delegate the executive powers to any authority or a body, thus the SEBI got its existence14. But more than the executive organ, SEBI is touted as a mini state because it started as administrative body with few legislative power but due to the continuous amendments, it conferred SEBI with all the governmental power because it requires technical aspect as we saw in previous chapter but it’s also subjected to the scrutiny because as popular saying goes power tends to corrupt and absolute power corrupts absolutely , so there should always be a check and balance so there won’t be any violation. The powers of SEBI are vague because it hasn’t clearly defined in the act. When we see the provisions of the SEBI act 1992 it hasn’t clearly classified the powers of the SEBI, though there is a separate chapter IV which explicitly deals about the powers and functions of the SEBI but apart from that there are many provisions in the act scattered which speaks about the other powers like chapter VI which pertains about the judicial powers and the penalty awarded along with that there are miscellaneous powers also.
The quasi judicial powers are conferred in the statutory bodies because the regular courts can function or resonate with technical knowledge to understand the dispute, but this primarily violates the natural justice principle that “No person shall be the judge for its own cause” but fortunately there are appellate bodies and it’s also gives appeal to supreme court so the ends of the justices is safe guarded. The powers of the SEBI is scattered all over the act but there are no clear demarcation of the boundaries but there are set of sections which deals with the powers like the chapter 4 where it speaks mostly about the executive function but in that few sections talks about the judicial power like 11 (3),11(4), 11(b), 11(d), 12(3),15 and 24 which deals with the adjudicating power and the other functions of the court like summoning and finding the evidence and exercising it. After the 1995 amendment the SEBI got intense power on respect to judicial power but it can’t exercise its according to its whims and fancies there is balance of power because the securities appellate tribunal also been given power to exercise their jurisdiction over the quasi judicial orders of the SEBI and this notion was laid in the famous case law National securities depository ltd vs Securities and exchange board of India15, where it lays down the principle for the judicial order and the jurisdiction of the SAT as its mentioned in sec 15 T of the SEBI act.
According to the International ltd & anr. vs. Securities & Exchange Board of India16 , where it has been laid that even expert body exercise the judicial power their orders will be subjected to appellate decisions. So even when the regulatory bodies have judicial powers it isn’t absolute but the question of demarcation of powers isn’t visible because the chapter 6 A where it deals about the penalty provision where it has both the characteristics of the judicial and executive powers. In order to find the scope of the judicial powers the SEBI ( Prohibition of Fraudulent and Unfair Trade Practices relating to the Securities Market) Regulations, 2003 is been taken into consideration, it will be easy to navigate the powers of SEBI to issue any order with respect to judicial powers. The section 11 and 12 of the PFUTP regulation deals about the quasi judicial powers like that it can summon, suspend and impose and prohibit so it basically covers all the writs power and the basic judicial power the court has been bestowed with. So these are the elements that are being taken to the consideration to decide the powers of the SEBI because this regulation gives basic outline of the powers so when the SEBI act is vague about the powers of the other organs. This can be used as the legal test to constitutionalise the quasi-judicial powers and as well as the jurisdiction of SAT over the SEBI. The concept of the judicial power delegated to the administrative body is still an unexplored area.
(B) Comparative study of SEBI and other regulatory bodies in terms of Quasi-judicial power
There are many administrative bodies like of SEBI with the quasi-judicial powers. The intent of the legislator will be reflected in the acts they drafted so that is the will of the government so it important to do a comparative study with respect to other statutory regulators in order to find the fathom of judicial power of SEBI, so to navigate the powers of the regulatory bodies the two bodies as taken for the study that is Telecom Regulatory Authority of India and Competition Commission of India.
These two bodies are taken for the study because both the bodies are in the domain of expert knowledge and marketing there are also other bodies like election commission of India with a strong power but it derives its power from the constitution unlike these bodies where they derive their power from the statutes. The point of commonality is that all these three bodies were formed after the LPG era so it also gives additional reason to explore because it provides the ultimate reason for an executive body to exercise the judicial powers and etc.
