INTRODUCTION
The phrase "financial technology," or simply "fintech," describes state-of-the-art technology that is intended to enhance and automate the supply of financial services. Fintech helps organisations, businesses, and people manage their finances more effectively. Processes and lifestyles2. Fintech utilises specialised software and algorithms that act on Computers and, increasingly, cell phones. The global market has seen a major shift in financial services with respect to technology and businesses, earlier monopolised by the banks. With the increase in the purchasing power of the individual and the influx of disposable cash, the FinTech industry boomed-followed by massive growth in capital investment and venture funding. India with it’s manifold population of 1.3 billion, has become the 3rd largest fintech market globally followed by USA and China3.
Against this backdrop, there has been a paradigm shift in the global FinTech market, including India with the convergence of Data Science and Artificial Intelligence (AI)4 which acts as a catalyst for the dynamic development of the FinTech sector.
Following suit, the Reserve Bank of India (RBI), in pursuit of such changing dynamics of the financial sector, set up an inter-regulatory Working Group (WG) with the objective of investigating and reporting on the specific facets of FinTech and its consequences. This was done in order to assess the regulatory framework and address the dynamics of the quickly changing FinTech landscape5. On February 8, 2018, the WG report was made available for public discussion. In order to improve efficiency, manage risks, and open up new opportunities for consumers, one of the main recommendations made by the Working Group (WG) was to establish a suitable framework for a Regulatory Sandbox (RS) within a clearly defined area and timeframe, where the financial sector regulator will supply the necessary regulatory guidance.
THE ORIGIN AND SCOPE OF REGULATORY SANDBOX
Financial regulation focusses on hazards that affect the public interest, such as consumer protection, market integrity, and financial stability. Historically, regulators used rule-based enforcement with an emphasis on risk management. This inflexible approach, however, has developed into a more flexible, responsive style of regulation to accommodate the dynamic character of modern financial markets6. The emergence of technology like as algorithmic trading, computerised credit scoring, and digital identity has presented substantial hurdles to regulators, as existing rules may not sufficiently address new advancements. As a result, authorities have taken a cautious "wait and see" attitude, particularly in places such as the European Union, where financial regulators closely observe trends before imposing new laws.
However, there's a chance that FinTech companies would be hindered from innovating if current rules meant for traditional financial services are applied to them. For example, imposing capital adequacy regulations at the bank level on crowdfunding platforms may make it more difficult for them to enter the market. On the other hand, some authorities may enact too lax laws in an effort to draw in FinTech companies, raising worries about a potential "race to the bottom" in regulatory standards7.
Regulators across the world are still trying to figure out the best way to control the quick speed at which FinTech is developing8. A large portion of the global discourse is still experimental as authorities consider the best course of action while evaluating the financial potential of fintech9. This has resulted in the creation of innovation centres, incubators, and accelerator programs that offer FinTech businesses assistance, direction, and a regulatory framework in which to test their ideas.
The regulatory sandbox concept arose from this context as a hybrid regulatory and business advice tool that allows FinTech businesses to experiment in a controlled setting. Sandboxes promote innovation by providing a space for enterprises to "fail safely"10 without exposing the larger financial system to excessive risks, hence encouraging reciprocal learning between firms and regulators.
A regulatory sandbox is a framework that financial regulators have established to enable FinTech businesses and startups to test new products, services, and business models in a safe and regulated setting11. In order to reduce risks and maintain financial stability and consumer protection, the sandbox gives businesses a secure environment in which to test their ideas free from the full range of financial sector laws. The primary goal is to promote innovation in the financial sector by providing regulatory flexibility, which enables businesses to grow and enhance their offers while still abiding by the law.
The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) started the process in 2016 by forming an inter-regulator working group, and in 2019 it finalised the regulatory sandbox framework. The goal of this group was to investigate how low-cost financial services and products may be provided in the rapidly developing FinTech market. The working group emphasised the necessity of a regulated sandbox, which is a controlled setting for testing ideas on a limited scale. The 2017 Household Finance Report was when this concept was first put forward. A Draft Framework was released in April 2019 following lengthy discussions, and the 'Enabling Framework for Regulatory Sandbox' was released in August 201912.
