VidhiAagaz
International Journal ofLaw Management & Humanities
ISSN 2581-5369 · Open access
International Journal ofLaw Management & Humanities
Open accessArticlesVol. 8 No. I (2025)pp. 1211–1228

Cameroon’s Tenancy Conundrum: Navigating the Intricacies of Lease Agreements

705views326downloads
Published 9 February 2025 · pp. 1211–1228 · Vol. 8 No. I (2025)
Abstract

More than half of Cameroon’s population live in urban areas with majority being tenants or lessees. Lease agreements often present a wide range of problems causing squabbles between lessees and lessors or tenants and landlords, especially due to the fact that there is no uniform law regulating this domain in Cameroon. Therefore, resort can only be made to OHADA Uniform Act on General Commercial Law that deals with commercial lease. Most often, lease or tenancy agreements are concluded verbally without formal writing. Also, many people enter into such agreements without clear definition of the rights and obligations of the parties. The legal considerations put in place by the law to regulate lease agreements are imperative especially to traders who take out premises on rent for commercial/business purposes. Traders enjoy their business profitability where premises are rented in an environment which is conducive for commercial purposes. Therefore, this paper seeks to identify the nature of a lease or tenancy agreement, while establishing the rights and obligations that exists in such agreement, and the grounds for termination. While making use of an in-depth content analysis and critical evaluation of primary and secondary data, this paper argues that the rights of the lessee or tenant who is the weaker party, goes beyond that of possession as imbedded in the rights and obligations of the parties. The paper culminates with some recommendations for better protection of the rights and obligations of both the lessee and lessor or tenant and landlord.

Keywords
LessorLandlordLesseeTenantLease agreementTenancy Rent
Contents
Full text

INTRODUCTION

Nowadays, with the advent of globalization, the most valuable investment of mankind is on land which most often, appreciates and scarcely depreciate. Life is built and surrounded around the use of land for several purposes such as agro-pastoral, activities, other business investment, habitation etc. As such, while on one hand, we have the owner of land and on the other hand a seeker of land thereby bringing to live the landlord-tenant (lessor-lessee) relationship.3 Landlords may at times exercise ownership of their lands not just to the detriment of their tenants but even the society as a whole.4 In fact, laws on the landlord and tenant relationship were triggered by the inhumane and demeaning attitudes of landlords towards their tenants, especially after the Second World War5 due to the unequal nature of the landlord-tenant relationship where the landlord possesses certain discretionary power to withhold access to personal properties of the tenant,6 unilaterally increase rent and even terminate the tenancy. We take an example in the High Trees case,7 which though did not out-rightly spark tenancy law is instrumental in the law of contract, as tenancy law developed from the law of contract. Worse still, Cameroon continues to face the same problem till date. Thus, tenancy law is very vital in the protection of the tenant from unfair treatment by landlords.8

Due to mass movement of people to urban areas; crisis in the Northwest and Southwest regions of Cameroon, Boko Haram insurgencies in the Far North region and political crisis in neighbouring countries such as the Central African Republic, Chad, etc., housing has become a great problem as there is a mass influx of persons moving in from different areas to specific towns such as Douala and Yaounde in search of greener pasture like seeking for job opportunities or business ventures which no doubt increases the demand for land and housing. Therefore, it is reality that many refugees and internally displaced persons who were formal landlords become tenants in various cities. As a result, the increasing cost of housing is exacerbated by high inflation rates in the society. Tenancy law has been isolated from discussions that have sparked interest in contract law and philosophy due to decades of comparatively low scholarly attention. In order to create a critical vocabulary that goes beyond its current state, it appears appropriate and vital to bring tenancy law into discussions.9

In the past, the only legal basis for the landlord-tenant relationship was a contract or the law of responsibilities. The connection was viewed as the strict respect of the Doctrine of Privity in contract that only resulted in personal rights, not property rights, meaning that only the parties to the arrangement may profit from it, not outside parties. By the end of the fifteenth century, the law regarded the landlord-tenant relationship as granting the tenant a property right that was enforceable against third parties.10 Family members of the tenant who are residing in the property due to the tenant’s agreement with the landlord, subtenants brought into the property by the tenant, and any other individuals to whom the tenant may have alienated his or her interests as a form of security are all considered as other people in this context.11

Leases or tenancy relationships between landlords and tenants in Cameroon are governed by three different legislations; to wit: the OHADA Uniform Act on General Commercial Law (UAGCL) 1998 (hereinafter referred to as the UAGCL) as amended,12 the Code Civile13 applicable in French-speaking Cameroon14 and the Recovery of Premises Ordinance Chapter 176 of the 1948 Laws of Nigeria applicable in English-speaking Cameroon.15

UNDERSTANDING THE CONCEPTS OF LEASE OR TENANCY AGREEMENTS

A lease agreement or tenancy is a contract whereby one party, the lessor or landlord grants the right to use a particular premises (building or land) for a period of time to the other party, the tenant or lessee who pays for the transfer of the right to use, a fixed amount regularly. This contract sets out the rules the landlord and tenant will follow in the tenancy. A tenancy is created by the parties either in writing or orally. It can also be created by operation of the law, as in the case of successive and statutory tenancy.16 A tenancy or lease agreement is therefore a vital document that should be completed prior to a lessor or landlord letting out his property to a lessee or tenant.