(C) Comparative study between TRAI and SEBI quasi- judicial power:
The TRAI act which actually came into power on 1997 where there was in need of the strict regulation to oversee the telecom sector and others, but since the fact there is no much of an individual people interference in the market there wasn’t a need of a continuous need of amendment and it also has only 40 sections throughout the act. The act is been structured in a way that it covers only the main aspect of the process and not in detail, the quasi judicial power of the TRAI hasn’t been discussed much in detail but there are few sections which deals about the powers of TRAI like the section 1217 and 1318 which gives the basic functions of the judicial body like where it explains about that it can appoint any person as investigation officer and can summon any telecom company and ask them to produce for the evidence. So these sections is same as the sec 11(3) of the SEBI act which falls under the primary function of the SEBI so it gives basic outline of the judicial powers other than this there are no other additional quasi judicial power exercised by the TRAI or there are no explicit provision as stated in the SEBI act. In 2016 the legislators rejected the TRAI commission’s request for imprisonment power.It shows that SEBI was in need of more judicial power to curb the market because there was series of scams and schemes happening and they were in need a stronger and longer arm of judicial proceeding to take over the matter unlike TRAI.
(D) Comparative study between CCI and SEBI quasi- judicial power:
Whereas in comparison to the Competition act ,the scenario is totally different because the competition act is more similar to that of the SEBI act because the entire chapter IV from sec 18 to 40 it discuss about the powers and the functions of the board in detail. Before in all the act it was just the main functions of the quasi- judicial power was dealt but here there are many provision which not only deals with the substantial part but also the procedural part explicitly. The major difference is that in Competition Act chapter IV starts with the laying the duties of the commission where it says that its shall protect the welfare of the consumers and the same is been said in the preamble part also it shows that the duties are being again mentioned to show the will of the drafter and that isn’t in the case SEBI. The procedural aspect of the act has been expanded after the 2007 amendment of competition act19. It also deals about the transnational combinations in the section so it shows that the competition act is more developed than the SEBI act and it also gives a detailed procedure to call a person and ask to produce necessary documents in the given time. So it shows that the said act is better structured in terms of its powers and the powers of the commission isn’t scattered like that of SEBI. The judicial power to investigate and to appearance of the party and it also gives clear procedure to conduct the investigation and to pass orders. The jurisdiction also differs from that of a SAT because the NLAT is the appellate tribunal and it doesn’t have separate appellate authority which is been established in the act which is one of the major differences between TRAI and SEBI.
As laid in the NSDL vs SEBI case where it’s said that the appellate body has power to deal with only judicial orders of the SEBI but in the competition act it isn’t the same because from the section 53A20 where it says that the NCLAT has absolute jurisdiction over the all type of orders passed by the CCI. In sec 42 of the competition act where it gives power to commission to imprison a person for 3 years but it should be passed by the metropolitan magistrate unlike SEBI where sec 24 gives ultimate power to commission to imprison for 10 years and without any regular court approval. So this is the major difference because it shows that SEBI as powerful separate entity which passes many orders with respect to the other powers sp the other orders are wont be subjected to appeal.
(E) Impact of quasi judicial power wielding by the body
Regulatory body are the creation of the statute so technically legislator drafts an act for creating a executive body and bestows judicial power to the regulatory body so it is violation of separation of powers because the delegation of power is from the other body. If that is being the case there might be loads of issue arises due to this
When a quasi judicial statutory bodies exercise a jurisdiction over a particular subject then there will be a issue in the legality of the functions because in case of actual judicial function they adjudicate the problem it mainly focus on the rights and duties of the parties and it usually goes with the precedent cases when it decides the present scenario but it is so different in this scenario because the commissions makes a judgment with respect to the rigid policy and regulation21 without considering parties condition and the principle of precedent isn’t been followed. So it is a grey are that hasn’t been explored in a greater extent because exercising quasi judicial is under continuous watch by the regular court because there is duty laid on the regulatory body to act judicially.
There are many cases which spoke about the quasi judicial body like in the case of Ridge vs Baldwin22 case where it dealt about the main principle that is been laid on these bodies that is principle of natural justice so this is one of the greatest impact on the bodies exercising the judicial power because when a regulatory body performs a judicial function then there might a issue like the officers aren’t professional trained to take evidences and move along with that so it should be considered and more over the proceedings are not public hearing so it is against the principle of judiciary.
In the case Rex vs electricity commissioner23 where it is been said that when a statutory body have a authority to determine the rights of the parties and have duty to act judicially then they will be subjected to king’s division bench, so there is a latent principle to act judicially by complying with all the procedural aspect and substantial part. So there should be constant check on this part because the jurisdiction of the high court’s has been taken away by the statutes so the supreme court is in a place to check whether the commission has applied necessary mind. So when the commission exceeds its limit then that time it can be rectified but two ways like one is extending the categories of jurisdictional defects and the second option is by giving remedies for the parties who is affected by the decision, so for this in the case Ball v shoreham24 where the court lays the test of unreasonableness so if any quasi judicial body exceeds the limit or he jurisdiction the higher court shall always apply this test to verify whether they have functioned in a way as statute mentioned
So from this we can understand that the basic principle which has been laid on the SEBI like the quasi judicial body that it should act according to the statute and power conferred with in it. So if it breaches the duty of act judicial then it will face the consequence as we saw in DLF vs. SEBI case.
