INTRODUCTION
“If You Wish For Peace Cultivate Justice”2
Cooperative trade liberalization facilitates development and socio-economic integration. In the interwar period, the first ILO Director Albert Thomas proposed a visionary synthesis of an emerging “world economy” and “new economic organization” in which labour protections and free trade are complementary3. Over the years various multilateral regulations and inter-governmental cooperation have been adopted to achieve the said objective employing mutual help and interdependence.
In 1944 Declaration of Philadelphia, the ILO noted the objective utilization of world’s productive resources, including the measures to promote a high and steady volume of international trade, and pledged ILO cooperation in such new international bodies as may be entrusted with these responsibilities4. In 1945, when UN Charter was drafted and approved one of the provisions called for the United Nations to promote “a higher standard of living, full employment, conditions of socio-economic progress and development5. These and other milestones over several decades set the stage for the decision by the U.N. Economic and Social Council in 1946 to convene a conference on Trade and Employment. The Governments saw trade and employment as twin issues linked in both economics and law6. As a result of across the board deliberation the Havana Charter for an International Trade Organization put employment first with a chapter on “Employment and Economic Activity”. The core commitment was to maintain full and productive employment and large and steadily growing demand within own territory through measures appropriate to its political, economic and social institution”7. Furthermore, the ITO was authorized to initiate consultation among governments for appropriate measures against the international spread of decline in employment, production or demand. The ITO does not come into existence resulting in GATT as the provisional mechanism. However, GATT does not have any principal provision as to labour standard. And the void as to social clause for the regulation of labour standard sustains.
(A) Statement of problem:
The linkage of trade with the labour essentially involves the idea of fairness in terms of trade concessions and comparative price advantage. Labour standards are primarily a matter of Human Rights which has been addressed in 1998, the 86th International Labour Conference resulting in the adoption of Declaration on Fundamental Principles and Rights at Work and identified eight conventions as fundamental principles and rights at work which all members have an obligation to implement even if not ratified. The standards embodied in these conventions have been called "Core Labour Standards". These Core labour issues enjoy a high degree of support and ratification.
Therefore, the point of controversy is not on desirability of standards but on the suitable forum for addressing them. The labour trade integration is all about the realization of labour standard instead of identifying it. It becomes much more complex when the implementation process involves stakeholders with the divergent share in the international economic field. It becomes much more cumbersome when the stakeholders involved are driven much by politics and protectionist measure instead of complying with the labour standard. Further, the debate for the inclusion of Social clause in WTO has a long history. It started with the Tokyo round of negotiation, spearheaded by many developed Country, and continued to Doha Round of trade negotiation. In the Doha Round, ministerial Conference concluded that “We reaffirm our declaration made at the Singapore Ministerial Conference regarding internationally recognised Core Labour standards. We take note of the work underway in the International Labour Organisation (ILO) on the social dimension of globalization”. Thus, it reaffirmed the lack of consensus on the inclusion of social clause and perpetuated debate. However, one thing that can be noted here is the active involvement of developing countries over the global trade agenda instead of passive bystanders.
Thus, the record of effort to construct the official link between trade agreement obligations and labour standard has thus been marked more by the failure than success. However, given the proportion, obligations, and consequences there is the rapid increase in regional and bilateral agreements on trade and labour integration than multilaterally.
(B) Research Questions:
• What limitation does ILO have to enforce the labour standard?
• Whether the present WTO structure particularly GATT is sufficient to enforce labour standard?
• What methodologies could be adopted by the WTO to enforce the labour standard?
(C) Hypothesis:
The economic prosperity of countries in the world is highly dependent on international trade. Therefore, trade can be potent tool for enforcing the humanitarian standard.
(D) Objectives of study:
The rapid increase of liberalization has led to the expansion of export-driven economic policy. It has rigorously strengthened the manufacturing sector of a country. However, it does not artificially improve the cluster of basic rights of persons involved therein. Therefore, the researcher advances for the effective institutionalized system to monitor the rights of the roots of industry i.e labours. A promise withheld from them for too long.
(E) Scope of the study:
Researcher addresses the labour standard debate between ILO and WTO by resorting only to the GATT agreement and not the other agreement of WTO due to paucity of time.
