Introduction
The general populace of the nation today exhibits a comparatively greater degree of receptivity towards the notion of the transgender community coexisting on equal terms with other members of society, as opposed to attitudes prevailing several decades ago. An examination of the historical trajectory of this community underscores the substantial challenges it has faced in modern India. Their endeavours to attain acknowledgement and entitlements within the dynamic socio-political landscape of the country can be characterized as exceedingly arduous, nothing short of a herculean task. Unfortunately, it is a task that seems to be a long way off from completion in a manner and degree that induces satiation.
The primary objective of this paper is to shed light on one such aspect, i.e. how legal recognition of a transgender individual through the mechanisms presented in the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019 places them at a fork in the road. Such a juncture questions their gender identity to an extent that one begins to look at the material benefits arising from it instead of proudly possessing a gender identity that is preferred by them.
Part I of the paper traces the existence of the transgender community in the nation, from depictions in mythology to the reign of diverse rulers in various regions of India, concluding by examining the profound influence of colonial perspectives on Indian legislative frameworks with respect to the community. Part II of the paper offers a comprehensive analysis of the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019, shedding light on the glaring discrepancies at various stages of its formulation and implementation. In continuation, a more focussed approach is taken to scrutinize the State's model for gender identity determination and how it unfortunately continues to contribute to the mechanism of legal recognition. Part III elaborates on the problems arising from the said mechanism, individually as well while operating with other governing legislations. Official statistics are relied upon to exhibit how in the broader context, the implementation has fallen considerably short of expectations. Part IV discusses the dilemma of either retaining old identity certificates which state one’s assigned gender at birth or procuring new identity certificates which state one’s preferred self-determined gender identity; as well as a concluding note by the author.
Turning the Pages of History: From Mythologies to British Legislations
The socio-political environment the country has offered to the transgender community throughout the past few decades have been an extravagant exhibit of a pre-conceived notion that the very existence of the transgender community is against the law of nature and hence, individuals who identify themselves as such are simply sub-human.
A gender identity that deviated from the conventional binary gender was simply regarded as ‘an ailment of the mind’ that could not be possibly have any associations to the pious and esteemed society and culture that flourished in the nation. Nonetheless, such beliefs are found to be profoundly mistaken when we delve into the pages of history and rigorously examine the society and culture of that time. Upon closer inspection, we witness a multitude of instances which exhibit that the concept of a third gender isn’t a malevolence from the West2 or a corrupting influence birthed in the growing degeneracy of modern times, but simply a gender orientation that has existed from ages ago3.
The Twelve-year exile of the Pandavas marked a pivotal moment in the epic Mahabharata. As Arjuna prepared to exact his revenge on Karna for humiliating his wife, Draupadi, he found himself at the gates of Swarga (heaven). While under the tutelage of Indra, Arjuna came across Urvashi, an apsara (celestial nymph) who was smitten by him. Arjuna respectfully declined her advances, for he regarded her as a maternal figure. Unfortunately, Urvashi felt deeply insulted and cursed Arjuna to be a eunuch. Arjuna later employed this curse to his advantage during the final year of their exile as he took up the name Brihannala4, teaching the art of singing and dancing in the kingdom of King Virata.
In the epic Ramayana, Lord Rama faced exile from his kingdom, necessitating his sojourn in the wilderness for a period spanning fourteen years. In response to this directive, his devoted followers, both male and female, initially accompanied him into the forest. However, Lord Rama earnestly implored all “men and women” among his adherents to return to the city of Ayodhya. Remarkably, transgender individuals opted to remain steadfastly by Lord Rama's side during this trying period for they didn’t conform to either of the binary genders. Lord Rama was profoundly moved by their unwavering love and loyalty, prompting him to bestow upon them a distinctive privilege—the authority to bestow blessings on significant and propitious occasions such as marriages and childbirth, amongst many others5.
In addition to mythologies and epics, more contemporary instances of the inclusion of the transgender community can be observed in the historical context of the Mughal period6. Transgender individuals were often a part of the emperor’s court and maintained esteemed positions. One such instance is that of the royal administration within the Amer Fort in Jaipur. The royalty recognized the unique attributes of transgender individuals and developed a system to utilise the same7. During their reign, the royal women i.e. the king’s wives and their female servants, were held in high esteem. The respect was to such an extent that any man, aside from the King, was strictly forbidden from even making eye contact with them. While this practice upheld the honour of the royal women, it posed numerous logistical challenges. It would be difficult to convey private messages between the King and the royal women, as well as prove to be a hindrance in ensuring the protection of the royal women by the royal guardsmen. To address these challenges, transgender individuals were enlisted since they did not conform strictly to the binary categories of male or female.
