Introduction
Euthanasia originates from the Greek words, 'EU' signifying 'good' and 'THANATOS' signifying 'death'. Uniting these, euthanasia signifies 'the good death'51. At the point when a patient with a terminal sickness is float amongst life and demise, the estimation of a not too bad passing may be more imperative than an awkward life. States of mind toward euthanasia vary amongst people and populaces, and in many examinations the therapeutic calling is more hesitant than the overall population additionally52, it has been characterized as the "painless inducement of a quick death "53. The word euthanasia was first utilized as a part of a restorative setting by Francis Bacon in the seventeenth century, to allude to a simple, easy, cheerful demise, amid which it was a " physician’s responsibility to alleviate the ‘physical sufferings’ of the body." Bacon alluded to an “outward euthanasia "— the expression "outward" he used to recognize from an otherworldly idea—the euthanasia “which regards the preparation of the soul."54 A man who experiences euthanasia for the most part has a hopeless condition. Be that as it may, there are different cases where a few people need their life to be finished.
Euthanasia and Types
Euthanasia may be classified according to whether a person gives informed consent into three types: voluntary, non-voluntary and involuntary55
Voluntary Euthanasia
This incorporates instances of requesting help with biting the dust, declining troublesome restorative treatment, requesting therapeutic treatment to be halted, or life bolster machines to be turned off, declining to eat, essentially choosing to bite the dust.56
Involuntary Euthanasia
This happens when euthanasia is performed on a man who might have the capacity to give educated assent, however does not, either in light of the fact that they would prefer not to pass on, or on the grounds that they were not inquired. Automatic euthanasia is broadly contradicted and is viewed as a wrongdoing in all legitimate wards. Reference to it or dread of it is now and then utilized as an explanation behind not changing laws identifying with different types of euthanasia.57
Non-Voluntary Euthanasia will be euthanasia directed when the unequivocal assent of the individual concerned is inaccessible, for example, when the individual is in a constant vegetative state, or on account of youthful kids. It diverges from automatic euthanasia, when euthanasia is performed against the will of the patient.58
Euthanasia is additionally named Active and Passive Euthanasia.
"Passive Euthanasia" is normally characterized as pulling back restorative treatment with the ponder aim of causing the patient's passing. For instance, if a patient requires kidney dialysis to survive, and the specialists detach the dialysis machine, the patient will apparently pass on reasonably soon. Maybe the great case of latent euthanasia is a "don't revive arrange". Typically if a patient shows some kindness assault or comparable sudden intrusion in life capacities, restorative staff will endeavour to resuscitate them. On the off chance that they endeavour yet basically stand and watch as the patient dies, this is passive euthanasia.
"Active Euthanasia" is finding a way to cause the patient's demise, for example, infusing the patient with harm. Practically speaking, this is generally an overdose of torment executioners or resting pills.
In other words, the difference between "active" and "passive" is that in active euthanasia, something is done to end the patient's life; in passive euthanasia, something is not done that would have preserved the patient's life.
There is no personal satisfaction when the patient is dead.
Euthanasia: Pros and Cons
Pros 59
1. An End to Suffering
Individuals that are living with a terminal sickness, or that are in an irreversible trance like state, are enduring. This is particularly obvious when you take a gander toward the finish of their fight. The agony can be crippling and the main choice for these individuals are to take abundant measures of medications and painkillers to help numb the torment
Indeed, even only a tad. The personal satisfaction is greatly low. Euthanasia gives these individuals an approach to stop theirs and their family's anguish.
2. Death with Dignity
A man that is confined to bed and wiped out is helpless before attendants, therapeutic staff, and family for things like eating, utilizing the restroom, evolving garments, and washing. This can be exceptionally debasing for a man, and many would prefer not to be a weight or recalled by their family in such a way. Giving them the chance to pick when they pass on and how amazing them take control of their own life, and the capacity to state what they need to state or improve the situation their family before their demise.
3. Frees Up Funds and Equipment
At death's door patients, or individuals that are in irreversible trance like states, utilize a substantial segment of the restorative financing accessible. This is likewise valid for space that is accessible in the healing centres and care offices. While this is in no way, shape or form a decent method to take a gander at it, it is essentially an additional advantage of euthanasia. These individuals, rather than putting in weeks, months, or even years utilizing these assets, could bite the dust in peace all while sparing cash and space for the healing centres.