(F) Research Methodology:
The researcher will be resorting to the doctrinal methodology for research employing historical, analytical and comparative approach. The researcher will be studying primary documents such as ILO regulation, the text of WTO instruments particularly GATT and secondary source of study including articles published in a different journal, books.
ILO- AN ORGANIZATION WITH A LIMITATION
The controversial debate of inclusion of labour standard in WTO is marred with the arguments for the inclusion and non-inclusion of the labour standard. Proponents argue that the inclusion of labour standard will avoid unfair trade advantage and race to the bottom among the country relying on the labour intensive market. While, the critics of trade-labour linkage argue that 'Labour standards have no place in the World Trade Organisation (WTO) because it is an organisation that exists primarily to promote mutually beneficial, non-coercive trade through reciprocal and mutually advantageous arrangements aimed at reducing barriers to trade. These critics suggest that the subject of core labour standards should be dealt exclusively by the International Labour Organisation8 (ILO). However, critics fail to recognize that the WTO Agreement makes reference to 'sustainable development' as one of its objectives which must, therefore, be balanced against other economic objectives. ILO is a tripartite organization responsible for maintaining uniformity in the labour standard. Till date it has adopted 188 binding convention and approximately 200 non-binding resolution. However the statics of the enforcement of labour standard presents an inconsistent picture9. There are various reasons presented for under-enforcement. Firstly, low rate of ratification of treaties which in-turn create patchwork of inconsistent legal obligation resulting in impediment to the global enforcement of labour standards. Secondly, soft approach of ILO towards the complain of enforcement of labour standard relying on public identification, embarrassment and shaming and technical assistance to promote compliance notwithstanding authorization of sanction by the ILO constitution in the event of non-compliance.
One of the contemporary example of such limitation can be seen Myanmar10 episode, which ILO has considered for 30 years and ultimately the inhibition agaist it was manifested much appropriately through political repressive existing in Myanmar instead of ILO declaration11 . In Myanmar there was rampant existence of forced labour both for public and private. A formal complaint was made in that regard by twenty-five worker delegates to ILO Commission of Inquiry. The commission of inquiry investigated and found extensive violations of the Forced Labor Convention, declared the incident as the “saga of untold misery and suffering, oppression and exploitation of large sections of the population inhabiting Myanmar by the Government, military and other public officers.” The Commission of Inquiry made several recommendations, namely
• that Myanmar’s government should bring several of its laws into compliance with the Forced Labor Convention by May 1, 1999 at the latest;
• That Myanmar should publicly renounce the practice of forced labor and take concrete steps to eliminate it in all its forms and
• That it should strictly enforce a long-neglected provision of the Myanmar Penal Code that provides for the prosecution and punishment of those who exact forced labor.
• The Governing Body take action under Article 33 of the ILO Constitution.
The commission has also for the first time in ILO history directed that the International Labor Conference should “take such action as it may deem wise and expedient to secure compliance” by Myanmar with the recommendations and with Myanmar’s obligations under Convention Number 29 on Forced Labor. However, even after such recommendation Myanmar remained non-compliant with the convention and ILO continues to report that the forced and compulsory labour remains prevalent in many areas of the country in the circumstances of severe cruelty and brutality. Neither did any country initiated and sanction against Myanmar products rather some of the member states such as China and India continued in the trade engagement with the Myanmar while EU’s and Australia trade restriction only target military junta and their family members.
In November 2010, the ILO reported that very few of the recommendations from the Commission of Inquiry had been effectively implemented. Statistics on compliance with CLS provide further testimony as to the need for a stronger enforcement mechanism. Simply put, it is a generally accepted fact that large numbers of violations of CLS occur every day. For instance, the ILO estimates that 153 millon children aged five to fourteen are engaged in child labor, including an estimated fifty-three million in hazardous work. Furthermore, child labor makes up approximately 26% of the total workforce in Africa, with one in four children engaged in child labor (approximately sixty-five to eighty million children) and 15% of all Sub-Saharan African children engaged in some form of hazardous work. In Asia, an estimated one in eight children are child laborers, with a total of 5.6% of Asian children engaged in hazardous work.