It certainly becomes hard to believe that a country that was so facilitating and nurturing of such an integral part of society centuries ago has now fallen from grace. For the same nation is now embroiled and severely plagued by erring conceptions which continue to put the transgender community under grave deprivation. It must be noted that such a drastic shift in the shared perspective can be traced back to the arrival of the British8. Viewing members of the transgender community as sub-humans, such a stance invited a degree of discrimination and oppression that was deemed to be justified. The spectrum of discriminatory actions could range anything from using derogatory terminology and language towards transgender individuals to a more systematic execution. One such instance would be that of extending the application of the Bombay Rent-Free Estates Act, 18529 in order to dispossess them of their land. The argument provided for such dispossession often revolved around the conception that the land in their possession lacked inheritance through blood relations10. Such an argumentation can be regarded as a pristine instance of the Britishers’ vile and craftily formulated legislations. The aforementioned act confiscated land of the individuals who had been granted the same by the rulers of the states, states that had later been annexed by the British colonial administration11.
Another instance is that of the implementation of the Criminal Tribes Act, 187112. The legislation enacted legal provisions for the registration, surveillance and control of certain criminal tribes as well as eunuchs. It conferred upon the local government the power to declare a tribe, gang or a class of persons to be a criminal tribe. Such a declaration was contingent on whether the local government ‘has reason to believe that any tribe, gang or class of persons is addicted to the systematic commission of non-bailable offences’13, if in the affirmative, permission from the Governor General in Council was required to execute the declaration.
It is evident that the perspectives harboured by the British exerted substantial influence on the numerous legislations that were brought forth during their time. But even in the face of such influence, it is perilous to comprehend how a society that held members of the community in such a high regard stopped abruptly and subsequently made legislations that were blatantly discriminative towards them. In order to understand such a change, it is imperative to observe the evolving governance structures, policies and practices of British India over time14. As it is these very aspects which significantly shaped the allocation of rights and privileges to diverse segments of society.
The Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019: A Comprehensive Analysis of the Mechanisms and Gender Identity Determination Models
Matters pertaining to adoption, marriage and succession aren’t governed by a uniform framework for every citizen of India. Rather, it is the varying religious laws that largely formulate the rules regarding such matters as per their own interpretation of such concepts. Legislations codifying such interpretations are given the overarching term, personal laws. The personal laws do not entirely derive from religious texts. The process of codification of such texts and practices into act was done almost exclusively by the Britishers. The omission of any instances other than that of the binary genders from these laws can be attributed to their interpretation being influenced by Anglicized perspectives15. Where Victorian moral ideals have were slyly blended with these religious texts and subsequently exhibited as personal laws.
The prudent Indian man can make an ‘educated guess’ that slowly but surely our country has grown to be more receptive and respectful of the diverse segments of society. Though it is not an absolute promise of a favourable response every time, the trajectory shows promise. Unfortunately, this is the half-truth. The transgender community continues to suffer at large. The only difference is that the manner of suffering has evolved. Now it is not about the blatant disregard for recognition and rights, for that has been ‘solved’ through varying Acts and legal pronouncements. The suffering is now about overcoming the obstacles that have materialised due to the lapses that exist in the law.
To cater to the growing needs of the community, The Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 201916, was brought forward. The act formally prohibit varying instances of discrimination and allowed for proper legal recognition, acknowledging the preferred gender identity. Unfortunately, a thorough analysis of the legislation reveals it to be infested with a series of gaping holes throughout. It becomes important to shed light on such lapses in order to understand just how extensive their impact is. However, prior to embarking on a rigorous examination of the subject, it is equally imperative to study how the legislation in question has become what it is today, so as to understand just where the problem takes root.
If one analyses the overall trajectory of the Indian state policy formulation prior to the Act17, the legal recognition of individuals who don’t conform to the binary code of gender has been nothing short of dismal.
In 2014, with the judgment pertaining to NALSA V. Union of India18 still pending, Tiruchi Siva, a member of the Parliament who represented Tamil Nadu in the Upper House, brought forth the Rights of Transgender Persons Bill19. The bill though subsequently passed, was deemed to be unsatisfactory and criticized for lacking adequate representation of transgender individuals during its drafting process. Subsequently, multiple recommendations were moved forward by interest groups advocating for essential revisions to the legislation.