A lessor or landlord is the owner of a rented premises, his agent or caretaker who has been given a power of attorney by the owner of the property, land or real estate which is leased to an individual or business who is called a tenant or lessee.17

A lessee or tenant is an adult, an emancipated minor or group of persons that have signed a rental or lease agreement or entered an oral rental agreement with a landlord or his agent to use the property for residential or commercial purpose and is in occupancy of such property for a period of time. Therefore, this does not include anyone who is in an unlawful occupancy under a bonafide claim to be the owner.18

Rent is the compensation paid by a lessee or tenant to the property owner, agent or caretaker (landlord or lessor) for use or occupancy of a property. Rents are often paid upon the terms agreed on in the tenancy or lease agreement. This is however subject to applicable legislative or regulatory provisions.

There lies a great difference between a tenancy and a lease, though they are often used interchangeably. A lease is a long-term contract between the landlord and tenant typically lasting for a fixed period19 for example 5 years or 99 years as was in the High Trees case and can be transferred or assigned (sublet) to another party on the consent of the landlord. A tenancy is a short-term contract often used for periodic tenancies20, for example, month-to-month and cannot be transferred or assigned to another party. Also, one may distinguish a lease from a tenancy by virtue of the use of the property let out. In tenancy agreements, it is often a residential premise let out, such as a living room, a residential apartment etc. While, when we talk of leases, what is often let out are business premises such as commercial rooms or buildings, sheds in markets, empty land in a commercial area etc. In essence the differences that lie between the lease and tenancy agreements is the fact that leases are typically longer-term, more formal and require a written document and can be transferred, while tenancies are shorter-term, can be less formal, may be unwritten and cannot be transferred. As such, one will discover that, whether the use of appellation, tenant or lessee on the one hand and landlord or lessor on the other hand depends on the purpose for which the rented property is used for and to an extend the location and characteristics of the property.21 As such, in the above remarks, this article shall use the words tenancy and lease interchangeably but will not at any one point in time fail to make a distinction of both terms wherever they cannot be used interchangeably.

A commercial lease is the letting of a premises or buildings for commercial, industrial, handicraft or professional purposes or non-built-on estate on which buildings for industrial, commercial, handicraft or profession purposes have been constructed, either before or after conclusion of the lease, where such buildings are built or used with the consent or knowledge of the owner.22 The UAGCL in its section 103 defines a commercial lease as any agreement, written or unwritten, between the owner of an immovable property or part thereof falling within the scope of Article 10123 of this Act and any natural person or corporate body allowing the latter to carry on any commercial, industrial, handicraft or professional activity on the premises with the consent of the owner. This lease shall be for a specified or unspecified period. In cases where the agreement is not written, it is deemed to be for an unspecified period,24 meaning its termination will be subject to prior notice. This is in no way saying that, prior notice is not required when the lease is written but the tendency is that there is already an anticipation of its termination unless the lessee expresses the will to renew.

On the other hand, a tenancy agreement is the renting out of a building for residential purposes whereby the agreement can either be written or unwritten for a specified or unspecified duration. However, it has become customary in Cameroon that most tenancy agreements are often unspecified and the contract comes to an end upon the issuance of a notice to quit by the landlord or tenant.

TYPES OF LEASE OR TENANCY AGREEMENTS

There exist different types of tenancy or leases which could be grouped into a contractual tenancy (fixed-term and periodic tenancies) and statutory tenancy.25 A fixed-term tenancy is one with a specific start and end date while periodic tenancy is one that continues from one period to the next such as weekly, monthly, quarterly etc. We can also identify tenancy at will which has no fixed term and can be terminated by either party at any time; tenancy at sufferance which occurs when a tenant remains in possession of the property after the lease has expired; joint tenancy involves two or more tenants who share equal rights and responsibilities, such as two friends renting same room or apartment and each contributing to its maintenance and rent; tenancy in common where two or more tenants who have separate and distinct shares in the property (such as where the landlord lets out same apartment to separate individuals, each having a separate room but both sharing the living room, kitchen etc.; and leasehold tenancy which involves a tenant who has a long-term lease for example 10 years, (as where a company rent out a building or land to use as their base in order to carry out a project. This is very common in cities like Douala and Yaounde where lands have been rented for the construction of hotels and resorts) as practiced in Cameroon. These tenancy or lease agreements can be drawn up by the parties themselves or solely by the landlord. It therefore depends on the parties concerned and can also be drawn up by a notary public to give more legal effects in case of a breach. However, in Cameroon, lease agreements are often a contract of adhesion while tenancy agreements are often negotiated by the parties.

The UAGCL however was applicable only to commercial leases and not tenancy agreements in towns having at least five thousand inhabitants.26 The effect here was that, in rural areas whereby the population is less than five thousand inhabitants the UAGCL will be inapplicable to commercial lease agreements and so the right pieces of legislation will be the Code Civile and the Recovery of Premises Act in the different divides of the country as seen above. However, the revised OHADA Act of 2010 no longer upholds this hindrance, thereby approving the application of the UAGCL throughout Cameroon with respects to commercial lease.