Thus, the weak enforcement mechanism ILO advocates for the incorporation of labour standard in GATT. Moreover, it is often alleged potent enforcement mechanism of WTO is exceedingly inadequate, non-transparent and biased based on the view that it is working exclusively to aid business interest at the expense of competing public objectives. Therefore to sustain its legitimacy and importance it is imperative for WTO to incorporate the non-trade issues such as labour standard.
HISTORICAL DEVELOPMENT OF DEBATE12
The linkage of trade and labour dates back to the end of Ist World War and conclusion of treaty of Versailles . The treaty made government responsible to secure humane condition of work at their home country and in all the country wherein they enter in commercial engagement. The provision as unfair labour condition is also stipulated in Article 7 of Havana Charter. IT also stipulated consultation between the ITO and the ILO on all the matters of labour. When the ITO failed to achieve ratification, this direct link between the enforcement of labour standards and the trade rules was lost. However, it again came into deliberation with the series of negotiation from Tokyo to Doha Ministerial Conference.
(A) The Tokyo Round of Negotiation to Doha Ministerial Conference
During the Tokyo round of negotiation for the first inclusion of non-tariff barrier was debated. The developed country taking advantage of the debate succinctly advocated for inclusion of labour standatd along side non tariff barrier. However, the real intention for their advocacy was motivated by desire to curb the eastern country share in global debate rather than fair trade. However, due to strong opposition from developing country it was not realized and further deliberated in Uruguay Round Of negotiation. In Uruguay Round developed countries particularly US, Switzerland and some European Member forcibly contended for the explicit recognition of labour standard in the final Act of the conference that gave birth to WTO. However, there are some important issues which need to be deliberated and issue of labour standard left unanswered. But the trade Negotiating Committee left the issue open for possible future discussion13. Further, the issue again came for deliberation in Singapore ministerial conference. Developed country particularly US and Norway advocated for the establishment of a working group so as the study the relationship between ILO and WTO. The matter was again opposed by the developing country. However, this time several industrial country tried to find a middle way for it. It was declared that
“We renew our commitment to the observance of internationally recognized core labour standards. The International Labour Organization is the competent body to set and deal with these standards, and we affirm our support for its work in promoting them. We believe that economic growth and development fostered by increased trade and further trade liberalization contribute to the promotion of these standards. We reject the use of labour standards for protectionist purposes, and agree that the comparative advantage of countries, particularly low-wage developing countries, must in no way be put into question...”14
Thus, declaration was interpreted as not establishing a relationship between trade nad labour standard . It has only identified ILO as a competent body to set and deal with labour standard .
Further, the matter was deliberated in Geneva Ministerial Conference and Seattle ministerial Conference wherein the US and EU were in the forefront. However, due to lack of consensus as to labour standard Seattle Conference failed. Moreover, one point which became clear after Seattle failure was labour issue on WTO agenda will distract attention and energies away from market access negotiation of developing Country . Again in the Doha Round wherein it was reiterated that
“We reaffirm our declaration made at Singapore Ministerial Conference regarding internationally recognised core labour standards. We take note of the work under way in the International Labour Organisation (ILO) on the social dimension of globalisation.” 15
Compatibility and limitation
The fundamental impediment in the enforcement of core labour standard through GATT lies in core principles of GATT16 . For instance MFN principle17, it’s unconditional requirement advocate for avoidance of distinguishing the product on the basis of labour standard of exporting country and identification of likeness of the product on the basis of consumer taste and preferences(EC Asbestos case). Thus the information of consumer is the determining factor. Moreover, even if likeness of the product is proven it is imperative that un-favorable treatment to the domestic products need to be established so as to establish violation of Article III (4). And considering specific labour srandard this condition is impossible to satisfy.
Further, there is only one explicit mention of labour standard via exception in GATT article 20(e). It provide an opportunity to the contracting party to exclude the products of prison labour. The provision was incorporated in GATT 1994 in the same form as provided in GATT 1947 and without considering the provision specified in Human Right Convention in 1947 on suppression of slave and on forced labour and without considering the suggestion of providing an extensive interpretation to the expression ‘Prison Labour’. Moreover, the provision explicitly mentions products of prison labour rather than conditions of the labour under which they were produced. Thereby, pointing out the exclusion of production method of product (Diller and levy, 1997).Thus, Article 20(e) emphasizes on product that led to trade distortion not on the process through which product was produced. (Muntarbhorn, 1998).