4. The Freedom to Choose
No one needs to be helpless before any other individual, particularly not an infection or affliction that has controlled your life for so long. The greatest advantage of euthanasia is just having a decision. It returns individuals responsible for their own particular life, when it is important the most. This gives individuals an extraordinary feeling of peace and seek after their family.
Cons60
1. Devalues Human Lives
By enabling our specialists to effectively "murder" individuals, they will start to consider euthanasia to be an answer and it will start to be abused. This additionally gives the impression to different spots and youthful kids that the human life has a lesser esteem.
2. Religious and Ethical Problems
A standout amongst the most widely recognized raised subjects in the euthanasia wrangle about is that of religion. The greater part, if not all, religions have extremely strict perspectives on taking lives, particularly your own. It is seen as one of a definitive sins against God. The view that taking an existence all in all is likewise well known, even without the mention of religion.
3. Corruption of the Worst Kind
There are colossal costs engaged with the care of in critical condition patients or patients that who are in the phase of trance like state. These important assets are spared in an incredible sum if a man takes an interest in doctor helped suicide. This could incite healing facilities and specialists to start utilizing euthanasia as a methods for cash sparing, which could bring about individuals that have not concurred, being killed.
4. Debating For Euthanasia:
• We need it -.'The compassion argument' Supporters of euthanasia trust that enabling individuals to 'pass on with pride' is kinder than constraining them to proceed with their lives with misery.
• We want it 'the autonomy argument'-. Some trust that each patient has a privilege to pick when to pass on.
• We can control it -'the public policy argument'. Defenders trust that euthanasia can be securely directed by government enactment.61
5. Debating Against Euthanasia:
• Euthanasia debilitates the general public's regard for the sacredness of life.
• Accepting euthanasia resembles with respect to individuals' life not commendable any more.
• Gives a lot of energy to the specialists and giving them a chance to choose when the patient's life does not merit living. In Netherlands, amid 1990s around 1,000 individuals were murdered without their assent.
• This will dishearten the inquiry and innovation of new treatment and medicals for the patients.
Euthanasia around the world
1. Netherlands
In April 2002, the Netherlands turned into the primary nation to sanction euthanasia and helped suicide. It forced a strict arrangement of conditions: the patient must endure insufferable torment, their sickness must be serious, and the request must be made in "full consciousness" by the patient. In 2010, 3,136 individuals were given a deadly mixed drink under restorative supervision.
Alleged palliative sedation has additionally turned into a far reaching practice in healing centers, with 15,000 cases every year since 2005, as indicated by the Royal Dutch Medical Association. Patients with a future of two weeks or less are placed in a therapeutically instigated trance like state, and all nourishment and hydration is pulled back.
The enactment has incited a furious verbal confrontation over the "right to suicide," in light of the fact that assisted suicideoutside of the criteria set for euthanasia is as yet illicit and is considered as homicide.62
2. France
France does not have a particular law prohibiting assisted suicide, but rather such a case could be prosecuted under 223-6 of the French Penal Code63 for inability to help a man in risk. Feelings are uncommon and disciplines minor. France bans all productions that prompt on suicide - 'Final Exit' has been prohibited since 1991 however few these days take any notice of the request.64
3. Germany and Switzerland
In German-talking nations, the expression "euthanasia" is for the most part maintained a strategic distance from in light of its relationship with the eugenicist strategies of the Nazi time. The law consequently has a tendency to recognize assisted suicide and " active assisted suicide” In Germany and Switzerland,– active assisted suicide i.e. a specialist recommending and giving over a deadly medication – is illicit. Be that as it may, German and Swiss law allows assisted suicide inside specific conditions. In Germany, assisted suicide is lawful as long as the deadly medication is taken with no assistance, for example, somebody managing or supporting the patient's hand. In Switzerland, the law is more casual: it permits assisted suicide insofar as there are no “self-seeking motives “included. Switzerland has endured the formation of associations, for example, Dignities and Exit, which give helped biting the dust administrations to an expense.
4. Belgium
Belgium passed a law in 2002 sanctioning euthanasia, turning into the second nation on the planet to do as such. The law says doctors can help patients to end their lives when they freely express a wish to die because they are suffering intractable and unbearable pain. Patients can likewise get euthanasia on the off chance that they have plainly expressed it before entering a trance like state or comparative vegetative state.