THE ENTRY OF A LEASE OR TENANCY AGREEMENT

A lease or tenancy is concluded between two persons, whether natural persons or artificial persons as where an individual (landlord) lets out his premises to an individual or a corporate body (tenant) and, or a corporate body lets out its premises to an individual or corporate body to be used for residential purposes or as a business premises. A tenancy may be created on any land or building thereof, and such tenancy shall carry with it a right of exclusive possession.27 In this regard, the parties shall freely determine the duration of the lease as well as the amount of money to be paid for usage of such a premise as well as the payment period and date of payment of rent.

A lease may be concluded for a specified or unspecified duration.28 Where the lease is unwritten, it shall be deemed to have been concluded for an unspecified duration.29 As such when the lease is for a specified duration, rents are paid as agreed upon and the lease expires upon the lapse of the period leased for, but when it is an unspecified duration, the continuous payment of rent subsist the tenancy and terminates it when any of the parties indicate to end the lease. The lease takes effects from the moment the contract is entered into unless otherwise agreed by the parties.

Usually in Cameroon, lease or tenancy agreement can be made just between the lessor or landlord and lessee or tenant. However, in order to add up more impetus and a legal backing, these agreements are often drawn up by notary publics and signed by both parties in his presence upon the terms agreed on, such as the rented premises, its commencement, rents, rates and mode of payments, notices and termination of tenancy, taxes and outgoings, assignments and under-letting, alterations of premises and the covenants of both parties to the tenancy.

In cities such as Douala, Buea, Limbe, Garoua and Yaounde, estate agents exist who represent house owners, though some act out of any prior agreement between them and the landlord and some others roles end only after bringing a prospective tenant. As such most of these estate agents either have a power of attorney over the owners’ premises or are only middlemen for the house owners.

In cities such as Bamenda, there exist a very little number of estate agents as most house owners either make advertisement themselves of their premises on rent or they appoint caretakers through power of attorney to act in any such way as will benefit the landlord with respect to the premises on his behalf.

Before a lease or tenancy comes into existence, there usually exist no prior agreement on the rented premises between the lessor or landlord and lessee or tenant, as they may never have met each other before. During the period of negotiations, all what is said will be taken as mere inducements to contract and not words that could be taken seriously. As such, the parties could either end up in an agreement or not. Most often, the parties have a prior agreement on the rent to be paid by the intending tenant and the period the advance is to be made. It has often been noticed that pre-negotiations sometimes do not end up in a tenancy agreement, and so no actions are often taken against someone who breach a promise to let, be it the landlord who gets a new tenant with higher rent or the intending tenant who finds a more accommodating premises at either same or lower price. This gives the reason why no binding contract will exist where negotiations are still taking place especially in house rent business.

There might however be squabbles where the landlord, for example asks the intending tenant to make a deposit as a guarantee for keeping the premises from being rented to someone else and the intending tenant does so, but due to certain reasons does not occupy such premises. In such a case, an understanding on the amount to be refunded will be made between the lessor or landlord and lessee or tenant and in case they cannot get into an agreement, a court action will be proper and it will be at the discretion of the court to make whatever decision it deems fit depending on the submissions brought forth by both parties.

RIGHTS OF PARTIES IN THE LEASE OR TENANCY AGREEMENT

The rights of the lessor and the lessee are first of all in respect to the obligations of the parties. In addition, other rights exist such as those dealing with compensation for improvements made by the lessee on the rented property, subsistence of the tenancy in case of death of either party, transfer of ownership etc.

a) Right to remove fixtures and to compensation for improvements made by the lessee

There is no argument that a lessee upon the expiration of his tenancy enjoys the right to make away with tenant’s fixtures,30 to wit, trade appliances, domestic and ornamental fixture or agricultural fixture at the expiration of the tenancy. However, this right to remove fixtures is sub modo to certain conditions. Firstly, the removal must be either before the expiration of the lease31 or within a reasonable time after the expiration of the lease.32 Secondly, the right to remove fixtures entails that such removal must be done with care ensuring not to leave the property in a state of disrepair, else he will be liable for such repair and also damages for loss of rent and for delay if the lessor can prove that the property cannot be let out due to such repairs as was held in Westminster (Duke) v Swinton.33

From the forgoing, conceptualisation of improvements, it would appear that improvements in relation to landlord and tenant on a real estate are generally the obligation of the landlord as provided in UAGCL.34 But more often than not, tenants saddle themselves with the responsibility of not just annexing tenant’s fixtures, but execute more permanent improvements that ‘forms part of the leased land and ipso facto, part of the landlord’s reversion’.35 These permanent improvements is premised on the common law doctrine of quic quid plantatur solo cedit, which means ‘whatever is affixed to the soil belongs to the soil’, and therefore is subjected to the same rights of property as the soil itself. It thus follows that, all annexations, attachments and/or improvements of a permanent nature made on the leased property by the tenant with or without the consent of the landlord belongs to the landlord. As such if the tenant erects a fence, builds a washing sink, tiles the rooms of the house, before the law, the landlord who is the owner of the house becomes the owner irrespective of the amount spent by the tenant. In the Nigerian case of Akerele v Akerele,36 the court stated that ‘the fact that a person spent money on the improvement of another’s property cannot divest the owner of his title to the property.’37

The question to be posed here is, if a tenant is subject to compensation for carrying out improvements on the property with or without the consent of his landlord? Issues pertaining to compensation are governed by statutes and/or the principles of law and equity. Under the common law, tenants are at liberty to carry out any improvement they desire on property let to them, subject however to the law of waste and any contrary stipulation in the lease, but are not entitled to compensation. This matches with the principle of quic quid plantatur solo cedit, other than improvements classified as tenant fixtures.38 As such, the UAGCL clearly provides that tenants are subject to compensation if the landlord gives consent for improvements to be made.39 However, the reading of this Act, does not provide any particular form upon which consent can be given, nor does it provide if an antedated consent is not valid.

