INTRODUCTION
Proliferation Life insurance policy is a contract between the policyholder (assured) and the insurer (insurance company), where the insurer promises to pay a designated beneficiary a sum of money upon the death of the insured person. In return, the policyholder agrees to pay a stipulated amount (at regular intervals or in lump sums). In a nutshell, life policies are legal contracts and the terms of the contract describe the limitations of the insured events. The best explanation of the definition and nature of a life insurance contract occurs in Dalby v. India and London Life Assurance Co.1 wherein it was stated that life insurance is a contract to pay a certain sum of money on the death of a person in consideration of the due payment of a certain annuity for his life calculated according to probable duration of life. The basic fact about life insurance recognised in this case is that a contract of life insurance is not a contract of indemnity.2
Specific exclusions are often written into the contract to limit the liability of the insurer. Common examples are claims relating to suicide, fraud, war, riot and civil commotion. Suicide means a wilful and intentional act on the part of the self-destroyer. It includes every act of self-destruction. The position of England and India is different in case of executing a life policy of a person who has committed suicide with a sane mind.
This seminar paper examines the development of law and policy in relation to claims on a life insurance policy where the assured or insured has committed suicide after the commencement of the policy and the effect of suicide clause in a life insurance contract. Is that the present practice of insurance companies to insert a suicide clause in life policies, indirectly promotes commercial suicide in cases of suicide felo de se.
NATURE OF LIFE INSURANCE CONTRACT
DEFINITION OF LIFE INSURANCE CONTRACT
Insurance is an arrangement by which losses suffered by a small number of insured are spread over many, exposed to similar risk. Thus, the primary function of insurance, be it life, or non-life or reinsurance, is providing protection by assessing the risk and sharing the same with many by the process of risk sharing and, thus, minimizing individual risk and its impact. In the today’s complex and busy life risk is at every step. So, these days insurance has become essential for managing risk. The insurance company collects the premium from insuring public and act as a trustee to the amount so collected. In case of any unexpected incident the loss is paid out of the premium so collected.3
A life insurance contract is simply a legally enforceable agreement between an applicant and an insurance company. Ordinarily it is set forth in a life insurance policy, but this is not essential. If the actions of the parties and the document exchanged otherwise satisfy the legal requirements for the formation of a contract, an insurance contract may be held to be effective even though no policy has been issued. On the other hand, it is possible also that even though a policy has been issued and delivered, the company may not be obligated under it. This is true in many situations where one or more of the basic legal requirements for the formation of a contract have not been met. There are also some factors, such as misrepresentation and fraud in the application, which go to the essential validity of the contract.4
Life insurance policy is a contract between the policyholder (assured) and the insurer (insurance company), where the insurer promises to pay a designated beneficiary a sum of money upon the death of the insured person. In return, the policyholder agrees to pay a stipulated amount (at regular intervals or in lump sums). In a nutshell, life policies are legal contracts and the terms of the contract describe the limitations of the
insured events. The best explanation of the definition and nature of a life insurance contract occurs in Dalby v. India and London Life Assurance Co.5 wherein it was stated that life insurance is a contract to pay a certain sum of money on the death of a person in consideration of the due payment of a certain annuity for his life calculated according to probable duration of life. The basic fact about life insurance recognised in this case is that a contract of life insurance is not a contract of indemnity.6
Thus Life insurance provides a sum of money if the person who is insured dies whilst the policy is in effect. The definition captures the original, basic, intention of life insurance: i.e. to provide for one’s family and perhaps others in the event of death, especially premature death. Originally, policies were for short periods of time, covering temporary risk situations, such as sea voyages.
As life insurance became more established, it was realized what a useful tool it was for a number of situations, which would include:
(a) Temporary needs/threats: the original purpose of life insurance remains an important element in life insurance and estate planning, as things like children’s education etc. occupy responsible people’s thoughts.
(b) Savings: providing for one’s family and oneself, as a long-term exercise, becomes more and more relevant as society evolves from a tribal, clan, family orientated community to relatively affluent individual independence.