Assisted suicide isn't specified in the law, which does not indicate a technique for euthanasia. As Jacqueline Herremans, leader of the Association for the Right to Die with Dignity says: “We don't make a distinction in the semantics...” However, the doctor must be available at the bedside of the patient to their final gasp, dissimilar to the Oregon demonstrate where the specialist gives just the remedy of medications.
5. United States of America
Euthanasia is unlawful in the vast majority of the United States. Physician aid in dying (PAD), or assisted suicide, is legal in the states of Washington DC, California, Colorado, Oregon, Vermont, and Washington. Its status is disputed in Montana its status is questioned in Montana. The key distinction amongst euthanasia and assisted suicide is who directs the deadly measurement of pharmaceutical: Euthanasia involves the doctor or another outsider managing the medicine, though assisted suicide requires the patient to self-control the drug and to decide if and when.
6. Colombia
Colombia's Constitutional Court in 1997 affirmed restorative willful euthanasia yet its parliament has never confirmed it. These days’ specialists there every now and again do - attentively - help enduring terminal individuals to kick the bucket at their demand.
7. Uruguay
In Uruguay it seems a person must appear in court, yet Article 27 of the Penal Code (effective 1934) says: "The judges are authorized to forego punishment of a person whose previous life has been honourable where he commits a homicide motivated by compassion, induced by repeated requests of the victim." As far as is known, there have been no legal sentences for kindness slaughtering in Uruguay.
"Euthanasia is a long, smooth-sounding word, and it conceals its danger as long, smooth words do, but the danger is there, nevertheless."... American creator Pearl S. Buck.
Euthanasia Statistics and Opinion Polls65
Euthanasia Statistics
• Total level of therapeutic professionals that help Euthanasia -54%
• Percent of open who bolster euthanasia for the in critical condition/in a coma 86%
• Average percent of critically ill patients who bite the dust in torment 55%
• Total number of years Dr. Jack Kevorkian served in jail for Physician Assisted Suicide - 8yrs
• Total number of spots that straightforwardly and legitimately authorize active assistance in dying (Oregon, Switzerland, Belgium, Netherlands) - 4
• Number of individuals killed each day by assisted suicide in Belgium -5
• Total number of biggest gathering (Right-to-Die) that have paid supporters (Japanese) of rights to assisted suicide-100,000
Euthanasia Opinion Poll
• Percent of individuals who bolster Euthanasia-42%
• Percent of individuals who restricted Euthanasia -37%
• Percent of individuals who were uncertain about Euthanasia-22%
• Percent who replied "Strongly Support" Euthanasia-28%
• Percent who replied "Moderately Support" Euthanasia-28%
• Percent who replied "Moderately Oppose" Euthanasia-14%
• Percent who reply "Strongly Oppose" Euthanasia-23%
• Percent of Democrats who bolster Euthanasia-47%
Euthanasia: An aspect from the Indian Context
India has amalgamated its constitution by alluding to the suggestions of different nations, and the courts have been now and again alluding to various outside choices.
In India, euthanasia is unquestionably unlawful. In the vast majority of the occurrences of euthanasia or benevolence murdering, there is dependably an aim with respect to the specialist to execute the patient. Therefore, such cases would doubtlessly fall under Section 300(1) of the Indian Penal Code, 1860.
“Except in the cases hereinafter excepted, culpable homicide is murder, if the act by which the death is caused is done with the intention of causing death, or—
(Secondly) —If it is done with the intention of causing such bodily injury as the offender knows to be likely to cause the death of the person to whom the harm is caused, or—
(Thirdly) —If it is done with the intention of causing bodily injury to any person and the bodily injury intended to be inflicted is sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death, or—
(Fourthly) —If the person committing the act knows that it is so imminently dangerous that it must, in all probability, cause death or such bodily injury as is likely to cause death, and commits such act without any excuse for incurring the risk of causing death or such injury as aforesaid.”
On the other hand, as in such cases, if there is the legal assent of the withdrew, at that point, Exception 5 u/s 300 of IPC, 186066 would be immersed. The specialist or any benevolence executioner would be subject to discipline under Section 304 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860, for the at fault manslaughter, not adding up to kill. Be that as it may, this special case is pertinent just in instances of deliberate euthanasia (where the patient agrees to death). The instances of automatic and non-deliberate euthanasia would be counteracted by the principal stipulations to Section 92 of the IPC, which peruses that, “This exception shall not extent to the abetment of any offence, to the committing of which offence it would not extend” and thus is considered illegal.