The distinction between improvements and tenant’s fixtures as stated in Newzealand Property Corporation v H.M & S Ltd.40 is that improvements must be construed as alterations or anything of the nature of renewal of, addition to, or substitution for a structure in existence made by the tenant which are landlord’s fixtures, and of which the tenant is never able to remove. But this is not the case with tenant’s fixtures which may be removed by the tenant if desired. It follows that albeit made by a tenant, an improvement which prima facie adds value to a leased property41 is by and large a landlord’s fixtures which the tenant cannot physically remove but may make claim for compensation under certain conditions as discussed above.

b) Subsistence of a lease after the death of any party

Where any of the party to the commercial lease dies, the lease still subsists. In the case of death of the lessee who is a natural person, the lease shall be continued with the spouse, direct ascendants or descendants of the lessee who have so requested the lessor by either a judicial or extrajudicial act within a period of three months following the death.42

c) Agreement of rent

The parties to a commercial lease have been given the rights by the UAGCL to freely agree upon the rent subject to applicable laws and legislations.43 Any modifications of the rent shall also be upon conditions laid down by the parties or in case of no agreement, the aggrieved party can seize the competent court. The parties further have the possibility to make an application to the court to fix the rent in case they cannot come into a consensus. The court in setting the new rent, takes into consideration the state of the premises, its surface area, state of dilapidation and the rent for commercial purposes commonly charged in the area or the vicinity.44

d) Renewal

The lessee and lessor both reserve the right to renew the lease of an unspecified or specified period. The lessee shall acquire the right to renew the lease when he shows prove of having carried on under the conditions stipulated in the lease, the activity provided for in it during a minimum period of two years.45 The renewal will last for a period of three years where it is for a specified duration46 and if it were for an unspecified duration, the party wishing to terminate will have to give a six (6) months’ notice to quit before the expiration of the lease.47 It is also the opinion of the law that the lessee interested to renew a specified duration lease has to give notice to the lessor at least three (3) months before the expiration of the lease by either a judicial or non-judicial act and when the lessor fails to reply to the renewal request within one (1) month, it is considered accepted. Failure to give such notice forfeits renewal rights of the lessee.48

The parties are not allowed by law to include in the lease contract any stipulation that restricts the right to renewal of the lease.49 The lessor may only object to a renewal upon the fulfillment of certain conditions such as the payment of an eviction fee to the lessee be it for a specified or unspecified duration. In the case of non-agreement on the amount of the eviction fee, it shall be set by the competent court taking into account the lessee’s turnover, investments made by the lessee, the geographical location of the premise and moving expenses due to the denial to renew.50 However the lessor may not be liable for an eviction fee were he does not renew the lease for the reasons that, if he can establish legitimate reasons for non-renewal which include the non-observance of substantial terms of the lease agreement such as non-payment of rent. The above reason can only be possible if the non-observance of the main term of the lease continued continuously for at least two (2) months and the lessor had issued a notice to cease the lessee from such act or omission.51 Also in case of a demolition of the building where an approved plan is shown by the lessor, renewal may be objected. However, the lessee is entitled to remain in the premises up to the time of demolition and shall have priority to obtain a lease after rebuild. Where the newly rebuilt premises are devoted to something else other than the activity in the lease or if a new lease is not offered to the lessee, the lessor shall pay an eviction fee.52

Also, the lessor may without liability, to pay the eviction fee deny to renew the lease of the main premises which are close to a residential premise owned by him where he intends to use them himself or to be used by his spouse or ascendants or descendants or those of his spouse. Nonetheless, this right is limited in the event that the lessee establishes that a deprivation of enjoyment of the adjoining or accessory premises seriously disrupts the enjoyment of the lease on the main premises or when the main and accessory premises are in an indivisible state or connected to each other.53 It is worth noting that the right of renewal extends to sub-tenants who may ask the principal lessee to renew subject to a clause on sub-leasing in the original contract.54

Where works and improvements are made on the premises by the lessee with the permission of the lessor, he is entitled to recover a value of the modifications done where the right to renew is denied irrespective of the reason. In case the parties cannot agree on this, the lessee may seize the competent court at the expiration of a lease or specified duration or at the time of the receipt of the notice to quit in an unspecified duration lease to make an order accordingly.55

e) Transfer and sub-lease of the premises

When we talk of transfer of the premises, this is to the effect that the business ownership may change hands and so does the lessee; as in a situation of sale of the entire business by the owners to a new trader. In this regard, Article 118 of the UAGCL says any transfer of the lease shall be notified in writing to the lessor by a judicial or extra-judicial act. The notice must carry the identity of the assignee, his address and his registration number in the Trade and Personal Property Credit Register (TPPCR).56 The transfer shall not be applicable to the lessor where he is not notified57 and so the lessor reserves the right to object such a transfer within one month from time of notification by bringing before the competent court an action to that effect stating legitimate reasons for rejecting such breach of lease obligations by the lessee etc. In case the lessor fails to reply within the stipulated period, it is considered as an acceptance.58

