VidhiAagaz
International Journal ofLaw Management & Humanities
ISSN 2581-5369 · Open access
International Journal ofLaw Management & Humanities
Open accessArticlesVol. 8 No. I (2025)pp. 1812–1828

Human Rights and Intellectual Property Rights

GL
Gargi LahiriPh. D. Student at the Department of Law, and University of Calcutta and State aided College Teacher, South Calcutta Law College, Kolkata, India
755views342downloads
Published 1 March 2025 · pp. 1812–1828 · Vol. 8 No. I (2025)
Abstract

Human rights and intellectual property rights these two are independent disciplines. Human rights secure the fundamental freedoms, equal, inalienable rights and inherent dignity of human beings. Intellectual property rights are concerned about the protection of intellectual creativity. Considering the socio economic significance of the intellectual property rights human rights recognition of intellectual property rights is crucial. The relationship between human rights and intellectual property rights is dynamic. Human rights approach to intellectual property rights on the one hand acknowledges the moral and material interest of the creator and inventor and on the other hand secures the public right to access and enjoy the benefit of intellectual creation. The human rights acknowledgement of intellectual property rights protects the private interest as well as promotes the common good of society at large. This raises conflict between the private interest of intellectual property rights owner and the public interest. Under this context the present study attempts to resolve the conflict and examines whether human rights and intellectual property rights are complimentary to each other.

Keywords
Dynamic relationconflicting interestprivate interestpublic interestcomplimentary
Contents
Full text

Introduction

The human rights and intellectual property rights both are distinctly separate areas of study. These two fields have developed independently. Initially they were in isolation of each other. In the era of globalization and in the changing socio economic scenario the segregation of these two fields is not feasible. It is the human rights discipline which concern about the intellectual property. The intellectual property rights emphasise on the individualism where as the human rights law not only protects the individual right but also highlights the importance of group interest. The object of human rights is to promote and protect human dignity and common good. Human rights recognition of intellectual property rights has found its place in the international human rights instruments namely the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR), 1948 and the International Convention on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR), 1966. The analysis of the provisions of the Article 27 the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, 1948 and the Article 15 of the International Convention on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, 1966 shows that human rights approach to intellectual property rights raises a complex relationship between these two areas.

The intellectual property has immense socio economic significance for nations’ progress. The Recognition of novel creation of human intellect and grant of exclusive monopoly right to the creator fosters further innovation. It is one of the substantial features of today’s advanced society. The human rights acknowledgement of the moral and material interest of author, inventor or creator for their intellectual endeavor is one of the important human rights. It has intrinsic value in the expression human dignity. This incentivises further creation which ultimately ignites fuel to socio economic advancement. On the one hand human rights protect the private interest of the creator and on the other hand safe guard the larger interest of the society in terms of access the scientific, technological and cultural advancement. Intersection of human rights and intellectual property rights raises ethical dilemma between narrower and larger aspects of human rights in other words internal conflict between the exclusive right and access. The present study highlights whether human rights are complementary to intellectual property rights? If it is yes then how the internal conflict can be resolved? To find the answers the study has been designed in five parts. First part explains the concepts of human rights and intellectual property rights. The second and third part discuss about the features of these two different areas. Fourth part analyses the conflicting and coexisting relation between human rights and intellectual property rights. Fifth section investigates is human rights complementary to intellectual property rights? Lastly the study has been concluded.

Concepts of Human Rights and Intellectual Property

(A) Concept of Human Rights

The concept of human rights is as old as human civilization.2 Though the term human rights is of recent origin which has been emerged with the United Nations Charter, 1945, a post Second World War Instrument.3 Traditionally human rights are known as natural rights or rights of man. Thomas Paine in his English translation of the French Declaration of Rights of Man, 1789 first time documented the term human rights.4According to Dr. D.D. Basu human rights are those minimal rights which every individual must have against the state or other public authority by virtue of his being a member of human family irrespective of any other conditions.5 So, it is the duty of the state or other public authority to protect the enjoyment of human rights of every member of this human family. Section 2(d) of the Protection of Human Rights act, 1993 explains the term human rights as rights relating to life, liberty, equality and dignity of individual guaranteed by the Constitution or embodied in the International Covenants and enforceable by courts in India. The Preamble to the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, 1948 asserts that as the foundation of freedom, justice and peace in the world equal, inalienable rights and inherent dignity of all members of this human family should be recognised.6 The Sanskrit phrase vasudhiva kutumbakam7 has recognised the approach of human family as the universe is one family and the members the world community should act towards each other in a spirit of common brotherhood. Chales R. Betiz acknowledges social justice approach to human rights.8 In the study of Krishna and H.S., 2024 it is stated that the Preamble to the United Nations Charter, 1945 affirms the essence of social justice through promotion of social progress and economic and social advancement of people. Justice can be secured with the equality of rights, equal enjoyment, economic and social advancement without any discrimination.9 Equality is the foundation of social justice. Equal availability of wealth and social opportunities are means to achieve social justice.