The advisability of permitting euthanasia is one of the passionately debated issues in many countries including India. Euthanasia can be active or passive. The former involves doing something to hasten the death of a person. Unless expressly permitted by law, it is clearly a crime and is treated as a crime in most of the countries. Passive euthanasia, on another hand, involves refusing to do something to (or “intending to”) keep the person alive. This is understood that in Gian Kaur v. State of Punjab67 , 21st March 1996 the Supreme Court, while holding that right to life did not include the right to die, did not categorically rule out the permissibility of passive euthanasia. Either variety of euthanasia is sought to be justified in the case of a person who is terminally ill since a long period of time, and all hopes of his recovery are ruled out. In most cases, the patients are found to have lost their consciousness and their life is prolonged quite often by artificial means. It is argued, that it is better to let such a person die so that he gets relieved of misery and pain in a dignified way.
1. Indian Constitution remain on Euthanasia
In the prompt case, Aruna Ramchandra was observed to live in a lasting vegetative state however her brain was observed to be functioning a bit. She had no relations and was being dealt with by the KEM doctor's facility staff in Mumbai where she had been functioning as a nurse earlier. The healing center staff was sincerely appended to her and did not need her to be left incredible. The care taken by the staff was observed to be radiant. A social dissident had moved the Court, however it was held that she didn't have a locus remaining in the issue. Nonetheless, the case drove a two-judge seat of the Supreme Court comprising of Markandey Katju and Gyan Sudha Mishra, JJ. to give profound thought to the entire issue of allowing euthanasia.
The seat precluded dynamic euthanasia however held that passive euthanasia might be permitted in appropriate cases subject to specific precautionary measures. On the off chance that the patient is cognizant his/her own particular wishes must be considered. Then again, if the patient is in coma, the desires of close relatives (spouse, guardians, children and others) must be considered. On the off chance that no close connection is accessible or is inevitable the following companion, as in the present case the KEM healing center staff can step up. At that point the issue needs to go to the High Court, and a seat of no less than two judges needs to make the choice. The seat is to constitute a group of three capable specialists to look at the patient. Moreover, the seat ought to likewise discover the perspectives of the State and the close relations of the patient. The Supreme Court decided that this technique ought to be taken after until the point when Parliament had administered on the issue.
Justice PB Swanat “If the purpose of the prescribed punishment is to prevent prospective suicides by deterrence, it‘s hard to understand how the same can be achieved by punishing those who have made the attempts. those who make the suicide attempt on account of mental disorder requires psychiatric treatment and not confinement in the prison cells where their condition is bound to worsen leading to further mental derangement. those on the other hand, who make a suicide attempt on account of actual physical ailments, incurable disease, torture (broken down by illness), and deceit physical state induced by old age or disablement, need nursing home and not prison to prevent them from making the attempts again. No deterrence is going to hold back those who want to die for a special or political cause or to leave the world either because of the loss of interest in life or for self- deliverance. Thus in no case does the punishment serve the purpose and in some cases it is bound to prove self-defeating and counter-productive.
The Union Government of India has given a decision to decriminalize suicide. It is to be noted that all the cases under Section 309 of IPC, 1860 which denotes that “Whoever attempts to suicide and does any act towards the commission of such offence shall be punished with simple imprisonment for a term which may extend to one year or with fine or both”.
2. Aruna Shanbaug Case– A New Dimension in the Indian Legal Context68
In a judgment, the Supreme Court on account of Aruna Ramchandra Shanbaug v. Union of India, seventh March 2011, opened the portal for approval of aloof euthanasia.
The Court rejected the appeal to record in the interest of Aruna Shanbaug and watched that inactive euthanasia was reasonable under the supervision of law in a remarkable situation yet dynamic euthanasia was still not allowed under the law. The Court likewise recommended decriminalizing the endeavor to suicide by revoking the discipline gave in Section 309 of the Indian Penal Code.
A choice must be taken to stop life bolster either by the guardians or the spouse or other close relatives, or without any of them, such a choice can be taken even by a man or an assortment of people going about as a next companion. It can likewise be made by the specialists going to the patient. In any case, the choice ought to be made true blue to the greatest advantage of the patient. Regardless of whether a choice is taken by the close relatives or specialists or next companion to pull back life bolster, such a choice requires endorsement from the High Court concerned. At the point when such an application is filled, the Chief Justice of the High Court ought to forthwith constitute a Bench of no less than two Judges who should choose to allow endorsement or not. A board of trustees of three rumoured specialists to be designated by the Bench, who will give a report with respect to the state of the patient. Before giving the decision, a notice with respect to the report ought to be given to the nearby relatives and the State. In the wake of hearing the gatherings, the High Court can give its decision.