Keeping in view the abovementioned limitation other provision of exception provided in Article 20 can invoked such as Article 20(a) and Article 20(b)
• necessary to protect public morals
• necessary to protect human, animal or plant life or health
(A) Necessary to protect Public morals18
The Panel in United States — Measures Affecting the Cross-Border Supply of Gambling and Betting Services (‘US — Gambling’) stated that ‘the term “public morals” denotes standards of right and wrong conduct maintained by or on behalf of a community or nation. In China — Measures Affecting Trading Rights and Distribution Services for Certain Publications and Audiovisual Entertainment Products, the Panel treated the term public morals as an evolutionary one, observing that ‘the content and scope of the concept of “public morals” can vary from Member to Member, as they are influenced by each Member’s prevailing social, cultural, ethical and religious values even for the matter of Human Rights it has been interpreted broadly so as to whole range of Human Right instruments .
Thus, public morality cannot be relied in absolute manner for enforcement of labour standard as it differ from country to country and due to lack of uniformity as to public morality.
(B) Necessary to protect human, animal or plant life or health19.
As pointed in shrimp turtle case that exception of GATT should be read in evolutionary approach keeping in view the contemporary concerns of community at large. The phrase ‘health and human could be interpreted to include labour standard including their physical, psychological health and wellbeing. However, the conclusive interpretation as to exception rest with the panel and appellate Body. This interpretation is conducted rigorously taking account of all available evidence, including enacting member view, legislative history and other evidences as to measure in question.
Further, any member invoking the exception must satisfy the first satisy the requirement of exception invoked and then requirements specified in chapeau. Two precondition set out in the chapeau are. First the member must show that its measure is not applied in a manner that constitutes an arbitrary or unjustified discrimination between the country where same condition prevail. Secondly, any measure must not amount to disguised restriction on trade. Thus the chapeau emphasizes on the application of the measure adopted.
However, it is often seen trade measure designed to protect human Rights act as protectionist measure. For instance US-Gambling Case
SUGGESTION
ILO and WTO should work co-jointly20 and labor standards should be set by WTO and ILO according to the level of development and subject to the standards at issue having the predominate determining voices in standard-setting. This would level the playing field among comparable nations, helping to eliminate the incentive to compete by lowering labor standards and encouraging, via the types of incentives described below, the raising of them. This would not only assist in improving labor standards where poverty is widespread, but would also help to prevent lowering of labor standards by industrialized nations seeking to compete with one another. Establishing differing standards would not be simple, but is not impossible.
Carrot and stick method as to the enforcement of labour standard
Traditional methodology such as shaming or withholding technical assistance as to the enforcement of labour standard is only effective between country of same level of development than between the country occupying different of development.
Secondly, labour standard of developing or least developed country should be improved through incentives. A recent example of it can be seen from reduction of child labour by establishment of schools, providing funds for school fees and loss of income.
CONCLUSION
The issue of inclusion of labour standard in trade agreement is much a political issues. However, WTO to a certain extent can produce a viable solution by establishing an Joint WTO-ILO body which will possibly eliminate trade bias without compromising current existing specialization and expertise. However, the long term solution entirely depend on political will of states.
*****
Footnotes
2. Albert Thomas, International Social Policy (Geneva: ILO, 1948). In reference to the ILO’s “palace of wood and stone”, Thomas stated, “In the parchment which I am going to place under the foundation stone, and which, according to custom, commemorates today’s ceremony in the ancient Latin style, there is inscribed a motto. It sums up our Charter in a phrase. Si vis pacem, cole justitiam. If you wish peace, cultivate justice. It is with hearts resolute in the passion for justice that we shall enter into the fair and radiant dwelling which we are founding today”
3. See Thomas (1948) (speeches in 1925 and 1930)
4. ILO Declaration concerning the Aims and purposes of the ILO(Declaration of Philadelphia), 10 May 1944(annexed to the ILO constitution)