After the Second World War the protection and promotion of human rights have become the international concern. It is the task of the United Nations Organisation to respect for fundamental freedom and human rights.10 Under the supervision of the Charter of 1945 the Economic Social Council established the Human Rights Commission to prepare the International Bill of Rights.11 It is the concrete step to achieve the objectives of the United Nations. First precise step to design and recognise several human rights is the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR), 1948.12 The member states of the UDHR, 1948 are under moral obligation to implement human rights into their domestic legal arena. To provide legally binding effect to the UDHR, 1948 two covenants namely the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights have been adopted by the General assembly on 16th December, 1966. First generation of human rights that is the civil and political rights and second generation of human rights that is the economic, social and cultural rights have been codified under the two covenants - the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, 1966 and the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, 1966 respectively. All these substantive rights whether civil and political or economic, social and cultural are subject to reasonable restrictions. Article 4 paragraph 1 of both the covenants of 1966 provides that in case of urgency or in necessity the state can impose the reasonable restriction on the enjoyment of rights.

Among several human rights property right is one of the important aspect of human rights. With the advent of science and technology one new form of property that is intellectual property has been introduced in the traditional arena of property. The concept of intellectual property has been discussed here.

(B) Concept of Intellectual Property

With the changing socio, economic and cultural scenario it is essential to differentiate mental labour from manual labour. These changes demand to introduce new concept of intangible form of property named as intellectual property along with the traditional concept of tangible form of property. Creativity and skillful ideas with industrial proficiency have been brought within the scope of intellectual property.13 One’s own creativity, originality, and inventiveness are all about the essence of intellectual property.14 Human intellectual endeavor turns into his creation in the form of scientific, literary or artistic work. The intellectual property has its quintessence not in the material where the creation has been embodied but in the incorporeal effort which has been presented in material form.15 The intellectual property protection is provided to intellectual endeavor means the knowledge and ideas what have been transformed into tangible object.

Origin of the intellectual property has been found in the western civilization. In14th and 15th century the United Kingdom and England promoted the intellectual creativity. The United State Constitution in its Article 1 Section 8 provides that the congress of the state can foster the scientific and technological invention and guarantee the exclusive right of the inventor over his creation for a limited period of time.

Article 1 Section 8 of the said Constitution stated that the Congress shall have power to advance useful art by assuring exclusive right for limited period of times to author and inventor for their creation.

Till mid ninth century there was no precise legislation relating to the intellectual property. In the absence of proper legislation subject matters in this area are very scattered. Initially the term industrial property has been used to address the technology based subjects like patent and design, where as the term intellectual property has been used for copyright, literary or artistic work.

The Paris Convention for the Protection of Industrial Property, 1883, has applied the term industrial property to cover patents, trademarks and designs. Property, which has industrial application for commercial purpose is known as industrial property.16

The Berne Convention for Protection of Literary and Artistic Work, 1886 protects the intellectual efforts of authors, musicians, artists, poets and painters.

Gradually with the modern international intellectual property conventions the phrase intellectual property has been started to refer both industrial and intellectual property.17 The Convention Establishing the World Intellectual Property Organisation (WIPO), 1970 uses the expression intellectual property to denote rights relating to artistic literary, scientific works, performing art, broadcasts and phonogram, industrial designs, commercial names, trademarks, service marks and protection against unfair competition.

In the realm of the intellectual property rights the Agreement on Trade Related Aspects of Intellectual Property rights (TRIPs), 1994 is a landmark development. In the era of globalization the TRIPs Agreement, 1994 is significant multilateral treaty which has addressed all forms of intellectual properties. The TRIPs Agreement has been negotiated at the end of the Uruguay Round of General Agreement on Trade and Tariff (GATT), 1986-1994 with the establishment of the World Trade Organisation (WTO) and came into force on the 1st January, 1995.18 Object of the TRIPs Agreement, 1994 is to reduce hindrances in the area international trade and to promote adequate standard and uniform protective measures for the intellectual property. Under the TRIPs obligation the member states have to bring their national intellectual property law in conformity with the TRIPs Agreement, 1994. The TRIPs Agreement, 1994 includes various rights under the umbrella of intellectual property rights these are - copyright and related works, trademarks, rights of manufacturers and producers for geographical indications relating to productions, rights of industrial designers, rights of inventors protected through patent, computer technologists’ right regarding their integrated circuits layout designs, trade secrets or confidential information or simply know-how.