The question whether Article 21 includes right to die or not first came into consideration in the case State of Maharashtra v. Maruti Shripathi Dubal 69 , 25th September 1986. It was held in this case by the Bombay High Court that ‘right to life’ also includes ‘right to die’ and Section 309 was struck down. The court clearly said in this case that right to die is not unnatural; it is just uncommon and abnormal. Also the court mentioned about many instances in which a person may want to end his life. This was upheld by the Supreme Court in the case P. Rathinam v. Union of India70 , 26th April 1984. However in the case Gian Kaur v. State of Punjab, it was held by the five judge bench of the Supreme Court that the “right to life” guaranteed by Article 21 of the Constitution does not include the “right to die”. The court clearly mentioned in this case that Article 21 only guarantees right to life and personal liberty and in no case can the right to die be included in it.71
3. Law Commission Report72
The Draft Bill, which was proposed in the 241st Report of Law Commission, manages the subject of aloof euthanasia and will of living, a deed in which a man expresses his or her desire to have or not to have uncommon life broadening measures utilized when recuperation from the infection isn't conceivable. On the off chance that acknowledged, the Medical Council of India (MCI) will have a dynamic part in the law. The MCI would define and issue systems for medicinal specialists in the matter of withholding or pulling back the restorative treatment to an equipped or an inept patient experiencing an ailment that is terminal and can't be dealt with.
Religion and Euthanasia73
Most religions object to willful extermination. Some of them totally restrict it. The Roman Catholic Church, for instance, is a standout amongst the most dynamic associations in restricting willful extermination.
For all intents and purposes all religions express that the individuals who wind up plainly helpless through sickness or handicap merit uncommon care and security, and that appropriate end of life mind is a greatly improved thing than willful extermination.
Religions are against euthanasia for various reasons.
1. Religious perspectives on euthanasia:
Buddhism, Christian, Roman, Catholic, Hindu, Islam, Judaism, Sikhism are a few religions chatting on Euthanasia.
• God has taboo it.
• Virtually all religions with an incomparable God have an order from God in their sacred texts that says 'you should not slaughter'.
• This is generally deciphered as signifying 'you should not murder pure individuals'.
• This discounts euthanasia (and suicide) and additionally kill, as completing any of these future against God's requests, and would be an assault on the power of God.
2. Human life is hallowed
• Human lives are unique since God made them.
• Therefore human life ought to be secured and safeguarded, whatever happens.
• Therefore we shouldn't meddle with God's designs by shortening human lives.
3. Human life is uncommon
• Human creatures are made in God's picture.
• Therefore they have an uncommon esteem and poise.
• This esteem doesn't rely upon the nature of a specific life ending an existence disregards that uncommon esteem and respect.
• Even if it's one's own particular life regardless of whether that life is brimming with agony and enduring.
4. Eastern religions
Adopt an alternate strategy. The key thoughts in their states of mind to death are accomplishing flexibility from mortal life, and not-hurting living creatures. Euthanasia obviously clashes with the second of these, and it meddles with the first.
5. Freedom from mortal life
Hinduism and Buddhism see mortal life as a major aspect of a proceeding with cycle in which we are conceived, live, pass on, and are renewed again and again. A definitive point of each being is to get free of this cycle, as be totally freed from the material world amid each cycle of life and demise. Thusly they say that we should endeavor to abstain from hurting living things this tenets out murdering individuals, regardless of whether they need to bite the dust.
6. The sacredness of life
Religious individuals frequently allude to the sacredness of life, or say that human life is consecrated. They generally mean something like this: God gives individuals life, so just God has the privilege to take it away.
We can take a gander at this sentence in three distinctive ways;
• God gave us our lives
• We owe our lives to God
• God is the last expert over our lives
God is personally associated with our lives. God was personally engaged with our births. God will be personally engaged with our passings.