Financial inclusion and innovation are intended to be enhanced by the regulatory sandbox environment established by the RBI. It is in favour of small-scale testing of financial services that increase access, especially in underbanked areas, such as mobile banking, microfinance, and microinsurance. But the sandbox doesn't allow for things like credit registries, cryptocurrency, and initial coin offerings (ICOs)13. Banks and other financial institutions that fall under this category must fulfil certain criteria, such as having a strong IT infrastructure, sufficient management manpower, and insurance coverage. In order to support India's drive for FinTech innovation and a paperless economy, the framework also introduces theme cohorts such as financial inclusion, payments, lending, and digital KYC. In 2020, the first sandbox cohort will be centred on digital retail payments14.
This paradigm emphasises how FinTech may improve access to digital payment options, particularly in poor nations where it is difficult to access physical financial institution
PROACTIVE REGULATION AND THE ROLE OF REGULATORS IN PROMOTING COMPETITION IN FINTECH MARKET
The regulatory sandbox acts as an effective forum for regulators to showcase and prove their agility and inventive spirit in working in and around the “deadening effect of regulatory lag.” Rushing to regulate is more often than not proves to be counterproductive, thus regulatory sandbox also represents a ‘reasonable compromise.’15
In the context of FinTech innovation, the regulatory sandbox is a proactive and flexible regulatory interface. Sandboxes, as opposed to other forms of support like innovation hubs, give authorities the ability to keep an eye on FinTech products in a regulated setting. This is important since normal regulatory systems were not meant to address the unforeseen dangers that these items present. The sandbox reduces risks and offers early feedback to help companies refine their goods and business models by enabling them to test their products on a smaller scale.
The opportunity-based regulation of the sandbox, which actively fosters competition in developing FinTech markets, is one of its primary features. By fostering innovation and fostering communication between regulators and innovators16, this strategy goes beyond conventional risk- or problem-based regulation standards. Instead of releasing items into the open market, this technique lets FinTech companies test ideas in a controlled setting, which lowers costs and failure rates17.
The establishment of a regulatory sandbox in India is an example of a proactive regulatory approach meant to foster innovation while controlling risk. The Reserve Bank of India's sandbox framework, which welcomes a wide spectrum of users and enables a range of FinTech solutions18, demonstrates the nation's dedication to developing a vibrant FinTech ecosystem. FinTech companies benefit from the sandbox's regulatory advice and controlled testing environment, which aid in navigating the challenges of market entrance and compliance. This program supports the overarching goal of increasing competition and stimulating economic growth via innovation, all the while making sure that regulatory supervision changes to meet the changing requirements of the financial industry19.
Regulatory sandboxes have gained traction in India, particularly in industries such as InsurTech20, where it serves as a platform for FinTech innovation while maintaining market integrity and consumer safety. Through the sandbox, regulators may make early business decisions about the feasibility of innovations, ensuring that only really unique items make it to market, so decreasing regulatory latency and promoting competition21.
RBI’S ENABLING FRAMEWORK FOR REGULATORY SANDBOX
An inter-regulatory Working Group (WG) was formed by the Reserve Bank of India in July 2016 to investigate the specifics of FinTech and its effects on the regulatory landscape. This group sought to evaluate the FinTech industry's rapid growth and offer suggestions for how the regulatory framework should change to reflect these changes. The suggestion to establish a Regulatory Sandbox—a-controlled environment for testing new financial services and products—was one of the main results of this initiative. This study served as the basis for the RS, which enables inventors, regulators, financial service providers, and customers to evaluate the advantages and disadvantages of novel technology in an actual, supervised setting. The RS framework is intended to promote responsible innovation in the financial industry by boosting efficiency, reducing risks, and opening up opportunities for customers.
(A) Regulatory Sandbox: Eligibility Criteria
According to RBI standards, the following are the qualifying requirements for companies applying to the Regulatory Sandbox (RS)22:
1. Type of Entity: The entity must be an Indian bank with an operating licence, a Limited Liability Partnership (LLP), a partnership business, or a corporation that has been formed and registered in India. Financial institutions established in India pursuant to a legislation would likewise be qualified.