The natural right theory and the economic incentive theory justify the intellectual property protection. The natural right theory recognises that the creator and inventor should be the true owner of his creation. He must be entitled to the legal protection of his creation from arbitrary interference of others. The economic incentive theory stimulates the intellectual efforts with the granting of exclusive monopoly right for a specified period of time in return of advancement of society and for disclosure of related information which will belong to public domain after expiry of tenure of protection.19 This property protection is not absolute like any other tangible property it is subject to reasonable restriction and also the government’s acquisition on the basis of requirements.

Intellectual property rights are the legal instruments which provide protection to the creator of intellectual efforts. Intellectual Property is owned by the producer or creator. Under this property protection creator is safe to exploit his creation at commercial level.

Under the Intellectual property protection on the one hand interest of the creator is protected from imitators, his intellectual efforts is recognised and is encouraged with economic incentive for further creation and on the another hand industrial growth, cultural progress and economic development are promoted through acknowledgement of mental endeavor. The intellectual property rights promote simultaneously the exclusive right of creator and socio economic development.

Every creator or inventor wants to protect his creation, invention, cognitive exploration like any other tangible object. There are various theories to justify human intellectual exploration as property.20 These are as follows Utilitarian Moral Justification, Lokean Labour Theory of Property, Hegel’s Personality Theory.

The Utilitarian Moral Justification has been enshrined in the Article 1 Section 8 Clause 8 of the United States Constitution. The U.S. Constitution promotes and protects the intellectual efforts of author and inventor. Acknowledgement and protection of creator’s work and skill is the moral value. In return of protection it is the duty of the creator to disclose the details of invention as well as he must have to utilise the invention for the benefit of society. According to the utilitarianism the ultimate object is to foster science, technology and culture with the socio economic development of the nation.

In the line with the Lokean Labour Theory of Property labour must be the property of labourer. Certain form of labour whether mental or physical is required for production of ideas. Obviously whatever the form of property should be the property of labourer. Prof. Douglass states that it is not possible to hold the idea physically. Ideas require some form. It is the right in the ideas which have been hold by the creator. If the production of labour provides valuable benefit to society then producer must deserve in return certain benefit. This asserts that it is the right of one to enjoy the ultimate creation of his labour even if it is intellectual. This Lokean labour theory is also known as value added theory or labour desert.

Prof. Margaret Radin states that the property is unique mechanism requires for personal expression, dignity as well as for recognition as an individual.21 The Hegel’s Personality Theory rocognises that personal development requires certain extent of possession and individual control over external resource. This can be possible through securing some sets of rights these are property rights or interests. One should have moral and material interest over his intellectual expertise.22 Recognition of intellectual property is essential for advancement of individual personality.

Above discussed theories though not directly but impliedly recognise that the intellectual labour belongs to the category of property. The human rights instruments also reaffirm this assertion.

(C) Human Rights Approach to Intellectual Property Rights

Human Rights and Intellectual Property Rights are two independent disciplines. Both are isolated from each other for a long period of time. With the passage of time gradually two areas have become intimate and interlinked. Initially it was the human rights discipline which was concerned about the intellectual property rights. International human rights instruments have recognised the concept of intellectual property rights in the way to protect author’s moral and material interest. In this respect Article 27 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, 1948 and Article 15 of the International Covenant on Economic, Social, Cultural Rights, 1966 are important. Before discussion of these two Articles the provision of Article 17 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, 1948 is essential to mention here as it recognises right to property.

The Universal Declaration of Human Rights, 1948 in article 17 paragraph 1 has recognisesd every individual’s right to property solely or with others. Paragraph 2 of Article 17 of the UDHR, 1948 provides the protection against arbitrary deprivation of property.23

Article 17 of the UDHR, 1948 nowhere states anything about the intellectual property only acknowledges individual’s right to property. From the above explanation of various theories it is clear that the author’s or inventor’s interest on their creations is recognised as their valuable property. So obviously creator’s interest over his creation must be acknowledged as property under Article 17 of the UDHR, 1948.

Article 27 (2) of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, 194824 asserts that everyone is entitled to protect his moral and material interest over his scientific, literary or artistic creation.

Article 15 (1) (c) of the International Convention on the Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, 196625 also in identical term with the UDHR, 1948 recognises everyone’s right to protect their moral and material interest relating to their scientific, literary and artistic work.