(F) Comparative analysis between SEBI and SEC with respect to power
The SEBI and SEC maybe the regulators of the securities market in India and USA respectively but they are different in their own terms so as their powers too but both the bodies differ to the great extent because of the fact of forms of the government of the country. In India they follow parliamentary form of government but whereas in America it is presidential form of government, so the congress is the primary part which decides the powers of the regulatory body but it isn’t in the case of SEBI.
One of the major differences is that SEBI act is more like small time legislation but whereas the SEC act 1934 even when it came around long before it is vaster and covers all the sections in very detailed the procedures has been dealt. The congress is in charge of all laws that is being drafted and in very act amendment or the regulation is it passed in the senate so there is no absolute sovereignty for U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission like in case of SEBI where it has authority to regulate itself and drafts rules and regulation for the time being and thus it regulates the securities market but SEC always has to depend on the senate for passing major amendments. The fact that SEC act is voluminous because the act consist of the related regulations like whistleblowers regulations or the intermediaries regulations are part of the act it isn’t same in India because the SEBI regulates its own legislative work by drafting their own regulations.
Judicial powers are exercised are by different types of person because in SEBI new chapter VI A in SEBI act 1992 that discuss about the judicial powers exercised by the Adjudicating officer(AO) but the issue is that the adjudicating officers aren’t the trained judicial officers so they are totally from an executive background where they become an adjudicating officer without any proper judicial practice so they don’t have much prior experience but whereas in the SEC act where the judicial proceedings are done before the separate types of judges they are administrative law judge where they appointment in a constitutional manner and it is also said in the case Freytag v. Commissioner25 where it has laid the powers of the administrative law judges because their powers are more supreme than judges in other courts because like if there is no review in the supreme court of US then the decision of the ALJ will be binding on the parties so this isn’t a case in SEBI because always there decisions can be appealed in SAT so it isn’t final order.
One of the primary differences is the review power of the SEBI there is no review power as present in SEC before 2014 amendment so it is a grave mistake not to confer with review power because the review power is the soul of the judicial function which helps to exercise better.
In the sec 4 C 26of the act where it deals with prohibiting few people from appearing before the commission who doesn’t qualify according to the norms that has been laid, so this section isn’t found in the SEBI act. This section lays a principle that whoever appears before the commission should be of a clean hands and shouldn’t have breached any securities laws. So it is high time that even Indian laws should adapt this principle to maintain the sanctum of the securities market.
In sec 11C of the SEC act where it deals with the powers of SEC where it has dealt in detail about the working and functioning mechanism and it also establish a separate body Advisory committee for advising or recommending necessary changes time to time, it shows that SEC is more like solid form executive body but whereas the SEBI started as an administrative body but after many amendments its slowly inclining towards being judicial body but SEC is pure executive body and it is been constantly monitored by the Senate.
In sec 19 where its deals about Registration, Responsibilities, and Oversight of Self-Regulatory Organizations27 where it gives the procedure to regulate the self regulatory which has all 3 powers in it but in SEBI act there are no provisions like this.
Sec 21 of the SEC act28 where it deals with the Investigations and injunction where there is a clear demarcation of the judicial powers unlike in SEBI the powers lines are blurred, in this section it gives a clear explanation of the investigation procedure and the ground for passing injunction but whereas in SEBI it just mentions about the powers vested in CPC 1908. The peculiarity of this section is that it also gives acknowledgement to foreign authorities and provides assistance to the investigation in the judicial proceeding but this part is totally missing in SEBI act it shows that American laws are much broader and has private international law elements. In sec 21 A29 and 21 B30 it deals with the procedures of the court which is more or less similar to the mechanism of SEBI act.
In sec 21 C of the SEC act where it deals about the cease and desist proceedings but compared to the Indian counterpart mention in Sec 11D31 of the act there are no intense procedural aspect laid by the US law because in SEC act it gives about the time limit to initiate and end the proceeding but there are no provision like that in SEBI act.
