VidhiAagaz
International Journal ofLaw Management & Humanities
ISSN 2581-5369 · Open access
International Journal ofLaw Management & Humanities
Open accessArticlesVol. 5 No. I (2022)pp. 1077–1089

Fair Dealing Under the Copyright Law: A Critical Analysis

RB
Radhika BhusariLLM student at Symbiosis Law School, Pune, IndiaGoogle Scholar
2,316views1,140downloads
Published 24 January 2022 · pp. 1077–1089 · Vol. 5 No. I (2022)
Abstract

The Intellectual Property laws seek to promote creativity and protect creative works. The object of the copyright law is to incentivize the works of the creators. The Copyright laws grant an exclusive right to the owner of creative work, and the unauthorized use of a copyrighted work amounts to infringement of the copyright. Nevertheless, this exclusive right granted to the copyright owner over the creative works is restricted by the “Doctrine of fair dealing.” This concept allows the public to use or access the copyrighted work for specific limited purposes. Section 52 of the Act defines fair dealing and enumerates certain acts that do not amount to copyright infringement. The doctrine of fair dealing is a vital concept under the Copyright act. It aims to establish a balance between the rights bestowed upon the copyright owner and the public, but many instances have come forward where this exception is used in bad faith. Although the Indian legislature has adopted the factor analysis method as established under the U.S. copyright act, there is a difference between the two. The Indian legislation sets out an exhaustive list of provisions that come under the purview of fair dealing and, in a way, restricts the scope of its applicability. On the other hand, the U.S. has a far broader approach and hence provides an open-ended application that is robust and flexible. This paper aims at identifying the concept of fair dealing in India and fair use in the USA by identifying the difference between its application and scope.

Keywords
CopyrightExceptionsFair dealingFair useIndiaUSA

References

  1. Elizabeth Verkey, Intellectual Property Law and Practice (Eastern Book Company). Google Scholar
  2. Richard W. Stim, Intellectual Property: Patents, Trademarks, and Copyrights (Delmar Cengage Learning 2) (2020).
  3. Archana. K, An Analysis On The Principle Of Fair Dealing With Special Reference To Delhi University Photocopy Case, 7 European Journal of Molecular & Clinical Medicine (2020). Google Scholar
  4. Ayush Sharma, Indian Perspective of Fair Dealing under Copyright Law: Lex Lata or Lex Ferenda?, 14 Journal of Intellectual Property Rights , 523-531 (2009). Google Scholar
  5. Revant Ranjan, THE ‘FAIR DEALING’ EXCEPTIONS UNDER INDIAN COPYRIGHT LAW: A CRITICAL APPRAISAL, 5 South Asian Law Review Journal (2019). Google Scholar
  6. Dr. Prashant Kumar, Understanding Copyright and the Principle of Fair Use, 22 IOSR Journal of Humanities and Social Science, 104-106 (2017). Google Scholar
  7. Doctrine of Fair Dealing - Balance of Conflicting Interests Medium, https://medium.com/legis-sententia/doctrine-of-fair-dealing-balance-of-conflicting-interests-ac2ae02c7f7b (last visited Nov 13, 2021).
  8. Critical Analysis Of The Fair Dealing Provision As Under India’s Copyright Law Legalserviceindia.com, https://www.legalserviceindia.com/legal/article-4831-critical-analysi s-of-the-fair-dealing-provision-as-under-india-s-copyright-law.html (last visited Nov 13, 2021).
  9. Limits on Copyright: Doctrine of Fair Use Legal Desire, https://legaldesire.com/limits-on-copyright-doctrine-of-fair-use/ (last visited Nov 13, 2021).
  10. Concept Of Fair Use And Fair Dealing In Copyright - Intellectual Property - India Mondaq.com, https://www.mondaq.com/india/copyright/930556/concept-of-fair-use-and-fair-dealing-in-copyright (last visited Nov 13, 2021).
  11. India: “Fair Dealing” In Copyrights: Is The Indian Law Competent Enough To Meet The Current Challenges? Mondaq.com, https://www.mondaq.com/india/copyright/299252/f air-dealing-in-copyrights-is-the-indian-law-competent-enough-to-meet-the-current-challenges (last visited Nov 13, 2021).
  12. Fair Use Law in India under Copyright Act - iPleaders iPleaders, https://blog.ipleaders.in/fair-use-law-india-copyright-act/ (last visited Nov 14, 2021).
  13. Historical Development Of Law Of Copyright - Intellectual Property - India Mondaq.com, https://www.mondaq.com/india/copyright/978858/historical-development-of-law-of-copyright (last visited Nov 14, 2021).

How to cite

Radhika Bhusari, Fair Dealing Under the Copyright Law: A Critical Analysis, 5 Int'l J.L. Mgmt. & Human. 1077 (2022).

Cite this article

Radhika Bhusari, Fair Dealing Under the Copyright Law: A Critical Analysis, 5 Int'l J.L. Mgmt. & Human. 1077 (2022).
Chat with us