2. Minimum Net value: Based on its most recent audited balance statement, the firm should have a minimum net value of Rs. 10 lakhs.
3. Reapplication: The entity may only reapply with the same or a comparable product following the conclusion of a six-month statutory cooling-off period if its application for participation is denied under the RS.
4. Fit and Proper Criteria: Based on particular documentation filed for each promoter/director/partner, the entity's promoter(s)/director(s) should all be fit and suitable23.
These standards are intended to guarantee the financial soundness, regulatory compliance, and suitability of the persons holding senior positions within the RS participating firms.
The RBI's aim to restrict participation to financially sound and compliant organisations is reflected in the qualifying standards for companies applying to the Regulatory Sandbox (RS). The RBI minimises jurisdictional issues by restricting participation to Indian banks, limited liability partnerships, and registered companies, so ensuring that participants are firms governed by local laws. Given the risks involved in testing new financial technology, it is imperative that enterprises have a certain degree of financial resilience, which is ensured by the minimum net value requirement of Rs. 10 lakhs.
The six-month cooling-off period for reapplication promotes careful planning prior to application submission, discouraging several, fruitless efforts. Fit and adequate requirements for key workers further highlight the need of competent leadership, guaranteeing that these enterprises are led by responsible professionals exclusively during the sandbox phase. The overall goal of these standards is to link the objectives of regulatory supervision with market innovation by striking a balance between innovation, financial stability, and responsible leadership.
(B) Design Aspects
1. Regulatory Sandbox Cohorts
• The Regulatory Sandbox (RS) operates through cohorts—groups of entities participating in a defined cycle where they test new and innovative financial products or services. Each cohort is focused on a specific theme, such as financial inclusion, digital Know Your Customer (KYC) processes, or payment solutions24.
• The structure of the cohorts ensures that innovation is directed toward regulatory priorities while remaining manageable in scope. By limiting the number of participants in each cohort, the regulator can provide detailed supervision, thereby maintaining the balance between innovation and consumer protection.
• Each cohort lasts a maximum of nine months, including periods for testing, feedback, and evaluation. This timeline is significant because it allows for flexibility while ensuring that participants receive adequate time for experimentation.
The cohort structure guarantees that testing is done in a controlled setting, avoiding widespread market disturbance. It enables the regulator to examine the impact of innovation in real time and modify regulations as appropriate. However, a nine-month deadline may restrict some initiatives that require a longer development cycle, thereby restricting their efficacy.
2. On-Tap Application
• The RS has a 'On Tap' feature, which allows for the continual introduction of new entities or items within locked themes. This feature guarantees that creativity is not strangled by strict timetables and allows for ongoing involvement, making the sandbox more accessible to innovators even after the original cohort has graduated25.
• Entities interested in entering the sandbox can apply directly through the Reserve Bank's website, where they can find comprehensive terms and conditions. This open-door strategy enables increased involvement and promotes continued fintech growth.
This continuous entry method is advantageous because it guarantees that innovators are not stifled by rigid entry windows, fostering continued experimentation and improving competitiveness. However, this may create a strain on regulators, who must guarantee they have the resources to oversee both early and late entrants. Proper resource allocation for supervision is critical to ensure the success of this system.
3. Regulatory Requirements/ Relaxations: During the sandbox testing phase, the RBI relaxes key regulatory standards, including liquidity ratios, management qualifications, and capital adequacy. However, critical areas like as consumer privacy, Know Your consumer (KYC)/Anti-Money Laundering (AML) compliance, and data protection are unavoidable.
4. Exclusion from Sandbox Testing
• Not all concepts are suitable for sandbox testing. For example, services such as cryptocurrencies, initial coin offerings (ICOs), and other items that are already publicly accessible or prohibited by Indian regulators are exempt from testing26.
