INTRODUCTION
The Factories Act of 1948 was categorical not to allow women to work in any factory from 7 PM to 6 AM1 This was limited to underground work by the Mines Act of 19522. These restrictions were presented as protective, and their real impact was exclusion; women were not allowed to work on higher-paying shifts and in whole sectors of industry, just because they were women. These bans were no longer sustainable as the economy of India started to liberalise, and other sectors of the economy, like IT, healthcare, and export manufacturing, started to become a round-the-clock industry. Their constitutional validity was questioned in the courts. They were substituted with conditional permission by legislatures based on enforceable employer obligations. This paper follows that change to the bandwagon and examines just how far India has actually come in its legal system.
Thesis
The legal system in India that regulates the employment of women on night shifts has experienced a true structural change, a shift in the paternalistic prohibition to the protection based on rights – but this change has not yet been fully realized as the majority of working women in the informal sector are still not covered by the protection, and the available protection is not consistently enforced.
Literature Review
The old prohibition is cited by existing scholarship as an example of what Buchmann, Meyer, and Sullivan refer to as a form of paternalistic discrimination, i.e. the restrictions that seem to protect women, but deprive them of control over their employment choices.3 A study of night shifts by the National Commission of Women, which was co-published with ASSOCHAM, discovered that blanket bans lowered the earning power and job mobility of women without resolving existing safety issues.4 In a 2025 article in the International Journal of Social Science and Human Research, the transition between the Factories Act, 1948, and the OSH Code, 2020, was examined, concluding that the paternalistic reasoning of the former has been tamed, but not abolished, with states still having the freedom to limit the night work of women.5
Empirically, Gupta, Mahajan, Sharma, and Walia (2025) investigated the outcomes of the removal of the night shift in seven Indian states between 2014 and 2017. Their working paper at Ashoka University discovered a statistically significant rise in the number of women in employment, but in larger, organised-sector firms.6 Similar results were obtained by Vernekar and Singhal (2025), who discovered that women in reformed states spent more time on night hours and were more formalised in the organised sector.7 The 2016 report, Women at Work: Trends, by the ILO, cited legal restrictions such as night work bans as one of the structural factors in the South Asian region that continue to drive low rates of female labour force participation.8 The global aspect of the issue was confirmed by the Women, Business and the Law 2024 by the World Bank, which states that at least twenty countries still ban the night work of women completely.9
Research Gap
The literature available is more geared towards formal manufacturing and IT. Very little systematic legal analysis has been given to the application – or rather non-application- of night work protections to the large informal workforce in India. Also, although the results of employment are measured in empirical studies following legal reform, little research has been done on the quality of enforcement: whether the required measures of mandated transport, consent mechanisms and POSH compliance requirements are actually implemented in small and medium enterprises. This paper will fill both gaps by combining legal analysis of the exclusion of the informal sector and the data on enforcement.
Methodology
The research approach used in this paper is a doctrinal legal research approach with secondary empirical data. The Bluebook 20th edition citation standard is used to analyse primary legal sources, which are constitutional provisions, central and state legislation, judicial decisions, and government notifications. These are complemented by secondary sources such as ILO reports, World Bank data, NCRB statistics and peer-reviewed working papers. There is no original fieldwork carried out in the paper; rather, it summarises the available empirical evidence to evaluate the disjuncture between law on the books and law in practice.
DATA ANALYSIS & INTERPRETATION
A. Constitutional Foundation
Articles 14, 15(3) and 21 of the Constitution101112 give the context in which the old prohibition could not exist.ve. In Vasantha R. v. Union of India,13 the Madras High Court declared section 66(1)(b) of the Factories Act to be unconstitutional on the ground that Article 15(3) permits provisions to be made to women, not to prohibit them, and that Article 21 is the right to the choice of occupation. This was reaffirmed when the Supreme Court interpreted Article 21 in Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India14 to provide the right to life with a life of dignity and meaningful economic opportunity. The directive of just and humane conditions of work in Article 42 also imposes on the state the duty to guarantee safety, not exclusion.15
B. State-Level Reforms
After Vasantha, several states changed their laws regulating the factories and establishments. The state of Tamil Nadu (2016) allowed women to work till 10 p.m. under the condition of transport, CCTV, and lighting requirements.16 Maharashtra (2020) required written permission and safe transportation.17 The conditional framework across the states comprised written consent of every woman employee; transportation with security escorts; CCTV surveillance within and outside the premises; proper lighting; and regular reporting to the State Labour Commissioner.18 This substituted one prohibitive regulation with a series of enforceable employer obligations, and moved the regulatory onus off women and onto their protection.