(c) Investment: the accumulation of wealth and safeguarding it from the ravages of inflation become realistic goals as living standards rise.
(d) Retirement: provision for one’s own later years becomes increasingly necessary, especially in a changing cultural and social environment.
B. History of Life Insurance Contract
Year 1818 saw the advent of life insurance business in India with the establishment of the Oriental Life Insurance Company in Calcutta. This Company however failed in 1834. In 1829, the Madras Equitable had begun transacting life insurance business in the Madras Presidency. 1870 saw the enactment of the British Insurance Act and in the last three decades of the nineteenth century, the Bombay Mutual (1871), Oriental (1874) and Empire of India (1897) were started in the Bombay Residency. This era, however, was dominated by foreign insurance offices which did good business in India, namely Albert Life Assurance, Royal Insurance, Liverpool and London Globe Insurance and the Indian offices were up for hard competition from the foreign companies.
In 1914, the Government of India started publishing returns of Insurance Companies in India. The Indian Life Assurance Companies Act, 1912 was the first statutory measure to regulate life business. In 1928, the Indian Insurance Companies Act was enacted to enable the Government to collect statistical information about both life and non-life business transacted in India by Indian and foreign insurers including provident insurance societies. In 1938, with a view to protecting the interest of the Insurance public, the earlier legislation was consolidated and amended by the Insurance Act, 1938 with comprehensive provisions for effective control over the activities of insurers.7
The Insurance Amendment Act of 1950 abolished Principal Agencies. However, there were a large number of insurance companies and the level of competition was high. There were also allegations of unfair trade practices. The Government of India, therefore, decided to nationalize insurance business. An Ordinance was issued on 19th January, 1956 nationalising the Life Insurance sector and Life Insurance Corporation came into existence in the same year. The LIC absorbed 154 Indian, 16 non-Indian insurers as also 75 provident societies—245 Indian and foreign insurers in all. The LIC had monopoly till the late 90s when the Insurance sector was reopened to the private sector.8
C. Need of Life Insurance Contract
Whilst 2.1 above outlines the developing appreciation of the many uses of life insurance, the modern scene tends to look upon available life insurance products from the perspective of meeting various needs. These we may think of as:
a. Personal needs:
Life insurance policy takes care of the dependents living expenses, the dependents do not have to depend on others, it also helps in dealing with debts, life insurance can be used to pay debts, it also helps in achieving long term goals, it also helps dependents to meet the final (end of life) expenses, it takes care of dependents educational funds, if the insured survives the policy, the policy amount can be useful for planning retirement, it is also pertinent to note that life insurance is available to young people so sometimes people may not be qualified for it later, it also helps in mortgage repayment fund, life insurance policy is seen as a tax saving tool, thus can be used for tax- saving purpose, it is also considered as a tool for forced savings, whereby people are forced to give stipulated premiums and stipulated intervals, which can be half yearly or annually, it also provides peace of mind to the insured because after his death dependents don’t have to depend on others and also at the same time provide peace of mind to the dependents of the insured, it can be used as emergency fund and disability income.
b. Business needs:
Life insurance policy is helpful for the people engaged in business. They can raise loans to expand or diversify their business. It is also beneficial for the employees. An employee has interest in the life of employer to the extent of his salary and thus he can take life insurance policy for his employer.9 Life insurance can help us to cope up with few events can cause more turmoil in a small business than the death of an owner. Besides the personal loss, there’s the practical loss of a key asset and the question of ownership going forward. A life insurance payout can provide operating cash to get the company through a tough time. It can also help the surviving owners buy a late partner’s share from his or her heirs. Arrangements like this are often set in a buy-sell agreement, one of the most important documents in any business partnership. Buy-sell agreements are like prenups. They’re legal contracts between business co-owners, detailing how the ownership transfers if one partner dies, becomes disabled or leaves the business.
LIFE INSURANCE, POLICY CONTRACT AND SUICIDE
After understanding the meaning of Life Insurance, it is pertinent to know about the insured event in life insurance and also to understand about the legal position regarding suicide in India.