Sub-lease refers to the situation whereby the tenant who had contracted the commercial lease sub-let the premises to a third party thereby contracting out of that normally entered into between him and the lessor. The UAGCL in its Article 121 rejects partial or total sub-leasing of the property. In this regard, the lessee can only sub-lease where it is expressly agreed upon in the commercial lease contract, failure of which there shall be no sub-leasing. However, where there is an agreed sub-lease clause, any such shall be upon a written notification to the lessor and so the lessor is not bound when he is not notified.59 It also follows that where the sub-lease rent is higher than the original rent, the lessor may also increase the commercial lease rent. Failure to agree on the increase amount, the competent court may make such increase taking into consideration the appurtances of the premises.60

OBLIGATIONS OF THE PARTIES TO A LEASEOR TENANCY AGREEMENT

(A) Obligations of the lessor

The lessor has got two main obligations amongst others. These two main obligations are those to deliver up the rented premises to the lessee and that of carrying out major repairs in order to keep the premises in perfect rental state.

a) Delivery of the leased premises in good condition

The lessor shall deliver the premises given out for lease in good condition. It follows that the lessor has the obligation to repair the premises prior to the occupation by the lessee.61 This obligation also extends to secondary premises essential to the operation of the business of the lessee. It may include parking, secondary premises serving as warehouse, etc. So, to put the parties free from legal uncertainties, the OHADA legislator foresees the establishment of a situation prior to occupancy. This obligation rests primarily on the lessee because the presumption of conform delivery favors the lessor. This is one brand of balancing of charges between parties. Incidentally, the lessee will have to be especially careful because in practice it often takes a relatively long time between the conclusion of the contract and the taking of premises. This period is generally used by the lessor to repair the premises to suit the context agreed in the tenancy.62 If he is dishonest, a less demanding lessee while taking possession could see his rights jeopardized later. Hence the importance of the inventory.

b) Major repairs

According to Article 106 of the UAGCL, the lessor also has the obligation to maintain the premises in good rental condition; thus, it is required to carry out at his expense the necessary and urgent work of major repairs. The major repairs shall in particular include the repairs of major walls, vaults, beams, roofs, supporting walls, enclosing walls, septic tanks and drainage tanks. This is however distinguished from the maintenance done by the lessee.

Within this period of repairs the lessee shall bear the inconveniences and if the urgent repairs make it impossible to enter into possession of the premises, the lessee could request the legal termination of the lease or its suspension during the duration of the repair works. The amount of the rent shall thus be reduced in proportion to the time the lessee was deprived of the use of the premises. If the lessor fails to carry out such major repairs, the lessee can seek for legal redress before the competent court and if the lessee carries out such repairs, the lessor is bound to reimburse the lessee.63

c) The Guarantee of quiet enjoyment

The lessor shall ensure that the lessee enjoys the premises with no disturbances from either himself or that of any descendants, beneficiaries or whosever in relation to the lessor.64 As such, the lessor shall be liable to the lessee for disturbance affecting the use and enjoyment caused by him or by his rightful claimants or agents.65 Neither shall the lessor of his own free will, change the state of the premises leased or restrict the use thereof.66 This is the right of full possession of the tenant which must be fully and exclusively enjoyed. Any unlawful entry into the premises by the landlord or any of his descendants or beneficiaries is actionable as a trespass.67

(B) Obligations of the lessee

The tenant has also got obligations as to the lease agreement while occupying the premises rented by him. These obligations are of three major types though others exist. The three main obligations are that of rent payment, diligence in the use of the premises and maintaining the lessee’s premises.

a) Payment of rent

Tenancy relationships are acknowledged by payment of rent.68 The main obligation of the lessee is to pay the rent according to the terms agreed. In the Nigerian case of Olaniyan v Shokunbi,69 the court stated that it is profit earned by the landlord, which must be certain and must have been earned from the property granted. In principle, the rent is payable as agreed by the parties and in the absence of any agreement, payable monthly. However, in practice, the parties may agree on a trimester, quarterly or half-yearly or yearly payment and it begins to run from the date agreed. But where no date is given regarding when the rent should begin to count, the rent shall start to count from the day on which the tenancy is created70 and subsequent payments follow suit based on whether rent is paid monthly, per trimester or yearly. Its essential character in a lease contract makes it a substantial obligation whose violation may justify the opposition of the lessor to transfer, contract renewal or even cause its termination and recently the Cameroonian legislators have provided for criminal sanctions for the non-payment of rent in section 322-1 of the Penal Code.71

One of the modernity character of the OHADA law is to have introduced the possibility of rent payment by mail or electronically. It follows that the lessee can now use the cheque, credit card and other electronic means of payment and not necessarily in cash.72

b) Diligent use of premises

The lessee is supposed to use the premises leased with due diligence and in accordance with the specifications in the lease or, in the absence of any written agreement, according to the presumed use, depending on the circumstances. The tenant will be liable for any damages caused and must repair them upon the termination of the lease ortenancy in the state he met the property.73 Where the lessee puts the premises into use other than that of which they are intended, and as a result of which the lessor suffers damage, the latter could bring an action before the competent court to terminate the lease. The same shall apply where the lessee carries on a connected or additional activity to that specified in the lease.74