• An indicative negative list of products/services/technology which may not be accepted for testing is given below27.
a) Credit registry
b) Credit information
c) Crypto currency/Crypto assets services
d) Trading/investing/settling in crypto assets
e) Initial Coin Offerings, etc.
f) Chain marketing services
g) Any product/services which have been banned by the regulators/Government of India.
• This exclusion list illustrates the RBI's cautious approach to some financial instruments, notably cryptocurrency. While the exclusion of forbidden goods is appropriate in order to maintain regulatory integrity, the blanket exclusion of widely available services may stifle incremental innovation in well-established domains, thereby impeding fintech development in mature sectors. Furthermore, the absence of sandbox chances for cryptocurrencies may force India to lag behind in the fast-changing global fintech business.
5. Numbers of FinTech Entities in a Cohort:
• Each cohort will be strictly targeted and confined to a small number of participants to guarantee regulatory scrutiny and thorough analysis. The selection process is based on a thorough evaluation of the product or service's ability to contribute to financial innovation, with the RBI having ultimate say on selections28.
• Limiting the number of participants leads to a more concentrated and efficient review process, lowering the danger of regulatory fatigue. This framework also encourages greater participation among participants and regulators. However, it may restrict possibilities for smaller players with less proven products to enter the RS, skewing the sandbox towards larger, more established companies.
6. Fit and Proper Criteria for Participants
• All applicants must satisfy specific conditions, such as having a registered Indian company/LLP/partnership business or a licensed bank. Furthermore, they must have a net worth of at least Rs.10 lakh, an acceptable credit history, and strong technological preparedness and IT infrastructure29.
• This guarantees that only organisations with the requisite financial stability and technological capabilities enter the RS, reducing the risks associated with financial solvency or technical failure during the experimental stage. However, for companies, the minimum net worth threshold may be a barrier to entrance, thereby restricting the variety of inventions evaluated in the sandbox.
7. Boundary Conditions and Consumer Protection
Defining these limits is critical to reducing risk and protecting consumers. It avoids overexposure to new technology without adequate precautions. The restrictions on transaction volumes and particular target markets serve to mitigate any systemic risk during the trial period, ensuring that new products do not create unanticipated disruptions. The RBI Guidelines also establish clear boundary conditions, including30:
a) Start and end dates for the testing period
b) Target consumer or merchant types
c) Transaction volume limits.
Consumer protection measures is an essential component for ensuring that customers are safeguarded even when dealing with experimental items or services. The RS addresses customer trust concerns by enforcing transparency and liability covering, boosting confidence in fintech developments. However, ensuring that all companies offer appropriate coverage may raise operating expenses, thus discouraging participation from smaller players. Entities within the sandbox must prioritize consumer protection by31:
a) Notifying consumers of potential risks.
b) Providing liability insurance insurance to cover consumer losses in case of failure.
The Reserve Bank of India's (RBI) framework for the Regulatory Sandbox (RS) is an important step towards encouraging innovation in India's fast developing fintech industry. By establishing a regulated environment for testing new financial services and products, the RBI has effectively balanced regulatory monitoring with the flexibility to experiment, fostering responsible innovation. The qualifying requirements, which include minimum net worth, kind of company, and fit and proper standards, guarantee that only financially solid and compliant businesses participate, reducing the risks connected with emerging fintech advances.
The RS's cohort-based structure, combined with its stated timescales, encourages concentrated testing and regulatory prioritisation, while the nine-month duration may restrict the effectiveness of longer-term initiatives. The addition of a "On Tap" function for continuous involvement expands the sandbox's flexibility and accessibility, enabling continued creativity even after special cohorts have ended.
However, obstacles still exist. The absence of some technologies, such as cryptocurrencies and initial coin offerings (ICOs), may limit India's competitiveness in new fintech domains, particularly given the worldwide emphasis on these technologies. Similarly, although restricting the number of participants assures a comprehensive review process, it may unintentionally favour larger, more established businesses, thereby suffocating smaller fintech firms that may contribute to more diversified developments.