The right of authorship has also been reaffirmed in paragraph (1) of the General Comment 17 on Article 15 of the International Convention on Economic, Social, Cultural Rights, 1966.26 Right of acknowledgement27 of intellectual effort is known as moral interest. Even after the end of protection period product of intellectual endeavor will have become under the public domain this interest in the form of recognition has not been disappeared.28 Material interest on the one hand empowers the owner for monetary exploitation of his creation to earn profit and on the other hand entitles him to is remuneration29 for use of his work to serve the requirement of society during the protection period. This material interest has been justified by just remuneration approach. This approach asserts the human rights obligation to curb the over exploitation of monopoly right to secure public interest. Under certain special circumstances even within the tenure of protection without authorisation of author or inventor his work can be used for public welfare. In return holder of the right is entitled to be compensated with just remuneration proportionate with value of his creation. Just remuneration approach has been recognised in paragraph 24 of General Comment 17 on the Article 15 of the International Convention on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, 1966. The Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights in the General Comment 17 on Article 15 of ICESCR is of opinion that it is the inherent dignity and worth of all human beings to protect their intellectual creation.

To give the legal effect to the provisions of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, 1948 Article 15 (1) (c) of the International Convention on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, 196630 along with the acknowledgement of intellectual property right as one of the human right belongs to the category of socio, economic and cultural right, imposes obligation on the state parties to take adequate measures for proper realisation of rights31 as mentioned under Article 15 (1),32 to respect the freedom indispensable for scientific research and creative activity33 and to recognise and promote international co-operation in the area of science technology and culture.34 These are significant for dissemination and advancement of the science, technology and culture.

(A) Features of Human Rights

Human rights are universal, equal, inalienable, indivisible and interdependent in nature. Universally all human beings naturally inherit these rights by virtue of being born as human. It has been reaffirmed by the World Conference on Human Rights, 199335 that the states have to promote universal respect for and protection of human rights and fundamental freedoms according to the guidelines of the United Nations Charter, 1945. All human beings of this universe are equally entitled to the enjoyment and protection of human rights irrespective of race, caste, creed, religion, language, place of birth, nationality, sex etc. Everyone is born free and equal in right and dignity.36 These rights are basic and fundamental cannot be transferred or waived by any one. The Authority also cannot arbitrarily interfere with these rights. One human right is not inferior to other kind of human rights, it is based on the principle of indivisibility of human rights. Interdependency of human rights acknowledges that it is difficult to realise one human right in isolation of other human rights.

(B) Features of Intellectual Property Rights

There are various features of the intellectual property rights. Intellectual property is in form of right to protect the intellectual efforts of the creator. This mental labour is resulted in a physical form whatever the nature of work be it scientific, literary, artistic or design etc. Intellectual property rights do not exist in the material rather exist in knowledge of the creator what has been turned into the substance. That is why the unique feature of intellectual property is intangible one. Intellectual property rights are assignable in return of reasonable consideration.

Once the product has been sold with the consent of the owner or proprietor all the rights relating to it become exhausted. This is also known as first sale doctrine. Exhaustion and parallel import both are interrelated concept. Parallel import is obvious consequence of exhaustion of right.37 Under the doctrine of exhaustion parallel import is legal otherwise it would violate owner’s right. Article 6 of the TRIPs Agreement, 1994 provides that there is nothing in the said Agreement, 1994 which prohibit the member states to design the policy and regime relating to exhaustion38 and parallel import.

Along with conferring exclusive monopoly rights to the owner the intellectual property rights subject to public domain to protect the interest of the consumers and other members of user community. Standard ensuring and limited duration these two are requirements to promote public domain. Intellectual property protection is grated to the creator or author for his original, non obvious work, for his innovative skill what has not been extracted from the subject matter of public domain. Intellectual property protection is provided for a particular period of time. After the expiry of tenure the work is no longer the property of the owner it will enter in the public domain. It turns into public property from private one.39

Nature of intellectual Property rights is of positive and negative. It is positive because owner is entitled to economically exploit his right. It is negative because the owner is empowered to prevent other form unauthorized use of his creation.

Compare and Contrast Between Two

Human rights and intellectual property rights both are independent areas of study. Human rights are concerned with the public right whereas intellectual property rights safe guard the private interest. With the advent of science and technology and changing socio economic scenario these two regimes cannot be kept in isolation. Real life practice shows the interrelation between human rights and intellectual property rights.

Analysis of human rights discourse of intellectual property rights focuses on contrasting and coexisting relation in between them.