In this regard, the lessee shall use the property as if it were owned by him and not carry out other activities which was not agreed upon at the time the lease agreement was signed. In case of such a change of activity or where there is a need for modification in the structure of the property, the lessee must inform the lessor.

c) Maintenance of the premises

The lessee will be required to make maintenance repairs, knowing that he will answer for the damage or losses due to negligence. This maintenance shall be minor in nature so as to continue an enjoyment of the premises. In this vein, it may concern paint or sanitary facilities repairs etc.75 No alterations of the property without the consent of the landlord is acceptable.76

TERMINATION OF A COMMERCIAL LEASE

This relates to the coming to an end of the commercial lease. This can be by two main ways; upon the act of the parties or judicial termination.

a) Termination by the parties

This can occur in different ways. Firstly, where the lease is for a specified period, the end of such a period without renewal will automatically terminate the lease without need for any prior notice. However, if the tenant wishes to renew the rent, he must notify the landlord before the date of expiration. So will the tenancy be renewed to that of an unspecified duration in the absence of further agreements where the landlord goes ahead to collect rent for any additional period upon the expiration of the previous tenure.77 In situations of unspecified duration, the notification of termination by either party ends the lease, 30 days of notice for monthly pay, 90 days for yearly pay renewable.

b) Termination by judicial act

By this, the lessor may make an application to the competent court where the lessee fails to pay rent or does not comply with the lease contract where a notification by an extra judicial act is given complying with the clauses and conditions of the lease for the court to terminate such a lease. The judgment of termination shall be done one month after notification of the registered creditors of the lessee’s business.

THE TERMINATION PROCEDURE OF A LEASE OR TENANCY AGREEMENT

The termination of a lease agreement or tenancy could be as a result of a natural end of the lease or due to a breach. In the former case, the lessee or tenant may just indicate to the lessor or landlord of his intention to leave the premises at the expiration of the lease. In case of a breach, the UAGCL enjoins the lessor or landlord to serve on the lessee or tenant a notice calling on him or her to comply with the particular clause which the lessee or tenant is in breach for a period of 30 days.

The law further provides some breaches as fundamental; for example, failure to pay rents, which warrant that, the formality of notice may not be followed. When the requisite condition is not complied with, the landlord can seize the competent court for an eviction order. An eviction is an act of ejecting a person from a rented property by process of the law.78 Nonetheless, if there has been no breach of the clauses of the contract and the lessor or landlord wishes to terminate the lease contract, the practice in Cameroon has often been to give a three months’ notice renewable before engaging or proceeding to obtain an eviction order from court.79

As aforementioned, in the Anglophone regions of Cameroon, it is the Recovery of Premises Ordinance Chapter 176 that regulates these issues. This ordinance has graduated the length of notice to determine the lease or tenancy and to proceed to seeking an eviction order from court with jurisdiction. Article 8 (1) (a) (b) (c) (d) stipulates the various durations, that is, a week’s notice for weekly tenancy; a month’s notice for monthly tenancy, and three months’ notice for a yearly tenancy. Failing to respect this notice allows the diligent party to seek redress in a Law Court for the other party to be evicted. It should be noted that the various periods of notice is renewable once.

The Code Civile in French-speaking Cameroon has its own provisions which all converge before the law court for an order of eviction. It is therefore jungle justice to remove one’s door or throw out the belongings of a lessee or tenant who has breached the contract. The law frowns at such behaviour that can expose the landlord to criminal prosecution for invasion of residence under the Penal Code.

The competent authority to enforce eviction order in case of non-respect of the lease clauses or terms such as the non-payment of rents or in other cases are the courts put in place by the Judicial Organisation Act of 2006. By this the court of First Instance (otherwise known as the Magistrate Court) is competent to hear and decide on cases that do not exceed 10.000.000fcfa (ten million francs),80 while the High Court will determine cases that exceed the sum of 10.000.000fcfa (ten million francs).81

CHALLENGES ENCOUNTERED IN ENFORCING THE LAW

The challenges in enforcing the law are two-fold. First, the Land Tenure Law of 1974 in Article 8 forbids any Public Notary from drawing up a lease when the land in question is not registered in the name of the lessor. The reality in Cameroon is that a majority of houses in urban areas along commercial centers purported to be owned by private individuals are on national land. The question now is on what legal basis are the parties standing when entering into a lease agreement?

Secondly the court cannot enforce an illegal contract because the party leasing without title over the peace of land has no locus standi to contract, let alone enforce the obligation arising therefrom. The UAGCL provisions face a difficult terrain, thus leaving the enforcement of legal provisions in this area at the mercy of good faith, culminating to why most complaints end at the level of the legal department or police rather than being heard in court and are eventually abandoned by the complainants who presumably settle by negotiation or conciliation.

(A) Recommendations

The local legislator has to rethink a possible amendment of Article 8 of the Land Tenure Law so as to increase the protection of lessors or landlords against crapulent lessees or tenants who may exploit this provision to their advantage by evading the payment of rent and going free without any legal redress for the lessor or landlord.