A. Insured Event in Life Insurance Contract
The insured event in ordinary life insurance is the death of the life assured arising from disease or accident. It is immaterial whether the death is caused by natural or accidental causes or even due to the criminal act of a third party. Courts of law do not enforce contracts, the objects of which are against public policy. One of the cardinal rules of legal theory based on public policy is that no man shall be allowed to take advantage of his own wrong and this rule is expressed in the maxim ex turpi causa non oritur action, i.e., no cause of action arises out of a wrong. Based on this principle the general rule is that the legal representatives of the assured can recover on a life policy of the assured on his death, whether the death is due to natural or accidental causes including death caused by a criminal act of a third party. There are two exceptions to the aforesaid principle that have been laid down. Namely, where the first death of the assured is caused due to the violation of a rule of criminal law by the assured himself, and secondly, where death is the result of a suicide.
The willful misconduct of the assured has always been treated as an implied exception in a policy not only in life insurance but in other branches also. For example, in the case of fire insurance where the fire is caused by the wilful misconduct of the assured, he is debarred from recovering on the policy (Liberty National Life Insurance Co. v Weldon).
If the insured violates the law or commits an act punishable with a capital punishment and if he is sentenced to death, he is said to bring death on himself and the rule of public policy that no one can make a profit out of his own wrongful or culpable conduct comes into play and debars the assured or his representative to recover under the policy. It shall be seen presenting that when the assured commits suicide the claims under the policy are denied. In such cases, it was pointed out that it would be contrary to public policy to insure a man to benefit upon his death, by the hands of justice. Death resulting from illegal operations or death in a fight or duel falls within this principle and the insurance company is absolved from liability in such cases.10
B. What is Suicide?
According to Merriam Webster dictionary the word ‘suicide’ means “the act or an instance of taking one’s own life voluntarily and intentionally”11
Thus we can say suicide is the act of intentionally causing one’s own death. Risk factors include mental disorders such as depression, disorder and substance abuse including alcoholism. Other suicide is impulsive acts due to stress such as from financial difficulties, troubles with relationships. Those who have attempted suicide are at higher risk for future attempts.
C. The Suicide Clause
Every year, more than eight lakh people commit suicide around the world and 17% of them are from India. The cases of suicide in India are also increasing every year, which has pushed our country among the top 12 countries with maximum number of suicide cases per year. The major reasons for suicide in India are family problems, depression, illness and marital issues and many more. Dealing with such unexpected event is very difficult for the family, which suffers the emotional trauma and pain due to the loss of the family member. Losing the only financial security in the form of life insurance due to exclusion of suicide in the policy increases the difficulties of the family.12
Life insurance companies are in the business to make a profit and that’s why they elude most of the avoidable risks related to life by adding exclusion clauses which makes the policy void in many circumstances. The regulator IRDAI has made changes in the suicide clause which got applicable from 1st January 2014. So all the policies which are issued before 1st January 2014 will have the old clause of suicide while the new suicide clause will be applicable to the policies issued after 1st January 2014.
The suicide clause for all the policies issued before 1st January 2014 states:-
“If the life assured commits suicide within one year from the date of commencement of risk or date of revival if revived, whether sane or insane at that time, the policy will be void and no claim will be payable.”
So if the policyholder commits suicide before 12 months of the commencement of the policy, then no any claim will be paid by the company and the insurance policy will become void. While if the policyholder commits suicide after one year of the commencement of the policy, then the death benefit will be paid. Some of the companies have a waiting period of even 2 years for such claims. It is important to look at the terms and conditions of the policy.13
The fundamental reason for the suicide being regarded as exclusion is to eliminate the presence of Moral Hazard in the case. Moral hazard means that there is a wrong intention of policyholder to take insurance and maybe he or she wants to make profit out the insurance policy. Some customers might try to protect their families by purchasing insurance plan and then committing suicide. Be aware that doing this will not help in any manner and the losses will be catastrophic in terms of a life lost while gaining no material benefit.14
Covering suicide without waiting period would instigate people to look life insurance policy as a lucrative way to get financial incentives for their family and here the loss of life is planned! This defeats the entire concept of insurance.