ROLE OF REGULATORY SANDBOX IN RISK-MITIGATION
Small-scale testing over a period of time in the controlled environment of a regulatory sandbox helps in mitigation of risks to consumers. The most fascinating design feature of the regulatory sandbox is the aspect of the controlled testing environment which helps in mapping out the risks and containing them. Implementing small-scale testing in a regulatory sandbox within a set timeline helps to reduce consumer risks connected with new financial products and services32. One of the most important design features of any regulatory sandbox is the implementation of strong controls to properly map and contain possible hazards. Typically, authorities work closely with each sandbox participant to develop a unique framework of safeguards customised to the nature of the testing activity. This tailored strategy guarantees that risks are recognised, managed, and mitigated effectively, providing a safety net for both customers and the financial system as a whole33.
Regulators have several obstacles when creating appropriate investor, consumer, and systemic safeguards, especially in the quickly changing FinTech industry, where innovations frequently go into unexplored territory. This complexity is heightened by FinTech advancements in India, which use modern technology including as blockchain, artificial intelligence, digital payments, and peer-to-peer lending platforms34. The novelty and sophistication of these technologies make it impossible to foresee all potential threats, necessitating regulators' vigilance and adaptability.
The Consultative Group to Assist the Poor (CGAP) emphasises that new goods and services evaluated in a sandbox may introduce extra hazards that are difficult to detect before full market introduction35. These risks may stem from the inherent characteristics of the innovation or from limitations in regulatory and supervisory capacity, such as inadequately designed regulatory requirements—whether overly lenient or excessively stringent—or insufficient supervisory tools required for data collection and analysis.
(A) Role of RBI’s Enabling Framework in Risk Mitigation
In India, the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) has aggressively tackled these issues inside the regulatory sandbox framework36. The RBI offers oversight through its specialised FinTech Unit, which is led by an Inter-Departmental Group of subject specialists from diverse sectors. This approach guarantees that each sandbox participant receives targeted attention to assist the successful design and execution of their experiments while effectively navigating the complicated regulatory landscape.
The RBI assigns case officers who work closely with sandbox participants. This ongoing interaction ensures that the business models comply with existing regulatory frameworks and that all required protections are built into the testing process. The RBI's approach is defined in "Enabling Framework for Regulatory Sandbox," particularly paragraph 7.1, which explains the duties and responsibilities of the FinTech Unit and Inter-Departmental Group in terms of advice and oversight37.
(B) Consumer Protection Measures
Consumer protection is a top priority in the RBI's regulatory sandbox framework. Throughout the testing phase, participants must put in place thorough procedures to protect consumer interests. These measurements include the following:
1. Mandatory Insurance Coverage: Unlike some countries, which may provide regulatory waivers or reliefs, the RBI requires sandbox participants to get proper insurance coverage to pay consumers for any losses suffered during the testing period. As stated in paragraph 6.8.3 of the RBI's framework, participants must submit proof of enough insurance to cover any consumer damages38.
2. Restrictions on Testing Scale: In order to efficiently manage risks, the RBI may set quantitative testing limits. This may include limiting the number of consumers engaged, transaction amounts, and transaction frequency. Such precautions avoid any negative influence on financial stability and shield individual customers from undue exposure to possible hazards39.
3. Targeted Consumer sectors: In some situations, the RBI may compel sandbox participants to limit their services to specified consumer profiles or market sectors that are better prepared to identify and handle possible risks. This tailored strategy guarantees that vulnerable people are not unintentionally exposed to high-risk items throughout the testing process.
4. Data Privacy and Cybersecurity: Recognising the essential necessity of protecting sensitive customer information, the RBI prioritises strong data privacy and cybersecurity safeguards. Participants must follow tight criteria to secure customer data, lowering the risk of data breaches and cyber-attacks40.
(C) Regulatory Oversight and Collaboration
The RBI's enabling framework encourages continual conversation and recalibration among regulators and sandbox participants. This collaborative method enables real-time modifications to testing settings and protections as necessary. The specialised case officer approach makes this engagement easier, ensuring that any developing concerns are addressed quickly.