It is also advisable that parties to a lease or tenancy contract should carefully study and understand each clause of the contract vis-a-vis the regulations in force. People should consult legal practitioners to advise and draw up lease or tenancy contracts for them that represent their true intentions and the spirit of the law.

There is also the need for a Law Reform Commission which can look into these problematic areas of the law and propose possible amendment for a smooth implementation of international treaties duly ratified by the country.

Again, ignorance of the obligations and rights implied in the contract by law on the part of all the parties to it, contributes to poor implementation or respect of the law on tenancy. As such, better measures for implementation of these obligations and rights needs to be put in place.

CONCLUSION

Lease agreements can be concluded by an individual, a group of persons or between natural persons and artificial persons (companies). The obligations and rights existing in every lease contract is either provided for by the law and also as a matter of custom in the area or city concerned. Any party to a contract has a legal right to challenge the other party if he/she is aggrieved. The UAGCL provides that a lessee or tenant can object to a notice to quit the premises and the competent court will appreciate the grounds of objection and rule accordingly. For example, if the requisite length of notice is not respected by the lessor or landlord, the lessee or tenant can object before a law court.

In view of the possibility of unequal bargaining powers that may exist in the tenancy relationship especially to the detriment of the tenant, the urgent need to regulate tenancy relationships is inevitable82 especially with the growing nature of Cameroon’s urban cities. Following findings conducted in Garoua, Bamenda, Buea Douala and Yaounde, most landlords and tenants do not fully understand their rights and obligations and presumably, this expands to other cities and rural communities. In fact, there are always quarrels between landlords and tenants during the termination of the tenancy as to the return of the caution fees paid, money spent by tenants for maintenance with the consent of the landlord etc. This only indicates that a legal text is required to better regulate the tenancy relationship. For example, the existing laws are each lacking in different aspects; The UAGCL and the code civile makes no mention on the recovery of premises, while in Anglophone Cameroon, the law in place regulating this aspect, does not adequately reflect the Cameroonian standards.

*****

Footnotes

3. Ater S. Vendaga, An Examination of the Meaning, Types, and Nature of Tenancy under the Nigerian Law, 1 J. L., 1 (2023), https://www.researchgate.net/publication/376958005 (last visited Aug. 22, 2024).

4. Ibid.

5. Arinze V., Understanding the Legal Disparities Among Leases, Tenancies and Other Forms of Occupation: The Convolutional Conceptions of Tenancy Laws, 3 Int’l J. Comp. L. & Legal Phil. (IJOCLLEP) 3 (2021).

6. Debrunner G., Kolocek M. & Schindelegger A., The Decommodifying Capacity of Tenancy Law: Comparative Analysis of Tenants’ and Landlords’ Rights in Austria, Germany, and Switzerland, Int’l J. Hous. Pol’y 4 (2024), https://doi.org/10.1080/19491247.2024.2367835 (last visited Aug. 22, 2024).

7. Central London Property Ltd v. High Trees House Ltd [1947] KB 130. In 1937, Central London Property Ltd (the landlord), leased a block of flats to High Trees House Ltd (the tenant) for 99 years. due to World War II, the tenant struggled to pay full rent and in 1940, the landlord agreed to reduce the rent by half in an oral agreement, but after the war, the landlord sought to recover the full rent for the period between 1940 to 1945.

8. Kettunen H. & Ruonavaara H., Rent Regulation in 21st Century Europe: Comparative Perspectives, 36 Hous. Stud., 1448 (2021), https://doi.org/10.1080/02673037.2020.1769564 (last visited Jan. 30, 2025).

9. Eller H. Klaas, The Political Economy of Tenancy Contract Law – Towards Holistic Housing Law, 1 Eur. L. Open 999 (2022), https://doi.org/10.1017/elo.2023.8 (last visited Aug. 22, 2024).

10. Bolaji S. Ramos, Understanding the Essential Principles of Law of Landlord and Tenant Laws in Nigeria Through Judicial Decisions, 6 Commonwealth L. Bull. (2020), http://www.tandfonline.com/ (last visited Aug. 22, 2024).

11. Ibid.

12. OHADA Uniform Act on General Commercial Law of 30th December 2010.

13. The French Civil Code of 1804 and its amendments.

14. According to section 68 of the 18th January 1996 Constitution of Cameroon, the laws of the former East and West Cameroons remains in use in so far as they are not incompatible to the constitution and subsequent local laws are not yet in place to handle issues regulated by these laws.

15. This is by virtue of Section 68 of the 18th January 1996 Constitution of Cameroon as seen above.

16. Evans D., The Law of Landlord and Tenant, Butterworths Publications, 1974, at 12.

17. Bolaji S. Ramos. (2020). Op.cit., 3.

18. Ibid, 4.

19. Ater S. Vendaga. (2023). Op.cit, 4

20. Ibid.

21. With regards to the location of the property, we will discover that in Cameroon, some buildings are constructed in commercial areas of towns and advertised for letting, for which both persons seeking to operate commercial activities in the form of companies while same building owner may let out some of the apartments in the same building to others for residential purposes. As per premises based on their characteristics, there buildings that have been specifically design for commercial purposes only and can only be let out to persons wishing to carry out commercial activities.