The suicide clause for all the policies issued after 1st January 2014 states, as per new guidelines, there are changes in the suicide clause which is applicable to policies issued after 1stJanuary 2014 on the basis of the type of insurance plan.
Market Linked Life Insurance plans- In case of linked plans, if the policyholder commits suicide even within 12 months from the commencement of the policy during the policy term, then the nominee is entitled to receive 100% of the policy fund value.15
Non-Linked/Traditional Life Insurance Plans- In case of non-linked plans, the nominee is entitled to receive 80% of the premium paid in case of death claim due to suicide even within 12 months from the commencement of the policy during the policy term.
The terms and conditions of a suicide clause in the case of third party and group insurance policy are mentioned below:-
In case of third party where a policyholder has taken a loan against his policy and he commits suicide during the policy term, then the interest of the third party (housing company or bank) is protected by the insurer by repaying the loan. But it is applicable only if the notice of assignment of the policy has been received by the insurer, one month before the date of death.
In group insurance policies, the organization, employer or entity which decides the type of insurance to purchase for the group members is known as the master policy holder and the members of the group who are covered under the policy are known as Member of the policy or Group Insured. So in group insurance policy, the master policyholder is the actual policyholder, not the individuals in the group and that’s why no claim is accepted by the insurer in case of death due to suicide in a group insurance policy.
D. The Contestability Clause
Almost all life insurance companies out there will insist on including what’s known as a contestability clause in any policy taken out through them. This is done to protect the insurance company from losses that result from fraudulent claims. Specifically, a contestability period typically lasts anywhere from one to two years; during this period, if a death benefits claim is made by a beneficiary, the claim will automatically be investigated deeply before it is approved.16
Like the suicide clause, the “contestability period” is a two-year window from the date that a life insurance policy takes effect. It says that if a policyholder dies within those first two years, their insurer has the right to investigate their cause of death. During this time, the insurance company can obtain an autopsy report, medical reports, and interviews with family and friends of the deceased. The contestability clause applies to any death that happens in the first two years of a policy start date, whether or not it was intentional. Say, for instance, that somebody die of lung cancer. The insurer will look through the medical report to see if that person has a history of smoking. If he does, and didn’t disclose that to his/her insurance company, they have a right to cancel your death benefits.17
The language in this clause usually specifically references suicide as a contestable cause of death. Though this may sound harsh, it’s actually designed to protect the insurance company from the possibility that someone might purchase a large life insurance policy, and then commit suicide for the benefit of their loved ones only days or weeks later. But there are also reasons why an insurance company might refuse to pay the death benefit, even after the period contestability ends.18
E. Non Disclosure of Health Condition
There are certain health conditions that have a close correlation to suicide. These include depression, bipolar disorder and other psychological conditions that can result in suicide. That doesn’t mean that an insurance company will decline an applicant who has these disorders. However if the person does, and fails to disclose it on the life insurance application, this can be the basis of a claim denial.
Generally speaking however, the insurance company will become aware of the condition through the investigation of the insured’s medical records. The company would then make a determination as to whether or not they will approve the policy.19
F. Accidental death treated as Suicide
This is an even more complicated outcome. Insurance companies can sometimes determine that what appears to be an accidental death is actually suicide. If the policy contains language that specifically excludes payment of the death benefit in cases of suicide, it can become a problem. Here’s how it plays out. The insured engages in a certain activity that results in his death. The insurance company determines that the activity was actually suicide, and not an accident. Again, if the policy specifically excludes payment of benefits in the event of death by suicide, they may deny the claim.20
G. The Burden of Proof
For a death to be considered suicide, the insurance company has to prove that the policyholder deliberately took their own life.21 Even if a policyholder’s death is declared an accident, insurers still have the right to investigate within the time period dictated by the suicide clause.