So from these we can understand that SEC is more wide and detailed compared to the SEBI but when we see in terms of judicial power the SEC commission is more of solid executive body comparatively to the other function of the body. The administrative law judge who is in charge adjudication in SEC isn’t like the AO in SEBI because adjudication officers are executives originally but become judicial officers and can convert back to being executives so there is no proper professional graph which will severely impact on the judicial decisions and compared to the SEBI act the SEC act is more detailed and the procedural aspect is cleared and even allows a room for foreign commission proceedings and it has crystal clear provisions for judicial powers. So it is high time that SEBI makes necessary changes in the act to redefine its powers.
Conclusion
SEBI maybe started as the one of the regulators for administrative purposes with limited powers, but with the time it has evolved into a strong adjudicating body with more judicial powers and especially after many amendments and when we compare that with the other regulatory bodies in India like TRAI and CCI, SEBI is more well structured and many precedent cases focusing and developing its powers moreover its quasi judicial powers are greater than US securities exchange commission. It shows how progressive Indian laws are and the fathom of regulatory on the securities market. Though the procedural aspect hasn’t explained in detail in the act but it has bestowed with wide powers. With the detailed analysis we can conclude that just like how Supreme Court of India is one of the powerful court in the world, SEBI is one of the powerful quasi judicial regulator in the world.
*****
Footnotes
3. Quotefancy, https://quotefancy.com/quote/1692932/John-Thain-Regulators-are-in-the-best-position-to-regulate-when-they-are-intimately
4. hyperhistory. 2014. Louis XIV. [ONLINE] Available at: https://www.hyperhistory.com/online_n2/ people_n2/persons6_n2/louis.html#:~:text=. [Accessed 5 May 2021].
5. Art 324 constitution of India.
6. SEBI. 2020. Why Join SEBI. [ONLINE] Available at: https://www.sebi.gov.in/department/human-resources-department-37/why-join-sebi.html. [Accessed 5 May 2021].
7. Shreyashi T, aishmghrana. 2020. SECURITIES MARKET – WHAT CHANGED IN 1992?. [ONLINE] Available at: https:// aishmghrana.me/2020/07/03/what-in-the-securities-market-changed-in-1992/. [Accessed 5 May 2021].
8. Pandey A, ipleaders. 2017. Development of Competition Law in India. [ONLINE] Available at: https://blog.ipleaders.in/competition-law-india/. [Accessed 5 May 2021].
9. Chapters VI A and VI B containing sections 15A to 15J and 15K to 15Z respectively, inserted by Securities Laws (Amendment) Act, 1995
10. Kumar, L., 2015. SEBI Act, 1992 Scheme and Scope of Powers of SEBI. J. Sagar Associates advocates & solicitors, 27 August 2015. p.1.
11. Appeal No.42 of 2017
12. PTI New Delhi,BusinessLine. 2018. Srikrishna panel report proposes unified regulator for financial sector. [ONLINE] Available at: https://www.thehindubusinessline.com/money-and-banking/srikrishna-panel-report-proposes-unified-regulator-for-financial-sector/article23090275.ece. [Accessed 5 May 2021].
13. Statutory Regulatory Authorities in India A Constitutional perspective
14. Article 53(3)(b) in The Constitution Of India 1949 ” prevent Parliament from conferring by law functions on authorities other than the President”
15. , 2017 SCC Online SC 256
16. [(2004) 8 SCC 524]
17. Section 12. Powers of Authority to call for information, conduct investigations, etc.
18. Section 13. Power of Authority to issue directions.
19. Thacker S. mondaq. 2007. Introduction Of The Competition (Amendment) Bill, 2007. [ONLINE] Available at: https://www.mondaq.com/india/trade-regulation-practices/52606/introduction-of-the-competition-amendment-bill-2007#:. [Accessed 6 May 2021].
20. Sec 53A of competition act 2002-Appellate Tribunal
21. Mrs. K.L. Sahgal vs State Of U.P AIR 1965 All 465
22. [1964] AC 40
23. [1924] 1 K.B. 171 at 205,
24. Town of New Shoreham v. Ball, 14 R.I. 566, R.I. Supreme Court (1884).
25. 501 U.S. 868 (1991)
26. Sec. 4C. Appearance and Practice Before the Commission.
27. Sec. 19. Registration, Responsibilities, and Oversight of Self-Regulatory Organizations.
28. Sec. 21. Investigations; Injunctions and Prosecution of Offenses.
29. Sec. 21A. Civil Penalties for Insider Trading.
30. Sec. 21B. Civil Remedies in Administrative Proceedings
31. Sec 11D. Cease and desist proceedings