In the wake of the 2014 bill20 still pending, the incumbent government introduced the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Bill in 201621. This bill, too, faced substantial backlash and was subsequently referred to a standing committee, which delivered its report in July 201722. This process resulted in a revised version of the bill in 2018, encompassing a total of twenty-seven amendments to the original draft23. Nevertheless, the 2018 bill encountered vehement criticism and widespread protests across India, primarily since it exhibited a blatant disregard for the recommendations made by the standing committee as well as numerous interest groups. Ultimately, the 2018 bill lapsed due to the dissolution of the Lok Sabha.
After the reconstitution of the Lok Sabha after the 2019 general elections, the bill was reintroduced in July 2019 and secured the endorsement of the union cabinet on 10th July 2019. It garnered approval through a voice vote in the Lok Sabha on 5th August 2019. Subsequently, the bill was presented in the Rajya Sabha on 20th November 2019, where it was passed without any modifications on 26th November 2019. As the motion to refer the prospective legislation to a select committee failed to garner sufficient support, the bill ultimately received presidential assent and consequently came into effect on 10th January 2020.
There is a definite reason as to why the implementation of the Act is considered hasty beyond measure. The reintroduced bill in 2019 had still failed to incorporate the recommendations given by the standing committee24, which had also included a variety of submissions from the judgment given in NALSA V. Union of India25. Furthermore, the nation collectively did not have the faintest idea regarding the infamous COVID-19 nationwide lockdown, which sat a mere three months. Any efforts to question and challenge the legislation that rose up during this brief three-month window were rendered futile as the focus shifted from questioning the legislation to having a question looming over one’s own survival. The imposition of the lockdown brought forth an extreme change in almost every sphere of life of every citizen in the country. This left absolutely no space to study and raise voice against the most glaring discrepancies in the Act. One of the most prominent discrepancies being the power of ‘self-determination’ in the hands of the state.
Article 15 of the Constitution of India prohibits discrimination on five prominent grounds, namely religion, race, caste, sex or place of birth. However, there is a grave error in understanding the encompassing aspects of discrimination on the grounds of sex. Discrimination on grounds of sex doesn’t just encompass the conventional biological sex but also the more diverse self-determined gender identity an individual has the liberty to choose26.
Unfortunately, the absence of understanding of the gender spectrum and the consisting nuances of the same continue to plague the Indian society. Time and again, instances have emerged where a conspicuous lack of comprehension and awareness has been publicly evident. A collection of such instances is hidden in The Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019. The Act invited heavy criticism27 right from its inception due to a severe lack of representation of transgender individuals during its formation. While it is praiseworthy that the act took a step towards acknowledging one’s ‘self-perceived gender identity’, a critical analysis reveals that the devil is in the details28.
The act seems to aim for a biological and/or medical model of gender identity. The act evinces blatant neglect of any model other than biological for the purposes of determination, which considers the physical male and female bodies as the benchmark29. This leaves no space for any discussion regarding the self-determined gender identity one might prefer since the model places a man to be only a man and a woman to be only a woman. Furthermore, the difference between an individual’s preferred gender orientation and the gender assigned at birth can be bridged through surgical interventions. The act views such interventions as means ‘to change the gender either as a male or a female’, wrongly affirming the process of a gender transition to a sex-reaffirming surgical procedures. Such an understanding poses to be a severe violation of the concept30.
Such misconceptions serve to be a clear indicator of the dire misunderstanding of the concepts of gender identity and sexual orientation. While sexual orientation pertains to an individual's enduring inclination towards another person in terms of physical, romantic, and/or emotional attraction; gender identity encompasses one's internal and intrinsic perception of their self-identification as per their preferred gender identity31.
The Numbers Game: Unveiling the Truth Behind the Statistics
The Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019 legally recognised the third gender and consisted of provisions outlining the procedure to be followed if an individual wished to procure a certificate of identity which stated their self-determined gender identity in place of the gender assigned to them at their birth.