Coexisting association exists with the human rights recognition of intellectual property rights. Article 27 (2) of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, 1948 and Article 15 (1) (c) of the International Convention on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, 1966 in identical terms acknowledge everyone’s moral and material interest in respect of his scientific, literary or artistic work.

Conflicting relation has been discussed from two points of views external conflict and internal conflict.

Comparison of charecteristics between human rights and intellectual property rights and the human rights approval of intellectual property rights show external conflict.

Charecteristics of the intellectual property rights and human rights are completely different. Intellectual property rights are secured as private property right where as the later belongs to the category of public law. Intellectual property law is territorial in nature but human rights law is universal in nature. Every individual naturally inherits and enjoys human rights forever but the intellectual property rights are granted for a limited period of time. Intellectual property rights are transferable, assignable as well revocable. In contrast human rights cannot be transferred, assigned, revoked or waived. Irrespective of these distinctions there is close association between these two disciplines.

The provisions of Article 27 (2) of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, 1948 and Article 15 (1) (c) of the International Convention on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, 1966 assert intellectual property rights as one of the notable human rights.

Undoubtedly inventor or creator has right to protect their moral and material interest but it is true that stringent property protection undermines the consumer interest that means interest of the society at large in realisation of social, cultural and economic rights these relate to dissemination of information, technology transfer to developing and least developed nations, bio piracy, traditional knowledge, access patented medicines, access to food relating to plant variety right etc.

Human rights dimension of intellectual property rights has two aspects. One of the aspects is to secure author’s or inventor’s private interest. Another aspect is to guarantee the public interest which might be violated with the over exploitation of the intellectual property rights. Articles 27 and 15 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, 1948 and the International Convention on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, 1966 respectively are concerned about the interest of society at large with guarantying the rights of the inventor or creator.

Article 27 (1) of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, 1948 asserts everyone’s right to freely participate in the cultural life and enjoy the benefit of scientific and cultural advancement. Article 15 (1) (a) and 15 (1) (b) also guarantees collective rights of society to access the progress of science, technology and culture.40

The provisions of Article 27 (1) and 27 (2) of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, 1948 and 15 (1) (a), 15 (1) (b) and 15(1) (c) of the International Convention on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, 1966 themselves raise internal conflict between their own provisions respectively.

On the one hand article 27 (1) of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, 1948 and Article 15 (1) (a) and 15 (1) (b) of the International Convention on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, 1966 are concerned about public interest and on the other hand Article 27 (2) of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, 1948 and 15 (1) (c) of the International Convention on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, 1966 promote and protect the private interest. So the conflict raises in between public and private interest, broader and narrower aspects of human rights.

After the enforcement of the TRIPS Agreement, 1994 potential tension in between implementation of the TRIPs provisions and society’s realisation of social cultural and economic rights in other words rights of intellectual property rights holders and consumer rights has been increased.

The following section of the study analyses various approaches and policies to resolve the conflict between private and public interest as well as investigates whether human rights and intellectual property rights are complementary to each other.

How Complementary to One Another

To find out the answer how these two distinct areas of study complementary to one another it is essential to resolve the conflicting relation and draw a balance in between these two separate fields. In this regard it is required to analyse some important theories and approaches. These are as follows: core minimum approach, just remuneration approach and progressive realisation approach, core zone of autonomy, balancing method. It is further necessary to highlight international policies, recommendation significant in this area.

The United Nations Sub Commission on Promotion and Protection of Human Rights in its statement on intellectual property rights and human rights asserts that primacy should be given to human rights obligation to secure larger aspect of human rights over the economic policy and agreement.41

The Vienna Declaration and Progragramme of Action 1993 reaffirms that the prime objective of the government should be the promotion and protection of human rights.

At the time of implementation of the international rules in the field of intellectual property the state should be sensitive towards interest of society.42 Therefore the state can regulate property right to adjust them to meet social and economic needs.43

The TRIPs Agreement, 1994 as one of the most significant treaty in the arena of intellectual property rights in observance of human rights principles frames its objective to draw balance and promote mutual advantage of the owner of the intellectual property rights and the user.44 The objective of the TRIPs Agreement, 1994 is the advancement of technological innovation, transfer of information and dissemination of technology. Article 8 of the TRIPs Agreement provides the principle that at the time of implementation of the TRIPs provisions the member states can adopt necessary mechanisms favourable to social welfare.