In contrast, other jurisdictions may use various risk-mitigation strategies. For example:
(a) United Kingdom: The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) allocates specialised case officers to sandbox participants and may provide flexible regulatory reliefs to encourage innovation, as long as consumer protection is not jeopardised. Participants who use robot-advisory services may have their automated advice examined by trained financial advisors to guarantee accuracy and suitability (FCA, para 4.42)41.
(b) Australia: The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) provides a FinTech license exemption with built-in safeguards such as consumer protection measures, client exposure limitations, dispute resolution procedures, and compensation plans42. These preconditions seek to strike a balance between promoting innovation and protecting consumers and market integrity.
(D) Shift in Policy-Making Post Financial Crisis
Since the global financial crisis, policymakers' opinions have shifted significantly over the world, especially in India. Policymakers have shifted from seeing financial consumers as fully empowered players to acknowledging the need for stronger safeguards to ensure equitable treatment. Consumers and investors in FinTech may be especially vulnerable to the attractiveness of new goods that they may not fully comprehend the dangers and implications of. The RBI recognises this risk and has included strict consumer protection safeguards inside its sandbox structure. These methods are adapted to the individual business models and technology under examination, ensuring that adequate protections are in place. For example, when assessing digital lending systems, the RBI may implement:
(a) Enhanced disclosures: Participants must offer clear and thorough information about the product, possible hazards, and consumer rights.
(b) Transaction Limits: Limiting loan quantities and interest rates to protect consumers from becoming overly indebted.
(c) Complaint Redress Mechanisms: Ensuring that customers have access to effective mechanisms for addressing complaints throughout the testing period.
(E) Systematic Risk Containment
Beyond individual consumer protection, the RBI is also focused on managing systemic risks that might have an influence on the country's overall financial stability. The RBI controls the volume and breadth of sandbox testing to avoid untested technologies from triggering unexpected financial system disruptions. This careful approach allows the advantages of innovation to be realised while maintaining the integrity of the financial industry.
The Reserve Bank of India's regulatory sandbox framework demonstrates a thorough commitment to risk minimisation in the FinTech sector. By combining customised consumer protection measures, strict regulatory monitoring, and mandated insurance requirements, the RBI creates a secure environment for innovation. This strategy assures that improvements in financial technology benefit the economy while protecting customers and preserving financial stability.
The RBI's framework illustrates a balanced policy to promote the growth of FinTech technologies in India. It recognises the complexity and uncertainties inherent in emerging financial technology and handles them with thorough risk management methods. By doing so, the RBI not only promotes responsible innovation but also strengthens trust in the financial system, which is critical for the long-term growth and acceptance of FinTech solutions in India.
*****
Footnotes
2. E. Avgouleas, Regulating Financial Innovation, in N. Moloney, E. Ferran, and J. Payne (eds), The Oxford Handbook of Financial Regulation (OUP 2015).
3. R. Baldwin and J. Black, Really Responsive Regulation, 71 MOD. L. REV. 59, 65 (2008).
4. M. Fenwick, Wulf Kaal, and E.P. Vermeulen, Regulation Tomorrow: What Happens When Technology is Faster than the Law, 6 AM. U. BUS. L. REV. 561, 566 (2016).
5. C. Brummer and Y. Yadev, Fintech and the Innovation Trilemma, 107 GEO. L.J. 235, 240 (2019).
6. Iris H-Y Chiu, The Disruptive Implications of Fintech - Policy Themes for Financial Regulators, 21 J. TECH. L. & POL’Y 1, 10 (2017).
7. C. Brummer, Disruptive Technology and Securities Regulation, 84 FORDHAM L. REV. 977, 980 (2015).
8. European Commission, FinTech Action Plan: For a More Competitive and Innovative European Financial Sector, COM (2018) 109/2, para 2, November, 2019.
9. D.W. Arner, J.N. Barberis, and R.P. Buckley, FinTech, Reg-Tech, and the Reconceptualization of Financial Regulation, 3 NW. J. INT'L L. & BUS. 371, 380 (2017).
10. E. Biber and others, Regulating Business Innovation as Policy Disruption: From the Model T to Airbnb, 70 VAND. L. REV. 1561, 1570 (2017).