22. See Section 101 of the UAGCL.

23. It provides that, this title shall be applicable to all leases on buildings falling within the following categories: (1) premises or buildings for commercial, industrial, artisanal or any other professional use; (2) accessory premises depending on a premise or building for commercial, industrial, artisanal or any other professional use, provided that if these accessory premises belong to different owners, this location has been devoted to common use intended by the lessee, and such use has been known to the lessor at the time of the conclusion of the lease; and 3) Raw land on which were built, before or after the conclusion of the lease, properties for industrial, commercial, artisanal or any other professional use, if such buildings that have been elevated or operated with the express consent of the owner or brought to his attention specifically and he approved.

24. Section 104 of the OHADA UAGCL, 2010.

25. Ater S. Vendaga. (2023). Op.cit, 6

26. This was the provision of the OHADA UAGCL of 1998, see Section 69.

27. Jessica A. Ajonumah & Ikubogh H. Nnenna, Land and Development in Nigeria: An Appraisal of Slum Tenancy, 5 Int’l J. L. 108 (2019).

28. Article 104 Para. 2 of the UAGCL.

29. Ibid, Para. 3.

30. Tenant fixtures are those that are movable such as air conditioners affixed to the walls of a building for the use and benefit of the lessee as opposed to fixtures that are ipso facto characterised as real property.

31. Poole’s case (1703} 2 Salk 368.

32. Smith v City Petroleum Co. (1940) 1 All ER 260.

33. (1948) 1 All ER 248 at 251.

34. Article 106.

35. Arinze V. Chinelo & Green P., Examining the Law of Tenant’s Fixtures, Compensation for Improvements and the Modus of Quic Quid Plantatur Solo Cedit, 6 Afr. J. L. & Hum. Rts. 3 (2022).

36. (2021) LPELR-53984 (CA).

37. Arinze V. Chinelo & Green P., (2022). Loc.cit, 3.

38. Ibid.

39. Article 131 of the UAGCL.

40. [1982] QB 1145

41. It is important to note that whether alteration or addition amounts to improvement to the leased property such as building a kitchen sink where none existed originally is a question of fact, to be considered from the point of view of the tenant

42. Article 111, of the UAGCL.

43. Ibid, Article 116.

44. Ibid, Article 117.

45. Ibid, Article 123.

46. Ibid, Article 125

47. Ibid.

48. Ibid, Article 124.

49. Ibid, Article 123.

50. Ibid, Article 126.

51. Ibid, Article 127(1).

52. Ibid, Article 127(2).

53. Ibid, Article 128.

54. Ibid, Article 130.

55. Ibid, Article 131.

56. Ibid, Article 118.

57. Ibid, Article 119.

58. Ibid, Article 120.

59. Ibid, Article 121.

60. Ibid, Article 122.

61. Article 105 of the UAGCL.

62. Information from an interviewee, Mr. Paul Formisang, lessor to several commercial residential buildings.

63. Article 107 of the UAGCL.

64. Nwinye M. & Matthew Y. Ibinabo, Comparative Analysis of Landlord and Tenant Relationship in Tenancy Law, Nigeria, 16 Int’l J. Soc. & Econ. Res. 99 (2020).

65. Article 109 of the UAGCL.

66. Ibid, Article 108.

67. Onyekaozurule L. Nwauzi, The Practice of Customary Tenancy Under the Nigerian Customary Land Law, 6 J. Prop. L. & Contemp. Issues 105 (2017).

68. Dimasa Property Ltd v Yusuf [2009] LPELR – 8144 (CA

69. [1997] 6 NWLR (Pt 509) 447

70. Property Holding Co. Ltd v Clarke [1945] 1 All ER 165

71. See Law No. 2016/007 of 12 July 2016 Relating to the Penal Code of the Republic of Cameroon.

72. Article 112 of the UAGCL.

73. Nwinye M. and Y. Matthew Ibinabo, 2020. Loc.cit, 99.

74. Article 113 of the UAGCL.

75. Ibid, Article 114.

76. Nwinye M. and Y. Matthew Ibinabo, 2020. Loc.cit, 99.

77. Nwinye M. and Y. Matthew Ibinabo, 2020. Op.cit, 96.. 2020.

78. Ibid.

79. This is a standard put in place court practices. Unfortunately, most matters that go to court on tenancy issues are hardly ever head in open court. On the bright side of it, the State Counsels (prosecutors) often settle or issue orders to be respected by one or both parties.

80. Section 15(1)(b) of Law No. 2006/015 of 29 December 2006 on Judicial Organisation of Cameroon.

81. Ibid, Section 18(1)(b).

82. Bolaji S. Ramos. (2020). Op.cit, 3.

How to cite

Awah Ambe Harvey & Adamu Yusufa, Cameroon’s Tenancy Conundrum: Navigating the Intricacies of Lease Agreements, 8 Int'l J.L. Mgmt. & Human. 1211 (2025).

Cite this article

Awah Ambe Harvey & Adamu Yusufa, Cameroon’s Tenancy Conundrum: Navigating the Intricacies of Lease Agreements, 8 Int'l J.L. Mgmt. & Human. 1211 (2025).
Chat with us