In this regard the Doha Declaration on Public Health and TRIPs Agreement 200145 is very significant. The importance of the TRIPs flexibilities to address public needs has been recognised by the Doha Declaration, 2001. This Declaration also reaffirms that that the provisions of the TRIPs Agreement, 1994 should be interpreted and implemented in the supportive way to the WTO members to ensure public interest in terms of accessibility and affordability of life saving medicines for all.46

From the human rights perspective author’s or inventor’s rights are not absolute subject to condition to satisfy adequate needs, common good and welfare of society.47 That is why in return of intellectual property protection it is required to disclose detail information relating to the creation as well as the rights holder must have to address the public requirements during the tenure of protection.

Here various approaches have been discussed to resolve the conflict between the human rights and intellectual property rights.

The creator enjoys personal autonomy under the intellectual property rights to achieve creative potential, to control his material interest relates with the creation and to enjoy independent intellectual life. These are indispensible for one’s own dignity and development of personality. This is justified under the Core Zone Autonomy Approach. According to the provisions of Article 15 of the ICESCR, 1966 it is the core obligation of the state to provide protection to creator for his intellectual endeavor which ultimately serve the society as well as to secure the public interest in terms of access to essential, enjoy the scientific, technological and cultural advancement. This has been also recognised in paragraphs 30 and 31 of the General Comment 17 on Article 15 of the ICESCR, 1966. These two paragraphs emphasise that the obligation of the state is not only to prioritise commercial interest of the intellectual property rights holder but also to secure the diffusion of information, availability and accessibility of essentials. The core minimum approach shows the state’s obligation to strike a balance between private and public interest. When the core minimum approach is considered in the light of realisation of other human rights it is justified that to impose limitation on the exercise of monopoly right of proprietor.

Realisation of other human rights require permits individual to enjoy the creative work even during the tenure of protection which cannot be prohibited by the holder of intellectual property rights. In return he is entitled to economic compensation. In this regard grant of compulsory licence of essential patented medicine for social wellbeing is crucial example to curb the arbitrary exploitation of monopoly right but the owner is also compensated with just remuneration on the basis of importance of his work. Paragraph 24 of the General Comment 17 on Article 15 of the ICESCR, 1966 states about the just remuneration approach. This approach is a unique technique to stabilise the public and private interest.

The Progressive Realisation Approach has its basis in the ICESCR, 196648 under which the state is under obligation to allocate the available resources in such progressive manner so that the realisation of socio, economic cultural rights become available and affordable. The Human rights dimension of intellectual property rights shows that that the state has to secure the moral and material interest of the author or inventor for the creation of his intellectual effort parallally the state must have to guarantee the other socio economic rights of public. Human rights principles impose dual obligations upon the state to secure private interest as well as promote the interest of the society at large.

In this respect the Article 27 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, 1948 and Article 15 of the International Convention on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, 1966 are significant. From the aforesaid discussion it is shown that these two Articles of the UDHR, 1948 and the ICESCR, 1966 raise the internal conflict within their own provisions by recognizing creator’s intellectual property rights on the one hand and on the other hand securing and promoting the social interest. Irrespective of internal conflicts the said Articles49 strike a balance between individual interests and community interest. In the report of the High Commissioner on Human Rights on the Impact of the TRIPs on Human Right on 27th June 200150 the importance of maintaining equilibrium has been acknowledged. Objective of the TRIPs Agreement, 1994 as mentioned in the Article 7 also affirms the importance of balance between these two sets of interests.

The above analysis asserts that the human rights and intellectual property rights are compatible to each other. Human rights recognition of author’s, inventor’s or creator’s intellectual endeavor fosters the creative environment which results socio economic development. In consideration of recognition the proprietor has to serve the public requirement. Even during the protection period the government under certain special circumstances can use the product to meet the social need as well as permit third person to use the same.

The Human rights principles set standard to evaluate the intellectual property protection and the scope of public access. Human rights discourse of intellectual property rights always emphasises on the wider aspects of human rights that is the interest of society. The Intellectual property rights should not undermine the realisation of other economic, social and cultural rights.51 This demands a sensitive balance between the protection of intellectual creation and the public access.

Conclusion

The intellectual property rights are instrumental for advancement of society. It has immense socio economic significance. Human rights recognition of author’s and inventor’s moral and material interest is essential to encourage creators for their further creation which must have social and economical utility. Parallally in return of the intellectual property protection the owner or proprietors must have to serve the society and also must have to disclose the information regarding their brainchild which ultimately at the end of tenure become in public domain. The relationship between human rights and intellectual property rights is very dynamic. This human rights dimension of intellectual property rights presents conflict between the narrower approach of human rights that is the private monopoly right in the way of intellectual property protection and the wider approach of human rights that is the interest of society at large. The core minimum approach, just remuneration approach and progressive realisation approach, core zone of autonomy, balancing method show the constant effort to resolve the tension between the private interest and public interest and to maintain the equilibrium between these two sets of interests. Undoubtedly the human rights and intellectual property rights both are complementary to protect the interest of inventor, author as well as to secure the interest of public at large. But the promotion and protection of the social welfare is the foremost important principle of the human rights discipline.52 At the time of crisis wider aspect of human rights that means the public interest must be prevailed over the private interest means the interest of the intellectual property rights holder.