The Act allowed individuals who hadn’t undergone Sex Reassignment Surgery or hormone therapy or laser therapy or such other therapy32 to be recognised as a transgender, a deviation from the conventional model of gender determination. Unfortunately, the application for the certificate of identity had to be made to the District Magistrate who would have the final power to approve a certificate. The very idea of self-determination relies on the foundation that it is free from any external intervention. But if an individual’s self-determined gender identity can only exist if an absolute stranger to the process finds it to be conforming to the provisions and mechanisms proposed in the Act, then the core principle of self-determination is effectively compromised. The conceptual framework within which transgenderism operates isn’t about linking one’s gender identity to their anatomy but rather the inward perception of one’s self.
In response to the considerable criticism directed at this particular aspect of the mechanism, the National Portal for Transgender Persons was launched33 on 25th November 2020. The portal provided an online platform which facilitated the procurement of the Certificates and Identity Cards without any physical interaction. This diminished any possibility of being subject to discrimination and personal biases the officers of the government. Furthermore, the portal also placed the issuing authorities under “under strict timelines to process the applications and issue certificates and identity cards without any necessary delays”34. Numerous features were offered to both the applicant as well as the issuing authority, such as allowing the applicant to see the status of their application and initiate complaints as per their grievances. On the other hand, the issuing authorities, acquired the capability to monitor the number of received applications, those that have been approved, and those currently pending or placed on hold. This functionality enabled them to undertake requisite actions as deemed necessary from their perspective.
As per the statistics available on the National Portal for Transgender Persons35, a total of thirty thousand two hundred and thirty-nine applications36 have been made on the National portal. Out of which, twenty-five thousand four hundred thirteen37 have been duly approved. Furthermore, there are twenty-five thousand four hundred and three applicants38 who are also in possession of identity cards which state their preferred self-determined gender identity.
On the face of it, the numbers look promising. Approximately eighty four percent of the applications made on the portal are accepted and issued the certificates and identity cards. With the exception of just four thousand two hundred sixty-seven applications considered ineligible on account of document-based discrepancies. But on the other hand, four thousand eight hundred seventy-seven applications are still being processed. It is important to note that the portal itself states that ‘It is mandatory for the district authorities to issue transgender certificates & ID cards within thirty days of Receiving the Application.’39 But a closer look at the statistics shows that there are a large number of applications that have been pending for a much longer time. As of today, nine hundred ninety-nine applications40 have been pending in the one to three months category, seven hundred twenty-three applications41 in the four to six months category and eight hundred seventy-three applications42 have been pending in the seven to twelve months category. Perhaps even the statistics pertaining to the pending applications can be brushed under the rug under the garb of rusted bureaucratical mechanisms or technical failures. However, the matter at hand becomes considerably significant when additional sources of information are duly taken into account.
The Census of 2011 is considered to be a benchmark43 since it was the first time a government-backed survey provided the respondent with three codes with respect to their gender. Three codes, Male-1, Female-2 and Other-3 were provided for the enumeration at the discretion of the respondent which subsequently led to a total of 4,87,803 individuals44 coming under the population of the ‘other’ code in the Census of 2011.
It is important to note that the data from the Census of 2011 needs to be taken into account with a few considerations. The Other code in the data is not in particular regard to just transgender individuals. Thus, an individual who didn’t wish to identify code 1 or 2 was instructed to record themselves as code-3, which doesn’t necessarily imply the ‘other’ population to be transgender explicitly45. Furthermore, it doesn’t correctly exhibit the number of individuals who at the time of the Census identified with the ‘other’ code and have now, through sex reassignment surgery, began to identify themselves as a male or a female. Keeping the aforementioned factors in mind, one can still conclude that of the 4,87,803 individuals who opted for code-3, a substantial portion of them still opt for the same46. Furthermore, the number of transgender individuals in the country has only gone on to increase considering the trajectory of population growth the country is witness to.
Now if we compare the statistics of the Census of 2011 to thirty thousand two hundred and thirty-nine applications made till date47 for the procurement of certificates of identity, the latter constitutes to be a mere 5.35% of the former. It is important to note that such a picture comes up to the surface only after two key factors are disregarded while making such an evaluation. Firstly, the growth in population from 2011 to 2023. Secondly, the number of applications made to the District Magistrates between the enactment of the Act, 10th January 2020, and the imposition of the lockdown, 24th March 2020, aren’t considered. Even if the data pertaining to applications made in the three-month window is made available, it would remain relatively insignificant in the face of the growth of population over the twelve-year timeframe. The overall population growth if taken in due consideration, would only intensify the already substantial disparity.