5. Charter of United Nations, 26 June, Art. 55.
6. See Aaronson (2001)
7. ITO Charter, Art.3.
8. Tapiwa V Warikandwa and Patrick C Osode, Forging institutional cooperation to protect core labour standards in trade: are a world trade organisation and an international labour organisation joint dispute settlement system practical, The Comparative and International Law Journal of Southern Africa, Vol. 47, No. 3 (NOVEMBER 2014), pp. 490-508, Institute of Foreign and Comparative Law,https://www.jstor.org/stable/43894819 Accessed: 06-09-2019 10:38 UTC
9. Lee Swepston, The future of ILO standards, Monthly Labor Review, Vol. 117, No. 9, Special issue commemorating the 75th anniversary of the International Labor Organization (September 1994), pp. 16-23, https://www.jstor.org/stable/41844331, 11-09-2019 10:33 UTC
10. Seyed Mohamad; Hassan Razavi, Labour Standards and WTO - Dilemma of Legitimacy and Efficacy, 11 J. World Investment & Trade 879 (2010).
11. Tapiwa V Warikandwa and Patrick C Osode, Forging institutional cooperation to protect core labour standards in trade: are a world trade organisation and an international labour organisation joint dispute settlement system practical, The Comparative and International Law Journal of Southern Africa, Vol. 47, No. 3 (NOVEMBER 2014), pp. 490-508, Institute of Foreign and Comparative Law,https://www.jstor.org/stable/43894819 Accessed: 06-09-2019 10:38 UTC
12. Jordi Agusti-Panareda; Franz Christian Ebert; Desiree LeClercq, ILO Labor Standards and Trade Agreements: A Case for Consistency , 36 COMP. LAB. L. & POL'Y J. 347, 380 (2015)
13. Jordi Agusti-Panareda; Franz Christian Ebert; Desiree LeClercq, ILO Labor Standards and Trade Agreements: A Case for Consistency , 36 COMP. LAB. L. & POL'Y J. 347, 380 (2015
14. Belachew Mekuria, Seeking Compliance with Labour Standards through Trade Sanctions: A Disguised Protectionism or Anything More, 25 J. ETHIOPIAN L. 186, 198 (2011).
15. Belachew Mekuria, Seeking Compliance with Labour Standards through Trade Sanctions: A Disguised Protectionism or Anything More, 25 J. ETHIOPIAN L. 186, 198 (2011).
16. Seyed Mohamad; Hassan Razavi, Labour Standards and WTO - Dilemma of Legitimacy and Efficacy, 11 J. World Investment & Trade 879 (2010).
17. Tapiwa V Warikandwa and Patrick C Osode, Forging institutional cooperation to protect core labour standards in trade: are a world trade organisation and an international labour organisation joint dispute settlement system practical, The Comparative and International Law Journal of Southern Africa, Vol. 47, No. 3 (NOVEMBER 2014), pp. 490-508, Institute of Foreign and Comparative Law,https://www.jstor.org/stable/43894819 Accessed: 06-09-2019 10:38 UTC
18. RACHEL HARRIS* AND GILLIAN MOON†, GATT ARTICLE XX AND HUMAN RIGHTS: WHAT DO WE KNOW FROM THE FIRST 20 YEARS? https://law.unimelb.edu.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0007/168 7786/Harris-and-Moon.pdf
19. RACHEL HARRIS* AND GILLIAN MOON†, GATT ARTICLE XX AND HUMAN RIGHTS: WHAT DO WE KNOW FROM THE FIRST 20 YEARS? https://law.unimelb.edu.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0007 /1687786/Harris-and-Moon.pdf
20. Tapiwa V Warikandwa and Patrick C Osode, Forging institutional cooperation to protect core labour standards in trade: are a world trade organisation and an international labour organisation joint dispute settlement system practical, The Comparative and International Law Journal of Southern Africa, Vol. 47, No. 3 (NOVEMBER 2014), pp. 490-508, Institute of Foreign and Comparative Law,https://www.jstor.org/stable/43894819 Accessed: 06-09-2019 10:38 UTC