*****

Footnotes

2. . Karan Gahrana , Human Rights: A conceptual Perspective, 29, Indian Journal of International Law, 3 & 4 (July-December, 1989).

3. . Jatindra Kumar Das, Human Rights Law and Practice (PHI Learning Private Limited, Delhi, 2016).

4. . Jatindra Kumar Das,Human Rights Law and Practice (PHI Learning Private Limited, Delhi, 2016).

5. . Durga Das Basu , Human Rights in Constitutional Law (Lexis Nexis Butterworths New Delhi,2008).

6. . The United Nations General Assembly adopted the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR) on 10th December, 1948. The Preamble to the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, 1948 provides: Whereas recognition of inherent dignity and of the equal and inalienable rights of all members of the human family is the foundation of freedom, justice and peace in the world.

7. . P.L.Mehta & Meena Verma, Human Rights Under the Indian Constitution The Philosophy and Judicial Gerrymandering (Deep & Deep Publication, New Delhi 1999).

8. . Chales R. Betiz, Human Rights and Social Justice (G. Peter and Maclean Doglus (ed.) Human Rights in US Foreign Policy, Lexinton Books, Massachusetts, 1979).

9. . Dr. Sridevi Krishna and H.S. Shivakumara, Protection of Human Rights and Ensuring Social Justice_ A United Nations Perspective, 12(07) International Journal of Advanced Research (IJAR) Int. J of Adv. Res., (July 2024).

10. . Article 55 of the United Nations Charter, 1945.

11. . International Bill of Rights consist of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, 1948, the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR), 1966, the International Covenant on Economic, Social, Cultural Rights (ICESCR), 1966 and their optional protocols.

12. . The General Assembly has adopted the Universal Declaration of Human Rights on 10th December, 1948.

13. . David Bainbridge , Intellectual Property, (Fifth Edition, Pearson Education, Singapore, 2010).

14. . Colstan Catherine, Principles of Intellectual Property Law, (Cavendish Publishing Ltd. London, 1999).

15. . J. Slater, The Law relating to Copyright and Trade Marks Treated more particularly with Reference to Infringement, (Stevens and Sons, London, 1884).

16. . Holyoak and Toremans, Intellectual Property Law, (Second Edition, Butterworths, London, 1998).

17. . Dr. Peter Drahos and Queen Mary, The Universality of Intellectual Property Right: Origin and development, wipo_unhchr_ip_pnl_98_1.pdf

18. . TRIPS Agreement, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TRIPS_Agreement

19. . Dr G.B. Reddy, Intellectual Property Rights and The Law (8h Edition, Gogia Law Agency, Hydrabad, 2010).

20. . McMains R Charles., Human rights as constraint on intellectual property rights: the case of patent and plant variety protection rights, genetic resources and traditional knowledge, Chapter 13, Intellectual Property and Human Rights A Paradox, (Grosheide Willem (ed.), Edward Elgar Publishing Limited, 2010).

21. . Justin Hugos, The Philosophy of Intellectual Property, 77 Geo. L. J. 287, Dec. 1998, Georgetown Law Journal association, https://heinonline.org/HOL/Landing Page?handle=hein.journals/glj77&div=19&id=&page=

22. . Itellectual Property, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, plato.stanford.edu

23. . Article 17of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, 1948: (1) Everyone has the right to own property alone as well as in association with others(2) No one shall be arbitrarily deprived of his property.

24. . Article 27 (2) of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, 1948: Everyone has the right to the protection of the moral and material interest resulting from any scientific, literary or artistic work of which he is the author.

25. . Article 15 (1) (c) of the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, 1966 : The state parties to the present Covenant recognise the right of everyone: to benefit from the protection of the moral and material interest resulting from any scientific, literary or artistic production of which he is the author.

26. . General Commen of the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, 1966 : t 17 on Article 15 of the International Convention on Economic, Social, Cultural Rights, 1966 has been adopted by the United Nations Economic, Social, Cultural Rights Committee in its November 2005 session.

27. . Paragraph 13 of the General Comment 17.