Insurers might look at the policyholder’s death certificate, autopsy report, or hospital report. They might interview family, friends, and (unfortunately) witnesses. They might also review the deceased’s mental health history to see if they had recent psychiatric care, diagnoses of mental illness, a history of suicide attempts or threats, recent changes in behaviour, ongoing drug habits, or even receipts for weapon purchases. A suicide note could also offer convincing evidence that the person intended to kill themselves.
LIFE INSURANCE AND SUICIDE: JUDICIAL INTERPRETATION
The Indian Courts have played a very significant role in interpreting suicidal clauses in the life insurance policy.
Life Insurance Corporation of India v. Dharamvir Anand22
• Dharamvir Anand, the respondent, took a policy of life Insurance on the life of his minor daughter, Kumari Rajan Anand. The proposal was submitted on 25.3.90 and on the request of the insured the policy was dated 10.05.89. The policy contained a Clause, Clause 4B which read as follows : “Notwithstanding anything mentioned to the contrary, it is hereby declared and agreed that in the event of death of Life assured occurring as a result of intentional self injury, suicide or attempted suicide, insanity, accident other than an accident in a public place or murder at any time on or after the date on which the risk under the policy has commenced but before the expiry of three years from the date of this policy, the Corporation’s liability shall be Limited to the sum equal to the total amount of premiums (exclusive extra of premiums, if any), paid under the policy without Interest. Provided that in case the Assured shall commit suicide before the expiry of one year reckoned from the date of this policy, the provisions of the Clause under the heading “Suicide” printed on the back of the policy.”
• The insurer called upon the insured to indicate whether the policy is to be back dated and if so, the date from which it should be dated back. The Insured indicated that the policy should be dated back to 10.5.89 and the premium for the period 10.5.89 till 25.3.1990 was accordingly paid. The policy was issued to the Insured on 25.3.90.
• The minor girl whose life had been insured under the policy committed suicide on 15.11.1992. The respondent thereafter lodged a claim for payment of the entire sum for which life of the deceased had been insured. The Corporation gave a reply to the respondent that his claim for the full sum assured could not be entertained as the assured had committed suicide within three years of the date of the issue of policy and Clause 4B of the policy would be attracted.
• The respondent then filed a complaint under Section 12 of the Consumer Disputers Act upheld the contention of LIC. In appeal the State Commission upheld the view of the corporation and contended that the policy would be treated as effective from 30.03.1990 i.e. the date of the issue and decided that Clause 4-B will apply. The father of the girl filed an appeal to the National Commission. Dharamvir Anand, the father of the girl filed an appeal before the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court ordered that the entire sum for which the life of the minor girl had been insured should be paid to the respondent together with the Bonus and interest which accrued due
• Held: The Apex Court ruled that undoubtedly the risk under the policy had commenced from 10.5.89 and not from the date of issue of the policy i.e. 31st of March, 1990. The Corporation was ordered to pay a total sum of Rs. 3 Lacs to the respondent-claimant in full satisfaction of the claim within eight weeks.
Life Insurance Corporation of India v. Surat Mal Tak23
• Respondent-Complainant being the nominee of the insured filed the complaint before the District Forum, inter alia, stating that his son Sajjan Kumar, now deceased, had taken an insurance policy for a sum of Rs. 50,000/- from the Petitioner on 8th January, 1996 bearing policy No. 10034282843 for a period of 25 years but the insured died on 8.3.1997 Claim preferred by the Respondent was repudiated by the Petitioner on 30th August, 1997 inter alia stating that since the insured had committed suicide within one year of issuance of the policy the claim was not payable as per terms of the policy.
• Held: that in the present case, the policy was issued on 21st March, 1996 and the insured had committed suicide on 8th March, 1997 i.e within one year of the commencement of the policy. Clause 6 of the policy would be squarely applicable and the Respondent would not be entitled to the insured amount as the insured had committed suicide within one year of taking of the policy.