11. Id.
12. W. Magnusson, Regulating FinTech, 71 VAND. L. REV. 1167, 1175 (2018).
13. J. Armour and L. Enriques, The Promise and Perils of Crowdfunding: Between Corporate Finance and Consumer Contracts, 2018 MOD. L. REV. 51, 60 (2018).
14. J. Armour and L. Enriques, Individual Investors' Access to Crowd investing: Two Regulatory Models, in D. Cumming and L. Hornuf (eds), The Economics of Crowdfunding (Palgrave 2018).
15. Iris H-Y Chiu, Pathways to European Policy and Regulation in the Crypto-Economy, 10 EUR. J. RISK REG. 738, 745 (2019).
16. R.H. Weber and R. Baisch, FinTech: Eligible Safeguards to Foster the Regulatory Framework, 33 J. INT'L BANKING L. & REG. 335, 340 (2018).
17. A. Wardrop, Co-Regulation, Responsive Regulation, and the Reform of Australia's Retail Electronic Payment Systems, 30 LAW IN CONTEXT 197, 205 (2014).
18. E. Biber and others, Regulating Business Innovation as Policy Disruption: From the Model T to Airbnb, 70 VAND. L. REV. 1561, 1570 (2017).
19. W. Magnusson, Regulating FinTech, 71 VAND. L. REV. 1167, 1175 (2018).
20. M. Arnold, UK FinTech Sector in Buoyant Mood as Valuations Soar, FIN. TIMES London, 27 September, 2018.
21. Basel Committee on Banking Supervision, Sound Practices: Implications of FinTech Developments for Banks and Bank Supervisors, Bank for International Settlements, 2018.
22. Reserve Bank of India, Enabling Framework for Regulatory Sandbox, August 2019, para 5.
23. Reserve Bank of India, Enabling Framework for Regulatory Sandbox, August 2019, para 6.5.
24. Reserve Bank of India, Enabling Framework for Regulatory Sandbox, August 2019, para 6.1.1.
25. Reserve Bank of India, Enabling Framework for Regulatory Sandbox, August 2019, para 6.1.2.
26. Reserve Bank of India, Enabling Framework for Regulatory Sandbox, August 2019, para 6.3.
27. Reserve Bank of India, Enabling Framework for Regulatory Sandbox, August 2019, para 6.3.
28. Reserve Bank of India, Enabling Framework for Regulatory Sandbox, August 2019, para 6.4.
29. Reserve Bank of India, Enabling Framework for Regulatory Sandbox, August 2019, para 6.5.
30. Reserve Bank of India, Enabling Framework for Regulatory Sandbox, August 2019, para 6.7.
31. Reserve Bank of India, Enabling Framework for Regulatory Sandbox, August 2019, para 6.8.
32. Consultative Group to Assist the Poor (CGAP), Jenik, I., and Lauer, K., Regulatory Sandboxes and Financial Inclusion, October 2017, p.6.
33. Financial Conduct Authority, Regulatory sandbox lessons learned report, October 2017, para 2.14 and 4.42.
34. Id.
35. Buckley, R. P., et al., "The Dark Side of Digital Financial Transformation: The New Risks of FinTech and the Rise of Tech Risk," European Banking Institute Working Paper No. 54, 2019.
36. Reserve Bank of India, Draft Enabling Framework for Regulatory Sandbox, April 2019.
37. Reserve Bank of India, Enabling Framework for Regulatory Sandbox, August 2019, para 7.1.
38. Reserve Bank of India, Enabling Framework for Regulatory Sandbox, August 2019, para 6.8.
39. Reserve Bank of India, Enabling Framework for Regulatory Sandbox, August 2019, para 6.8.3.
40. Reserve Bank of India, Enabling Framework for Regulatory Sandbox, August 2019, para 6.1.3.1.
41. Financial Conduct Authority, "Regulatory Sandbox: Lessons Learned Report" (2017), para 4.42
42. Australian Securities and Investments Commission, "Fintech Licensing Exemption Framework" (2017).