28. . Paragraph 12 of the General Comment 17.

29. . Wendy J. Gordon, Current patent laws cannot claim the backing of human rights, chapter 9, Intellectual Property and Human Rights: A Paradox, (Williem Grosheide, (ed.) Edward Elgar Publishing Ltd. U.K., USA, 2010).

30. . Article 15 (1) of the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, 1966 : The state parties to the present Covenant recognise the right of everyone: to take part in cultural life; to enjoy the benefits of scientific progress and its applications; to benefit from the protection of the moral and material interest resulting from any scientific, literary or artistic production of which he is the author.

31. . Article 15 (2) of the International Convention on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, 1966: The steps to be taken by the state parties to the present Covenant to achieve the full realisation of this right, which shall include those necessary for the conservation, the development and diffusion of science and culture.

32. . The International Convention on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, 1966.

33. . Article 15 (3) of the International Convention on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, 1966: The state parties to the present Covenant undertake to respect the freedom indispensable for scientific research and creative activity.

34. . Article 15 (4) of the International Convention on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, 1966 : The state parties to the present Covenant recognise the benefits to be derived from the encouragement and development of international contacts and co-operative in the scientific and cultural fields.

35. . Dr. H.O. Agarwal,Human Rights, (Central Law Publications, Allahabad, 2014.

36. . Article 1 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, 1948.

37. . Shamnad Basheer and Mrinalini Kochupillai, TRIPs, Patents and Parallel Imports in India: A Proposal For Amendment, 2, Indian Journal of Intellectual Property :Law, 63-86,2009, www.ssrn.com

38. . Exhauation may be territorial, national or international.

39. . Dr. J.K. Das, Intellectual Property Rights, (First edition, Kamal Law House, Kolkata, 2008)

40. . Article 27 (1) of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, 1948: Everyone has right to freely participate in the cultural life of the community, to enjoy the arts and to share scientific advancement and its benefit.

41. .Peter k. Yu, Reconceptualizing of Intellectual Property Interests in a Human Rights Framework,Researchgate.net/publication/228169331_Reconceptualizing_Intellectual_Property_Interests_in_a_Human_Rights_Framework

42. .Philippe Cullet, Patent and Medicine: Relation between TRIPs and Human Right to Health, 79 I (2003), International Affairs, jstor.org/stable3095545

43. . Siwjela Mpaz, Human Rights and Intellectual Property Rights: Tension and Convergences, 2, The Royal Wallenberg institute New Author Series Martinus Nijhoff publishers, Leiden/Boston (2007).

44. . Article 7 of the TRIPs Agreement, 1994.

45. . WTO Fourth Ministerial conference held in Doha Qutar from 9- 13 November, 2001 and the Doha declaration on Public Health and TRIPs Agreement was adopted on 14th November 2001.

46. . Paragraph 4 of the Doha Declaration, 2001.

47. . Audrey R. A. Chapman, Human Rights Perspective on Intellectual Property, Scientific Progress and access to the benefits of science, wipo_unhchr_ip_pnl_98_5.pdf_Adobe Reader.

48. . Article 2 (1) of the International Convention on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, 1966: Each state party to the present covenant undertakes to take steps, individually and through international assistance and co-operation, specially economic and technical, to the maximum of its available resources, with a view to achieving progressively the full realisation of the rights recognised in the present Covenant by all appropriate means, including particularly the adoption of legislative measures.

49. . Article 27 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, 1948 and Article 15 of the International Convention on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, 1966.

50. . Duncan Mathews, Intellectual property rights, human rights and the tight to health, chapter 7, Intellectual Property and Human Rights: A Paradox, (Williem Grosheide,(ed.) Edward Elgar Publishing Ltd. U.K., USA, 2010)

51. . Duncan Matthews, Intellectual Property, Human Rights and Development: The Role of NGO and Social Movement, (Edward Elger Publisher Ltd. Cheltenham, Uk. Northampton Massachusctts, © 2011) .

52. . Peter Drahos, The Universality of Intellectual Property Rights: Origins and Development, WIPO Publications No. 762 (E)), wipo.int/edocs/mdocs/tk/en/wipo_unchr_ip_pnl_98/wipo_unchr_ip_pnl-98_1.pdf

How to cite

Gargi Lahiri, Human Rights and Intellectual Property Rights, 8 Int'l J.L. Mgmt. & Human. 1812 (2025).

Cite this article

Gargi Lahiri, Human Rights and Intellectual Property Rights, 8 Int'l J.L. Mgmt. & Human. 1812 (2025).
Chat with us