Life Insurance Corporation of India v. Shanta Alias Rahike Lagma Dolli24
• The respondent is a widow of one Lagama. Lagama died on 30-12-1995 at Belgaum. The certificate of hospital treatment shows that at the time of admission the nature of Lagama’s complaint was “consumption of metacin” and the diagnosis at the time he arrived at the hospital was organo phosphorous poisoning. The Medical Attendant’s Certificate which is signed by the Senior Specialist of the hospital at Belgaum also states that the primary cause of death was organo phosphorous poisoning. The certificate also shows that an inquest or formal inquiry was held regarding the death of Lagama and the finding was “organo phosphorous poisoning”.
• Lagama had insured his life under three insurance policies with the appellant. After his death Lagama’s widow filed a complaint before the District Forum, Belgaum alleging deficiency of service because LIC had made “undue inquiries and had repudiated the claim”.
• The District Forum dismissed the complaint holding that apart from the various medical reports and certificates, in the claim petition itself the respondent had stated that the insured had committed suicide. The case-sheet also referred to the statement of the deceased’s relations that Lagama had been to his father-in-law’s house to bring back his wife but the in-laws did not send his wife and that was the reason why he had consumed poison.
• Held: The Supreme Court set aside the decision of the National Commission as well as that of the State Commission on the ground that respondent could not give evidence whether the deceased had taken poison accidently or been administered and thus restored the order of the District Forum. While doing so, having regard to the facts of the case the Supreme Court allowed the respondent the cost of litigation assessed at Rs 25,000.
Seitzinger v. Modern Woodmen of America
• Insurance company have adopted different expedients to protect themselves from adverse decisions. One is to insert in the policy an express condition against “suicide, sane or insane” – a form almost everywhere construed as covering self- killing caused by any form of insanity.
Ellinger v. Mutual Life Insurance Company 25
• A second expedient is to use, instead of an express condition, a warranty by the insured that he will not commit suicide, sane or insane. The law implies a condition that if the warranty is broken the underwriter need not pay. So, in few cases that have arisen, a warranty against suicide has been given the same effect as an express condition in the corresponding form.
Branch Manager, Hdfc Standard Life Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pradosh Mandal & Anr26
• Respondent filed a consumer complaint against the petitioner insurance company alleging that his wife was insured with the petitioner company. During the currency of the policy the insured died due to burn injuries. Insurance claim was submitted with the insurance company. The opposite party insurance company, however, repudiated the claim on the ground that the insured had committed suicide and no insurance claim was payable as per the insurance contract in a case of suicide.
• Held: that the petitioner was unable to prove that the insured has committed suicide and hence repudiation is not justified.
LIC of India v. Kanya Bai27
• Briefly put, facts relevant for the disposal of the revision petition are that Shri Babulal, husband of the complainant Kanya Bai, purchased LIC policy for sum assured Rs. 3 lakhs from the petitioner/opposite party on payment of premium. The policy was valid from 25.2.2002 till 25.2.2018 It is an admitted case of the parties that during the currency of the insurance policy, Babulal was found dead in a hotel room at Kota on 8.8.2002 A police report in this regard was instituted at police station Bhimganj Mandi. The post-mortem on the dead body was conducted. As per the post-mortem report, opinion as to cause of death was kept pending till the examination of viscera.
Respondent Kanya Bai filed insurance claim with the petitioner/opposite party. The claim however, was repudiated on the ground that Babulal have committed suicide by consuming poison and, therefore, as per the exception clause of the insurance policy, claim was not payable.
• Held: that the petitioner has failed to establish that the life assured committed suicide. Thus the repudiation of the claim on the part of the petitioner is not justified and it amounts to deficiency in service.