C. Central Legislation
The POSH Act, 2013 – which is signed to lend statutory effect to the guidelines of the Supreme Court in Vishaka v. State of Rajasthan-19 mandates all employers to form an Internal Complaints Committee and offers a time-limited redressal mechanism, which extends to all shifts.20 The Maternity Benefit (Amendment) Act, 2017, increased the paid maternity leave to twenty-six weeks and required crèche facilities in workplaces with fifty or more workers.21 The new OSH Code, 2020, allows women to work between 7 p.m. and 6 a.m. with their consent, provided there are conditions prescribed by the state.22 The Code on Wages, 2019, forbids any wage discrimination based on gender, and this directly relates to the issue of refusing women the same pay as men working night shifts.23
D. International Standards
The previous prohibition-based approach was substituted with a protection-based system with ILO Convention No. 171 (1990): health checks, rights to pregnancy transfer, rest, and access to childcare to all night workers.24 Convention No. 171 has not been ratified in India.25 Article 11 of CEDAW obliges state parties to do away with discrimination in the workplace and provide equal access to employment opportunities and terms.26 According to the World Bank (2024), twenty countries have banned the night work of women altogether, which proves that India is moving in a progressive direction in the reforms, albeit with flaws.
E. Enforcement and Coverage Gaps
NCRB statistics reveal that crimes against women in the open area are still a major issue, which means that the introduction of mandatory transport protection is not being done everywhere.27 The informal sector, where most of the working women in India work, is virtually beyond the scope of the Factories Act, the employer requirements of the POSH Act and the Labour Codes. The compliance analysis conducted by Nishith Desai Associates proves that small enterprises are regularly not meeting the requirements of consent, CCTV and transport. The crèche requirement is only applicable to the facilities with more than fifty employees, and millions of people are left without any childcare facilities, even though ILO Convention No. 171 has defined this as a basic need.
TESTING OF THE THESIS
The thesis that the change of prohibition into protection is real, but partial, is substantiated by the evidence. The legal change is real: Vasantha overturned the ban on blankets as unconstitutional; state amendments have developed enforceable conditional structures; the POSH Act and OSH Code have enshrined consent and safety as legal obligations28. These reforms have led to actual growth in female employment and formalisation in the reformed states, as confirmed by the empirical studies of Gupta et al. (2025)29 and Vernekar and Singhal (2025).30
The metamorphosis is not complete as well. The analysis of the IJSSHR (2025) shows that the paternalistic logic has not been destroyed, as the discretion of the state level was maintained in the OSH Code. Smaller employers still did not comply with the Lawrbit compliance review (2025) documents.31 ILO statistics indicate low levels of female labour force participation that continue to prevail in South Asia in the wake of sectoral reform. The exclusion of the informal sector (and especially the exclusion of most women who work at night in India) implies that most of the women working at night in India do not get any of the legal safeguards outlined in this paper. On both limbs, therefore, the thesis is confirmed.
SUGGESTIONS & RECOMMENDATIONS
In light of the above analysis, it is recommended to reform the following:
1. India must become a signatory to the ILO Convention No. 171 (1990) to establish a binding international commitment on the safety of night work and to have a reference point in evaluating the national level systems.
2. The Labour Codes need to be enforced with state implementing rules that contain enforceable minimum standards of transport, consent, CCTV, and lighting that apply to all establishments, irrespective of size.
3. The basic night work protections to informal sector workers should be extended through a separate statutory framework, based on the Unorganised Workers Social Security Act, 2008.32
4. The creche requirement in the Maternity Benefit Act must be made available to smaller establishments with the facility arrangements in common-pooled or shared in the industrial zones.
5. The labour inspection equipment needs to be reinforced with specific auditing of the conditions of compliance with the night shift, such as spot-checks of the transport registers, the functionality of CCTV, and the consent documentation.
CONCLUSION
India has taken the required legal step, from a system that did not favour women working at night to a system that, theoretically, safeguards them in that system. The constitutional framework of Vasantha, Maneka Gandhi, and Vishaka; the legislative framework of the POSH Act, amendments by states, and the OSH Code; and the international undertaking of CEDAW are all a real break with the paternalism of 1948. Protection in a statute, which does not extend to informal workers and is not applied to small employers, is only protection on paper. Whether the woman who finishes her night shift at 6 a.m. will have a safe ride home will be the measure of whether India has really come a long way or not, not in the text of the OSH Code.