The Dual Edged Sword of Recognition: A Dilemma of Identity
The 174th Report of Law Commission of India, 200048 asserted that the legislation which appears to exhibit differential treatment based on gender by distinguishing between males and females, should be revised to adopt a gender-neutral stance. In more recent times, the judgement of NALSA V. Union of India49 is widely regarded as the torchbearer of progress with regards to the recognition of the transgender community and their rights. The judgement, on various occasions highlighted the significance of conferring inheritance rights to members of the transgender community. It cited recommendations from UNDP’s report on transgenders in India, ‘HIV Human Rights and Social Exclusion’ 50. It is also worthy to note that the judgment also comprised of the notion to consider the self-determined gender identity model as opposed to the biological model, “we cannot accept the Corbett principle of “Biological Test”, rather we prefer to follow the psyche of the person in determining sex and gender and prefer the ‘Psychological Test’ instead of ‘Biological Test’ ...”51.
One of the most prominent problems that is faced by members of the transgender community is the absence of any facilitating provisions for them throughout any of the legislations that govern the matters of inheritance.
The Hindu Succession Act52 governs the matters of succession for ‘Hindus, Buddhists, Jains or Sikhs by religion’ 53, with the definition clause of Act outlining who come under its ambit. The inception of the problem begins from the definition of heir54, referring to any male or female individual, exhibiting that the framework of the legislation considers the binary notion of gender as normative. The categories of agnate55 and cognate56 are put to use in highlighting the categories of relatives who are allowed to partake in matters of succession, which is again defined as per the binary model. Furthermore, there are different sections dealing with the general rules of succession only for the males57and females58, with no provisions for the transgender community. Parallelly, the Muslim Personal laws (Shariat) are formulated as per the Quran. In India, the Muslim property remain uncodified and any matter pertaining to succession are governed by the Shariat law. Throughout the law, there are absolutely no provisions which allow space for an interpretation which could subsequently confer inheritance rights upon a transgender individual.
To ensure acquisition of a part of or the entirety of the estate to a transgender individual, the mechanism of estate succession via a will can be utilized. However, in the case of lack of a will, the succession becomes complex. Such a scenario gives rise to intestate successions, i.e., the legal procedure employed for the allocation of the assets and possessions of a deceased individual in instances where they have not left a valid will or any other legally binding document outlining the specific distribution of their estate. Unfortunately, intestate successions too follow the binary model which again prevents transgender individuals to inherit property.
During intestate succession, transgender individuals often identify with their assigned gender identity and move forward with the proceedings in order to avoid any complications that could prove to be an obstacle in obtaining the property. Such practice is a gross infringement of the rights of transgender individuals. A legislation that coerces the citizens under its domain to conform to binary gender identities in place of their self-determined gender identities, just to access their rightful entitlements is compelling evidence regarding the necessity for substantial reforms in such an oppressive framework59.
Ms. Ranjita Sinha, a transgender activist & founder of the Network of Transgender in West Bengal60, has been in tussle with this aspect since 2016. Sinha’s father, a police inspector, died during his tenure of service in 1982. Subsequently, as mandated, his wife began receiving the pension. Unfortunately, after her death in 2016, the pension stopped. As per the rules pertaining to the matters of pension, an unmarried and unemployed daughter is entitled to receive her parent’s pension. But the same has been denied to her since Sinha identifies herself as a transgender and is hence not a daughter. In 2022, Sinha decided to move to court61 after the State government’s stance seemed indifferent to her pleas. Sinha states that her fight isn’t about the monetary entitlement but rather her self-respect. Preventing Sinha to acquire the pension solely on the grounds of her self-determined gender identity also disregards her as a child of her parents just because her self-determined gender identity is different that her assigned gender identity.
Sinha’s move is starkly different from the normative approach adopted by transgender individuals who find themselves in a similar peril. The said approach is to identify oneself with the binary genders i.e., male or female, and secure the entitled inheritance, insurance claims or any other benefits that can be conferred upon the individual as long as they exist within the domain of binary genders. Such an approach ensures the procurement of benefits at the expense of forfeiting one’s self-determined gender identity to the legislations and government-backed mechanisms. Subsequently, it shoots down any possibility of initiation of a litigation since individuals are far more comfortable forfeiting their gender identity and securing the entitlements. The route of staying true to the self-determined gender identity and challenging the governing legislations, invites the possibility of losing out or deferring the possession of the entitlements indefinitely, neither of which are desirable.