• Hashmukhbhau Ishwarlal Patel v. LIC of India28
• The brief facts are that the petitioner/complainant, Shri Hashmukhbhai Ishwarlal Patel and his wife took joint life insurance policy, named, Jeevan Sathi, (Double Cover Joint life Plan) with profits and Accident benefits for the sum of Rs. 1,50,000/- under plan 89-30. It was commenced from 15.12.2005. The yearly premium was fixed for an amount of Rs. 5747/-. Under this plan, the husband is the principal life assured (P.L.A) and wife was spouse life assured (SLA). The wife of the complainant has committed suicide on 16.1.2008 The incident was informed to the OP on 17.3.2008 The complainant filed a claim before the OP alongwith relevant documents and police report. On 17.06.2009, the OP informed that the policy holder is entitled for the amount which he has paid by way of premium and the said policy was closed. It was alleged that the OP without obtaining consent from the complainant closed the policy. The claim was rejected on the ground that the policy holder has committed suicide before completing three years. Therefore, aggrieved by the repudiation, complainant filed a complaint before the District Forum, Gandhinagar for the alleged deficiency of service from the OP.
• The OP contested the complaint, filed written version and contended that claim in question falls under clause 4-B of the policy, therefore, the insurance Company is not liable to allow the claim
• Held: that the insurance policy issued by OP was without the consent for Clause 4(b), as stipulated under Regulation 6(1)(I) of IRDA Guidelines which make it mandatory for OP to clearly state the clauses or conditions but the OP failed to do so in the instant case. and thus ordered OP to pay the entire insured amount with interest @9% per annum from the date of filing of the claim within a month, failing which, the entire amount will carry interest @ 12% per annum from the date of pronouncement of the order.
Beresford v. Royal Insurance Co. Ltd29
• Where a policy of life insurance contained a condition that the policy amount was not payable in case of the assured committing suicide within one year from the commencement of the assurance, and the assured having committed suicide about 9 years thereafter while he was of sane mind, the administratrix of the policy instituted an action for the recovery of the policy amount and the insurance company contended that the assured having died by his own hand it was contrary to public policy to make the company liable:
• Held: that there was nothing contrary to public policy in making the company pay the amount under the circumstances of the case.
CONCLUSION
The judicial decisions in India preferred not to follow the rule in Beresford’s case. The committing of suicide is not a crime in India and the rule that laid down in Beresford’s case has no application in India and the insurers are therefore liable. Further English Common Law principle was inapplicable in India as the criminal law in India was the creation of a statute no punishment for suicide is provided. In India the committing of suicide is not a crime. Attempted suicide is punishable under Section 309, I.P.C., while abetment of suicide is punishable under Section 306. The committing of suicide itself is not and cannot be regarded as a crime in India. In this respect the English Common law is inapplicable to India as the criminal law of India is the creation of the Statute. In Faquir Singh v. Union of India, the insured had died due to asphyxia on account of rope round the neck causing cardiac failure. However the fact of suicide had not been proved and existence of a vital proof suggested that it may even be murder. In such a situation, it was held that denial of benefit of postal insurance to father of the insured on ground that death was due to suicide is improper.30
The question whether suicide is opposed to public policy in India was considered in the later case of Scottish Union and National Insurance Co. v. Jahan Begum, in which on the strength of the insurer’s representation that they are the only company operating in India that issued policies free of suicide restrictions whatsoever and that they would pay the sum assured in the vent of the life insured committing suicide even
after the payment of the initial premiums. The insured in this case took fresh policies on his life on 31st August 1935 and paid the initial premiums. A fortnight later, on account of domestic problems he shot his second wife and shot himself. When the insurance company rejected the insured’s claim, the court said: “Whatever the usage or the custom in this business may be, we cannot shut out an intention so clearly defi ned by the contemporaneous interpretation of the company itself. Nor can we ignore the conclusions to which we are inevitably led by the subsequent incorporation of suicide restrictions in the policies of 1935 onwards.” The court therefore passed on to deal with the question whether suicide is opposed to public policy in India or not. After an elaborate reference to Beresford case, the court emphatically held that suicide is “unhesitatingly” not against public policy in India.
Thus, the premise on which modern life policies legalises suicide clauses in case of intentional death rest on that no one would wait for a stipulated period of one or two years and then commits suicide in no way justifies the act.