*****
Footnotes
1. Factories Act, 1948, § 66(1)(b), No. 63, Acts of Parliament, 1948 (India).
2. Mines Act, 1952, § 46, No. 35, Acts of Parliament, 1952 (India).
3. Nina Buchmann, Carl Meyer & Colin D. Sullivan, Paternalistic Discrimination (2023) (Working Paper).
4. National Commission for Women & ASSOCHAM, Night Shift for Women: Growth and Opportunities (2022), https://cdn.ncw.gov.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/02/NIGHT-SHIFT-FOR-WOMEN.pdf (last visited Apr. 14, 2026).
5. Veda Kalra, Legislative Barriers to Female Participation in the Indian Workforce: A Historical Analysis of Factories Act, 1948 and the Occupational Safety, Health and Working Conditions Code, 2020, https://ijsshr.in/v8i12/Doc/74.pdf (last visited Apr. 14, 2026).
6. Bhanu Gupta, Kanika Mahajan, Anisha Sharma & Daksh Walia, From Dusk Till Dawn: The Impact of Lifting Night Shift Bans on Female Employment, Ashoka Univ. Econ. Discussion Paper 147 (2025), https://dp.ashoka.edu.in/ash/wpaper/paper147_0.pdf (last visited Apr. 14, 2026).
7. Nisha Vernekar & Karan Singhal, Breaking the Night Barrier: Night-shift Reforms and Women’s Work in India (Aug. 16, 2025) (SSRN Working Paper No. 5393817), https://ssrn.com/abstract=5393817 (last visited Apr. 14, 2026).
8. International Labour Organization, Women at Work: Trends 2016 (ILO 2016).
9. World Bank, Women, Business and the Law 2024 (World Bank Group 2024).
10. Indian Constitution art. 14.
11. Indian Constitution art. 15, cl. 3.
12. Indian Constitution art. 21.
13. Vasantha R. v. Union of India, (2001) 7 SCC 487 (India).
14. Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India, (1978) 1 SCC 248 (India).
15. Indian Constitution art. 42.
16. Govt. of Tamil Nadu, G.O. (Ms.) No. 81, Labour and Employment Dept. (June 21, 2016).
17. Govt. of Maharashtra, G.N. No. LBR-2020/CR-25/Lab-7, Industries, Energy and Labour Dept. (Sept. 30, 2020).
18. Nishith Desai Associates, DEI Series Part I: Female Employees Working in Night Shift in India (2023), https://www.nishithdesai.com/research-and-articles/hotline/hr-law-hotline/dei-series-part-1-female-employees-working-in-night-shift-in-india-recent-updates-10628 (last visited Apr. 14, 2026).
19. Vishaka v. State of Rajasthan, (1997) 6 SCC 241 (India).
20. Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition and Redressal) Act, 2013, No. 14, Acts of Parliament, 2013 (India).
21. Maternity Benefit (Amendment) Act, 2017, No. 6, Acts of Parliament, 2017 (India).
22. Code on Occupational Safety, Health and Working Conditions, 2020, No. 37, Acts of Parliament, 2020 (India), §§ 24–28.
23. The Code on Wages, 2019, No. 29, Acts of Parliament, 2019 (India), § 3.
24. International Labour Organization, Night Work Convention, 1990 (No. 171), June 26, 1990, 1675 U.N.T.S. 347.
25. Karuna Santwan Baskar, Legal Framework and Regulations Concerning Shift Work in India, iPleaders Blog (Oct. 24, 2019) https://blog.ipleaders.in/regulations-on-shift-work/ (last visited Apr. 14, 2026).
26. Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women art. 11, Dec. 18, 1979, 1249 U.N.T.S. 13.
27. National Crime Records Bureau, Crime in India 2022 (Ministry of Home Affairs 2023).
28. Vasantha R., (2001) 7 SCC 487.
29. Gupta et al., supra note 6.
30. Vernekar & Singhal, supra note 7.
31. Lawrbit, Women in Night Shifts: Compliance, Safety and Employer Duties (Sept. 12, 2025), https://www.lawrbit.com/article/women-in-night-shifts-compliance-safety/ (last visited Apr. 14, 2026).
32. Unorganised Workers’ Social Security Act, 2008, No. 33, Acts of Parliament, 2008 (India).