Such forfeiture of gender identity is nothing short of a brazen violation of the rights vested in a citizen. The constitution guarantees that the state shall not discriminate on the grounds only of religion, race, caste, sex, place of birth or any of them62. With every passing day, it becomes more and more important to include discrimination on the grounds of the self-determined gender identity as a vital aspect in the overarching ground of discrimination based on sex.
Unfortunately, such an iteration of discrimination fails to gain its due recognition owing to an absence of foundational understanding. The lack of understanding stems directly from the lack of exposure, which in turn is a direct result of individual interest taking precedence over the interest of the community as a whole. A transgender individual finds it far more comfortable to forfeit their rights if it means that their title to their rightful entitlements is secured. Such a difference in priority leads to a severe dearth of litigations. The fight for legal recognition takes a backseat due to a lack of inclination to go against the existing oppressive mechanisms by taking the due legal recourse, as the entitlements in question could very well be lost if an unfavourable judgment is passed. It is truly shocking to witness how such a severe violation of rights gets swept under the rug all so conveniently. Which is why Sinha’s decision to move to court becomes all the more important to the discussion at hand.
It is also worthy to note that not every transgender individual shares a social and financial standing similar to that of Sinha. A substantial number of transgender individuals do not possess sound financial foundations63. This in turn directly influences their perspectives and a large number of their decisions64, ranging from the inclination to fight for equal legal recognition or something as primal as one’s survival. An individual who is unsure about whether they will have the luxury of eating even a single meal could not care less about how the legislations in place perceive their gender.
Today, a transgender individual who can voice their opinions and grievances to the society is only able to do so for they stand on the shoulders of the members of the community who suffered in silence and persevered through the prevailing decades. However, the struggle continues65. The issue at hand is far craftier than before, for now that conflict is not about legal recognition but rather securing the legal rights which ensure that the community is brought to an equal social footing with the rest of the society66. Unfortunately, in pursuance of the same, the community finds itself in the labyrinth of the bureaucratical system. A direct result being that the affected members actively avoid indulging in any legal recourses as their rights continue to go for a toss. The problem might not seem all that grave on the face of it, but such a perception can most certainly shift if we consider the following hypothetical.
A transgender individual who had been thrown out of their house during their formative years due to their self-determined gender identity was able to make a living for themselves due to the aid provided to them by a Non-Governmental Organisation. The NGO assist them in procuring documents that state their preferred gender identity as well as helping them find employment opportunities. The documents in their possession are nothing short of godsent for them as it allows them to enjoy benefits conferred only upon transgender individuals. Half a decade later, the same individual in now unable to secure their inheritance arising from an intestate succession because their only mistake was to legally recognise their self-determined gender identity on their documents. Furthermore, if they do wish to secure their inheritance, the only recourse available to them is to not go by their self-determined gender identity. If they do so, they forfeit the rights & benefits that have allowed them to reach where they are today. If they do not, they forfeit their rightful entitlement to their inheritance.
It is glaringly obvious that the mechanism in place is plagued with a severe flaw which pushes the affected individuals to move towards a grave disadvantage no matter what they do. Such an environment actively demands for a careful amendment of the governing legislations in a manner which ensures the inclusion of the transgender community and grant them equal rights and benefits akin to the broader society.
*****
Footnotes
2. H.B. Elischberger, J.J. Glazier, E.D. Hill, et al. Attitudes Toward and Beliefs about Transgender Youth: A Cross-Cultural Comparison Between the United States and India. 78 SEX ROLES, 142–160 (2018).
3. Ibid.
4. K. RAJESH AND V. RAJASEKARAN, THE THIRD GENDER: STAIN AND PAIN 160 (Vishwabarati Research Centre 2018).
5. S.P. Srinivasan & Sruti Chandrasekaran, Transsexualism in Hindu mythology, 24(3) IJEM (2020).
6. M. Michelraj, Historical Evolution of Transgender Community in India. 4 ASIAN REV. OF SOC. SCI., 17, 17–19 (2015)
7. Ibid.
8. Ibid.
9. Bombay Rent-Free Estates Act, 1852, No. 11, Acts of Maharashtra State Legislature, 1852 (India).
10. Aarthi Shankar, An Overview of Transgender Rights in India, 3 INDIAN J.L. & LEGAL RSCH. (2021).
11. Rupal Sharma, Inheritance Rights of Transgender: A Cry of Humanity. 3 INT'L JL MGMT. & HUMAN. (2018).
12. The Criminal Tribes’ Act, 1871, §2, No. 28, Acts of Parliament, 1871 (India).
13. Ibid.
14. Supra, Note 11.
15. Supra, Note 10.
16. Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019, No. 40, Acts of Parliament, 2019 (India).