*****
Footnotes
1. Dalby v. India and London Life Assurance Co (1854) 15 CB 365: 139 ER 465
2. Avtar Singh, Law of Insurance, Eastern Book Company, Lucknow, 2018.
3. B.S. Bodla and M.C. Garg, “Insurance: Fundamentals, Environment and Procedure”, Deep & Deep Publications, New Delhi, 2004.
4. Janice E, Beadles Greider, William T., “Law and the Life Insurance Contract(1960)”, available at http://heinonline.org/HOL/Page?handle=hein.beal/lawlife0001&div=6&start_page=25&collection=beal&set_as_cursor=0&men_tab=srchresults
5. Dalby v. India and London Life Assurance Co (1854) 15 CB 365: 139 ER 465
6. Avtar Singh, Law of Insurance, Eastern Book Company, Lucknow, 2018
7. ICSI- Professional Programme “Insurance Law And Practice” available at https://www.icsi.ed u/docs/webmodules/Publications/9.3%20INSURANCE%20LAW%20AND%20PRACTICE.pdf
8. Ibid
9. Hebdon v. West, 3 B & S 579: 122 ER 218
10. Vivek Dubey, “ Suicide Clause in Life Policies in India: How far legally valid?”, available at http:// www.erevija.org /pdf/articles/eng/Vivek%20engl%203-2014.pdf
11. Merriam Webster dictionary available at https://www.merriam-webster .com /dictionary / suicide
12. Harjot Singh Narula, “What is suicide clause in life insurance?” available at https:// www. Comparepolicy.com/blogs/ suicide-clause-life-insurance/
13. Ibid
14. Ibid
15. Harjot Singh Narula, “Does Life Insurance Policy Cover Suicide in India?”, available at https://www.comparepolicy.com/blogs/life-insurance-policy-cover-suicide-in-india/#respond
16. Available at, http://www.lifeinsuranceattorney.com/blog/2016/august/suicide-exclusion-denials-resolved-by-life-insur/
17. Ibid
18. Ibid
19. Avtar Singh, Law of Insurance, Eastern Book Company, Lucknow, 2018.
20. Kevin Mercadante, “How Does Suicide Affect Life Insurance?”, available at https://www.mcmha.org/how-suicide-affect-life-insurance/
21. Branch Manager, Hdfc Standard Life Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pradosh Mandal & Anr 2017 NCDRC 892 available at http://www.scconline.com/DocumentLink/tk3TCzRM
22. Life Insurance Corporation of India v. Dharamvir Anand (1998) 7 SCC 348 available at http://www.scconline.com/DocumentLink/Cpj6Rl1X
23. Life Insurance Corporation of India v. Surat Mal Tak (2011) NCDRC 10 available at http:// www .scconline.com /DocumentLink/DuQ1wF3O
24. Life Insurance Corporation of India v. Shanta Alias Rahike Lagma Dolli (2004) 13 SCC 748 available at http://www.scconline.com/DocumentLink/o31OSs6A
25. Ellinger v. Mutual Life Insurance Company (1905) 1 K.B. 31, available at http :// www . scconline.com/Members/SearchResult2014.aspx?documentLink=NTXT-0000324 913
26. Branch Manager, Hdfc Standard Life Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pradosh Mandal & Anr 2017 NCDRC 892 available at http://www.scconline.com/DocumentLink/tk3TCzRM
27. LIC of India v. Kanya Bai (2015) NCDRC 3433 available at http:// www .scconline. com/ DocumentLink/C1gwaP5h
28. Hashmukhbhau Ishwarlal Patel v. LIC of India 2017 NCDRC 891 available at http://www.scconline.com/DocumentLink/qvZ97ozq
29. Beresford v. Royal Insurance Co. Ltd.: 1938 AC 586
30. Vivek Dubey, “ Suicide Clause in Life Policies in India: How far legally valid?”, available at http:// www.erevija.org /pdf/articles/eng/Vivek%20engl%203-2014.pdf