Conclusion
"Life and demise is given by God and we ought not to endeavor to come in the middle of God's cycle", sufficiently reasonable. Indeed, even we concur that euthanasia you or giving somebody a chance to help you with that is a wrongdoing yet would it say it isn't miscreant to give a man a chance to bite the dust each day? In the event that a man is in such a vegetative state and in no plausibility of making due, than even God will consent to give that individual a chance to have a tranquil passing than for what reason can't our law? Life is a wonderful gift surely however when the gift turns into a weight and body surrenders totally, than there's no point of keeping a man alive when they can't carry on with this life and will never ready to. One simple demise will resemble a gift for a man who's withering each day and if the specialist causes the individual to kick the bucket in the wake of taking his/her assent than he shouldn't be ordered as a criminal since he isn't perpetrating a transgression rather being a holy messenger for the individual biting the dust each day still not dead. Article 21 of our Indian Constitution characterizes Right to Life, Right to Live with Human Dignity, Right to Livelihood, Right to Medical care, Right to Health, at that point for what reason not Right to Die? Isn't this a privilege of an Indian national and if not then would it say it isn't ought to be? We are guided by law to think about our do's and don'ts. We are given different rights; can't a man enduring so seriously have a privilege to pass on? Minor demise of a man alone wish isn't against any law and ought not to be so. Nations like Netherlands, Oregon and other people who has authorized it as great demise, and a nation like India who adjusts the western learning, western culture, western instruction and even our Indian Constitution is obtained from each fragment of the world, at that point for what reason not Euthanasia?
*****
Footnotes
51. Helga Kuhse , Euthanasia Fact Sheet, The World Federation of Right to Die Societies <http://www.worldrtd.net/euthanasia-fact-sheet.>
52. Karlsaon M, Attitude against euthanasia among Swedish medical students, NCBI, <https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17942500>
53. Kohl, Marvin, The Morality of Euthanasia, New York: Humanities Press, 1974, p.94. A similar definition is offered by Blackburn (1994) with "the action of causing the quick and painless death of a person, or not acting to prevent it when prevention was within the agent’s powers.
54. Brian Vickers, Francis Bacon: the Major Works, Oxford World’s Classics, Oxford University Press, USA, 2008, p. 630.
55. . R. W. Perrett. "Buddhism, euthanasia and the sanctity of life", Journal of Medical Ethics 22 (5): October 1996, pp. 309–13. See also Hugh LaFollette, Ethics in Practice: an Anthology. Oxford: Blackwell, 2002, pp. 25–26.
56. Voluntary and involuntary Euthanasia, BBC, http://www.bbc.co.uk/ethics/euthanasia/overview/volinvol.shtml.
57. Involuntary Euthanasia, Wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Involuntary_euthanasia.
58. Non-voluntary euthanasia, Wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-voluntary_euthanasia.
59. 7 Important Euthanasia Pros and Cons, Flow Psychology, https://flowpsychology.com/7-important-euthanasia-pros-and-cons/.
60. 7 Important Euthanasia Pros and Cons, Flow Psychology, https://flowpsychology.com/7-important-euthanasia-pros-and-cons/.
61. Arguments for and against, Care, https://www.care.org.uk/our-causes/sanctity-life/arguments-for-and-against-euthanasia.
62. Euthanasia and assisted suicide laws around the world, The Guardian, https://www.theguardian.com/society/2014/jul/17/euthanasia-assisted-suicide-laws-world.
63. anyone who willfully fails to render to a person in danger any assistance which, without risk to himself or to third parties, he could render him either by his own action or by initiating rescue operations....’ is punishable by imprisonment and fine."
64. World laws on assisted suicide, ERGO, http://www.finalexit.org/assisted_suicide_world_laws_page2.html.
65. Static Brain, Static Brain, http://www.statisticbrain.com/euthanasia-statistics/.
66. Culpable homicide is not murder when the person whose death is caused, being above the age of eighteen years, suffers death or takes the risk of death with his own consent.
67. Gian Kaur v. State of Punjab A.I.R. 1996 SC 946.
68. Aruna Ramachandra Shanbaug v. Union of India, (2011) 4 SCC 454.
69. Maruti Shripati Dubal v. State Of Maharashtra 1987 (1) BomCR 499.
70. P.Rathinam vs. Union of India 1994 SCC (3) 394.
71. Mohita & Aman Chibber, Euthanasia and Human Rights, Legal Service India
72. Law Commission of India Report, 11 Aug., 2011.
73. Religion and Euthanasia, BBC, http://www.bbc.co.uk/ethics/euthanasia/religion/religion.shtml.