17. Ibid.
18. NALSA V. Union of India, 2014 AIR SC 2285.
19. Rights of Transgender Persons Bill, 2014, Bill No. 49, 2014 (India).
20. Ibid.
21. Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Bill, 2016, Bill No. 210, 2016 (India).
22. The Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Bill, 2016, https://prsindia.org/billtrack/the-transgender-persons-protection-of-rights-bill-2016 (last visited: January 2, 2025).
23. Ibid.
24. Ankana Bal, The Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019: A Critical Analysis. 3 INT'L JL MGMT. & HUMAN. 1069, 1070-1073 (2020).
25. Supra, Note 18.
26. J. Kothari, Trans Equality in India: Affirmation of the Right to Self-Determination of Gender, 13 NUJS L. REV. 549 (2020).
27. Supra, Note 19.
28. Indra K. Lahoti & Nitisha Agrawal, Transgender Rights - An Ongoing Wrangle, 9 NLIU L. REV. 540 (2020).
29. Neena S. Sawant. Transgender: Status in India. 1 ANNALS OF INDIAN PSYCHIATRY. 59, 59-61 (2017).
30. BROWN, MILDRED L. AND ROUNSLEY, CHLOE ANN, TRUE SELVES: UNDERSTANDING TRANSSEXUALISM - (Jossey Bass 2003)
31. NATIONAL ACADEMIES OF SCIENCES, ENGINEERING, AND MEDICINE ET. AL., MEASURING SEX, GENDER IDENTITY, AND SEXUAL ORIENTATION (2022).
32. Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019, § 2 (k), No. 40, Acts of Parliament, 2019 (India).
33. Garima Greh: A Shelter Home for Transgender Persons, https://pib.gov.in/PressReleasePage.aspx ?PRID=1675629 (last visited Dec. 28, 2024).
34. Ibid.
35. As per statistics available on https://transgender.dosje.gov.in/ as of 15th February 2025.
36. Ibid.
37. Ibid.
38. Ibid.
39. Ibid.
40. Ibid.
41. Ibid.
42. Ibid.
43. Welfare of Transgenders, https://pib.gov.in/PressReleasePage.aspx?PRID=1575534 (last visited Dec. 29, 2024).
44. Ibid.
45. R. Mehta, Analysing Transgender Rights In India, 2 Indian J.L. & Legal Rsch. (2021).
46. Ibid.
47. As of 15th February 2025.
48. Law Commission of India, Property Rights of Women: Proposed Reforms under the Hindu Law, Report no. 174, (May 2000).
49. Supra, Note 18.
50. UNDP, Hijras/Transgender in India: HIV, Human Rights And Social Exclusion. UNDP.ORG (Dec. 28, 2024, 9:36 PM), https://www.undp.org/india/publications/hijras/transgender-india-hiv-human-rights-and-social-exclusion.
51. Supra, note 18.
52. Hindu Succession Act, 1956, No. 30, Acts of Parliament, 1956 (India)
53. § 2, ibid.
54. § 3 (f), ibid.
55. § 3 (a) ibid.
56. § 3 (c) ibid.
57. § 8, Ibid.
58. § 15 & 16, Ibid.
59. Gulati, K. and Anand, T., 2023. Inheritance rights of transgender persons in India. Indian Law Review, 7(1), pp.1-25.
60. Ranjita Sinha (no date) The National Network of Transgender Persons. Available at: https://www.nntp.org.in/ranjita-sinha/ (Accessed: 1 August 2024).
61. B. Ghosh, Prominent member of Kolkata’s transgender community to approach court for father’s pension, The Hindu.com (Dec. 29, 2024, 2:48 PM).
62. INDIA CONST. art. 15, cl. 1.
63. A. Homes, J. John, A. Sreevalsan, Financial security among transgenders in India: An introduction to trans-inclusion model, INTNL.L JOUR. OF ADV. RESEAR., IDEAS AND INNOV. IN TECH. (2019)
64. Ibid.
65. Dr. K.R. Hotchandani, Problems Of Transgender In India: A Study From Social Exclusion To Social Inclusion, 4 INTL’ RES. JOUR. OF HUM. RESOURC. AND SOC. SCI. (2017).
66. Ibid.
